The speech of the President of the Republic of Poland at the conference "Together for the Constitution, together for local government."

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

11 October 2017 · Conference "Together for the Constitution, together for local government" · Presidential Palace

Context
Duda addressed a conference at the Presidential Palace on October 11, 2017, discussing local government's constitutional role and potential legal reforms in Poland.
Main themes
Local government in Poland, constitutional foundations of local government, decentralization of state power, history of Polish administrative law, interwar legal scholars, post-1989 democratic transformation, reform and improvement of local government law, regional and municipal self-government
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,587
69th percentile
Sentences
111
68th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
12.6
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%65%
  • Ceremonial 19%19%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

111 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Minister,

Esteemed Ministers,

All Distinguished Guests,

Representatives of All Levels of Local Government,

Honorable Marshals, Starosts, Presidents, Mayors, and Village Heads,

Esteemed Councilors,

Representatives of All Local Governments – both local, referring to municipal and county governments, as well as regional governments,

All Distinguished Experts,

Dear Guests!

Thank you very much for coming to the Presidential Palace for this important meeting for me. I am immensely grateful to you, Ministers, representatives of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Ministry of Health, and the Ministry of Regional Development, who specialize in cooperation with local government units and their bodies. Thank you for your presence, as it – from my perspective – demonstrates a serious approach to this topic, as well as a goodwill for cooperation.

I have invited all of you here for a discussion about the place of local government in the system of the Republic. It is unnecessary to say that it is significant, as I believe none of us has any doubts about that. Today, local government is regulated in the Constitution of the Republic, it finds its place within it. But this is not a new matter and it is not some kind of anomaly. It can be said that in this regard we have a great historical tradition – starting from 1791, when in our first constitution, which is also one of the first constitutions in the world – the Constitution of May 3 – there was indeed this special element: the law on cities. And the seeds of municipal self-government appeared in this legal act, which we still take pride in today. Later, of course, in our constitutions of the free Republic after 1918 – the March and April constitutions – local government was present.

Was it easier then than it is today? I would say it was probably more difficult. Especially right after 1918, when our experts, professors primarily of administrative law and administrative procedure, met with practitioners of local government from partitioned states – because many Poles functioned within the structures of local government of partitioned states. They all met and began a discussion about the shape of Polish administrative law and Polish local government in the reborn, independent, and sovereign state. How to build it so that it is a state in which decentralization functions, which has modern systemic solutions.

These are the names of professors who have gone down in the annals and great history of Polish law, including administrative law, such as Professor Jaroszyński, Professor Panejko, Professor Marian Zimmermann, Professor Tadeusz Bigo, or Professor Franciszek Longchamps – great creators of Polish administrative law during the interwar period, who were educated during the times of partition, and who dedicated their entire adult lives to scientific work and translating it into the practice of the Second Republic – a free, independent Poland. The achievements of these people are still undisputed today and were later a great cornerstone laid for the reconstruction of Polish local government after 1989.

I will leave aside the period between 1945 and 1989; I will not comment on those times anymore. It is enough to say that local government as this extremely important branch, which decentralizes the state, decentralizes state power, did not actually exist then. Because national councils cannot be called a type of power leading to such a systemic solution.

Thus, local government revived after 1990 and – ladies and gentlemen – it must be said that it is reviving successfully. Whether it was a success or not – it is enough to look at how our local government is evaluated today from the perspective of those countries that are developing, those that are seeking membership in the European Union, those where democratic transformations are still taking place, where it is said that our transformations related to the establishment of local government, with its shaping, belong to exemplary models.

But we, being here, in our own backyard, observing these nearly 30 years of local government functioning, have many comments on this. In fact, just a moment ago, on the floor below, a meeting of the newly established team for reviewing local government law in a broad sense took place, introducing improvements, amendments, filling gaps – those that, from the perspective of people who have been dealing with local government issues for years and the functioning of authorities at the local or regional level, are today a sore point. These are elements that require repair or improvement. I am very pleased that this discussion is taking place.

But I am also glad that you are here, at this debate, which has a constitutional character. Because – as I said at the beginning – local government is now inscribed in the Polish Constitution, where we have its fundamental systemic foundations. And against this backdrop, a whole series of very serious questions arises today regarding the functioning of local government.

For example, is it enough that the municipal government is inscribed in the Constitution as the basic, first level of local government, as local self-government, while the other two levels – county and regional – are not inscribed in the Constitution? Is this a sufficient solution for the future from a systemic perspective? Or should further levels of government also be inscribed? Is the autonomy of local government guaranteed constitutionally, by laws, and by the European Charter of Local Self-Government sufficiently well constructed in this constitutional context? That is, one can ask questions in both directions: is local government sufficiently autonomous, or, as some claim, is it overly autonomous? Is it not the case that in some areas, supervision over local government, which always in some sense limits autonomy, should be increased?

I smile because I see how Minister Chwałek is looking at me; I know what it is about – the Act on Regional Audit Chambers. By the way, at your request, I directed it to the Sejm for reconsideration. I smile and I will say this: of course, there were very serious reservations regarding the solutions that were inscribed in the act. But only regarding some of them. They were indeed significant enough that I decided to – as it is colloquially said – veto it, that is, direct it to the Sejm for reconsideration, for further deliberation.

Unfortunately, the President cannot selectively challenge fragments of the law. The constitutional, systemic solution is such that the presidential veto, that is, the request for reconsideration, always covers the entire act; one cannot indicate individual provisions that the President considers to require reconsideration, while the rest of the act may remain. Is that good or bad? I do not want to assess that at this moment. Sometimes it seems that it is not the best, because as a result, parts of the act that carry beneficial solutions also fall away, and in this act – in my opinion – there were such parts as well.

However, I considered that to some extent, the introduction of very far-reaching interference in the functioning of local government is too strong, goes too far, creates too many possibilities for action with simultaneously too many undefined concepts. But I will set this issue aside for now. The question is as follows: whether and in which elements to possibly strengthen this supervision? Should this supervision be exercised by government administration bodies, primarily by the Prime Minister and the Minister of Internal Affairs, directly? Or could this supervision be broader in terms of subject matter, but carried out, for example, through administrative courts?

These are, ladies and gentlemen, the questions that arise. I am not saying that these are questions for a constitutional referendum, as they are too detailed for such a referendum. But if we are debating the very issue of the potential shape of the future Constitution – what directions we want to be set for the Republic in the coming years and indicated to experts as those that should be taken into account when developing either a new Constitution or constitutional solutions – because I do not want to prejudge that at this moment – I would like us to actively discuss these topics among experts.

Because if we are talking about creating a strong Republic for the future – a modern state that responds to the challenges of contemporary times, which takes into account the most modern models in its systemic solutions, allowing the state to develop in the most efficient way – both from a systemic-political, social, and economic perspective – I would like such a discussion to take place between the President and experts, among the experts themselves, but also between the President, experts, and society. Because what is the essence of local government? It consists of two elements: the territorial area and its residents.

Surely all of you know perfectly well that this basic unit of local government – as well as each larger one – consists of the area of territory and the people who inhabit it. That is, there is no separation between the territory and the residents, that is, the participants of the local government unit. It is the land and the people who live on it. Therefore, the essence of self-government lies in ensuring that these people are as involved as possible in the functioning of local government.

This is what self-government means to me and this extremely important element of the activity of local government and its units that should be realized – that is, building and creating a civic society that is oriented, interested in its immediate surroundings, and in public matters that are carried out in that environment. Is this sufficient in our country? I am afraid it is not.

A few years ago, my daughter, then still attending middle school, was assigned a task to conduct a survey regarding local self-government and how ordinary citizens are engaged in local and regional matters. I told her: “Listen – this is happening in Krakow – the matter is trivially simple. We write a survey, you go out to the Planty and simply ask 100 people. I know it will take a long time, many people will refuse to answer you, and you will probably even encounter unpleasant reactions. But we will come up with a not too long survey, with 10 questions, so that you can conduct it on 100 people – it may not be a large sample, but for your middle school level, it may be enough to gain some orientation. Are they able to name at least one city councilor? Are they able to indicate who the president of Krakow is? Are they able to name at least one councilor in the regional government? That is, in the regional self-government assembly, in Małopolska. Are they able to provide the name of the marshal of the region?”

And as far as I remember, we came up with 10 such questions. Ladies and gentlemen, the recognition of the president of Krakow was very high, that is, an absolute majority of respondents were able to say who the president of Krakow is. And basically, that was where the survey ended. In the remaining areas, sweet ignorance prevailed. There is a city councilor from Krakow here, Mr. Ryszard Kapuściński, looking at me with a smile, but unfortunately, Mr. Ryszard – he and I sat together in the city council when I was there for a year – this knowledge of the specifics is very low. And this, ladies and gentlemen, is today one of the problems that I would also like to address in this broad discussion about building the system of the Republic.

What to do – although this is a discussion more with sociologists, but also with representatives of local government – to make residents more interested in their local and regional affairs? That is, in the place where today the most money is to be distributed, where – as we know – so much political attention is focused like in a lens and so much depends precisely on that place: how the region will develop, how individual counties and municipalities will develop. What can be done to ensure that this development is carried out in the regions in a proportional manner? So that in this sense it is development within the region that is as balanced as possible?

And on the other hand, from the perspective of the President of the Republic of Poland, who is responsible, among other things, for the indivisibility of the territory of the Republic – what to do to ensure that Poland does not become excessively regionalized? That is, to prevent pathological regionalization of the country. Only to ensure that it is a regionalization that is beneficial for the economic and political system, and above all for the construction of a unified society, which is the absolute engine of the proper development of the country in the full sense of the word. These are today, ladies and gentlemen, the fundamental questions.

Of course – if during our discussions you have proposals for questions for a consultative referendum that I want to conduct regarding the Constitution, I will gladly listen to such proposals, we will gladly accept such proposals, because I definitely want to conduct this referendum, I would like it to take place. It is extremely important to me that Poles indicate what their vision of the state is, not just for us – as we sit here in this room – but for our children, our grandchildren, and God willing, for our great-grandchildren.

But if the Constitution that is currently in force has – someone might say "only," I would say "already" – 20 years, because that is almost half of my life, I assume that if we were to carry out such a significant constitutional reform or introduce a new Constitution – it would again be a constitution for 20, 25, or 30 years. I assume that the Constitution from 1997 is still a constitution that should last at least 25 years, because I do not expect that we would introduce a new regulation in this area within two or three years.

However, we know very well that it has its shortcomings and deficiencies. For instance, it does not take into account our membership in the European Union and the North Atlantic Alliance, and as a result, questions arise regarding the guarantees of our sovereignty. How should these guarantees be shaped? Are they strong enough, considering the current solutions? Or should they be strengthened? Or does someone believe that they should be weakened? This is the element that – in my opinion – is also necessary for discussion in the context of this systemic debate, this constitutional debate.

Once again, thanking you for being here today at the Presidential Palace, I invite you to listen to the statements of the panelists and to discuss this topic. Because for me – as the President of the Republic, and also as a lawyer who has dealt with administrative law and administrative proceedings for years, but inevitably also started to engage, albeit more from a practical perspective, in purely systemic matters, for instance when I worked here, in the Chancellery of the President and in the Presidential Palace, as the minister and lawyer of President Professor Lech Kaczyński, representing him also before the Constitutional Tribunal – these discussions are extremely interesting, and your voices, as practitioners and also as experts, are of great importance to me.

So once again, thank you for your presence and I invite you to the discussion.

Thank you.