Statements at the Question and Answer Session of Tarbiat Modares University

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

3 September 1998 · Question and Answer Session of Tarbiat Modares University · Tarbiat Modares University

Context
Khamenei addressed a question-and-answer session at Tarbiat Modares University on September 3, 1998, responding to student concerns on governance, judiciary, and appointments.
Main themes
Judicial reform, political appointments and integrity, support for three branches of government, unity of revolutionary forces, Afghanistan war concerns, Islamic governance, academic and university development, government accountability, leadership responsibilities
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,903
91st percentile
Sentences
254
93rd percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.90
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Persian

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

254 sentences in 51 paragraphs

I would like to express my gratitude and great pleasure for your presence at this university. You are aware that the university, while contributing to physical development, is also engaged in the training of teachers and professors. As a graduate of the master's program and a doctoral student at this university, I request that, for the sake of blessing and good fortune, you consider covering the costs of the university's sports hall.

The truth is that I do not have any money to give to the university; it is a matter of government funding. I may make a request. I have no objection if it is possible to make a request that could be of assistance.

As you know, reforming society is tied to reforming and strengthening its judiciary. The negative performance of the officials of this branch over the past few years and your support for them has led to despair and hopelessness among graduates of law regarding the reform of the judiciary. As a citizen and someone who is relatively informed about legal issues and the negative impacts of the judiciary's performance on the people's belief in the system, I expect a fundamental reconsideration in this regard.

Of course, I cannot deny the weaknesses of the judiciary; however, it is not the case that everything written by this dear sister or brother is entirely negative; I do not hold that view. There are indeed many good works, outstanding actions, and honorable judges in the judiciary; of course, there are also shortcomings. You should know that I have always supported the three branches and will continue to do so. It is my duty. The heads of these three branches, as long as they are at the helm, will have my support. This does not mean that I agree with everything these three branches do; no. There may be things in the executive and legislative branches that I do not agree with; however, this does not mean that I will withdraw my support. The same goes for the judiciary. Do not complain to me about why I support them; I must support the officials of the branches. Of course, this support is public. In meetings, in directives, and in footnotes, there is criticism, there are objections, and there are directives for certain matters. Yes; of course, in cases where reform is necessary and I can carry it out without interfering in the branch's work in a way that disrupts the system, I will intervene. Sometimes we even reprimand some individuals in private meetings; however, I believe that public moral support for all three branches is necessary; I will continue to support them, God willing.

Text of the Leader of the Revolution's remarks at Tarbiat Modares University

Greetings and wishes for victory and pride for Islam and dear Muslims, especially for you and other servants of the clear Islam. In an Islamic society, the most deserving and capable believers should hold positions and responsibilities. With this introduction, why are the individuals appointed to positions and responsibilities by you neither possessing integrity, nor management skills, nor a passion for service?! I kindly request that you appoint impartial, independent, and capable individuals to strengthen dear Islam and the front of the guardianship.

Of course, you should know that my intention is to see and appoint the best individuals in positions of responsibility; do not doubt this. In the areas you mentioned, for which I did not read the names and responsibilities, I have tried to select the best. Of course, selection is difficult. When one is sitting on the sidelines, they see the flaws. Occasionally, some motivations may interfere, and one may see a flaw as larger than it is; they may not see the merits and may not be able to compare different individuals. This is a very difficult task. Our effort is to utilize good and capable individuals. Of course, we appoint some individuals in certain positions, but after a while, we feel that they are not suitable for those positions; naturally, we remove them; we are familiar with such matters. It is not the case that appointments are always permanent; sometimes there are dismissals as well. However, dismissals can be of two kinds: sometimes they are out of anger and frustration; sometimes, they are based on considerations of expediency. These also exist.

As the Leader of the Revolution, I kindly request that you take measures to prevent us from entering the quagmire of Afghanistan.

If you mean the quagmire of the Afghan war, God willing, such a thing will not happen, and I have been particularly vigilant in this matter and, God willing, will continue to be.

I kindly request that you unite the revolutionary forces to solve the problems of society, so that they avoid division; because our system must be accountable to everyone in both thought and action.

Yes, you are right. My effort is to bring the opposing factions closer together in practice as much as possible. I do not try to merge the factions. I do not see it as necessary, nor possible, and perhaps not even beneficial; however, I strive and wish to bring them closer together in practice. But know that this is not an easy task. There are many motivations at play. If the motivations everywhere were truly pure and divine, things would be much easier. When the motivations are not pure—at least in one place or corner—the task becomes very difficult. Please pray that we can also find success; we will also strive, God willing.

Greetings and wishes for success and health to you. In the university system, there is no law for the transfer of faculty members at our university. This causes, for example, individuals to be forced to reside in an unfamiliar and undesirable city for many years, which greatly affects their motivation. If possible, please take measures so that factors such as the individual's work experience or other merits are considered in the transfers of individuals.

This matter is noteworthy for the responsible officials. I will set it aside, so that, God willing, the officials will see it later and think of a solution.

Why is there no priority given to the employment of graduates from Tarbiat Modares University? Some universities treat the graduates of this university with bias. Another question is that the faculty members in the military service plan of the Ministry of Culture and Higher Education have a poor living situation. Why are no measures taken to improve their situation?

Of course, I was not aware of your first question, and this is the first time I have heard that graduates of this university are treated with bias in other universities. If that is the case, it would truly be regrettable; however, I will set aside your first and second questions so that Dr. Mo'in can address them and, God willing, he will follow up to see what the reason is and what measures can be taken.

Since the esteemed government of Mr. Khatami is elected by the people and approved by you, why do you, as the Leader of the Revolution, not prevent pressure groups from obstructing the lofty movements of this government and do not stop them?

If I see and know that someone is truly obstructing this government, know that I will decisively stop them; I do not consider any favors. My belief is that today everyone must help this government, and if everyone does not help, it will not succeed. The issues of the country are very sensitive, and my advice to everyone has always been and will be this. Any support or assistance that both the President and the members of the government have requested from me and that I have been able to provide, I have done without hesitation, and I will continue to do so. If there are truly individuals who want to cause trouble, I will stop them. Of course, some actions may be oppositional; however, they do not count as obstruction. There are always opponents of governments. If someone is opposed to an issue and also criticizes it, as long as it does not lead to obstruction, it is not a problem; however, if it reaches that point, it will certainly be stopped.

Greetings and thanks for your presence. Despite going through ethical and academic selection processes and having commitment and expertise, unfortunately, we still face problems in attracting and employing these dear individuals and also in the hiring processes at universities. I kindly request that you provide guidance to facilitate this matter.

Of course, I do not get involved in the mechanisms of administrative matters, and if I have any guidance, it is that graduates of this university should at least be able to be utilized throughout the country. The maximum would be to grant them some privileges; because—as mentioned—this university was established with hope, and if privileges are granted to the graduates of this university, it would be appropriate; however, at the very least, there should be no obstacles placed in their way; this is my general statement. Of course, now that these reminders are being repeated, I imagine that, God willing, our brothers should think more about this matter.

The martyrdom of Mr. Lajevardi was painful; because he rendered many services to the revolution. After resigning from his position, he was martyred by the executioners while working in a scarf shop. Shouldn't the Islamic government support and protect individuals who have previously served the sacred system? Will Mr. Khalqali's fate be the same?

I wish you had not given this line to the terrorists! Of course, I do not know whether he had a bodyguard or not. Recently, I read in the newspaper that he himself was not interested in having a bodyguard. The truth is that if a person wants to go and take a free job in the market, having a bodyguard and bringing a bodyguard with them is not very easy. Now, I do not know what the system should have done. For example, should they have prevented him from taking a free job, or should they have given him another job? I really have not thought about this matter. Perhaps it is a reasonable argument to say that those who are at risk of such incidents, for example, when they resign from their official job, should have some form of employment that at least minimizes such dangers. In any case, he was a prominent figure. I knew him before the revolution—in the 1960s. At that time, he was considered a strong individual in the eyes of myself and many others who were in the line of struggle. As I wrote in the announcement of his martyrdom, he was truly a person who was always present in difficult fields and had no hesitation in entering challenging tasks. May God elevate his status. Of course, his fate is something we envy; blessed are they. When I was informed of Lajevardi's martyrdom, I said it was a pity that he died with that background; he should have been martyred. Blessed are they.

You are aware that the elections for the Assembly of Experts are approaching, and unfortunately, the atmosphere of doubt and skepticism regarding the way the qualifications of candidates are examined by the esteemed Guardian Council, for whatever reason, is an undeniable reality. Do you not think it appropriate, as we witnessed from Imam, to intervene in this matter? After all, the examination of candidates' qualifications by the Guardian Council has, to some extent, the problems mentioned by critics. Would it not be better, with your recommendation, for the Guardian Council to refer this matter to the authorities introduced by the Society of Teachers to eliminate this suspicion?

The Guardian Council does not conduct the examinations itself; the examiner is someone else. The administration of the work is in the hands of the Guardian Council; otherwise, the Guardian Council does not have the time to sit and conduct examinations; of course, it has the qualifications, to be fair. The gentlemen who are currently in this council—except for one person who was appointed during my time—are individuals whom Imam appointed; that is, Imam testified to their jurisprudence and justice. Therefore, there is no room for doubt. These esteemed individuals do not conduct the examinations themselves. They bring qualified and impartial individuals from the teachers of Qom and conduct the examinations. The examination is, as they have announced, written; without names and without letterhead. Therefore, there is no suspicion.

This suspicion of doubt that has been mentioned is a false claim; because the current leadership did not appoint this Guardian Council; the previous leadership appointed it. The experts who come do not want to elect the current leadership; they will elect the next leadership. What kind of doubt is this? If this leadership passes away or is removed for any reason, then they will elect the next leadership; otherwise, they do not want to elect the current leader. Therefore, there is no doubt.

You, who are fortunately educated and knowledgeable, should delve into the issues and think. After all, every action and every examination has a reference; some may not accept it. The important thing is that we know this qualification exists there. Both the examiners are reputable individuals, and those who will manage the examination are also worthy people. God willing, no problem will arise.

Since we are talking about the elections of the Assembly of Experts, I would like to say that this election is truly important; it is an exceptional election. Public participation in it is very good and necessary from various aspects. At the very least, it is a national maneuver against foreign enemies. Therefore, you, who are scientific personalities and active youth, should strive and encourage the people to participate in the elections. Of course, the people will participate themselves and will, God willing, choose a qualified candidate in every city and province. This election should, God willing, be a broad and good election.

While appreciating that you have come to this university, I kindly request that you state whether, given the importance of the Assembly of Experts and the unexpectedly silent atmosphere that is currently evident in society on the eve of this election, you do not think it appropriate to give necessary reminders, especially to the Guardian Council, to prepare for this important matter and encourage public participation?

Yes; I find it necessary. Now, the very statement I made here should, God willing, be disseminated and published; and later, God willing, I will recommend it whenever necessary. Both the Guardian Council and the media should prepare the ground, and—as I mentioned—you young people have a role. Strive in this regard, so that, God willing, something good comes out of it.

With greetings and condolences on the occasion of the days of Fatimah. Without making any comments, I kindly request that you instruct a research group to be sent to that university to maintain the dignity of your representative office at the university.

That is fine. I will put this paper in my pocket so that, God willing, there will be action taken on it.

I request that a serious and comprehensive review be conducted regarding the necessity of representative offices in universities. With the dispatch of a number of clerics and those who are at the minimum level in religious matters, do you not think that the image that is formed in the minds of university students is that of a low academic level of the religious seminaries? Do you not think that these offices, since they cannot present strong arguments against university students, are overextending your presence?

Of course, my perception of these brothers who are in the universities is not that they are written as "they are at the minimum academic level." Some of the brothers I know in the universities are very good. Of course, I do not know all of them; because I do not appoint these brothers. I appointed the central committee a few years ago and I trust them; they are prominent individuals. However, some of the individuals who are in the universities, whom I know, are very good. Of course, there was some complaint a few years ago; but in this new form that has emerged and has existed for three or four years, there are capable and good young people in the universities. Some of them are both students and clerics; some are capable clerics, and some are prominent teachers. It is not the case that this brother or sister has written that "they are at the minimum level." Now, if this brother or sister who wrote this point specifies in another letter to me where they are at the minimum level, I will certainly investigate through a reliable source, and if that is the case, I will remind the responsible brothers of this work; however, my assumption is not that.

Regarding the principle of the necessity of this representative office, when we took this action, everyone believed it was necessary and there was a lot of demand; it is still the same now. Of course, some people have approached me and said that these offices are not necessary. If in the university environment, the main goal of establishing these offices—namely, religious nurturing and the existence of a reliable center for religious reference—were present, I would not have taken this action, and it would not have been necessary; however, since it is not, the presence of these brothers is necessary. These brothers can be a source of many blessings in the universities. Young people have religious questions and needs. If a knowledgeable and young cleric like themselves is nearby, it is very valuable. This is how I perceive it.

In a general analysis, the election of Mr. Khatami was a vote for reform and provided a golden opportunity to strengthen the system and insured the Islamic Revolution for years. In this context: 1- What is the reason that your appointees in ... are from the opposing faction of this reform process? 2- Do you also consider the reminder of the duty of the Assembly of Experts regarding the oversight of the Supreme Leader to be insulting and undermining?

The statement that this brother or sister wrote about "a vote for reform" is their analysis; my analysis of the matter is not the same. Ultimately, twenty million people voted for the President with various motivations. How do you know that all these twenty million people voted for reform? They had various motivations; they voted based on these various motivations. What is certain is that this President is elected by twenty million people; this is something valuable. However, that you have conducted a referendum among these twenty million people and they told you that we voted for reform, no; I cannot believe and accept this.

Of course, everyone wants reform; there is no one who does not want reform; nor is there anyone who believes that everything was at the highest level of goodness before this government. No; there have certainly been many issues. When you elect a President, you elect them to address those issues. There is no doubt about this; everyone thinks this way and desires it. If there are elections in the future, it will certainly be the same; there will be some who accept certain things, and some who do not.

The fact that my appointees in those various institutions are opposed to this process, no; I do not accept this. No; they are also supporters of reform. Those whom I mentioned here—though I will not name them—are individuals who love reform; many of them love the government; they love Mr. Khatami and cooperate with him. In my opinion, such judgments are somewhat speculative and inappropriate.

Regarding whether you consider the reminder of the duty of the Assembly of Experts regarding the oversight of the Supreme Leader to be insulting, I must say no, what insult? The Assembly of Experts has a commission called the "Research Commission"; its investigation is according to the Constitution itself. The investigation is to determine whether this leadership, which the Experts once determined to meet the conditions, still meets those conditions or not? This is their job; they are still there and are working. They must determine whether the knowledge that was once determined to be scholarly still remains; because a person may forget and naturally lose their qualifications. They determined that this person is just; is he still just or not? If, God forbid, a sin occurs from him, he loses his justice. They determined that this person is a manager and capable; but now they must see whether his capability remains? Did they make a mistake that day? Or if he was capable that day, has he lost his capability? No; I neither feel undermined nor insulted; this is part of the Constitution. I myself was part of this Assembly of Experts during Imam's time. We had a "Research Commission" during Imam's time as well; there is no problem with that. This is neither an insult to the leadership nor undermining the leadership. If these gentlemen do not form this commission and this body, they should be asked why they did not form it.

If we consider three important educational, research, and training missions for the university, the "training" role, which precedes other roles, is closely related to the representative office of the Supreme Leader in the university and cultural councils. Unfortunately, there are individuals in such institutions and councils who sometimes can hardly tolerate hearing opposing views and are even from a specific faction, and in some cases, the composition of all members of research councils, such as educational, research, and cultural councils in some universities is almost uniform, and in fact, they do not allow others in. Please clarify our legal and religious duties.

The fact that they cannot tolerate hearing opposing views now, may God grant them patience to be able to hear opposing views! Of course, it is difficult. Let me tell you that I myself was President for eight years; I have been engaged in my current duties for eight or nine years. Contrary to the public perception that anyone who comes to us praises us and compliments us, no; it is not like that. Most of the people who come to us point out the issues. They either mention our personal issues or the issues of our appointees—like what you are writing here now—or they mention the issues of the government, which they consider to be my issues, or they mention the issues of the current situation, which they also consider to be my issues: there is poverty in such and such a place, there is weakness in such and such a place, there is underdevelopment in such and such a place. I regularly hear these things and I know that it is very difficult; you should know this. You look from afar and do not know how hard it is. Hearing opposing views and tolerating opposing views is not an easy task.

Of course, anyone who accepts responsibility must also have tolerance. The brother who manages the representative office at the university must certainly cultivate this tolerance within himself. Of course, I do not expect him to have as much tolerance as I do; but he must have it to the extent of that responsibility; there is no doubt about that.

As for your claim that there is a specific faction, I do not know. Unfortunately, the discourse of factions and lines has become overly widespread. Of course, a little of it is not bad; it is a seasoning in the system! As they say, the right wing, the left wing; they even take pride in it. I do not like these names—right and left and the like—at all. When it takes over all aspects of life, it truly becomes tedious and repulsive. We should not rely too heavily on these factions and such things.

After the election of Mr. Khatami, the scientific and political atmosphere of the universities has improved towards becoming more Islamic, and glimmers of hope have begun to shine more; however, we still have a long way to go to reach the lofty Islamic goals in the universities. It is expected that more support, beyond what exists, will be provided in all scientific and research aspects for universities, faculty members, students, completing education, and other matters; however, the limited resources of the ministries do not fully provide this possibility. What guidance and direction do you have in this regard?

First of all, I thank you for writing as a faculty member of the Medical Sciences University that after the election of Mr. Khatami, these good events have occurred in the universities, and I am very happy. Such encouraging words are rarely said to us! When someone tells us that this good event has occurred, it truly earns them a reward; because it makes us genuinely happy; thank God. We hope that this blossoming will improve day by day. As for the deficiencies and limited resources, the answer is the same as I provided for another note; this is in the hands of the government agencies. Of course, I will make the necessary recommendations. I will set this letter aside to give to Dr. Farhadi.

Why are the scientific capabilities within not being used effectively to solve problems? Why are we looking outside and relying on foreigners and foreign investments instead of depending on the faithful and specialized minds within? Did the revolution suffer any harm from relying on internal forces during the victory and the war that it would do so in reconstruction? Even if reconstruction were to take place relying on foreigners, what honor does that bring us? Tomorrow they will claim that we helped. Did our revolution not succeed with the slogan "Neither East nor West"?

I do not know what this brother or sister means by "relying on foreigners." We have never wanted to rely on outside help. Right now, in the field of construction, in architecture, in infrastructure projects—dams, roads, railways, large factories, power plants—work is being done inside the country by our own elements that was previously unimaginable.

In the early days of the revolution during my presidency, there was talk about how to let our engineers build these dams. Some people shouted, "How can that be?!" Then, coincidentally, I went to Khuzestan for a project; the brothers of the Jihad for Construction took me and showed me a massive silo of forty to fifty thousand tons that they had built themselves. A silo—according to what I have heard—is among the relatively complex tasks in architecture. In the past, the silos in Iran were built by the Russians. The regime obtained wheat from the Americans; its silos were built by the Russians! An Iranian engineer would not even allow himself to engage in such work. I saw that the young men of the Jihad for Construction—who had not created a lofty title for themselves—had built such a magnificent structure. My heart truly strengthened, and we pursued it. Now, in the country, dams, roads, massive infrastructure projects, factories, and power plants are being built, and we do not have any reliance on the outside in this sense.

If the intention is foreign investment, which has been approved by law and the government is pursuing it; in our opinion, under the conditions specified, there is no objection. This is something that is beneficial for the country. This foreign investment, to the extent that it does not conflict with the laws, is not a bad thing and does not contradict independence; sometimes, necessities require it. Of course, we have not had much success in this area yet; you should know that as well. The government is making significant efforts to attract investments; however, it has not yet materialized as it should. In any case, this is not a bad thing. No; I do not think there is any cause for concern in this regard. We are proudly seeking the faithful and specialized minds within.

A large volume of questions from brothers and sisters remains; however, time has run out, and I am truly tired. I will take these questions with me; however, answering each one of them is almost impossible for me; because I do not have the time, and such an opportunity is not available to me. At the same time, I hope to be able, God willing, to ask a few of the brothers and assign them to look into these questions. They know my opinions; perhaps, God willing, they can answer the questions and send them to the university. Since these questions are not signed, I do not know how to distribute them and get them to the questioners. Ultimately, we must think of a solution for this.

Our meeting today was a good one. If I had not been tired, I would have continued; but please acknowledge that it has been one hour and forty-five minutes that I have been speaking with you. May God Almighty accept it and look upon this meeting of ours with favor and grant acceptance to what we have said and heard and to our intentions for His sake and in His way, and accept it with His grace and favor.

And peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.