Statements at the beginning of the advanced jurisprudence course in the year 1379.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

10 September 2000 · Advanced jurisprudence course (opening statements)

Context
Khamenei addressed seminary students at the opening of the advanced jurisprudence course for the Iranian academic year 1379 (September 2000).
Main themes
Pursuit of knowledge, proper intentions in learning, Islamic jurisprudence, hadith from Tuhaf al-Uqul, seminary education, self-display and boasting, argumentation and contention, desire for ignorance, disdain for knowledge, shyness in learning, religious scholarship, Imam Ja'far al-Sadiq's teachings
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,724
83rd percentile
Sentences
133
76th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 65%65%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

133 sentences in 27 paragraphs

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds, and may Allah's blessings be upon our master Muhammad and his pure family, and may Allah's curse be upon all their enemies.

Before starting our jurisprudential discussions, as is customary, let us present a hadith from the noble book of Tuhaf al-Uqul; then we will proceed to our own remarks. "From the will of Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) to Muhammad ibn Nu'man al-Ahwal - the believer of Taq - (1) O son of Nu'man, do not seek knowledge for three reasons." Do not seek knowledge for three purposes: the first is "to show off"; that is, to boast with it; to show yourself to others that I am knowledgeable. Do not seek knowledge for self-display. The second is "nor to boast"; do not seek it for boasting either. Apparently, the first "to show off" refers to self-display among ordinary people that I am knowledgeable; the second - which is boasting - is for self-display among scholars; that is, when you are in the assembly of scholars, the aim of seeking knowledge should not be to boast that yes, we also know this or these matters. Do not seek knowledge for this purpose either. The third is "nor to argue"; do not seek knowledge for argumentation - for debate and contention. "Af'tamaroonahu 'ala ma yara" (2) which is in the noble Quran, means do you argue with him about what he has seen with his own eyes - referring to the events of the Night of Ascension? Therefore, according to this hadith, the Imam has stated that knowledge should not be sought for these three purposes. In fact, knowledge should be sought for the sake of knowing and acting upon it; not for self-display or to raise oneself above others or for debate and contention.

"And do not abandon it for three reasons"; do not abandon knowledge for these three motivations: "desire for ignorance"; one is due to a desire for ignorance. Some people want to remain ignorant; as if they have animosity towards knowledge and learning. Do not be surprised; there are people in the world who do not listen to certain words; or they prevent others from listening to certain words; so that this knowledge does not arise within them. Some do not listen themselves; some force others not to listen, so that they do not acquire this knowledge out of animosity towards it. Here, a categorical statement has been made; "desire for ignorance." Now, is this "knowledge" referred to the same knowledge defined in the words of the Imams? That is, religious knowledge, jurisprudence? It is possible. Therefore, "desire for ignorance" means ignorance in this context; ignorance regarding this knowledge. However, it is also possible for someone to say no; this definite article "knowledge" does not refer to this specific knowledge; it refers to knowledge in general. Do not abandon any knowledge just because you want to be ignorant of it. Sometimes a person may not have the motivation or the time; that is another discussion; but out of animosity towards knowledge itself, one should not abandon it. "And disdain for knowledge"; the second is that someone abandons knowledge because they have disdain and lack of interest in acquiring knowledge. "Disdain" means lack of interest, lack of enthusiasm. Do not abandon knowledge just because you lack interest in it. That is, it should not be such that knowing something is so unimportant to you that you show disinterest in it. "And shyness before people"; do not abandon knowledge out of shyness from people. For some, seeking knowledge seems to be contrary to their dignity and status; while if they listen, sit down, learn, and acquire knowledge, it will grant them ranks and honors. Yet, they do not want to; because they are shy about seeking knowledge; as if they consider their dignity to be above acquiring knowledge! Do not abandon the pursuit of knowledge for these three reasons. Now, sometimes a person wants to acquire knowledge but does not have the time; that is another discussion; or they want to acquire knowledge but do not have the means to do so, or do not have a teacher; that is not a barrier. However, abandoning the pursuit of knowledge should not be due to either disinterest, a desire for ignorance, or shyness before people. Then he said: "And the concealed knowledge is like a lamp covered over"; knowledge that a person keeps hidden and does not bring to the forefront for teaching and practice is like a lamp that is covered; that is, it is useless and its light will not reach anyone.

This is a hadith from Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) to the believer of Taq, which in our version of Tuhaf al-Uqul is on page 313.

I would like to say a few sentences today on the occasion of the beginning of the academic year in the seminaries: regarding the pursuit of knowledge in the seminaries and other matters that exist in these seminaries, we have presented various points, and others have also expressed and reminded them. There is hardly a word on this subject that has not been said. Of course, speaking and hearing and raising the issue is one thing, and having it become a culture, a necessity, and compelling the authorities to pursue it is another matter. The latter has not yet happened.

What I want to discuss today regarding academic issues and seminaries are one or two points that seem to me to be more necessary than the rest; although all these points are necessary for the seminaries; these are things that are in mind and have been said and perhaps repeated.

One point is the issue of planning in the seminaries. We once mentioned in this assembly of students and scholars that every small organization - an office, a university - has planning for its work. The seminary, in this regard, considering that it is a vast collection of great scholars, of great researchers, in various fields - jurisprudence, exegesis, principles, theology, philosophy, and other branches of knowledge that exist in the seminaries - must have a continuous planning system. Truly, in terms of the quality of the individuals in the seminaries - for example, a seminary like Qom - it cannot be compared to ordinary and conventional academic institutions. There are great personalities, researchers, and then there are so many young people in these seminaries; among them, how many capable, research-oriented, alert, and talented individuals are present. Such an institution, with this breadth and depth, with this quantity and quality, must have a continuous planning system. Of course, the day we made these remarks is different from today; that is, today in most seminaries or all seminaries - especially in the seminary of Qom - there are indeed advancements being seen. There is a management system, they are planning; however, these plans are not commensurate with this vast volume and this great quality.

If today we want to know what kind of planning is necessary for Qom with this capacity, we must look at the world; we must look at the needs of the world; we must look at the emergence and daily appearance of thoughts, theories, and issues that are related to the matters of the seminaries; not in fields and sciences that do not directly relate to the seminaries; no, but regarding the very issues that are directly related to the seminaries. In the world, continuously new discussions arise - regarding ethics, regarding rights, regarding philosophy, regarding the philosophy of religion, regarding theological issues - new discussions are constantly being raised; not in the sense that all these discussions are correct or important; but in the sense that these discussions occupy a vast space in the minds of people around the world.

Given the rapid communications that exist today in the world, where any statement, any thought, any logic, any doubt, any solution that is raised in one corner of the world can sometimes reach the other side of the world within a day or a month, a seminary like the seminary of Qom must plan. They must have individuals prepared to address issues that are currently being discussed in various fields around the world. They must have individuals ready for research, scrutiny, and innovation in the very issues that are currently being raised in the seminaries; such as issues of Islamic philosophy, such as issues of Islamic jurisprudence, such as issues of Islamic principles; some of these fundamental discussions that we raise in discussions of words and so forth are today among the very important issues being discussed in philosophical circles around the world. They should conduct research and innovation on these very matters.

There should be groups that discuss our materials in a comparative manner; that is, for example, compare our jurisprudence with the prevailing laws of the world; compare our philosophical discussions with the prevailing philosophical discussions in the world; compare our theological discussions with the prevailing theological discussions in the world and those things that are presented as the philosophy of religion. They should see how these relate to each other; how much they intersect and interact; what new elements exist in them that can complement the conventional and prevalent discussions among us.

Some should sit down specifically to identify what discussions are currently being raised in the world that may lead to doubts. I have once mentioned that we should not always act defensively against doubts. We should not wait for a doubt to arise - even to be somewhat late in realizing its emergence - to become well-established, to fill minds; at least among some people, among the youth; then they open their mouths and tell us that this doubt exists; then we only start thinking about how to resolve this doubt! This is not correct; we must recognize the grounds for creating doubts.

We have very strong and robust foundations at our disposal; our theology is very strong; our philosophy is very elevated; in our jurisprudence, there are very profound depths that are not seen elsewhere. We should proactively engage with discussions, proactively engage with doubts. This requires planning; these things are not easy without planning; they are not accessible. Sometimes a task with planning may be realized in ten years; however, the same task without planning may take a hundred years to come to fruition. Gradually, someone may emerge to do something; coincidentally, another person may emerge and complement that work. How much redundancy, how much repetition, how many contradictions. With planning, these issues are resolved. This is a very important matter and a very fundamental need.

Of course, I know that in Qom today, there are people of concern and compassion who are seeking this very planning; they are pursuing these matters - whether with these dimensions or more than these dimensions - they want to plan; however, as long as all the effective elements in this vast seminary, including the great authorities, the elders, the scholars, and the distinguished individuals, do not agree on this matter and do not dedicate their efforts to it, this work will not be realized. This is one matter that I believe is very important; because I see that in the seminary, there are scholars, brilliant talents, and outstanding thoughts, and there are young people with youthful energy.

You gentlemen should know that these works are primarily the work of youth; they are mostly related to the youth period. While you have youthful energy, while you have youthful ambition, appreciate it. If a planning system like this is established in a center like the seminary of Qom, then wherever there is talent - for example, suppose in Tehran there are so many scholars, clerics, and young people engaged in academic work, engaged in governmental work in the judicial system, in executive bodies, in ideological, political, and university settings - all of this can gradually be aligned in a straight and coordinated line. All of this can operate within the scope of a complete and comprehensive planning system in the right direction.

The reason I am now bringing this issue up with you - even though you are not in Qom, you are here; even though it has been repeatedly raised, it is discussed with the elders of Qom and others - is that one of the necessary conditions for ensuring the execution of these works is that it should become a culture; everyone should want it; it should become a public demand. Today is not a day for us to waste our human and intellectual resources, the scientific and human capabilities that exist in these elements, to spend them frivolously. Today is a day of need for these matters. Today is not a day for a scholar to sit in a corner of a city or village and say we will write books; they will be useful someday. No; today is a day when all intellectual capital must come into the marketplace of thought, so that it can grow, be exercised, be strengthened, and be utilized. The day has passed when an old woman, for example, would keep some cash in her chest for a rainy day; no, today that cash is invested in a productive endeavor; in a short period, it is multiplied tenfold, benefiting both herself and those who benefit from the circulation of that cash. Today is not a day to hoard resources in a corner. Anyone with talent, anyone with intellectual and cognitive capital, must bring it into the marketplace of work. The marketplace of work is not just a consumer market where one must necessarily be employed somewhere. Of course, the jobs you have, if we do not say all of them, at least a large part of them are religious duties; some of them are even above obligatory duties; because I do not have the capacity for it. This is necessary; but it is not just that; these talents and thoughts must come into action; they must be utilized; they must be strengthened; they must create connections between thoughts.

Another point - which is also related to this issue - is that when there is a vacuum in expressing pure, ancient, and correct ideas, confused, flawed, unhealthy, and incorrect ideas enter the market. This is a natural phenomenon; because the customer is always standing there. If pure, correct, and good products are brought and made available to the people, it is obvious that people will not turn to unhealthy products - of course, if they can recognize them. When a vacuum is created from this side, the market for counterfeit goods and false currency will flourish, and this is something that, unfortunately, we observe in our society today. Counterfeit currencies, very attractive; counterfeit bills, very attractive; but indistinguishable for ordinary people, and of no real value.

In the marketplace of Islamic thought, today it is like this; anyone from any corner appears and expresses opinions about high religious and Islamic concepts and religious concepts - understanding them, perceiving them, and recognizing them requires scientific foundations in religious sources, and they do not have those foundations - and they make statements: Islam says this, Islam says that! At the end of that speech and at the end of that sermon, there is no one to ask them where this Islam you are talking about says this. They also interpret all human concepts from the perspective of Islam - they interpret freedom, they interpret humanity, they interpret human rights, they interpret justice - and it is not clear what their references are; which Islam!?

This is a very ugly incident where individuals without the necessary qualifications enter a domain and make statements that, even if we assume there is no hint of malice or ulterior motives, become ignorant! If there are hints of political motives, factional motives, profit-seeking motives, and treacherous motives in it, then it is even worse! This is a very ugly phenomenon that exists in our society. Of course, it is not specific to today; it has always existed; however, today it has the characteristic that in the past, the ignorant would express opinions about religion; but within limited circles of the uneducated. Suppose someone, under the name of a preacher or by any other name, would say something about religion; there was a limited circle, and there were common people who accepted his words. Today, the difference is that the same erroneous statements regarding the Islamic and scientific foundations of religion, although popular, are expressed in polished forms, in the guise of new thought, in the guise of science, while it is not science; while it is wrong, and this requires scientific engagement. Governmental engagement is separate; governments should not always enter these domains and do not, and it is not correct, nor effective; but the field of science must be active and vibrant in this regard.

Regarding the essence of religion, regarding the philosophy of religion, regarding the foundational beliefs, regarding what has been presented from Islamic teachings that have been framed within the teachings of the Islamic Republic - such as the principles of the Constitution and so forth - discussions are held that are neither based on history, nor on hadith, nor on the Quran, nor on the principles of jurisprudence, nor on recognized religious foundations, nor on the methodology of jurisprudence - which is a very deep and delicate art - they are based on nothing; they are expressed in the forms of pseudo-intellectualism and pseudo-science, with colorful expressions! Those who enter this domain, unfortunately, are part of the elite and the intellectuals of society; this is the difference from the past. It was said:

For this slippery knowledge, when it takes a path

It increasingly enlightens the people.

It strikes at the informed people, it strikes at the path of the informed, it strikes at the path of the elites; therefore, there must be a response. I said, the response here is an intellectual response; it is a scientific response; it is a response in the field of debate; it is courageous. Of course, it is obvious that if we can accept the assumption that there are political motives behind these actions, God forbid there are treacherous motives, there are motives of corruption, then we must be prepared for the fact that if you enter the field of science, they will create a commotion; they will disgrace you; they will slander you; but let them do it.

The scholars of religion must not remain silent in the face of the distortion of religion. An unscientific response to these issues is wrong. We should not raise our voices saying, "Sir, this is blasphemy; let’s declare takfir, what should we do?" This is of no benefit. Many people also like this to happen; as soon as a statement is made, they immediately accuse the person of having said something against Islam, or against religion, or against the guardianship; they immediately cling to this; they enjoy it; because it keeps them away from scientific critique. If there is a scientific critique, then the argument will be dissected and the disgrace of the statement and its author will become clear. This work must be done.

Of course, if someone makes a statement that aligns with the principles we have in jurisprudence and has a punishment in Islam, I do not want to prohibit it or prevent it; no, that is preserved in its own place; but the path that scholars, seminaries, and religious propagators should take is not that; that is the work of the authorities; they must fulfill their own duties; they also have responsibilities; they must certainly carry them out; but the scholars and leaders of religion and the standard bearers of religion must enter the scientific field in these matters; they must discuss the argument, dissect it, and clarify the disgrace of the statement; which will subsequently lead to the disgrace of the author of the statement. "Guidance does not spread except from where misguidance spreads"; this is from the words of the late Sayyid Sharaf al-Din, may Allah's mercy be upon him. How do they spread misguidance? In the same way, guidance must be spread. Just as that ignorant or malicious person - now we do not judge; because both types are possible - has entered the field and has fed people with false knowledge, weak knowledge, rootless and unscientific knowledge under various names and titles, in the same way, the scholars and the people of religion must enter and present the authentic knowledge, the pure knowledge, and explain the incorrectness of that thought.

One should not think that there are no individuals among the seminaries who can do these things; no. Thank God, among these young people and our scholars, there are many; there are many who can do this work. Of course, one person may have the ability to research but may not have the ability to express. One person may be skilled in tracing and can find statements that the researcher cannot access. One person may know a language, for instance, and be able to find the root of this statement in some writing of a foreign jurist or philosopher, while that researcher does not know that language and cannot. They must connect with each other. These works must complement each other. They must help each other to present the correct thought to someone who can present it beautifully and with strong and solid arguments. This is a task that today is among your responsibilities; it is among the responsibilities of the seminaries; it is among the responsibilities of the scholars of religion. One must not be negligent about this; this is very important.

Today, our youth need to be intellectually supported; both those who are in doubt and those who have been affected by doubt and have strayed from the realm of this correct belief, and also those who are among the believers and practitioners; in these, the thought must be deepened; they must be brought in and the doubt must be removed from them. Those who are present must have their beliefs deepened; stability must be instilled in them and they must be fortified.