Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the fifth meeting of Nobel Laureates in Economic Sciences on August 20, 2014, in Lindau:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

20 August 2014 · Fifth Meeting of Nobel Laureates in Economic Sciences · Lindau, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the fifth Lindau Meeting of Nobel Laureates in Economic Sciences on August 20, 2014, speaking on the societal role of economics and policy advice.
Main themes
Economics and society, science-politics relationship, economic policy advice, dialogue between generations and disciplines, Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings, role of economics in democracy, theory versus practice, Max Weber's science and politics vocations, scientific freedom, knowledge sharing
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,326
79th percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 44%43%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

174 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Dear Countess Bernadotte,

dear Mr. Heikensten,

dear Professor Schürer,

Mr. President Tan,

dear colleague, dear Minister Gerd Müller, who is also a representative here in the beautiful Lindau, dear District Administrator Stegmann,

Mr. Mayor Schober,

but above all, dear Nobel laureates, guests, and participants here,

ladies and gentlemen,

the Nobel Laureate Meetings in Lindau are, in the best sense of the word, an institution with tradition. They are marked by over 60 years of success. A unique scientific dialogue forum has emerged. As the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, I would like to say to you: We are proud of these annual meetings, as they are a brilliant showcase for our scientific location, but also for the culture of dialogue that we cultivate in Germany. For here in Lindau, you, the laureates and young scientists, are building bridges – bridges of inspiration and motivation, and bridges between generations, countries, but also between scientific disciplines.

Science thrives on such open dialogue. I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to all those who contribute to this, who do not just barricade themselves in their own ivory towers, but share their knowledge and their quest for knowledge with others. Because today, in the 21st century, time is becoming increasingly the most precious commodity. That esteemed scientists spend time with young, equally diligent and stressed scientists is a wonderful thing.

I would also like to express my gratitude for the opportunity to be here today at the opening event. The Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting for Economic Sciences is still relatively young – it is taking place for the fifth time now – but it has received a very large response: 18 Nobel laureates, over 450 young and promising early-career researchers from over 80 countries have gathered here. I warmly welcome you to Germany.

The guiding theme for your meeting this year is: “How useful is economics – how is economics useful?” It is good that you ask this question. I can only help you very limitedly with the answers. But of course, the question also arises as to what benefit economics has for society. Then we are almost at politics, which enables scientific findings to be applied practically. Therefore, from the fundamental question of the societal benefit of research, another question can be derived. And that is: What does optimal economic policy advice actually look like?

Max Weber addressed the tension and division of labor between science and politics in his two lectures “Science as a Vocation” and “Politics as a Vocation” almost 100 years ago. There is a commonality: Science and politics are always in the service of a transpersonal cause. But there are also significant differences: For science, the freedom of research and teaching is central, and thus, of course, the acquisition of knowledge itself. In contrast, politics is tasked with shaping and leading the community. Politics must always come to decisions, even when there are completely contradictory analyses or theories. Furthermore, it bears responsibility for the implementation of those decisions.

In democracies, the matter is even more complex. Politics in democracies must also always win the necessary majorities for decisions. This already shows that not only economically rational considerations need to be taken into account. However, I would like to emphasize that they should not be neglected. Rather, societal developments and cultural backgrounds are also subjects of investigation. You know from economics, of course, that not everything can be researched in a vacuum.

Economic know-how finds its way into politics in many ways, whether through publications in the media, but above all through collaboration with experts, advisory boards, or expert councils. I must say that I am very grateful for this support, which we have in many forms in the federal government. Because understanding how markets function or why they may not function has significant implications for societal welfare and all our lives.

To be honest, it is better to heed a good piece of advice from an expert once than to later have to compensate for significant disappointments for an entire society. Therefore, it is good and also explicitly desirable that science meets the demand to continually build bridges from theory to practice and also provides guidance to politics.

Good policy advice is undoubtedly characterized by its proximity to practice, meaning that it takes into account existing realities and interdependencies. But of course, you also need priorities and premises for your research. The complexity and dynamics of reality cannot simply be pressed into models. However, the aspiration to come as close to reality as possible should exist where advice is given in the political and societal sphere.

I would like to add something else that I, as a former scientist, often miss in these consultations: One should also have the honesty to indicate the error rates or uncertainties when one does not know exactly. This sometimes helps to prevent disappointments, and we can certainly live with that.

Sustainability is an important principle for us in Germany in the entire economic, financial, and social sphere. Therefore, good policy advice must also always be based on proposals that endure over time. We are trying in Germany to make the principle of sustainability a political guiding strategy, taking into account ecological, economic, and social aspects equally, as that is essentially the essence of any sustainability strategy. However, this is easier said than done. In particular, such a sustainability strategy depends on knowing what the people for whom we are making policy understand by good quality of life.

We are trying to align our government actions, especially in this legislative period, precisely with this question of good quality of life. In doing so, we can build on work that has been done in France by the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission. At that time, efforts were made to create an expanded measurement and better representation of wealth and social progress. We certainly agree that pure growth rates and gross domestic product alone are not qualitatively sufficient indicators. I explicitly share this concern.

We want to approach this with a somewhat different approach in the coming years as a federal government, by more intensively gathering the concrete ideas of citizens about a good life and developing an indicator system that politics can then orient itself to. This also means that we are certain that the homo oeconomicus is much more than just a being with economic data, but that influences from behavioral economics and much more flow into a theory that is useful for society.

Ludwig Erhard, who is regarded in Germany as the father of the social market economy, was already convinced decades ago that economics is 50 percent psychology. We all learn again and again that a half-full glass can indeed be half full or half empty, and depending on the perspective, joy or annoyance arises. In this respect, a multitude of factors is extremely important for providing future scenarios.

Now we are coming out of years in which one – I want to say this very cautiously in such a learned circle – did not always have the impression that the economic sciences knew everything that was coming our way. One can now certainly ask what it was that caused some of what we assumed in our statistics and forecasts – not only we as politicians but also in highly expert organizations – to be so far from the reality that then emerged. There are various possibilities for this. Probably everyone has a share in it.

One reason is that the underlying theories were not sufficient, particularly that one did not correctly predict the transformation of quantities into completely new qualities. But one can also say: There have always been voices in science that predicted nearly everything that has occurred. One could therefore also say: We did not listen properly. Or one could say: We listened to the wrong people. In any case, there was not the impression that the majority made the correct predictions.

This also gives politicians some leeway. One can always choose among various scientific opinions the one that seems most likely. Therefore, the dialogue between science and politics will remain interesting. But of course, politics has an interest in not always reacting but in acting, meaning shaping developments preventively. Therefore, we must consider: What do we learn from the crises of recent years – from the financial market crisis, which quickly turned into a crisis of the Eurozone in the European Union?

We had to deal with the crisis of the financial markets very ad hoc, always experiencing that those who may have had something to do with causing the crisis were already safely on the shore, while those who had not been so involved in the crisis fell into severe economic turbulence. When we think of the millions of unemployed around the world, it is sometimes very bitter.

Therefore, we have tried in Europe to take new paths – especially in the crisis that we refer to as the Euro crisis. One can also call it a sovereign debt crisis or a competitiveness crisis. Today, we have a situation where productivity is rising again, current account deficits are decreasing, budget deficits are being reduced, and above all, various programs such as those from the EFSF and the ESM have also created securities.

One can therefore say: There are first fruits. But one must also ask: Is it enough already? I know that many of you here make very critical remarks about how Europe is managing its crisis. Therefore, I want to preface by saying: Europe – that consists of 28 member states, of which 18 now have a common currency. This is a rather unique occurrence when compared globally. These 18 states have their own budget policy, their own economic policy, and a common central bank. The question of how to deal with such a construct has, of course, become very pressing during this time. Because each of these 18 Euro countries has a national parliament that does not necessarily follow every recommendation of the European Commission or the European Central Bank when it comes to the preparation of budgets or economic or social policies.

Therefore, for me, there are three causes that we must work to overcome in order not to fall back into such a crisis.

First: We must correct the structural flaws of the Economic and Monetary Union. This is a significant undertaking. We have a single market, but we have very little economic policy coordination and certainly no binding and sanctioned means of being held accountable in any way for failing to meet one’s own promises. This must, in my deep conviction, be improved in the zone with a common currency – both in terms of budget preparation and competitiveness.

Second: We have, so to speak, legacy burdens in the form of very high national debts.

Third: We have banking systems that overall bring too many problems and too little transparency. Work has already been done on all these issues, but further work must continue.

One lesson will be – and I will continue to work on this – that we must better coordinate our economic policies across Europe, that our reference point should not be the average of all Eurozone member states when it comes to competitiveness, but that the reference point must be the best, and not just the best in Europe, but the best worldwide, if we want to maintain our prosperity.

One must always keep in mind: The European Union has a share of about seven percent of the world’s population. We have, when things are going reasonably well, a share of about 25 percent of the world’s value creation. And we have nearly 50 percent of the world’s social spending. If we want to maintain this in the long term – our share of the population is decreasing, our share of GDP is likely decreasing as well – then we must be quite creative, quite innovative, and we really cannot afford to orient ourselves to the average of the world.

Germany has experienced that we can quite well combine budget consolidation and growth. This is one of the major discussion points: must one always incur debt for growth? We have learned in recent years that this is not necessary, but that we could consolidate our budget – working and living with a debt brake in the constitution – while at the same time significantly more employment has been created in the last ten years. We have three million more employees than we did ten years ago and can now record a record 42 million employed persons in Germany. Since 2005, we have nearly doubled our research and innovation expenditures as well as our education expenditures at the federal level. And we have repeatedly seized our opportunities in investment spending in other areas whenever we had budgetary leeway.

I want to say one more thing for those who do not come from European countries: Europe is a continent that is shaped more by demographic change than, for example, the United States of America. This means that the number of older people is increasing while the number of younger people is decreasing. Germany is among the countries that will be most affected by demographic challenges. This means that when we aim for a zero in new debt today, we are doing so in light of a completely different demographic situation in the next ten years than, for example, in the United States of America. There is also a significant difference there. And we must not take away all the leeway from future generations. Therefore, I see growth and budget consolidation as two sides of the same coin.

Now, all the problems we have in the Eurozone are not completely unknown in other parts of the world. High public debt exists elsewhere as well, and there is also a backlog of reforms. We all experienced during the international financial crisis that at least the financial markets are already completely globalized, while the decision-making structures are largely national – in Europe also within the framework of the European Union. This naturally gives rise to significant regulatory problems.

It is already not easy to know how to regulate financial markets. Implementing this globally in such a way that the so-called level playing field is reasonably comparable for all and that no one says, I will now gain a competitive advantage by doing it a little differently, is of course a dramatic political task.

Since we have all experienced that it was completely irrelevant who caused the international financial crisis, and in the end, everyone was affected, we must try to approach this as strictly as possible and say: If we set out in the midst of this financial crisis at the end of the last decade that every financial center, every financial market actor, and every financial market product should be regulated, we cannot now, when things are somewhat running smoothly, start deviating from that and look for a way out.

When we, as the 20 leading industrial nations of the world, meet at the G20 summit this year in Australia, we still have an area that is quite "naked" in terms of regulation: these are the shadow banks. The entire regulation we have created in the banking sector has, of course, the effect that those who are subject to regulation try to evade into the shadow banking sector. If we do not also scrutinize this area with the same consistency, then the danger of the next crisis is already pre-programmed.

We have a new fiscal pact in Europe regarding budget consolidation. The European weakness is sometimes that we decide on something and then immediately call it into question after we have decided. We should not do that. In addition to the question that we need to coordinate our economic policy more closely in the Eurozone, I have spoken about the weakness of the banking system. We have made a real quantum leap in this area in recent years. We are working on a European banking union with a common supervision by the European Central Bank and clear liability cascades. This would have been completely unthinkable three or four years ago. It was also a difficult step for Germany to take this path. But we are convinced that it is of utmost importance for the transparency and also for the acceptance of the Euro system worldwide.

When we look at the real economy, the question is: how can we best utilize global growth opportunities? Seventy years ago, when the international Bretton Woods Conference was discussing the order of the world monetary system, U.S. President Roosevelt was a guest. He spoke about trade. I would like to quote him: "Trade is the lifeblood of a free society. We must ensure that the arteries that carry the blood flow are not clogged again, as they were in the past, by artificial barriers created by senseless economic rivalries."

We had set out during the international financial crisis not to let trade barriers rise. The reports from the World Trade Organization are not quite as optimistic as our intentions were. We want a multilateral trading system. We have had some successes at times. Bali sparked hope. Now there have been setbacks again. We are currently not making the best progress, and in my firm conviction, that is the multilateral way, but rather the second-best way with bilateral agreements. Here, the European Union has already conducted a number of negotiations.

At the moment, the so-called TTIP, the trade agreement with the United States of America, is very much in discussion. I do not need to tell you: if the European internal market and the American internal market were to form a free trade zone, it would open up significant growth potential. But there are also significant fears that standards for environmental, consumer, or labor protection could be endangered. Therefore, we still have a difficult debate ahead of us. But I want to make it very clear: free trade, barrier-free trade is one of the sources of growth without having to incur debt and live on credit, and therefore this is a very essential point.

You are examining market developments in your research, looking for new theories, for explanations. Whether demographic change or climate change, whether globalization or digitalization – there seems to be almost nothing that does not interest economists nowadays. I believe this makes your theories better rather than worse, although I suspect it also makes them more complicated.

Science can facilitate decision-making for politics. We as politicians know that you cannot make decisions for us. To be honest, we do not want that either; otherwise, we could be scientists ourselves. Science is certainly shaped by its own premises and values. Politics must always be aware of this. We must find a balance between the interests of all social groups. Therefore, I want to conclude with a commitment to the freedom and independence of science and thus also to the plurality of science. These are essential prerequisites for scientific advice to provide an unbiased decision-making aid, even if the results do not always suit one. Only such science is a true advisor for us.

Therefore, I would like to encourage you, especially the younger people among you: engage in political and social debates – with your expertise, with your experiences, regardless of your regional and cultural background and regardless of which school of thought within economics you are close to. Facing an open and free exchange of opinions may sometimes be uncomfortable, somewhat comparable to competition in the economy, but it will benefit us all. I am deeply convinced of that.

Finally, one more request: speak understandably as scientists. Even the most complicated issues can be expressed in simple language. This is the necessary prerequisite for us to be able to understand each other at all. In this sense, I hope that you could understand me, and thank you for your attention.