President: We must calmly wait for them to leave.

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

26 February 2019

Context
Duda addressed newly elected Presidents of the Supreme Court's Disciplinary and Extraordinary Control Chambers at a ceremony in Warsaw on February 26, 2019.
Main themes
Judicial reform in Poland, Supreme Court chamber elections, rule of law, judicial accountability, Disciplinary Chamber, Chamber of Extraordinary Complaints, public trust in judiciary, image of Polish justice system, judicial ethics
Duration
~11 min
37th percentile
Words
1,274
37th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 66%65%
  • Ceremonial 20%20%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

81 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Esteemed Presidents,

Honorable Chairman, Distinguished Guests, but above all, Esteemed Presidents of the Supreme Court Chambers and Honorable Judges, All Friends and Closest Associates of the Presidents!

I congratulate and thank you. I congratulate you on the election made by the judges serving in the chambers of the Supreme Court. I thank you, Judges, for gathering and for making this choice. From my perspective, it is very important, as it is the election of Presidents in two newly established chambers of the Supreme Court. Chambers that are very important, chambers that were created with the aim of changing the image, changing primarily the social opinion about not only the Supreme Court but above all the Polish justice system.

Because the Supreme Court is the most talked about. The Supreme Court is often mentioned in the media, we hear about the judgments and rulings of the Supreme Court much more frequently than about the rulings of other courts, primarily I think of common courts. And as a result, what happens in the Supreme Court is under particular social and media scrutiny. Consequently, apart from personal encounters with the justice system, it creates what we call the opinion about the Polish justice system, Polish judiciary in the eyes of Polish society.

It is very important for people to feel that the courts are fair. It is very important for people to feel that the courts in Poland make good judgments. It is very important for people to feel that judges – of course, they are a special social group, a special professional group, serving – but that it is a service to society. And that if a judge does not behave in a dignified manner, does not behave ethically, does not behave lawfully, they are particularly stigmatized, also in a professional sense.

I would like to thank the Disciplinary Chamber for its work so far. I have read in the media about the rulings issued by the Disciplinary Chamber, about how decisively those among the judicial ranks who violate the law are treated. Thank you for that. It is extremely important for restoring a good or the best image of the justice system. As I said, a judge has a very special social role. It is a power, the third power. Special requirements must also be placed on a judge. It cannot be that a judge is someone above the law or someone who feels they are above the law, and therefore is unpunished. No! On the contrary – they are subject to the law in a special way. Special requirements are placed upon them.

They are to be a model. Who is to uphold the law if not the judge? Can we demand that an ordinary citizen uphold the law if judges do not uphold the law? If judges ostentatiously disregard it? The question is rhetorical. Therefore, I thank you that this responsibility is being particularly emphasized here. This is certainly the right way to repair the image of the Polish justice system.

I know that it is difficult. I know that it is a responsible role – you are also from this environment. I know that it often meets with ostracism, with social and environmental dissatisfaction. But it is necessary. It must be performed in a state that is a rule-of-law state, a democratic state, and above all one that wants to be a just state. And I very much want Poland to be a just state – just in reality and one in which people have a sense of justice in the justice system.

That is why I thank you for this election and I believe that the President will perform this function well, that the chamber will be able to work calmly, that the judgments issued will be balanced and that you, Judges, will be able to function in a way that is socially expected, that you will present such an attitude. You have made your choice. I believe that the President of this extremely important role, a unique role also in the Supreme Court – alongside the First President of the Supreme Court – will manage. I wish this to you, Mr. President, from the bottom of my heart.

The Chamber for Extraordinary Complaints – also exceptional. It has raised many doubts, particularly in the media. I must tell you that I had no doubts. I knew perfectly well what the structure of the legal institution of extraordinary complaints is. The fear of a flood of complaints, undermining all cases in Poland… Let us remember that the extraordinary complaint goes through responsible bodies: through the Attorney General, through the Commissioner for Human Rights. I have never feared that a flood of extraordinary complaints would reach the Supreme Court, that this newly established chamber would not be able to cope with them, that there would be many undermined judgments. No. Ladies and gentlemen, a double filter, or even a triple one, one could say.

On one hand, the preparation of the extraordinary complaint itself, on the other – the bodies that consider whether to submit it or not. Finally, thirdly – a special chamber in the Supreme Court that is to consider these matters: the Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs. A chamber that also has a unique role, because we all know that there are legal rulings in Poland that are unjust, which – perhaps strangely – were issued in violation of rights, even subjective rights. That they exist, and that they carry a deep sense of injustice to the citizens affected and to those who know about them and know what they have caused. And here, precisely, repair is needed. And here, precisely, change is needed. And here, precisely, verification is needed. In order to restore a sense of justice in this regard.

Madam President! A serious role to fulfill. I have no doubt that it will be performed not only very well from a substantive point of view, but that it will also be performed perfectly from an organizational point of view. Leading this chamber is also a matter of great responsibility, but I am convinced that you, with your professional and life experience, will excel in these roles.

And finally, the last issue. I know, because I am also an observer and participant in public life, that many situations occur in the Supreme Court today that can be described as unpleasant. For you as experienced lawyers, as honest and reliable people – I have no doubt about that. I ask you to endure this calmly.

Those who humiliate you, and I know that this happens, with various kinds of terms… Unfortunately, I think of situations that occur within the Court itself, from judges, very often from high-ranking judges. [These situations] are very unpleasant, but in fact, they testify to themselves. If someone humiliates another person with various kinds of terms or actions, they primarily testify to themselves. And they show that they have no moral qualifications to be a judge.

Because a judge cannot humiliate another person, whoever they may be, even if they are a multiple offender, a murderer – they must treat them with respect. This is the essence of the justice system. These people testify to themselves that they should never have been nominated to this highly specific service. I ask you to approach it this way.

There is no other way. One must calmly wait until they leave. Thank you.

President of the Republic of Poland Andrzej Duda

Speech during the ceremony of appointing the presidents of the Chamber of Extraordinary Control and Public Affairs and the Disciplinary Chamber of the Supreme Court.