"A strong state must have efficient, reliable courts."

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

20 September 2018 · Appointment of first judges to the Supreme Court

Context
Duda addressed newly appointed Supreme Court judges at a nomination ceremony marking the first appointments under Poland's reformed Supreme Court law of December 2017.
Main themes
Judicial reform in Poland, Supreme Court renewal, Disciplinary Chamber establishment, judicial independence, rule of law, justice system credibility, judicial ethics, appointment of new judges, resistance to reform, public trust in courts
Duration
~9 min
33rd percentile
Words
1,134
33rd percentile
Sentences
45
29th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.25
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%76%
  • Ceremonial 24%24%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

45 sentences in 10 paragraphs

Most Honorable Minister, Honorable President, Honorable Deputy Prosecutor General, Esteemed Directors, but above all, most esteemed Judges, Dear Closest Ones of the Judges, an incredibly moving moment. I must say that this feeling is shared by my colleagues, as everyone knows what this moment is – the moment when the first judges are appointed to the Supreme Court operating under the law of December 8, 2017, the renewed Supreme Court. The Supreme Court, which these changes are meant to restore credibility to in Polish society, to enable it to function well, and above all, to foster among people a sense that the Supreme Court is a court of justice.

This is extremely important. This task falls largely to you – the judges appointed today to the Supreme Court as the first among all those who applied and who went through the procedure in the National Judiciary Council. You are the first, for whom the resolution has become valid and, consequently, the possibility of appointment has arisen.

I am very grateful that you have come forward, representing various legal professions until now, coming from different legal backgrounds, but deeply convinced of one thing: that the Polish justice system requires repair, and that you want to be part of this repair. And this is an extremely important and very difficult task. That it is difficult, you have realized recently, if only through the campaign that has been developed by legal circles and others against those who have come forward to repair the justice system: against you, against your loved ones.

This also shows what the current state of the justice system is. Because if lawyers are so resistant to changes in the Supreme Court, to the establishment of the Disciplinary Chamber, to the establishment of the Chamber for Extraordinary Complaints, it means that something is wrong in this justice system, and that is unequivocal. And there is no doubt that the justice system requires urgent repair so that it can finally serve Polish society; so that a judge can finally understand what the dignity of the judge's profession means – that the dignity of the judge's profession does not consist in being above the law, but that the dignity of the judge's profession consists in behaving in a dignified manner.

This is a great task, especially for the Disciplinary Chamber. This guard over the Polish justice system – over the actions of judges in accordance with the law, in accordance with the principles of professional ethics – has an absolutely fundamental task.

I am extremely moved because an incredibly important mission is entrusted to your hands. If someone is truly going to repair the Polish justice system, if someone is indeed going to contribute to the fact that the Polish justice system socially regains its face and that almost eighty percent of people do not say that the courts require change, meaning that they are simply bad and functioning poorly, if someone contributes to this the most, I am convinced that it is you who can contribute the most: through your attitude, your judgments, your decisions. You will be adjudicating as the Disciplinary Chamber in disciplinary matters of the judges of the Supreme Court; because you will be adjudicating in disciplinary matters as a second instance – an appellate court – in matters of judges of common courts, lawyers, legal advisors, prosecutors, and in the future also bailiffs. This is therefore an extremely important task and the responsibility associated with it is immense. However, I am convinced that you will rise to this responsibility. This is not my standard speech – the one I always give on the occasion of judicial nominations – because this nomination and today’s ceremony are exceptional.

I would like to once again sincerely thank you for your determination to repair the Polish justice system, to take part in this, despite everything that is happening around us. I am immensely grateful to you for that. I deeply believe that I am entrusting this mission today into the right hands. I would like to thank your loved ones for agreeing to this and also participating in what is happening; for being ready to support you in your extremely important service to the Republic.

We wanted and want this chamber of the Supreme Court to be as independent as possible. Why? Also to provide you with the proper working conditions, the proper conditions for adjudication. We all know very well that if there are pressures on judges somewhere, they are usually not pressures involving someone trying to offer them a benefit. These are pressures based precisely on internal, professional relationships. The aim was for the Chamber to be as resistant as possible to these pressures, as an institution. And to have as much independence as possible in this regard.

Of course, independence is not something that can be acquired, or something that can be attributed to someone. Independence is a state of mind. I am convinced that all of you represent this state of mind – that you are independent people and that you will perform this service for the Republic as you just stated in the words of the oath you took: that it will be carried out impartially, in accordance with the provisions of law, according to the principle of the rule of law, but also the principle of fairness. Because it is extremely important that you approach it this way, so that the cases that unfortunately occur in legal professions can finally be assessed objectively, and which, as a result of previous judgments, have astonished Polish society. That a judge who has stolen something continues to adjudicate, that there is a corruption scandal in the Supreme Court of which all of Poland learns and to this day one can read dialogues of judges on the Internet, and there is no accountability, neither criminal nor disciplinary. They are surprised that over 70% of people say that the judiciary is functioning poorly. And the most frightening thing is that they defend themselves tooth and nail against any accountability and against the possibility of introducing changes in this sick system.

I believe that you will implement these changes and that as a result, the Polish justice system will be repaired, and the assessment of the Polish judiciary in society will rise very quickly, because this is very much needed. A strong state must have efficiently functioning, credible courts, which people feel truly dispense justice, and not that they are a bastion of injustice. And judges should be people who serve society and Poland, not those who think that society should serve them, and that they are above the law. I believe that your activities will change this. And I wish you that. I wish this for Poland and for all of us. Good luck!