A conversation with Ayatollah Khamenei about Haj Ahmad Mr. Khomeini

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

1 June 1995

Context
Khamenei gave a reflective interview recalling his personal acquaintance with and assessment of the late Haj Ahmad Khomeini, son of Imam Khomeini, shortly after his death in 1995.
Main themes
Personal remembrance of Haj Ahmad Khomeini, character and personality assessment, relationship with Imam Khomeini, revolutionary activities and struggle, intelligence and devotion, seminary education, pre-revolutionary Iran, loyalty to the Islamic Revolution
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,922
74th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 50%41%
  • Institutional 41%34%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 18%

172 sentences in 21 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. Please provide details about your acquaintance with Hajj Ahmad Agha.

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. The first time I saw him was around the year 1961 when we frequently visited Imam's house in Qom. He apparently was attending high school at that time. I would see him coming and going on his bicycle from the inner door of the house. Of course, we entered through the outer door. At first, I did not know him. Later, I was told that he was the Imam's son. After that, I did not see him again. During the events of 1962, I do not remember anything about him and have no news of what he was doing or where he was. Until I think it was in 1964 or 1965 that I heard he had become a good seminary student and was very serious about his studies. It was said that the Imam had told him at that time that if he wanted to go to university, the costs would be his own responsibility; but if he became a seminary student, he would provide him with a stipend. In other words, the Imam was encouraging him to pursue seminary studies. Gradually, our acquaintance with him increased and became closer. I even visited his house in Qom once, which at that time was located in a street perpendicular to the hospital street and parallel to Safa'iyyah. I do not know the name of that street; but it was considered to be in the upper part of Qom and was a nice place.

When he had just gotten married, I was traveling from Mashhad to Qom and decided to go see the Imam's son. I visited him, and we got to know each other better. This was the beginning of our acquaintance. Later, when he went to Najaf and then returned to Qom, he was arrested once and imprisoned. When he was released from prison—coincidentally, I was in Tehran—I went to visit him at the house of the late Mr. Thaqafi. He was there, and a group of friends had also come.

After that, he got in touch with us regarding some activities—such as those related to the struggle. For example, he would hide some of the announcements that had come from Najaf in the covers of books and send them to me in Mashhad. Therefore, his connection with us was in both the areas related to the struggle and some intellectual matters. For instance, he took action to print the book "Intellectuals" by Al-Ahmad, which had just come out and was not allowed to be printed by the regime. I do not clearly remember with whom he was in contact regarding this matter. Later, in order to ensure various aspects, he sent me a copy, and I provided my opinions. In any case, we had such communications until the time of the victory of the revolution. These are the backgrounds of our acquaintance with him.

What is your overall summary and assessment of his personality and characteristics?

Hajj Ahmad Agha was a capable and worthy individual. First of all, he was very intelligent. In my opinion, among the inherent and characteristic traits that stand out in a person, if we were to consider one trait as the most prominent for Hajj Ahmad Agha, it would be his intelligence. He was a very sharp, clever, and astute man. I also saw some of the good qualities of the Imam in him. For example, he was a straightforward person. The Imam was the same way. The late Hajj Agha Mustafa was also like that. I had close interactions and friendships with him as well. In situations where it was necessary, he had no hesitation at all. He had a good sense of candor, of course in certain cases—I do not mean in all situations—which is accurately described as having no hesitation.

He was considered a wise man. He had a deep love for the Imam and was very devoted to him. In addition, he believed in this revolution from the bottom of his heart, and that is why his abundant intelligence was dedicated to the service of the revolution and the Imam. For him, these were the essentials. I later saw that he also emphasized this in his will. This is true. I personally saw that for him, the Imam and the revolution were paramount. Friendships, alliances, fronts, and groups were not significant. These were very good aspects that he possessed. In addition, he had studied both in Qom and in Najaf. I am not aware of his specific characteristics and the extent of his knowledge. The reason is that in the years following the revolution, during which we had various work-related interactions with him, scientific discussions did not arise for me to understand his level of knowledge. However, I know that he had studied. I think he once told me that he was teaching "Makasib" in Najaf. Well, that is a good level of education. In any case, he was a valuable personality. Honestly, he was a useful and valuable character.

The point you mentioned might be appropriate to say now. I also wrote in his condolence message. He was truly an indispensable element alongside the Imam. No one else could play this role next to the Imam; because informing the Imam was not an easy task. Sometimes it was bitter news that someone had to convey to the Imam. Not just news of deaths; but there were incidents, issues in the government, in officials, and in individuals that needed to be communicated to the Imam by someone. Not everyone could do this; because some might convey it, and then the Imam would not know what group or faction they belonged to and how reliable that news was. A person had to do this who was close to the Imam, and that person was Hajj Ahmad Agha.

He had a special skill in both conveying news and transmitting the Imam's opinions to the outside—whether to me and two or three others who were high-ranking officials of the system or to the people or some other officials—and he effectively reflected the Imam's views. He also provided the Imam with advice on multiple occasions. The Imam was not someone who would be swayed by emotions, and the issue of father and son did not have an undue influence on him. He made optimal use of Hajj Ahmad Agha's consultations. It was not the case that whatever Hajj Ahmad Agha said, he would listen to; rather, there were instances where the Imam had an opinion, and perhaps we thought that this opinion had been conveyed to him by Hajj Ahmad Agha. Then, God Almighty would arrange matters in such a way that we would understand that the Imam's opinion on this matter was something else and that Hajj Ahmad Agha's opinion was different. In fact, in one instance, an opinion was conveyed to me on behalf of the Imam. I was both surprised at how the Imam could give such an opinion and did not accept it; but both Hajj Ahmad Agha and Mr. Hashemi insisted on that opinion, and since it was presented as the Imam's opinion, we held a meeting to make a decision. It was a very important matter. I said we should go to the Imam and see what he says. Because I suspected that perhaps the Imam might not understand some of the nuances and realities correctly. We went to see the Imam, and after the discussions were presented, I saw that the Imam leaned towards the opinion I had. At that moment, it immediately occurred to me that how could Hajj Ahmad Agha have conveyed something different from the Imam? Hajj Ahmad Agha realized that this was a point that required attention. He immediately confronted all of us in front of the Imam and said: "Sir! I came to you this morning, and you did not say it this way?" Then he detailed the specifics. The Imam reflected for a moment and said: "Yes; that is how it is." This indicated that Hajj Ahmad Agha was sometimes in a position where he could be misled in conveying the Imam's opinion. I want to express that the Imam's words were not merely Hajj Ahmad Agha's consultations. However, the Imam also benefited from Hajj Ahmad Agha. Hajj Ahmad Agha had reflected many well-thought-out opinions to the Imam. Of course, there were also times when he said things that the Imam did not accept. We ourselves saw this in the case of the war, in foreign policy issues, and in many other instances where the Imam's opinion was one thing, and Hajj Ahmad Agha's opinion was entirely different.

As I said, he was a trusted advisor to the Imam. The Imam once said something to the effect that Ahmad does not attribute anything to me that I have not said. This testimony from the Imam is very valuable and important. And it was indeed so. To the extent that we saw, we felt the same.

You mentioned that the Imam expressed affection for Hajj Ahmad Agha many times; was the relationship between the Imam and him an emotional one?

I remember that the Imam said twice: "Ahmad is one of my dearest people." Mr. Hashemi also mentioned this at that time in his Friday prayer sermons; because coincidentally, we were both present when we heard this from the Imam. The first time was in 1979, on the occasion of an incident where the son of one of the gentlemen had created an emotional problem for his father. The Imam said something to the effect that although I love Hajj Ahmad Agha very much, if he were to be captured or killed, I would not be affected or shaken in my heart. It was a strange statement that demonstrated the Imam's strength of heart.

The second time was just recently when he mentioned in the course of a conversation—Imam had a habit of sometimes not stating things directly but rather weaving them into the conversation—that "Ahmad, who is one of my dearest people, if he were to do such a thing, I would confront him." In any case, he was one of the dearest people.

Please explain the advisory role of Hajj Ahmad Agha with the officials.

That is another topic. Perhaps you know that he participated in several meetings. One was in the Expediency Council meeting, which I think the Imam himself said or we requested from the Imam, and he agreed that Hajj Ahmad Agha should be present; because the issue of determining expediency is very important. There were times when it was necessary to convey news to the Imam or vice versa. But more importantly than all these meetings was the meeting of the heads of the three branches of government, which he regularly attended. The meeting of the heads of the three branches was initially held twice a week and later once a week. Then at one point, I said we had a lot of work, so we should increase the frequency of the meetings; it was again held twice a week. In some other meetings, such as the Supreme Defense Council, he sometimes participated. However, the meeting in which he participated as a member was the meeting of the heads of the three branches. This meeting was mobile. Initially, it was held every week in my office; later, for variety and to prevent the meeting from becoming dry, we decided it should be mobile. Every few weeks, we would also go to Hajj Ahmad Agha's house one night. On that night, we had the opportunity to meet the Imam as well. On the night we went to Hajj Ahmad Agha's house, the Imam would also come. Even when he was unwell and not feeling well, he would come there, sit for a few minutes, and leave. His coming had become a custom. In that meeting, we discussed the most important topics of the country. I would take notes on the important matters of some of those council meetings. The reason was that sometimes we would make decisions, and since no one was taking notes, disagreements would arise later. To ensure accuracy, I decided to take notes. If someone refers to those notes—which are, of course, very few—they will understand how important that meeting was. In that meeting, Hajj Ahmad Agha, as a thoughtful, intelligent, and experienced individual, was truly very helpful to us. When various issues, especially global issues, were discussed, his mind was open, and his opinions among the others were good and mature, and they had an impact on the progress of our meeting.

What was his position in the country's administrative system?

It is really very difficult to define a specific place for him; because he did not have an official position. I can only say that he was an outstanding and unique personality, and his absence was truly felt. He had qualities that no one else has and will not have. This is truly the case. His connection with the Imam, his closeness to the Imam, and his understanding of the Imam's opinions were unique. He knew things about the Imam that sometimes he would say that perhaps no one else knew. The ability to convey the leadership's opinions, like the Imam's, to the officials is a very important matter. Sometimes it is not expedient for the leadership to take action in a matter; however, it is good for their opinion to be known so that those who want to address certain issues are aware that the leadership's opinion is this. Hajj Ahmad Agha was a trustworthy and intelligent communicator who understood precisely and reflected what the Imam's esteemed opinion was. He was like this with us. Just think of the role he could have played. There were multiple instances where one might think that carrying out a certain action was a good idea and that the Imam's opinion was the same. Later, it would become clear that no; the Imam's opinion was not this. In the issues that arose towards the end of his honorable life, it was like this. We were mistaken and thought that perhaps the Imam, for example, deep down, felt the same way. Later, it became clear that no, it was not like that; we did not know. Of course, discussions had been held with the Imam repeatedly; however, one only knew the explicit viewpoints and the essence of the Imam's opinion. Perhaps in some matters, he acted differently. In any case, Hajj Ahmad Agha had the role of knowing the Imam's opinion and reflecting it outward. Neither during his lifetime nor after him did anyone else possess these qualities. In addition to personal aspects and apart from what was in his own character, he also had qualities in terms of historical, geographical, and human contexts that were unique to him; his close relationship with the Imam, his proximity to the Imam, the length of time he spent with the Imam, and his awareness of the issues of the revolution. He had a kind of presence and knowledge—albeit somewhat general—about most of the country's issues. Of course, in many matters, he did not delve into details. In some cases, he was not very patient; however, in general, he was aware of many of the country's affairs. In any case, he had an unparalleled role. What I can say is that nothing can fill his place.

Given that you say he always had opinions, but after the Imam's passing, we see that no statements opposing your views have been issued from him. Please explain this.

After the Imam's passing, Hajj Ahmad Agha took a position regarding leadership issues and then, secondly, regarding government issues, which was very commendable. He also had criticisms of some matters; however, these criticisms were not reflected in government issues or were very minimally reflected. Regarding leadership issues, his opinion was fully aligned with what was expressed by the leadership, and he agreed with it.

In the period following the Imam's passing, Hajj Ahmad Agha adopted one of the best positions that someone like him could take in defense of the principles and standards of the revolution and the true face of the Imam's line. He truly defended those positions and, among other things, defended the leadership with all his heart and soul. The very vigorous defense he made, both of the leadership's foundation and principle and of my humble self, had a significant impact on some spirits that might have thought or felt differently. In any case, the position he took after the Imam's passing was very valuable. I believe one of the best chapters of his life, in the sight of God, is this recent chapter where he truly chose the path of God, the path of truth, and the correct path, drawing closer to God. Although there were certainly various expectations from him, just as there were also temptations. One sees that around some individuals, there are temptations. Certainly, there were temptations around him as well. There is no doubt about that. However, he stood firm and resolute, expressing the principles that were esteemed by Imam Khomeini, may God be pleased with him, with complete determination.

* This conversation took place on June 1, 1995, conducted by Hojjatoleslam Masih Borujerdi, the grandson of Imam Khomeini (may God have mercy on him).