The President's speech during the 2nd plenary session at the Arraiolos Group summit.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

11 October 2019 · 2nd plenary session at the Arraiolos Group summit

Context
Duda addressed the Arraiolos Group presidential summit on October 11, 2019, speaking on European security, NATO commitments, and regional defense cooperation.
Main themes
European security and defense, NATO eastern flank, transatlantic cooperation, Russian Federation threats, territorial integrity, Central and Eastern Europe, PESCO and EU defense initiatives, defense spending commitments, Poland's geopolitical position, energy security, historical memory of war
Duration
~9 min
32nd percentile
Words
1,086
32nd percentile
Sentences
36
22nd percentile
Readability
24
7th percentile
Grade
17.0
89th percentile
Syntax
3.50
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
72nd percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 78%78%
  • Economic 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

36 sentences in 16 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I speak as a representative of a nation that throughout its history has come to know the high price that must be paid for the security of its borders and the maintenance of territorial integrity; we are very sensitive to this. This was reminded to the whole world by the recent celebrations of the 80th anniversary of the outbreak of World War II in Warsaw. (…) This is one of the reasons why, after the fall of communism, Poles were so eager to connect with the structures of the North Atlantic Alliance and the European Union. After successful integration, millions of Poles breathed a sigh of relief and hope that for future generations the horror of war and totalitarian enslavement would remain only a tragic memory, which is indeed taught in history lessons, but whose repetition would be impossible.

Unfortunately, over the last decade we have painfully awakened from this beautiful dream. The offensive of the so-called Islamic State, civil wars in North Africa, rising tensions in the Middle East, the intensification of separatism in the heart of the Old Continent, and finally, last but not least, the destabilizing actions of the Russian Federation in Georgia and Ukraine have brutally reminded us that living in peace is not a given forever, and that state borders, even here in Europe, are not an "inviolable sanctity."

It is completely natural that in this new reality Poland, along with other countries in the region, is seeking to strengthen the guarantees of its security – it does so by investing in national defense capabilities, but it also does so by strengthening old alliances and opening up to new forms of cooperation – specifically cooperation in the field of security and defense.

Dear Presidents,

Central and Eastern Europe remains the place on the map of the Old Continent where the convergence of our strategic interests and the need for allied cooperation is particularly evident. An example of successful cooperation in this region is the Bucharest Nine initiative, which unites the efforts of its participants to ensure a strong, credible, and balanced NATO military presence on its eastern flank.

I am aware that the leaders present here may have different views regarding the degree of NATO's engagement in this area; we differ in our positions on how strong a pressure we should exert on the Russian Federation, for instance. However, please understand that the countries that Russia still considers to be its "traditional sphere of influence," which are within the direct range of ballistic missiles from the Kaliningrad Oblast, and which observe Russian military exercises simulating an attack on their capitals, have a particular perspective on this situation. Our concerns should not and cannot be dismissed. Everyone should keep this in mind before criticizing our efforts for increased U.S. engagement on our territory, whether in terms of military security or energy security. If one takes into account that due to historical circumstances, most, if not all, of our supplies – for instance, gas – simply come from Russia.

Poland and other countries in the region operate on the assumption that to ensure peace in Europe, transatlantic cooperation at all levels: operational, expert, and political is a requirement that is not open to discussion. However, it must have solid foundations in the form of responsible and solidarity-based co-financing. Poland, in its specific geopolitical realities, has long understood that systematically increasing defense spending is key – we are pleased that today more and more NATO member states are increasingly fulfilling their allied commitments in this area. I believe that we have all understood that such action is in the vital interest not only of the eastern flank of the Alliance but today of all of Europe.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I am pleased to note that security issues have finally found their rightful significant place in the agenda of the European Union. The Common Security and Defense Policy should keep pace with new challenges, also strengthening the role of the EU as a global actor and a trustworthy partner in relations with the USA and Canada. New defense initiatives, such as Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO), the European Defense Fund (EDF), and the Coordinated Annual Review on Defense (CARD), have the chance to genuinely enhance our military capabilities and encourage Europeans to take greater responsibility for their own security.

The mentioned initiatives also have economic justification: by pooling their resources, EU member states can achieve much greater efficiency, collaborate in developing more advanced technologies, and produce better military equipment than they could do acting alone. EDF, PESCO, and CARD have the potential to succeed, but only if they help build European capabilities in an integrative manner and create new vectors of cooperation in the defense industry across the Union.

Nevertheless, certain general assumptions of the Common Security and Defense Policy should be clearly explained. First and foremost, clarification is needed on what exactly is meant by "strategic autonomy" – autonomy of whom from whom? – because that is the fundamental question. Poland would rather see strategic effectiveness, built through increasing our collective resilience, combat readiness, mobility, and raising the overall level of development of member states – as I have already mentioned in the previous part of our discussion. Under no circumstances should our European initiatives be aimed at weakening transatlantic ties or competing with NATO. Therefore, if the term "EU strategic autonomy" is understood as opposition to U.S. engagement in Europe, it not only contradicts the Polish vision of developing European defense but also genuinely undermines the security of the entire United Europe.

I would like to point out that the benefits of transatlantic cooperation are clearly mutual. Not only do EU member states benefit from the presence of NATO structures on their territories, but NATO also benefits from, for example, advanced EU projects aimed at improving crisis management capabilities or logistical facilitation that increases military mobility, which should remain the flagship project of our cooperation.

In summary: I encourage all of you to support all initiatives aimed at increasing security on the eastern flank of the EU and NATO; I assure you that Poland views its intensified cooperation with the USA not as an alternative to cooperation with the EU, or within it, but merely as a valuable complement and strengthening of it.

As for the Common Security and Defense Policy – all initiatives that will be complementary and synergistic to NATO, and that will serve to maintain transatlantic relations rather than marginalize them, can count on our support.

Thank you.