Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on humanitarian aid for refugees in Iraq and the fight against the terrorist organization Islamic State (IS) before the German Bundestag ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 September 2014

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on September 1, 2014, delivering a government statement on humanitarian aid in Iraq, the fight against IS, and the Ukraine crisis.
Main themes
Humanitarian aid for Iraqi refugees, Islamic State terrorism, Ukraine-Russia conflict, European unity and integration, World War II commemoration, NATO summit, sanctions against Russia, Donald Tusk as European Council President, Germany's historical responsibility, Common Foreign and Security Policy
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,891
74th percentile
Sentences
171
85th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
65th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 67%67%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Institutional 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

171 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Mr. President!

Dear colleagues!

Esteemed guests of this debate!

Ladies and gentlemen!

Today marks 75 years since the beginning of World War II. On September 1, 1939, Germany invaded Poland. The war unleashed by Germany and the crimes of National Socialism were the cause of millions of deaths and immeasurable suffering for many nations. Six million Jews and many other people were murdered in ghettos and extermination camps or near their hometowns. We Germans will never forget that. This is Germany's enduring historical responsibility, and we acknowledge this responsibility.

It took nearly six brutal years of war before the Allies achieved victory over Nazi Germany with united forces, and the inhumane crimes came to an end. At that time, the chasms between nations seemed insurmountable. Today, we, 28 member states, sit together at one table in the European Union. Former enemies have long become friends, and among them is our country, which once brought so much suffering to its neighbors. That is why, in 2007, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Treaty of Rome, we said: "We Europeans, we are united for our happiness."

We shape large parts of our policy in close coordination or even together. We tackle difficult challenges such as the international financial crisis and the debt crisis in the Eurozone together, and we represent our values, beliefs, and interests side by side in the world. The happiness that European unity brings is being brought to our attention daily. History and the present remind us to protect this happiness for future generations.

I am pleased that last Saturday, at the European Council, we were able to agree with Donald Tusk on a new President of the European Council, of whom I am sure will contribute with all his strength to ensure that Europe successfully meets the challenges ahead, whether they are of a foreign policy or economic and financial nature.

When Donald Tusk was awarded the Charlemagne Prize in 2010, I had the pleasure of delivering the laudation. At that time, I said – and I am happy to repeat it today:

"Europe still needs, more than anything else, passionate, convinced, and convincing Europeans who will bring our common house to life, expand it, and preserve it. Donald Tusk is one of them."

That a Pole will stand at the head of the European Council 25 years after the peaceful revolution in Central and Eastern Europe is, for me – and I believe for many others – highly symbolic.

From Gdansk, Donald Tusk's hometown, the Solidarity movement provided, if not the decisive impulse, for the end of the division of Europe. Without the quest for freedom of the people, especially in Poland, particularly by people like Donald Tusk, the overcoming of the division of Europe and Germany would have been unthinkable. Germany and Poland are closer today than ever before – as neighbors and as partners in Europe. Donald Tusk has played a significant role in this. I have worked intensively, trustfully, and amicably with him as the Polish Prime Minister. I also look forward to working with him as the new President of the European Council, just as I look forward to working with the new President of the Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, and with the newly appointed High Representative of the European Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, Federica Mogherini.

The office of the High Representative stands for our Common Foreign and Security Policy in the European Union. Together with Germany's NATO membership, these are the two pillars of our international alliance policy on security issues.

This Thursday and Friday, the NATO summit will take place in Wales. Together with our alliance partners, we will discuss the various global conflict hotspots and coordinate our actions. In addition to the situation in Iraq and Syria, the focus is currently on the situation in Ukraine. The Ukrainian President Poroshenko will participate in the meeting of the NATO-Ukraine Commission.

What is happening these days in Ukraine? Russia is attempting to change existing borders under the threat or even use of force. The territorial integrity of a sovereign country has been violated by the annexation of Crimea in a blatant breach of international law. This undermines the foundations of our European post-war order, which recognizes the territorial integrity of every country. Only in this way could peaceful coexistence arise in Europe.

Recent reports of Russian soldiers advancing into Ukrainian territory underscore the drama of the current situation. It is becoming increasingly clear: From the very beginning, this was not a conflict within Ukraine, but a confrontation between Russia and Ukraine.

We have already made it clear that we will not passively accept Russia's behavior. In great agreement between the European Union and the United States, we have decided on sanctions. A breach of international law must not go unpunished. In light of the recent escalation, we asked the Commission on Saturday to prepare further substantial sanctions within a week.

The Federal Government is guided by the conviction that there will be no military solution to the conflict. All EU member states agree on this.

Our efforts to achieve a political solution are therefore all the more urgent. For us, a quick ceasefire and securing the border are paramount. We will continue to advocate for this in all our discussions, as will the Federal Foreign Minister and I.

Due to Russia's behavior, concerns have grown among some NATO partners that they too could be acutely threatened. This applies, for example, to the Baltic states and also to Poland. I repeat today what I said during my visit to Latvia: We stand by our alliance commitments. Article 5 of the NATO Treaty applies to all. – Our decisions in Wales will reaffirm this. We will adopt measures to further strengthen the alliance's response and defense capabilities. It is important for Germany that we operate in accordance with the NATO-Russia Founding Act of 1997. It is characterized by the insight that security in Europe can only be achieved through cooperation, not confrontation. This is and remains our conviction. We will continue to advocate for this intensively.

In Wales, we will also have the opportunity to take stock of the Afghanistan mission just before the end of the ISAF mission, but also to discuss next steps to support the country. This includes plans for the follow-on mission "Resolute Support" and further support, such as for the Afghan security forces. Our goal is to secure what has been achieved so far as sustainably as possible.

The domestic political disputes in Afghanistan over the succession in the presidency and the military actions of the still-active Taliban show that Afghanistan continues to need support from the international community, and thus also our support. The end of the ISAF mission – I have repeatedly emphasized this in the past – does not mean the end of our commitment to Afghanistan and the Afghan people. I am confident that the summit in Wales will once again send a signal of joint support.

The new security policy challenges must be addressed by us and our partners in times of increasingly tight budgets. Therefore, we strongly advocate for better linking our defense policy efforts within NATO and also the EU. We want to work on developing and maintaining the necessary capacities together. I am confident that we can agree on the next steps at the summit.

Dear colleagues, for the Federal Government, it is clear: No conflict in the world can be solved solely by military means. But time and again, we have faced decisions in recent years where it became clear: There are situations in which only military means can help to regain a political option. Every conflict has its own character; each time the weighing process is difficult; each time we, the government, but also many members of parliament here, struggle to find the right path.

Looking back to the 1990s, we see that we have made numerous far-reaching decisions since then. There were controversial discussions when Germany was asked to participate in the NATO operation in the former Yugoslavia. There were controversial discussions when it came to sending combat troops to Afghanistan after September 11, 2001. There were controversial discussions about participation in other military missions. Soldiers of the German Bundeswehr are still deployed in the Balkans, in Afghanistan, and also in Africa. I thank them from the bottom of my heart for their service, which is associated with high personal risks to body, soul, and life.

The decision we are debating today is not about the deployment of soldiers. But even the delivery of military equipment to a conflict party is a decision that must be carefully weighed.

In recent weeks, we have witnessed unimaginable atrocities committed by a terrorist group under the name "Islamic State" in Iraq and Syria. Marauding, plundering, and murdering, their heavily armed militias have advanced in Iraq to the vicinity of Baghdad and most recently to the threshold of the Kurdish autonomous region in northern Iraq. Everything that does not conform to their worldview is brutally eliminated.

The threat to religious minorities in Iraq is particularly dramatic. The militias present members of Christian churches with the choice of either converting to Islam or abandoning their homes and livelihoods, otherwise they face death. The existence of an entire faith community, the Yazidis, was temporarily endangered. We all still have the dramatic images of the situation on Mount Sinjar in mind: the encircled crowd, the men and women struggling for survival, the children dying of thirst. In the end, Kurdish forces bravely intervened, supported by determined air support from the United States. Only in this way could a large part of the Yazidis escape from the mountains.

But not only minorities are threatened, but also Shia Muslims and Sunnis who oppose the terror. Anyone who stands against the terrorist group ISIS must expect the worst. Here, a religion is being horrifically abused to legitimize murder, terror, and claims to power.

More than a million people are now fleeing from the terror. Hundreds of thousands have found refuge in the Kurdish north of Iraq, but also in parts of Syria and Turkey. The Kurdish autonomous government is reaching its limits with the immense number of refugees. There is a lack of everything. There is a shortage of shelter, food, and medical care. A humanitarian catastrophe is looming.

The terrorist group ISIS demonstrates day by day and step by step a transnational claim to power. With modern weapons and plundered financial resources, ISIS is now operating in Syria and Iraq over an area larger than half of Germany, and the terror militias continue their advance. ISIS envisions a caliphate that is to extend to the Mediterranean and include Jerusalem. The terrorist group has created its own financial sources of income. This significantly contributes to its strength and makes it so dangerous. The fighters act in unimaginably brutal ways. UN Human Rights Commissioner Navi Pillay speaks of crimes against humanity; in the areas where ISIS operates, ethnic and religious cleansing is being carried out.

Furthermore, Iraq is facing a breaking point due to the expanding terrorist regime of ISIS. There is a threat of further destabilization of an already politically fragile region. Lebanon, Jordan, and Turkey are already feeling the effects of the terror. Such far-reaching destabilization of an entire region also affects Germany and Europe. Ladies and gentlemen, when terrorists subjugate an area to create a stable foundation for their reign of terror and a refuge for themselves and other fanatics, the danger also grows for us; our security interests are at stake.

Moreover, jihadists from many countries – including European states – are joining the terrorist group. More than 400 Germans have now traveled to the region. Estimates suggest that the number of European fighters in the ranks of ISIS is in the four-digit range. This falls within our responsibility. We must also fear that these fighters will one day return and pose an immediate threat to our security. The danger has been a topic of public discussion for months.

The ISIS terror cannot leave us cold in many ways. Its expansion must be stopped. We are united in this in NATO and the European Union.

The United Nations Security Council adopted a resolution on August 15, 2014. It condemns the terrorist group ISIS in the strongest terms and provides measures to combat it. At the special meeting of EU foreign ministers convened by Germany, the support from individual member states for the Kurdish forces in their fight against the terrorist group ISIS was welcomed.

For the German government, it is clear: First and foremost, the plight of hundreds of thousands of refugees must be alleviated. Thanks to the close coordination of the ministries, we were able to respond quickly to the call for help from the Kurdish regional government. More than 150 tons of aid supplies have already been airlifted by the Bundeswehr to Arbil in northern Iraq. Currently, we have already spent and newly pledged a total of around 50 million euros in humanitarian aid. This is urgently needed immediate assistance.

All of this is important, and where people are in need, we will help – also through the additional acceptance of refugees.

However, our policy must primarily aim to ensure that people can stay in their homeland and live there in safety. It is about not only alleviating the suffering of people but also preventing it.

Together with the units of the Iraqi army and the United States, the Peshmerga are trying to repel the further advance of the terrorist group ISIS. We can be grateful for that. They expose themselves to high risks to achieve something that is also in our interest.

Like some of our EU partners, the German government – at the request of the Kurdish regional government and with the consent of the Iraqi central government – has decided to provide further comprehensive assistance. We are coordinating closely with EU member states, the United States, and our other partners around the world. There is an urgent need for military equipment such as bulletproof vests, helmets, and radios. We are taking care of that, and we are also prepared, in a limited manner and in close coordination with our partners, to provide weapons and ammunition to the armed forces of the autonomous region of Iraqi Kurdistan for the fight against the ISIS terrorist militia.

To deliver these, the responsible ministries within the federal government are utilizing their political and legal scope. This concerns the provision of military equipment, namely vehicles, weapons, and ammunition, from existing Bundeswehr stocks. The provision is made with the consent of the Iraqi central government to the armed forces of the autonomous region of Iraqi Kurdistan. We have communicated the details of these aid measures to you, dear colleagues, separately, and they have been presented in the Defense Committee and also in the Foreign Affairs Committee.

This decision is far-reaching. We have weighed it very carefully and considered all foreign and security policy aspects. We faced the choice of either taking no risks, not delivering, and ultimately accepting the spread of terror, or supporting those who are desperately but bravely fighting against the cruel ISIS terror with scant resources.

We are aware of the risks of such support. We have, of course, considered them. Conversely, we have also asked: What about the acute risks posed by the terrorist group ISIS if we do not deliver weapons and ammunition now? Can we really wait and hope that others will confront this acute danger? No. This does not align with our understanding of responsibility in this situation. The immense suffering of many people cries out to heaven, and our own security interests are threatened.

What is at stake in this case weighs heavier than what could be. We now have the chance to help stop a dehumanizing terrorist group and avert its further spread. We now have the chance to save lives and prevent further mass murders in Iraq. We now have the chance to prevent terrorists from creating a new, safe haven from which to spread hatred and violence into the world. We must seize this opportunity.

I emphasize once again: The delivery of military equipment will take place with the consent of the Iraqi central government. It is far from our intention to support centrifugal forces in Iraq. On the contrary: At its core, it is about preserving the Iraqi state structure from disintegration. The crucial key to this lies in a political process that includes all population groups.

Iraq needs a reconciliation process. The marginalization of large parts of the population, especially the Sunnis, must come to an end. It is about giving the disappointed Sunni tribes and other groups, including the Kurds, an appropriate place in their state and community. It is about countering extremism at its roots. It is also about respecting constitutionally guaranteed rights, for example, for the autonomous Kurdish regional government.

These are significant challenges for the designated Iraqi Prime Minister al-Abadi. The German government stands ready to support Iraq in addressing these challenges. Because it remains true: No conflict in this world can be resolved by military means alone. Conflicts can only be resolved permanently through political means, as we have experienced in Europe through the European integration process after the end of World War II.