Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the WDR Europe Forum on May 9, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

9 May 2006 · WDR Europe Forum · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the WDR Europe Forum in Berlin on Europe Day 2006, speaking on the theme of Europe's uncertain future amid low public confidence in the EU.
Main themes
European integration, EU reputation and public sentiment, Constitutional Treaty failure, Europe's uncertain future, economic prosperity and growth, peace and reconciliation, renationalization risks, European identity, globalization challenges, demographic issues, European elections participation
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,163
87th percentile
Sentences
207
90th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%43%
  • Geopolitical 25%25%
  • Economic 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

207 sentences in 68 paragraphs

Dear Prime Minister Marcinkiewicz,

dear Vice President of the European Parliament,

Commissioner,

State Minister Gloser,

Mr. Pleitgen,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

above all, colleagues from the parliaments!

It is indeed Europe Day. I have learned that the officials of the Commission have the day off today and that the Commissioners, fortunately, have to work, otherwise we would not have Mr. Verheugen here at all. In this respect, it is good and right, also symbolically right, that the WDR is holding this Europe Forum today with the ambitious title "Europe's Uncertain Future."

You have not shied away from placing not even a question mark behind the title. One could understand the whole thing as relatively trivializing and harmless in the sense that the future is, by definition, always uncertain. Mark Twain already said this when he remarked: "Predictions are always difficult; especially those about the future." This title could thus embody a truism. But I suspect that this was not quite your intention, but rather that there should be a piece of provocation contained in this title.

Therefore, I would like to orient my remarks around three guiding principles.

First:

Europe is better than its reputation.

Second:

Europe is not good enough.

Third:

Europe must, but Europe can also become better.

Regarding the thesis "Europe is better than its reputation": It is certainly true that Europe has experienced better days in terms of general sentiment. It was mentioned this morning: The failure to find majorities in the referendums on the Constitutional Treaty in two founding states of the European Union – France and the Netherlands – was certainly something of a wake-up call. When one looks at why the "No" came about, all observers agree: This "No" was not a rejection of the text of the Constitutional Treaty, but this "No" arose from an economic and political context in which the votes took place. Even among those who did not hold referendums, who had positive referendums, or who have not yet voted, it is known that the mood towards Europe leaves much to be desired, that, for example, our participation in European elections cannot satisfy us at all. These are indications of an acceptance or understanding problem that we must, of course, address.

Part of the explanation could be that Europe is, in a way, suffering from its own success. If one looks at what the ideals of the founding fathers were, it was indeed the community of peace in Europe and the Europe based on common values. What was anything but self-evident at that time has now become a matter of course and a tremendous success. But for a young generation that is growing up in this Europe, it is no longer something special, but simply a state that one cannot imagine differently.

Last year, we celebrated the 60th anniversary of the end of the war. Let us occasionally – and this applies, for example, to me as well – put ourselves in the lives of our parents, who were born during the war, had their childhood during that time, and experienced bombings. When one imagines this in other European countries that were attacked by Germany, it is like history and is fortunately hardly comprehensible in emotional experience anymore. And thus, the peaceful coexistence today is, of course, simply a state for young people that they do not want to miss, but which they also do not celebrate every day.

Therefore, it is important that we remember that this is not an immutable natural state and that small prejudices and small things that are said can quickly become resentments, can quickly lead to separations, and can quickly give rise to a tendency towards renationalization. This means that, from my deep conviction, it is absolutely necessary to keep the process of European integration ongoing, because otherwise a regression with consequences that we certainly do not want will become very likely.

The second point, why we need to talk about Europe's reputation, is that Europe has also been a guarantor of prosperity for decades. Many people no longer feel this today. Europe is not necessarily the guarantor of ever-increasing prosperity because we live in a completely new environment and because many European member states are suffering from problems such as lack of growth, high unemployment, national debt, and demographic issues. This means that all the problems we have locally are also projected onto Europe. One wonders: Will Europe meet the demands?

This burdens Europe. Therefore, we must first say: Europe was and is, of course, a community of nation-states. I want to remind you of a passage from the valid EU treaty, which states: "The Union respects the national identity of its member states." Many of the tasks that we project onto Europe today are primarily tasks that we must solve at home.

However, because we understood – and that was the process of the 1980s, if I see it correctly – that the problems at home in a globalizing world can no longer be solved alone, it was decided to introduce the internal market. By the way, I consider this decision to be one of the most significant and, to this day, not fully digested. Perhaps it has been discussed too little in public regarding its fundamental importance. I am deeply convinced that this common internal market would need to be established today if it did not exist, because it is becoming evident in many places that the individual European nation-states can no longer fulfill their tasks in cooperation with other continents and states.

The fact that we have this internal market is, for me, proof that Europe has found the right answer to globalization. When I think of the world trade negotiations, the Kyoto negotiations, or the many competition negotiations from Boeing to Microsoft: We could not negotiate all of this with the confidence and with our common values if we did not have the European institutions. The individual nation-states could not achieve this.

By the way, in connection with the development of the internal market, we have experienced a very interesting trend of strengthening the European Parliament. Over the years, the Parliament has fought for many new rights. Just now, it was said quite casually: "First, the representative of the Parliament spoke, and now the representative of the government is speaking." – That a Commissioner is the representative of a European government is anything but undisputed in Europe, and not because I have a problem with that. I see it very much that the Commission has such tasks in relation to the Parliament. But try discussing this in the European member states. Our partner France alone has a completely different view on this. This, of course, also has something to do with the self-understanding of Europe, about which there are still very different ideas in the individual nation-states.

With the emergence of the internal market and the new rights of the Parliament, which I expressly welcome, the Parliament has now also taken on legislative work that is now of the highest professional quality. We briefly discussed with the Vice President what the European Parliamentarians have achieved in chemical policy, in the services directive, in the failure to establish the sun protection directive, in the financial outlook, and many other details. Ms. Roth-Behrendt is, so to speak, the expert par excellence for food labeling.

This is hardly matched in the national parliaments because the national parliaments have clear majorities and can rely on these majorities to support government apparatuses. Without revealing a secret, I can say that these government apparatuses are also quite often called upon by the Parliament. European Parliamentarians, on the other hand, have to do a lot on their own.

When I think alone about the work behind chemical policy – 13,000 pages, if you include the annexes – to make something acceptable out of it – if I may say so very cautiously – then that deserves the highest respect. I believe the parliamentarians treat this with such intensity because they are representatives of their own regions, which are still large enough, but nevertheless regions, and because they suddenly have to be accountable for something that Europe produces and that then has extreme effects on the individual chemical factory locally – whether it is a medium-sized or larger one. No parliamentarian escapes unscathed if they do not engage with this.

I would like to encourage you, on behalf of all European Parliamentarians, to continue on this path because it will also have an impact on the work of the Commission – Mr. Commissioner, forgive me – and the directorates-general. If you can still manage to democratize the comitology procedures so that not only what is important is dealt with in the annexes, but what is important is actually treated transparently in the parliamentary space, then the internal market will come closer to us than it already is today. That was a small plea from my side that Europe is better than its reputation.

Regarding the thesis "Europe is not good enough": There is no question, some things are moving at a snail's pace. I could now dwell on the development of various directives. The world has, so to speak, doubled its knowledge in the time it takes Europe to produce a directive. This is due to the Council. This is due to the Parliament. Sometimes it is also due to the Commission. We must, of course, see that people feel that other regions of this earth are developing dynamically. Some things in Europe are stagnant and find neither a good end nor a critical end.

And here is where my proposal comes in, which I will not tire of putting forward as long as I am politically active: In my firm conviction, we also need the principle of discontinuity in Europe when we have elections. This means that what happens in national parliaments after an election happens: After an election, all directives, proposals, or legislative proposals lapse and must be reintroduced so that they can be discussed anew. This would also be a contribution to "better regulation." Then many tasks would not exist because today we are still dealing with some things that are very time-consuming.

From the fact that some things take a long time, the impression arises that Europe must get better. Of course, a world in change also means that we must make clear decisions. Do we believe in the internal market? Then we must also clearly advocate for European champions. Then we must advocate that market mechanisms are designed freely and that this applies to all areas, from telecommunications to the energy sector and many other things.

If you look today at how the electricity price is formed in Europe, for example – this is one of the more interesting thought exercises – the formation of the price is largely influenced by the fact that the number of electrons flowing through the lines at some border crossings is extremely limited. For example, Spain has an almost decoupled electricity grid from the European Union, and we cannot deliver electricity directly to Italy, but must always go through France, which of course has consequences for price formation. All these things must be designed more freely. It will be a laborious process. We, as the European Union, will only be able to take advantage of the opportunities of the internal market – and this is my firm conviction – if we also decide to create European champions in all the areas that we also classically know from public services: electricity supply, postal services, and so on. Everything else will bring us into difficulties.

From the circumstances, it is clear that Europe has work to do, Europe has weaknesses. But I am firmly convinced that we can overcome these weaknesses. It has already been said here that some things that do not work at home are pushed onto Brussels. I was once a Minister of the Environment myself and know how this is attempted. When one does not have a majority at home in the cabinet, one hopes that at least the Minister of Economics is not paying attention and that one can push something through from Europe that would never find a majority at home.

These phases are largely over because European policy is now very well coordinated in the cabinets and the respective neighboring departments are paying very close attention. But here there needs to be honesty towards Europe. Because some things in Europe are anonymous, the blame is easily shifted to Europe. This principle should not be pursued by the nation-states. Otherwise, they do not do Europe any favors.

Second

Europe must make a decision: What are the priorities? – Before this event, I spoke with Commissioner Verheugen, the Vice-President of the Commission. I believe that the fact that we have unemployment problems, a lack of prosperity development, and partly insufficient growth must lead to the Lisbon process, that is, the question "How can we be a dynamic continent that cares about economic growth and jobs in a global world?" enjoying a high priority on the European agenda.

We must acknowledge that other continents are experiencing dynamic development and strengthening. However, we should also highlight our advantages more confidently. We know that India, China, and other countries have very high growth rates. We do not need to respond to this with our heads hanging low; rather, we can reflect on our strengths: This includes good education; the widespread ability in Europe to resolve conflicts democratically; the opportunity to draw on a long tradition of conflict resolution; and, of course, the model of the social market economy, which is also the foundation of the European economic order. This model has shown that the conflict between capital and labor can be resolved. When we look at the problems that the countries now referred to as "Asian Tigers" are facing, we certainly do not need to walk through the world with our heads down. But we do need to make some efforts in certain areas.

Some problems that we are incredibly eager to address are, in light of the actual challenges, simple, trivial, perhaps even negligible problems. Sometimes I have the impression that because we somewhat close our eyes to the great competitive challenge posed by, for example, India and China, we get caught up in the small fine details, pretending that they are the salvation of Europe. I do not want to directly address any specific directive. However, some of what is happening does not focus on the real problems facing the future of Europe.

Therefore, it is good that we clarify what the priorities are, and I will not tire of saying: Those who choose priorities must also acknowledge that there are posteriorities. One cannot pretend to do everything at once.

I believe it is right to say in the Lisbon Strategy: Countries must focus on research and innovation. If we are more expensive and have higher social standards than other countries in the world, then as a consequence, we must be more innovative; we must create things first; we must focus on development and creativity.

The Federal Government is trying to do this with a clear commitment to the three percent research and innovation target. We will be very interested in shaping and further developing the European research structures – we will bring this forward again during our presidency – so that they truly meet the criteria for promoting excellence. They must not operate according to any regional principles, whereby those who have received nothing for a long time must receive something again. This will certainly not advance Europe.

But there are very good ideas at play here. When I think of the "European Research Council," we are on a good path. I can only encourage the Commission to continue in this direction.

Another milestone that must be pushed forward and that we will also address during our presidency together with the responsible commissioners is the topic of "better regulation," which could also mean in plain German that we abolish something that has been created in terms of regulatory work.

Imagine a structure that next year, with the 50th anniversary of the Treaty of Rome, looks back on half a century of existence and has never dared to abolish something it has created at some point in its history. Such a nation-state could not be kept alive at all.

It is one of the truly remarkable principles that the new member states, if I think of Poland, have properly implemented all of this as "acquis communautaire." I believe they will also be glad if we can abolish something together.

In this sense, I believe that less Europe in terms of priority goals can indeed mean more, and we will then also gain more freedom to focus on the actual tasks.

When I talk about the actual tasks, I would like to happily note that Europe has recently taken on a topic that I consider essential, which will increasingly fall within the realm of common foreign policy: a common energy policy. At the last summit among heads of state and government, we held an internal discussion about this for the first time. We have asked the High Representative for Foreign Policy to continue to work on this topic annually. Because access to resources will be one of the major exciting questions internationally.

There is no way around the fact that the European Union as a whole – some more, some less – is dependent on energy supplies or raw materials from outside, and we must shape this dependency in such a way that we have a common European responsibility to ensure a common access to these resources. Otherwise, the internal market makes no particular sense if we then take raw materials from each other. We must ensure that we reconcile our political principles with our economic demands for the availability of raw materials.

This will be one of the very exciting questions of foreign policy. The Federal Foreign Minister was just in Latin America. We talked about this, also about the Chinese intentions to secure raw materials for decades to come. We will have to grapple with each other on how we shape our foreign policy so that it can meet both requirements: economic reliability and at the same time not deviating from our fundamental foreign policy values, which of course include human rights and much more.

This means that energy policy will also be a part of security policy. I think that we can already achieve a lot together today in conflict resolution.

Imagine there were no coordination processes regarding the European Union's dealings with Iran. Three European member countries do this, but always in close coordination with the member states of the European Union. Look at what the Quartet is doing in connection with the peace process between Palestine and Israel.

All of these are tasks – now further developed regarding security policy in the Balkans as European security policy – that have become almost self-evident, but which would have been almost unthinkable 15 or 20 years ago. That the European Union, for example, sits in the Quartet together with Russia and Israel is now completely normal for us. However, it certainly requires daily coordination.

In the future of Europe, alongside the economic aspects, alongside the Lisbon Strategy, we will have to deal with two questions, to which I cannot provide you with conclusive answers today, but which the German presidency will not shy away from.

The first is the enlargement of the European Union, which will of course be in a classic tension with deepening integration.

The issues regarding enlargement are difficult because we must say that if we do not want to completely stop or even reverse integration, we need to define where the borders of Europe are. On the one hand, we must be reliable – that is not in question – and try to keep our promises. But on the other hand, we will also have to tell certain countries that their membership is not possible in the foreseeable future.

This then presents us with the task – a task to be accomplished in the near future – that we must shape the neighborhood policy in such a way that it is a qualitatively demanding offer. This will not be exhausted with a simple free trade zone. The countries will not be satisfied with that; rather, they will also expect a kind of close political cooperation and commonality, which is, by the way, justified. This is in the European interest. Therefore, further work must be done here.

The second is deepening. The topic of the constitutional treaty is one that I closely associate with deepening.

At this moment, the constitutional treaty is being discussed and ratified in the Estonian parliament. We know that the outcome of this constitutional process is uncertain. But I am firmly convinced that Europe must give itself a constitution. Significant work has been done with the fundamental rights. For example, we have seen how difficult it is to achieve consensus among the various member states regarding the inclusion of the concept of God and the acknowledgment of our Christian roots. But this dispute is reasonable and important. The debate over common fundamental rights and values is, in my view, of crucial importance.

We will have to organize responsibilities. Democracy can only be lived if responsibilities are clear. If it remains unclear in many areas whether they belong to European or national jurisdiction, then one will not be able to draw the appropriate conclusions. Therefore, the part of responsibilities is a very essential part of the constitutional treaty. – By the way, this was the first time that this reflection has been advanced.

Thirdly, we will have to talk about institutional reforms. Because with so many members as we have, "Nice" alone is not enough – that much is certain. Therefore, the institutional proposals are reasonable. Institutional proposals mean, to make it practical: If nothing happens and we do not get an institutional reform, then the EU will not become more capable of action, and at the same time, we will find ourselves in a legal situation where even large countries will no longer be able to sit in the Commission permanently. I say it quite frankly: The thought that Germany would no longer be involved pains me – not only when I think of Mr. Verheugen, but for principled reasons.

I believe that, in terms of the work of a Commission, much is necessary here, including a clear commitment that we need a constitutional treaty.

When one analyzes the situation, it is complicated. Because it is so complicated, it is right not to make a hasty decision now, but to calmly observe the development and explore possibilities to eventually bring about such a constitutional treaty. Waiting does not mean letting it slowly fade away, but finding the right moment to act. This moment, in my firm conviction, is not currently given. But the reflection must continue.

I believe that we, as the Federal Republic of Germany, will play an active role and that we want to continue to do so in the future. I also believe that our representatives in the European Parliament, our representative in the European Commission, and our staff are doing this.

As party chair, I experience, for example, in the case of the Financial Perspective, how difficult it sometimes is to bring together people who have the same party membership but operate at different levels. We know this from the range from local politicians to members of the Bundestag. But I must say: Including the Members of the European Parliament in this range is sometimes very difficult when I think of the different views regarding the Financial Perspective.

Therefore, I believe it is good and right that we have party formations in the European landscape, which are also reflected in the formation of groups in the European Parliament. When there is political dispute in Europe, it is not an expression of a thwarted Europe, but it only shows that integration is deepening. As long as people only talked about peace, it was not surprising that there was little dispute. When we talk about the internal market, there is the same dispute in Europe as we have in national parliaments, and that fills me with joy. And when the disputing parties even come together and organize majorities, as happened with the Services Directive, it pleases me even more.

Therefore, I would like to say: We are committed to Europe. Europe is our future. Europe has led us to a situation where we can live in peace and freedom. This is a tremendous progress, and Europe must ensure that this is also a life of prosperity and prosperity. Then others will look at Europe with envy, at least with interest. Europe must become attractive again. Thank you for organizing this forum and contributing to it.