Statements at the meeting with a group of clerics.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

14 February 1993 · Meeting with a group of clerics

Context
Khamenei addressed a group of clerics, scholars, and students at a meeting on the eve of Ramadan in February 1993, discussing the clergy's historical role in Iran's social and political transformations.
Main themes
Role of the clergy in Iran, Islamic Revolution, thousand-year reputation of scholars, social and political transformations, constitutional revolution, clerical authority and public trust, religious community leadership, month of Ramadan gathering, historical Shia scholars, nation mobilization
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,658
90th percentile
Sentences
261
94th percentile
Readability
61
88th percentile
Grade
9.2
12th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 51%47%
  • Geopolitical 34%31%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

261 sentences in 21 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

First of all, I would like to welcome the esteemed gentlemen; the high-ranking scholars, the eloquent speakers, the preachers, and the respected students who have come from Tehran or other cities. We hope that this meeting and gathering will be among those that bring goodness, blessings, and guidance for ourselves and all believers. It is a good tradition to have an opportunity to discuss some of the issues that are raised in the religious community and among scholars at the threshold of the blessed month of Ramadan.

While I welcome this gathering and thank the esteemed gentlemen for creating this opportunity, I would like to present a matter that pertains to the clergy - from various classes and ranks. The matter is that in our country, at least for the past few centuries, the clergy, due to their special status and their connection with the people and the belief that the people have in them, have been the source of significant social, religious, and political transformations or have played a crucial role in these transformations. Among these are the events of the Constitutional Revolution, the nationalization of the oil industry - at the end of the 1920s and the early 1930s - and most clearly, in the victory of the Islamic Revolution and in the expansion of this movement. Of course, one should not think that it was only the young, passionate, and fervent students who influenced these massive gatherings before the victory. It was not like that. All the gentlemen who were involved in these matters know that in the provinces, the presence of respected scholars and elderly learned men, whom the people had faith in, was very effective. Although these individuals had no prior history in struggles - they had neither been imprisoned, nor had they fought, nor had they written any declarations - when they recognized in the last year and the final months before the victory that they had to enter the field, they did so, and their presence had a tremendous impact in attracting all classes of people. Therefore, in the marches, you could see all segments of the people. The fact that women felt a sense of duty at home; that elderly men felt a sense of obligation; that those who had no history of struggle felt a sense of duty; that people in cities and villages felt a sense of obligation, and suddenly a nation rose up, was because of this; because of the comprehensive presence of the scholars of religion and the clergy, from their elders to their youth, from their aged jurists to their fervent young preachers, when they entered, it meant that all segments of the people would join in. This is the nature of the matter. In Iran, at least in the last three or four centuries, it has been this way. Before this, the situation may have been different. In some other Islamic countries, it may also be the same. We do not judge countries we are not well-informed about; however, our country is like this. It may be that if there are no scholars, a segment of the people may enter the field and a group of society may commit to a struggle; however, suppressing, silencing, and bribing a group is not difficult. A large group that cannot be eliminated and whose path to victory cannot be blocked is the nation. If you want the general public and its segments to be present in one place, the clergy must be there. If the clergy and the scholars of religion are present in a place, it means that all classes, or a decisive majority of the nation, will be present there. This is the nature of our Iran. This is a characteristic that has been proven over many years - indeed, many centuries.

What is the reason for this? The reason is the status of the clergy. I have repeatedly stated that we should not think that the reputation of the current generation of clergy caused the people to lean towards the Islamic Revolution. No; this is a mistake. Rather, it is the thousand-year reputation of the clergy, which is an inexhaustible treasure, that has led to these victories and successes. This thousand-year reputation consists of the credibility that has been gained over centuries from the knowledge and piety of great scholars. That is to say, Allameh Hilli plays a role in this collection; Muhaqqiq plays a role; Majlisi plays a role; the two martyrs play a role; Sheikh Tusi plays a role; Seyyed Mortaza plays a role; Sheikh Ansari plays a role; great scholars over centuries in Najaf play a role; the greats of Qom play a role; the late Haj Sheikh plays a role, and the late Mr. Borujerdi plays a role. In other words, thousands of chosen individuals spent their lives in purity and piety, created high-level scientific collections, and presented scientific works, gradually leading a society and a nation to fundamentally believe in the clergy. It is not that a group of people; that the people of one era and generation want someone, but the next generation does not. When a love becomes fundamental and deep, it is inherited from one generation to the next. Like the love of Hussein ibn Ali, peace be upon him, or the love of the Ahl al-Bayt, peace be upon them. These are not characteristics that one generation has and another wants to acquire. No; these cannot be acquired. They are inherited from one generation to another and manifest in the teachings of fathers, in the upbringing of mothers, in the affection of educators, and in the lullabies of nurses for children. The fundamental establishment of a subject means this, and the belief in the clergy in our society has been and remains fundamental.

When such a thing exists and such an effect like the revolution is associated with it, it is clear that two major events are to be expected. The revolution is no joke! The establishment of the Islamic Republic is no joke! This means a threat to all the powerful and tyrants of the world! The victory of the revolution means the awakening of over a billion Muslims from centuries of slumber. This means that suddenly in all Islamic countries, a group of Muslim intellectuals, scholars, and the masses rise up, clench their fists, and raise the slogan of the revival of Islam. The victory of the revolution means this! The victory of the Islamic revolution is not that four officers carry out a military coup; overthrow a government; bring another one in; and then some others come and overthrow that government and bring in another! The matter of the victory of the Islamic revolution is not like that! The victory of the Islamic revolution means the raising of a flag that the powerful of the world have worked hard to bring down; spent a lot of money; devised many plans; killed many people; and did many things. Suddenly, the Islamic revolution triumphed, and with its victory, all the plans of the powerful were nullified. All those powerful became stalled and confused, and their interests were threatened. This is the meaning of the victory of the Islamic revolution.

Therefore, when this reputation and this transmission of religion and the clergy among the people can have such a significant effect, then two major issues are to be expected: one is that we, the descendants of those pure, learned, and sacred ancestors, must preserve their reputation. Because if this is not done and this generation does not preserve the reputation of the past, what was established and fundamental will gradually fade away and be lost. This is the nature of the matter. Now, how should we preserve their reputation? This itself is a lengthy story.

First of all, they were scholars; we must also strive to advance their knowledge. Their knowledge is a great and important legacy. Four people who have no understanding of legal and jurisprudential issues of Islam, or of Islamic philosophy, or of Islamic theology - even if they have expertise in a particular field - if they insult and belittle, do not pay attention to them. Islamic jurisprudence, and among Islamic jurisprudence, Shia jurisprudence, in terms of advancements and scholarly precision for those who are experts and understand, is a remarkable subject. It is no joke that a person like Sheikh al-Jawahir sits down and writes a complete course of jurisprudence from beginning to end, with all that precision and research, alone, and creates an encyclopedia of Islamic law by himself! This is akin to a miracle. The same goes for Sheikh Ansari. The same goes for Sheikh al-Riyadh. The same goes for other great scholars, both early and later. Sheikh al-Mufid has two hundred works. Allameh Hilli has nearly three hundred works. Khwaja Nasir al-Din Tusi is another case. Sheikh Tusi is another case. These are very significant for those who are experts. Of course, if an ignorant and uninformed person is in a place and a great jurist passes by, for him, there is no difference between that jurist and an uneducated person. If a great physician passes by, for him, there is no difference between that physician and an ignorant person. His judgment is not the criterion; the judgment of the experts is the criterion. The knowledge of Shia is a lofty knowledge that is abundant and significant in both quantity and quality. Do not pay attention to those who stand and belittle and say, "Shia scholars have done nothing." You do not understand what they have done. "You do not know my soul, the error is here." It is not that anyone can stand somewhere and make a critique to the extent that he himself is not an expert in it. This is not the method of scholars; it is the method of fools.

Their knowledge has been abundant. If today's scientific community wants to honor that legacy and preserve that reputation, it must advance in knowledge and make progress. The seminaries in one field and scholars outside the seminaries in another. Suppose you are striving in the field of preaching and teaching. Very well; the statements and discourses must be scholarly. One must avoid weak speech. One must avoid unstudied sermons. The best and latest statements about Islamic issues must be known. Of course, it may be that we go to fewer sermons; that is not a problem. A person who wants to speak well must inevitably speak less: "When one can speak, it is a brick that can be laid." If we want to find the essence, we must indeed strive; there is no other way. Whoever is, for example, engaged in preaching and the specific work of a cleric in universities or in the army or in the IRGC must intelligently and astutely recognize the intellectual needs of that group and its audience. They must see what complexes, ambiguities, and questions their audience has in mind, even if they do not express them. They must solve that problem in a scholarly manner. If they can solve it themselves, and if they cannot, they should go to someone more knowledgeable than themselves to solve the problem. This is how the level of knowledge rises. Everyone, in whatever position they are in - even in jobs that do not directly relate to study and education, such as judicial jobs - must pay attention to these issues. Of course, judicial jobs are scholarly; however, they do not have a direct connection to study and scientific advancement. One is a judge; an Islamic jurist; they must work diligently to find the true divine ruling regarding that event and incident.

This is regarding knowledge. As for piety and virtue, it is clear; a scholar who is greedy for the world is rejected. A scholar who does not avoid the forbidden is rejected. It is not that a scholar should not enjoy the pleasures of life; however, there are levels where a person must truly and justly forgo some pleasures. Scholars, like other people, should enjoy the ordinary pleasures of life; just as God said about the Prophet: "Say, I am only a human like you." But these two things - greed for the world and lack of avoidance of the forbidden - are prohibited. The presence of greed for the world in a scholar - even if, outwardly, they do not commit a forbidden act; but they are constantly seeking to accumulate worldly wealth - is against piety. Or, God forbid, if they do not avoid the forbidden and it is seen that it is easy for them to gossip, to lie, and, God forbid, to commit various forbidden acts. Therefore, this generation is obliged, both through the path of knowledge and the continuation of scientific fields and scientific advancement, and in terms of preserving the credibility of piety and virtue, to preserve the reputation of their ancestors.

Those who want to discredit the Islamic Republic, if they have to, slander and fabricate lies to undermine the virtue and knowledge of the clergy. They spread false news, fabricate false events, and exaggerate small issues to tarnish the reputation of the clergy in the eyes of the people. It is clear that this reputation is very important to them. They know how much difference it makes whether this reputation exists or not. Some also formulate this, dressing it in scholarly and argumentative clothing - as if they are discussing scientifically - that "yes; in the seminary, there is no knowledge and piety!" No, sir; honestly, piety and virtue among this class, relatively, is more than among all other classes. Just look at how much income and salary these seminary students have! Today, the highest salary in the seminary for a learned student - not a student who has just entered the seminary; and not even in Qom, which is the highest seminary - who has a wife and several children and has studied for years, is far less than the average salary of workers and employees in this country. In other words, it is even less than half. Half of the average salary of workers is more than the entire salary of a learned student in our seminary in Qom - I am not even talking about Mashhad; I am not talking about Isfahan; I am not talking about small cities; I am talking about Qom, which is the center! Yet, at the same time, they live with piety and purity. Well, what does virtue mean? What does piety mean? What does indifference to the world mean? It means this. Of course, there are also bad people; there are also cunning people everywhere. But the majority and the prevailing form among the students is what we observe. These distinctions, if they remain in a student during the years they are engaged in their responsibilities, are truly a sign of high status and high rank.

This is the first event and matter that the clergy must think of themselves; think of that legacy; think of that reputation. It is naturally so; but it can be added to that reputation; just as our great Imam added to the thousand-year reputation of the clergy. The Imam multiplied and elevated the reputation of the clergy from the time of Sheikh al-Mufid until today - whatever it was. He demonstrated the power of the clergy in confronting evils and oppression; how a scholar can be the heir of Moses, Jesus, Abraham, peace be upon them, and the Seal of the Prophets, peace be upon him and his family. Woe to those who do not appreciate this high role of that great man and think they are concerned or interested in the clergy! Woe to the ignorance and negligence of these people, who do not know and do not understand what a correct evaluation is!

However, the second event that we should expect when we face such greatness is the enmity of the enemies. You must know that when you are effective in removing oppression from the oppressed, the oppressor will harbor enmity against you. This is a necessary matter that when you are in a position to awaken a nation to confront oppression, you must know that oppression and the oppressor and the conditions that foster oppression will seek to eliminate you and will do whatever they can to negate you. Of course, they are rational - material rationalists, not true rationalists - they will start from the easier paths. First, they will try to perhaps bribe you to remove you from their path. If they cannot, they will threaten; if that does not work, they will act; if that does not work, they will resort to propaganda; if that does not work, they will resort to physical assassination; if that does not work, they will resort to spiritual assassination and discrediting. Ultimately, they want to pour their poison. There is a struggle between you and them, and it is no joke. Know that today, the enemies of Islam are vehemently opposed to the clergy and its valuable scientific legacy that has been present in this country for centuries, as well as to the bearers of this divine trust. They will take action as much as they can, and know that they are more opposed to you than to Islam. If they can separate you from Islam; if they can separate you from your Islamic duties and following them, they will feel at ease, and then you will no longer be considered a danger to them. They are opposed to Islam.

In recent years, that is, for about the past five or six years, the arrogant policies have made every effort to discredit and delegitimize Islam in the eyes of the masses and nations. Not just in the eyes of those who are not Muslim, but in the eyes of Muslim nations! They have tried to make them lose faith in Islam. How? By making their youth disbelieving and preoccupied with corruption; by distracting their minds with doubts and distancing them from that deep faith. They have made efforts in our country as well. In other Islamic countries - in Iraq, in North African countries, and in Eastern Islamic countries - they have done everything they could. One of the topics they have heavily promoted is Islamic fundamentalism! They said: "Islam is different from Islamic fundamentalism. We are not opposed to Islam; rather, we are opposed to fundamentalism!" What does fundamentalism mean? Our understanding of fundamentalism is different from the common understanding of the masses and the mindset of people in the West. Fundamentalism, from our perspective, means adherence to the principles and foundations of religion. That is not a bad thing; we take pride in it. When they say, "Sir, you are a fundamentalist," we say, "Of course we are fundamentalists." We do not deny or reject it. Adherence to principles is not a bad thing! Moral integrity is also a principle; honesty is a principle; justice is also a principle and moral foundation; not betraying is a moral foundation, and denying bad deeds is also a moral foundation. The whole world adheres to these moral foundations and institutions and takes pride in them, and no one considers them bad. We have this interpretation of fundamentalism, and of course, from this perspective, it is correct. We even see that in some countries, governments encourage people to adhere to meaningless, outdated tribal traditions. They dig up the decayed bones of their ancestors from graves and sanctify them! In various European countries, people are encouraged to preserve some of the outdated, meaningless customs and traditions. Therefore, there is nothing wrong with a person adhering to the principles of religion; to the lofty principles of faith and religious knowledge.

According to our view and understanding, this is commendable. However, in Western cultural discourse, fundamentalism is equated with stagnation and a closed mindset that does not understand logic, and in fact, they accuse us of this! They do not say that these people are committed to monotheism. When they say they are fundamentalists, it does not mean that they are committed to monotheism and truthfulness in speech and asceticism towards material phenomena. They say these people are stagnant! They close their eyes to the advancements of the world! This is a slander and a lie. Through this, they want to undermine Islam in the eyes of Muslim societies and make the Muslim masses lose faith in their religion. They also want to increase disbelief among Western masses who are inclined towards Islam. This is one of the actions they carry out alongside their propaganda.

The point that is appropriate to mention here is that they have started insulting Islam and have made it a policy. Of course, when a religion like Islam is sacred in the eyes of a billion-strong community and is the source of movement for that vast community, insulting it is a difficult task. They do not dare to openly insult Islam. Therefore, you see that even the Presidents of the United States and some powerful countries no longer dare to openly express hostility and directly insult Islam. For this reason, they have sat down and found a way: they have decided to find individuals who can act as a shield for them and ask them to insult Islam while posing as intellectuals, poets, and writers, so that gradually insulting Islam becomes common and accepted. This was a task that began with the book "The Satanic Verses" by that apostate individual. He wrote his book in England, and American magazines began to promote it. I remember seeing the American magazines that came here and being astonished at what kind of book they wanted to promote so much!? So many books are written! But there was a reason that suddenly the world's press, the mercenaries of the world, the Zionists of the world - who control most of the press and radio and television in the West - joined forces to promote one book. What was the content of that book? It did not take long to find out what was in this book. This book is meant to pave the way for insulting Islam. It mentions the Prophet and mocks him. It has written a fictional story; it mentions the name of the Prophet, the names of the Prophet's wives, the names of the Prophet's companions, and it has insulted them in a very shameless manner.

When this book became widespread and people read it, gradually insulting Islam became normalized. This is what they wanted! This is where divine inspiration compelled that righteous man to undertake that great movement, and their conspiracies were halted. The Imam, based on this thought and precise and radiant understanding - the light that God Almighty places in the hearts of His servants, shows itself here - issued the fatwa of apostasy against that apostate man and blocked their path. Suddenly, the whole world was astonished! The Imam issued the fatwa of apostasy against an apostate and said: "This man must face the legal punishment." All European governments summoned their ambassadors from Iran. Is this reaction related to an ordinary book? Do the governments of England, France, Italy, and others really care for the life of a human being!? They harvest thousands of humans for a minor issue. Which of them has not done so? Which of them has not caused groups of people to be killed? Which of them, if their interests require it today, would not kill thousands of people? Do they really care for human life? Right now, the Serbs are massacring Muslims; they are not bothered! Right now, the Israelis are torturing the Palestinians, the rightful owners of the land; they are not disturbed! And now, because one person is supposed to be executed, they react in this way!?

This was another matter. The plan that was laid out was a plan to insult Islam. The intention was to belittle Islam. With that fatwa, the Imam suddenly thwarted all their plans. The Islamic world also endorsed it and showed its adherence to the Imam's fatwa. Now some time has passed. That ignorant man and his ignorant supporters think the matter is over. No; this matter is not going to end. At that time, in one of the interviews I had in Europe, when I was asked, "What do you think of the Imam's fatwa?" I said, "The Imam has shot an arrow at this wicked and insulting man. This arrow has left the bow and has been accurately aimed. Sooner or later, this arrow will hit the target. Undoubtedly, this ruling must be executed, and it will be executed." Muslims who can today remove this harmful and malicious being, who has appeared as a base and vile agent for a massive anti-Islamic movement, from the path of Muslims must do so and punish him. It is now the duty of everyone. It is the duty of all those who can take this action and reach this person.

Now they are wondering whether the Imam's fatwa has changed? Can a fatwa be changed? Can anyone negotiate regarding this matter? The British government is unhappy? Well; we are also unhappy with many of the actions of the British government! Does a certain European government get upset? We are also upset with many of their actions. Have we promised that we will not do anything that the British government dislikes!? The British government dislikes nothing more than the independence of Iran. These are the same people who have exploited and plundered this country for many years, and now that the country is independent, they are upset. What should we do? The British government, if it finds the opportunity, would like to stand in the Persian Gulf, just like in the time of "Lord Curzon," and issue orders to the surrounding Gulf states, including Iran! The Iranian nation will not allow it. Whether it is the British government, the American government, or any other bully that wants to interfere in our affairs, our desires, our goals, our great ideals, and our sanctities! What does it have to do with them!? If they want to solve this incident and this problem easily, they should hand over that apostate and heretical individual to the Muslims and say: "This person has committed a crime. You Muslims, carry out whatever punishment you see fit." This is the wise way. They should do this. Why don’t they? We object to them for preventing the Imam's ruling! What objections can they have!? These are warnings for you and me. Know that if we are a little negligent, the enemy will begin to attack and act against our sanctities. This is one example, and there are many similar examples. Our responsibilities are many.

Now Ramadan is approaching. In Ramadan, we must take care of ourselves and also reach out to the people. Moreover, we must know that if we do not take care of ourselves, we cannot reach the people either. The prayers of Ramadan, the fasting of Ramadan, the supplications, the pleas, the remembrances, the supererogatory prayers in Ramadan, all serve to first illuminate ourselves a little. If we become illuminated, then we can reach others as well. Otherwise, if we do not become illuminated, we cannot illuminate others. No matter how much we say, it will be excessive, harmful, and will not be beneficial.

We hope that God Almighty grants us the success to build ourselves and also to help in the construction and spirituality of the people; and may God make the sacred heart of the Master of the Age, may our souls be sacrificed for him, kind towards us and include us in the prayers of that great figure.

And peace be upon you and the mercy of God and His blessings.