Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on European policy before the German Bundestag on May 11, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

11 May 2006 · Government statement on European policy before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag during European Week on May 11, 2006, delivering a government statement on the state and future of European integration policy.
Main themes
European integration, peace and stability in Europe, German-French relations, European values and identity, EU enlargement, Treaty of Rome anniversary, German EU presidency 2007, European Constitutional crisis, economic growth and unemployment, history of European unification, Robert Schuman legacy, EU financial framework
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,314
88th percentile
Sentences
229
92nd percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%38%
  • Geopolitical 39%38%
  • Economic 14%13%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

229 sentences in 61 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen!

It is a good tradition of this German Bundestag to regularly debate the state and perspectives of European unification. Such a debate this week, during European Week, is not only important because of this tradition, but in my opinion, it is necessary given the current situation and circumstances.

Therefore, I am very grateful to the parliamentary groups for requesting to discuss the questions of Europe precisely in this week; for in light of many individual issues that we debate, one can get the impression that the view of the whole is sometimes lost.

It was right that two days ago, on Europe Day, we once again remembered the great European Robert Schuman, the former French Foreign Minister, and recalled his initiative to establish the European Coal and Steel Community. Schuman proposed placing the raw materials necessary for the armaments industry, coal and steel, under a common authority. This was not just any initiative; rather, this initiative established the German-French relationship as a special relationship. But with this initiative, it was also intended to prevent the European states, especially Germany and France, from ever going to war against each other again.

Europe as a community of peace – this was a groundbreaking idea after the end of the Second World War, after so much suffering and such great loss of life. Europe as a community of peace – this utopia was truly brought to life in the following decades. The vision became reality: our lived reality.

You all know the key terms that document this: the European Economic Community of 1957, the introduction of the internal market and a common currency for twelve member countries with the understanding that countries sharing the same currency will never again compete against each other, and the further development of the European Community with today 25 and soon 27 member states.

In retrospect, one can state: Robert Schuman truly revolutionized the relationships of European countries with one another. A complete reordering of the European state system has emerged. In my opinion, this reordering is the greatest since the Peace of Westphalia.

After the fall of the Wall, with the eastward expansion and the end of the Cold War, the idea of peace and values finally reached our entire continent. Especially we Germans, with our history, can never be reminded often enough that peace in freedom is truly not a matter of course. It is a blessing and a gift. This peace in freedom, because it is not self-evident, must also be continually reworked and defended.

We should be aware that all good turning points in German post-war history are inextricably linked to Europe. Whether it is the reintegration into the European Union or German reunification: We owe the European integration an unprecedented period of peace, freedom, and prosperity.

This also shows us that Europe has always been more than just a community of purpose or interest. Europe has always been founded on common values, has always been aware of its shared history, and has a common will to shape the future for the benefit of all. It is precisely about this will that we will also have to talk with an eye toward the future.

A unique coexistence of larger and smaller states has emerged. Next year, we will celebrate the anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome 50 years ago. This is yet another good occasion to remember what has been achieved.

However, all of this also provides reason to look confidently to the future. Today is not the day to discuss in detail the German presidency in the first half of 2007 or the fact that the Federal Republic of Germany will simultaneously hold the G8 presidency; but we should become aware of what it is about. For this is also our common feeling: The invocation of values and the original idea of the European unification process is no longer sufficient today; that is not enough.

Therefore, this is not the hour for a historical reminiscence, but it is the hour for a government statement. The truth must be taken into account; for it is partly sobering. Many citizens experience Europe in the criticism of the most detailed regulations, in doubt as to whether Europe can tackle the problems of the future – unemployment and insufficient economic growth. In short, one must state: Europe is not as highly regarded by Europeans as historical hindsight might suggest. The two failed referendums in France and the Netherlands are certainly only indicators, but they do not tell the whole story.

This means that it is not enough for us to point out that indeed forward-looking solutions have been found. Yes, fortunately, a financial framework for the coming years has been decided. I add: It has also been ensured, by the allocation of funds and the criteria, that structural fund resources are no longer allocated when jobs are relocated from one country to another. This is a very important point that concerns many people.

Furthermore, an agreement regarding the chemical industry has been reached. A fundamental agreement on the services directive has been achieved. The European Parliament has succeeded in rejecting a pointless directive on sun protection and not passing it. All of these are facts that are encouraging and positive.

However, all of this is not enough to make it clear to citizens what Europe means for them and what responsibility Europe has. We must – I am deeply convinced of this – critically review the status of the project Europe. We must place the citizen at the center and answer their questions: What does this mean for my job, for my prosperity, and for my social security in case of illness and in old age? Does Europe make things easier, better, or is Europe a brake, an obstacle? I believe we must not shy away from these questions. We must answer them very specifically and concretely.

I think it is about nothing more and nothing less than adding a new foundation to the historical justification of the European Union. I do not want to dramatize things, but I believe a new foundation is more necessary than ever. For we are in the following situation: During the Cold War, it was a tremendous advancement that the Western European countries cooperated in the European Union, deciding not to act against each other anymore. But there was no question that this European Union was superior to the entire socialist and communist system. It did not have to justify itself as to why this Europe was the right answer. It was the better answer than anything that took place beyond the Iron Curtain.

Then came the great triumph of freedom. Then the superiority of the idea of freedom prevailed. The Cold War was over. The entire continent can today live according to this European idea. But the situation regarding other continents has changed. Europe must justify itself from within and show that it can shape politics according to its values in a world of greater competition, in a globally transparent world. This is the great task that lies ahead of us.

Citizens simply have doubts as to whether the model of the social market economy, whether our ideas of human dignity are so superior, so dominant, so compelling that we could not only win the battle in the Cold War in the past, but that we can also continue our way of life in a jointly responsible world and show others as a model. Therefore, we must think about what Europe means and how the claim to shape politics can be reasserted. Many have the impression that it is only about the flow of capital, that politics has no power anymore. However, we must demonstrate our superiority. Therefore, I believe it is right and important that we see: With 450 million people in the European Union, we can certainly influence the rules of world trade. No single member state could assert its interests as we can collectively. To give an example from environmental protection: Individual member states would never have been able to negotiate as successfully on the Kyoto Protocol. We have a common development policy.

We act as the European Union in many areas and can shape much more strongly. This means that one alone would face shipwreck where we can assert our interests together. This is a very tangible advantage of Europe.

However, to achieve the overall goal, we must concentrate and identify the essential areas where successes must be visible and where we must prove to our citizens that we are more successful with Europe than without Europe. From my perspective, the question of economic dynamism, the social responsibility we bear for the people, and jobs arises first.

Every member state – this will also apply in the future – will first have to solve its own tasks. This certainly applies to Germany; for Germany is the largest economy in Europe. We must not draw false conclusions from this. We have our duty to fulfill. We were the ones who introduced the Stability Pact within the framework of the Economic and Monetary Union to provide security to the people. Therefore, it is not acceptable for us to violate this Stability Pact for the third, fourth, or fifth time; for in doing so, we do not meet our own standards. I know that the federal government is asking a lot of the people in this country with some decisions these days. Credibility regarding the standards we apply to others in Europe is, however, a valuable asset. Therefore, this federal government has committed itself to adhering to the constitution and the Stability Pact in Europe again. It is that simple. This must be enforced.

We wholeheartedly support the Lisbon Strategy, according to which economic success, success in innovation, growth, and jobs is the be-all and end-all in a world of increasing contradictions. We will only be able to assert our weight in many areas in Europe if we first show that we have an economically successful model that is at the same time humane and ensures social responsibility in the sense of the social market economy. Our task is to actively participate in the Lisbon Strategy. It is important to consider where Europe has tied itself down with growth constraints.

Our task must always be to pay attention to competition in general and, above all, to give small and medium-sized enterprises in the European Union a chance. We know: If Europe is to be successful, it must be at the forefront in education, research, and innovation. These are our strengths. Therefore, our national measure to spend three percent of gross domestic product on research and development is right. It is equally right that we ensure that the European research structures meet the demand for efficiency. They must not correspond to a regional proportionality; rather, research must be promoted where achievements are made that are innovative and with which we stand at the forefront worldwide.

We have taken a path both domestically and at the European level that has brought many regulations with it. I expressly support that the Commission, especially the President of the Commission and Vice President Günter Verheugen, jointly state that reducing bureaucracy is the order of the day. We can save 25 percent of bureaucratic effort not only at home but throughout Europe. By the way, it is a revolutionary step that after almost 50 years of European unity – you can currently visit in Brussels the at least six-meter-high mountain of stacked papers that contain the entire acquis communautaire; all of this has been created in 50 years – we decide, in light of a dramatically changing world, to take a look at whether something can be changed or removed. This too is part of Europe.

The question of whether we will be economically successful, whether we can provide people with jobs, and whether people have the impression that the value concepts of a social order in the European Union can be realized better than at the national level is, for me, the decisive question by which the acceptance of Europe must be proven.

In addition to economic dynamism, we need an answer to the people's need for security, for internal security, and for legal certainty. According to surveys, this is, by the way, a very important requirement that citizens place on Europe; they want that.

But we are currently struggling in this area to allow national responsibilities to be transferred to Europe. You all surely remember the debates about the European Arrest Warrant.

Today, we use the Schengen Agreement quite naturally. Especially in internal and legal policy, there will always be areas where individual countries come together and take the lead. To give an example, I spoke yesterday with the Lithuanian Prime Minister: Lithuania is working hard to be integrated into the Schengen Agreement, as it is considered an incredible advantage to have internal borders and then jointly protect the external borders. This is a thought that we considered completely impossible 30 or 40 years ago.

Anyone who compares the conditions at the German-French border crossings with those at the German-Polish ones can already sense the impatience. One asks: When will it finally become a bit easier? The progress has an incredible added value for the people and has almost become a matter of course.

We now have a European criminal record and a European information network, keyword Europol. In internal and legal policy, we will have to continue the unification, even if many member states must give up their reservations. I think there will continue to be an intense discussion in the German Bundestag about how much sovereignty we want to give up and how much we want to retain. This discussion must take place.

Another central point – this also concerns the question of how Europe is perceived and how we can assert our interests – is the area of external security, European foreign and security policy.

After the end of the Cold War, completely new threats emerged: terrorism, fundamentalism. The realization is that no state, no country, can cope with this threat alone. Neither the superpower United States, nor Russia, nor the European Union, let alone a member state.

To be honest, one must acknowledge: Europe has had to learn a lot since the end of the Cold War. We did not act in time in the Balkans. Fortunately, we have learned lessons from this failure. It was then through our commitment, for example in Macedonia – there were heated debates in my faction about this – that we succeeded in preventing a civil war. The European Union has now managed to take responsibility for Bosnia and Herzegovina. This is a completely new milestone. We used to argue about whether we could even act outside our national borders! Today, it has become a matter of course for the vast majority of people that we take on responsibility here.

We are monitoring the peace processes in the Indonesian province of Aceh. As the European Union, we have taken on a very important role in the Quartet in the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. Our engagement in the Congo to secure the elections is part of our responsibilities.

What does this mean? It means Europe has learned: It must intervene before it is too late, before dramatic conflicts arise, before famines occur again like in the Great Lakes region of Africa. Europe can no longer assert its claim to have a value system solely within itself; if we are serious about this value system, we must help where others cannot cope alone. This is the consequence of the claim we have raised.

We will repeatedly notice: We are desired and sought after as partners. In light of this, some furrow their brows and ask: Can we manage all of this? But I say quite deliberately: If we want to make our way of living and doing business a way that earns us recognition and enforcement in the world, then we cannot shy away from the responsibilities and challenges in the world. Therefore, we must also be economically strong. If we want to shape politics – the fear of the people is that politics no longer has the shaping power – then we must enforce this and cannot shy away. If we shy away, it will be understood as capitulation to the challenges, and that would be exactly the wrong thing.

To be able to tackle all these tasks, Europe must be capable of action. Regarding the capability of action, there are two problems that we must address and that are not yet fully resolved.

We are only capable of action if we can make the necessary decisions sensibly from our internal structure.

We are only capable of action if we also know what kind of entity this European Union is.

Enlargement and deepening – both are questions that now arise in a completely new dimension because Europe is attractive, because many want to become members of this European Union, but we must also say who can and who cannot and what offer we make so as not to be perceived as a closed fortress.

Regarding the capability of action, the debate about the constitutional treaty is very important. It is a setback that the referendums in France and the Netherlands ended negatively.

But this does not make a statement about whether we need a constitutional treaty or not. I say: We need the constitutional treaty. We need it because it provides answers to various questions. It tells us what our fundamental rights are and what the common understanding is.

For the very first time – back then under the leadership of Roman Herzog – it was possible to get the member states of the European Union to write down what is generally referred to as our values in the form of a catalog of fundamental rights. We have had heated debates – and they will continue – for example about the question of how we refer to our Christian roots, whether that is even possible. We have gained a deep insight into the different histories of the individual European countries. In the confrontation with other religions, with other cultures, it will be important that we as Europeans are able to clearly name our roots. Others expect that from us. How do we want to fight for our values if we cannot do that?

The constitutional treaty has for the first time attempted to establish clear rules of competence, something that citizens rightly demand, which has been clearly included in our Basic Law since the first day of the existence of the Federal Republic of Germany. One of the wonderful features of the Basic Law is that it clearly distributes competencies to the individual levels. Next week, we will have the pleasure of discussing the reorganization of these competencies – a not so simple topic, but one that must be addressed. Blurred competencies are always a deficit of democracy. People no longer know whom they can hold responsible for what. This must again be possible in Europe.

This constitutional treaty creates for the first time the office of a European foreign minister. We must carefully consider what competencies we want to give him. I look at our foreign minister and say: He will not become unemployed due to the European foreign minister. However, it will naturally need to be clear who represents Europe, for example in the negotiations of the Quartet.

This constitutional treaty assigns significance to the national parliaments for the first time through the subsidiarity clause. By the way, the President of the Commission just told me that this does not go without differences with the European Parliament; because the European Parliament keeps a close watch that the national parliaments do not regain too many powers.

At this point, I want to say: The European Parliament has gained importance in recent years in a way that was unimaginable 20 or 30 years ago. In light of the services directive and the discussions about it, there have been demonstrations in Strasbourg for the first time. One of our Members of the European Parliament said he felt honored; it had never happened before that there were demonstrations over a European regulation. This shows that something is being decided there.

We will also need to continue discussing the following; this is not yet clarified in the constitutional treaty. I am firmly convinced that the decision was correct that the political force that receives the most votes in the European elections also has the right to nominate the President of the Commission. But we will also need to see further. If we have a legislative process in Europe with such a strong European Parliament, then there must also be – which is quite natural for us – the principle of discontinuity. It cannot be that directives are developed in directorates-general that survive decades, regardless of who is elected and working. This is also part of the development of Europe.

This means we have a European Union that is enabled by the constitutional treaty to make decisions. Because the institutional part – the questions regarding the Commission, the European foreign minister, the Council – must be clarified in such a way that Europe can work. The current decision-making mechanisms in Europe are so complicated that one almost needs a degree from a technical college to recognize who just had the majority or how to create a blocking minority. The composition of the Commission cannot remain as it is. Therefore, we absolutely need the constitutional treaty to have a capable Europe. The German presidency will deal with this at the latest.

However, because the topic is so difficult and the interests are so diverse, I am against a quick fix that puts us in a situation where we cannot move forward again. Instead, we should think very carefully about how to make the project of the constitutional treaty a success. I want this constitutional treaty, the federal government wants it, and I think the majority of this parliament does too.

The

second

major point is the question of enlargement. Here I want to explicitly say: What has been promised will be implemented – we are all moving in continuity here. However, the criteria under which accessions can occur are also clear. Next week, we will receive the progress report on Bulgaria and Romania. I think it is clear that Bulgaria and Romania will become members of the European Union. But I also expect the European Commission to clearly identify the deficiencies in its progress report.

We do not help the countries if we simply sweep the deficiencies under the rug and assume that the European Union and the European idea will cover them. I also assume that the European Commission will make proposals on how to remedy these deficiencies.

It is also important that accession negotiations are not a one-way street. The criteria must be met. This applies to Croatia just as it does to Turkey. There are also no package deals. Just because two countries started accession negotiations on the same day does not mean they must also conclude them on the same day. Each country has the right to be treated as it presents itself.

It was right for the European Union to suspend negotiations on a stability and association agreement with Serbia and Montenegro for the time being because there is no cooperation with the Hague Tribunal for War Crimes. Such signals must also be sent: Accessions do not come at any price, but the conditions that apply to the European Union must be met.

Since we cannot take in all those who want to become members, we will further develop the neighborhood policy. This is not a question at all. I am deeply convinced that we cannot simply do this with trade association agreements. We will have to offer these states enhanced political cooperation, which, however, cannot always mean full membership. I have explained why Europe must be capable of action. An entity that has no borders cannot act coherently within itself and have a certain structure. We must keep this clearly in mind and therefore draw borders.

I believe that if we answer the pressing questions and, as the Federal Republic of Germany, contribute to ensuring that people across Europe can understand that this European Union is a unique opportunity for us to make our interests, our values, and our way of life livable, then people will understand it as well. It may then be the case that some points revert to national competence while others transition from national to European competence. However, this must always be guided by the following questions: Does it provide added value for individuals, for their social security, for their jobs, and for our external and internal security? Do we have the opportunity to contribute to helping others solve their problems? If we answer these questions honestly, we will reach the Europeans, not just with words, but also with actions.

Our policy must have the strength to distinguish the important from the unimportant. We must believe in the power of peace in freedom, of democracy, and of human rights, which should be realized all over the world. With our policy based on this incredibly great success story, we must shape the future.

People like Schuman, de Gaulle, Adenauer, and many others faced incredibly great ruins at that time; but they had visions. We have a strong foundation on which we can build. We have decades of success behind us. Today, there are new threats, new challenges, and more competition. But with our history and the self-confidence we bring, we can succeed in making Europe a success story in the 21st century as well. I, for one, am determined to do this together with the Federal Government and with you.