Statement of the President of the Republic of Poland

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

2 June 2023 · Presidential Palace

Context
Duda addressed press at the Presidential Palace on June 2, 2023, explaining his decision to sign legislation establishing a commission to investigate Russian influence in Poland from 2007 to 2022.
Main themes
Russian influence investigation commission, Polish national security, gas contracts and energy policy, constitutional legitimacy of the commission, judicial review and appeals process, public support for transparency, political accountability, PO-PSL government decisions, media controversy and disinformation
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,861
74th percentile
Sentences
118
71st percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.0
56th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
16th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 87%86%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

118 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Good morning, I warmly welcome you all!

Thank you for coming to the Presidential Palace in connection with the actions I am taking today as part of the prerogatives granted to the President of the Republic of Poland.

Ladies and gentlemen, as you have also heard in this room, on Monday I announced my strong support for the bill establishing a special commission to investigate the issue of Russian influence in the Republic of Poland, particularly its impact on the security of our country from 2007 to 2022. My support for this bill has materialized in the form of signing it and sending it for publication, thus bringing it into effect. This decision was absolutely unequivocal, and I am completely convinced of its correctness. Moreover, public opinion research published not long ago – indeed, published yesterday – showed that the majority of Poles want such a commission.

With great interest, I also listened to a whole range of media comments, as well as discussions that took place in the media, including with Prime Minister Waldemar Pawlak. In my speech, which also took place on Monday, but in the afternoon, I mentioned that I would like to know why Poland entered into certain gas contracts under specific conditions, which resulted in gas being supplied to Poland at certain prices. As the media reported at that time, we were paying more for gas than Germany.

I wanted to know why this was happening, just as – I believe – many of our fellow citizens would like to know. In a conversation I heard, conducted on one of the online portals, Prime Minister Waldemar Pawlak was responding to a journalist's questions on this matter, stating, among other things, that one should ask Minister Wojciech Jasiński about it, and that the reason for the decisions made at that time by the PO-PSL government was what had happened earlier.

This clearly shows, ladies and gentlemen, how necessary this commission is and how much we need clarification on such matters. I would like both Prime Minister Waldemar Pawlak and Minister Wojciech Jasiński to testify before this commission so that Poles can hear these statements and so that the commission can also gather all expert data.

However, there is much discussion around the commission, there are many protests regarding the commission, and there are also many untruths that have appeared in the media. These arise partly from bad faith, from attempts to torpedo the commission, and, unfortunately, also from a lack of knowledge and professionalism among commentators.

Ladies and gentlemen, I want to say clearly and unequivocally: this law provides for the possibility of appealing the commission's verdict to the court. It provides for this because such a formula is generally provided for in the Polish legal system. In the form that any administrative decision – unless the law states otherwise – is subject to appeal to the provincial administrative court, and that is the general rule.

Therefore, it was not necessary to introduce such a solution in this law if the legislator intended to establish the principle that this appeal is governed by general rules, because it simply applies – and that’s it. Consequently, in the form in which this law exists today, anyone can appeal such a decision issued by the commission to the administrative court. Thus, there is no doubt for any lawyer looking at this honestly and knowledgeable about the matter that the judicial path in this case exists.

Of course, there has been controversy raised by some lawyers about whether the administrative path – in the judicial-administrative sense – is adequate here. In a situation where we would take into account the specificity of the functioning of administrative courts, which deal only and exclusively with examining legality, and thus compliance with the law of the decisions issued and the actions of public administration bodies – they cannot examine the substantive matter. And this is a matter for discussion. This is one of the accusations made against this law, that it – according to some commentators – may constitute a violation of the constitution.

I also stated in my Monday speech that I listen to all arguments, I understand that there are various arguments raised – especially those substantive ones that also show that the people who discuss know what they are talking about – and I am ready, within my presidential prerogatives, to refer this law for examination by the Constitutional Tribunal. However, in a subsequent procedure. Because I do not believe that the constitutional objections raised by some individuals are so significant that it would be necessary to block the implementation of this law.

On the contrary – I believe that this law was passed too late. I believe that this commission investigating the issue of Russian influence in Poland, their influence on our security, should have been established much earlier. I regret that it is only now. And that it is possible to say that it was passed in connection with the upcoming election campaign. That is the case, but it is good that it exists. And it should come into effect as soon as possible, and it should start functioning as soon as possible. Because its operation – this commission – will, in my opinion, prevent the further spread of Russian influence in our country, which our compatriots fear.

And there is no doubt about this, and no one who looks at Polish affairs honestly has any doubt that such a commission should exist in our country and that these matters should be thoroughly investigated. Because we are fully aware of the many strange situations we have encountered over the past years. And today, as we know, Russia is the aggressor that attacked Ukraine, brutally killing and bombing civilian settlements. We know very well that Russia was conducting gas contracts over our part of Europe, building large gas pipelines – a whole range of various actions that were carried out.

I believe that Polish society deserves an explanation of whether and what, if any, was – in the various actions taken by Russia, as well as in the attempts of those actions carried out on our territory, which I have already mentioned – the involvement of individuals who function in our public life, who held or hold important offices in Poland, or important positions, or important public functions. Therefore, I absolutely believe that the commission should start operating as soon as possible, and I hope that thanks to the wise, prudent, and calmly made decisions of the parliament, this will happen.

But at the same time, ladies and gentlemen, I am also fully aware that this commission should indeed be a commission above elections. Because we do not need a commission for elections. There is little time left until the elections. We need a commission that will operate and that will thoroughly clarify these matters. Therefore, I believe that there should be no members of parliament in this commission. And this should be clearly stated in the law: that individuals who hold their parliamentary mandates cannot be members of this commission – neither deputies nor senators.

This will also clarify many discussions and speculations that have been conducted in the media for several days. There is a discussion about various potential members of the commission, mentioning individuals who are currently members of the Polish parliament – our Sejm or our Senate. Ladies and gentlemen, I believe that this should be an expert commission. And therefore, I believe that there should be no members of parliament in it. That is my opinion.

Another issue. As I said, I am submitting this law with a whole range of reservations raised by various individuals – whom I listen to with respect – to the Constitutional Tribunal in a subsequent procedure. But, ladies and gentlemen, unfortunately, I am aware of the situation that occurred the day before yesterday. On Wednesday, two hearings were supposed to take place in very important matters before the Constitutional Tribunal, including regarding funds from the National Reconstruction Plan. Once again, both cases did not take place, once again they were removed from the Tribunal's agenda due to conflicts within the Tribunal, due to disputes among the judges, and disputes within the Constitutional Tribunal itself. This is a situation that I find disgraceful – I do not hide it – it outrages me, and above all, it is very harmful to the state, because these matters should have been resolved long ago.

Articles also appeared yesterday in the media claiming that the Office of the President was delaying the submission of a request to the Constitutional Tribunal, acting in some cynical way, calculated to ensure that the matter would not come before the Tribunal. Considering that the Tribunal is not functioning, the President is pretending that he actually wants an examination of the constitutionality of the solutions proposed in the law.

Ladies and gentlemen, no – the Office of the President is not delaying its work. The request will certainly be submitted before the commission begins its work. I responded yesterday to these accusations in the media, stating that I am convinced that it will be submitted within two weeks. We are currently working on this. But I do not hide that I am outraged by these accusations, which are evidently marked by bad faith towards me and my collaborators, and I decided to take a step that will be a kind of "check" also towards the participants in our political scene – both from the ruling camp and from the opposition.

Ladies and gentlemen, I have prepared an amendment to the law: a whole range of provisions that in this law additionally regulate or change the issues that raise the most controversy, which are often misrepresented in the media. And now, ladies and gentlemen, this amendment will be submitted by me today. Today, the presidential draft law amending the law on the commission for investigating Russian influence will reach the Marshal's office – as we say.

It will still be a commission that will be external to the parliament. Because I do not want it to be discontinued after the parliamentary elections, when there will be a new parliament – it should continue to operate, that is my assumption. But I want there to be no members of parliament in this commission, and this will be clearly stated in my proposal: that neither deputies nor senators can sit on this commission. That is the first matter.

Secondly, regarding the administrative court, which has raised controversy, I also propose that it be changed. And I propose that the appeal against the decisions made by the commission be directed to the appellate court. Additionally – to dispel any doubts – the designated court will be the Appellate Court in Warsaw. However, in the event that the person concerned by the proceedings before the commission and the decision issued by the commission wishes otherwise, then according to their wish, the appropriate court may also be the appellate court determined by their place of residence. So that it is not only the Appellate Court in Warsaw.

Someone who appears before the commission, someone whose case is before the commission, will be able to decide for themselves whether they want it to be the Appellate Court in Warsaw or whether they want it to be the appellate court appropriate for their place of residence. So not an administrative court, but a common court with the possibility of also filing an appeal against the ruling issued by the court in the first instance. Because the appellate court will act here as the court of first instance. This is my second proposal in this law.

The third proposal concerns the issue that has raised the most controversy. Ladies and gentlemen, it concerns the so-called remedial measures that were introduced in this law, including, in fact, a ban on holding office, a ban on access to classified information, a ban, ladies and gentlemen, on possessing weapons. What has primarily raised such controversy: the ban on holding office, which was also immediately linked to the fact that this would also result in the inability to run for election. Ladies and gentlemen, nothing could be further from the truth, and I thank the State Electoral Commission for immediately clarifying this. The issue of running for election has never been addressed by this law. And very well – it absolutely should not be. Because running for election is the right of every citizen, of course within the limits defined by the constitution.

However, I, ladies and gentlemen, propose that these remedial measures be abolished. And I propose that in their place there should only be a statement by the commission that a person determined to have acted under Russian influence – that such a person does not provide guarantees of properly performing actions in the public interest. An element that is already present in the law, but that it should be the main subject of the commission's determination if the commission establishes Russian influence. I will explain why.

This removes many of the controversies that arise regarding what is currently proposed in the law, and I hope it will also calm at least some commentators. As for politicians – especially the opposition – and those who shout the loudest: here you go, this is a "check." Do you really believe that the commission will operate poorly, or are you simply afraid to stand before the commission and possibly testify before it? To explain what, how, and why you did in the eyes of public opinion.

I am simultaneously strengthening, with the amendments I am submitting to the bill, the matter that is most important to me: namely, the transparency of the actions of this commission. Practically all actions of the commission – in particular, hearings before the commission and testimonies before the commission – will be public. Except in exceptional situations when they will concern very high state secrecy. Aside from those exceptional situations, all other actions of the commission – especially when individuals being questioned or those involved in the matters at hand appear before the commission – will be public.

For me, the most important issue in democracy is this – as I mentioned on Monday – and the most important way for such a commission to operate is for the public, that is, all of us, the citizens of the Republic, to have direct access to the information that comes from this commission. Anyone who wants to will be able to see the broadcast in the media, hear with their own ears the questions that are asked, see how the members of the commission behave, how those who stand before the commission behave.

And on that basis, to form their own opinion about how the Polish state functioned during the terms of given governments, how someone performed a public function, what their approach is to the issue of the public interest, and all those matters that are indeed important. I believe that it is the right of every citizen to listen to such issues. Therefore, transparency, transparency, and once again transparency.

And as I said, ladies and gentlemen: the change of jurisdiction by introducing a common court instead of an administrative court, the abolition of remedial measures, leaving the issue of the guarantee of proper performance of actions in the public interest as the most important premise, is in fact the credibility and responsibility of the actions of a given person in the Polish interest, and such – in my opinion – is the duty of every person holding office or a public function in our country, as well as, ladies and gentlemen, the prohibition of parliamentarians sitting on this commission and strengthening the transparency of its actions.

These are my most important proposals that I am submitting today, and I appeal to the entire parliament for their swift adoption in order to rectify and clarify this situation. But above all, so that this commission can operate as quickly as possible. And for society to see and hear as soon as possible how the issue of Russian influence on our public life, our economic life, and our security is being explained in our country.

And I will repeat once again what I said on Monday: over the past few years, we have had many attempts, for example, to sell important sectors of the Polish economy into Russian hands. Fortunately, we managed to stop the vast majority of them – the most serious ones. I would like to know who was behind this. Because it was not only the Russians who were behind it. There were also people who at that time held responsible state functions in Poland and responsible economic functions on behalf of the State Treasury.

These matters should be clarified; Poles deserve to have this knowledge. This knowledge should be provided to them – and that is precisely what this commission is meant to serve. Therefore, I appeal for it to be established as soon as possible, as it is also a matter of the security of the Republic of Poland.

Thank you very much.