Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the special meeting of the European Council of 27 on April 29, 2017, in Brussels before the German Bundestag on April 27, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

27 April 2017 · Government statement on the special meeting of the European Council of 27 on 29 April 2017 · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on April 27, 2017, ahead of the special European Council meeting on Brexit and to discuss Turkey's constitutional referendum.
Main themes
Brexit negotiations, European Council special meeting, Turkey constitutional referendum, German-Turkish relations, EU membership and rule of law, OSCE election monitoring, freedom of press and opinion, democratic rights, Venice Commission concerns, EU unity
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,815
73rd percentile
Sentences
125
73rd percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
12.7
53rd percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 53%47%
  • Institutional 21%18%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

125 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen!

Allow me to extend a warm greeting to the representatives of Tunisia before we begin, as I fondly remember speaking in the Tunisian Parliament a few weeks ago. We wish Tunisia every success in its work and on its difficult, yet so far very hopeful path.

The European Council will meet on Saturday in Brussels with the future 27 member states to discuss the United Kingdom's exit from the European Union. The exit negotiations will certainly demand a lot from the European Union as well as from the United Kingdom itself over the next two years. This is, I believe, beyond doubt. However, it is also beyond doubt that these exit negotiations are by no means the only challenge that Europe will have to face in the next two years. Therefore, please allow me to first say a few words about the developments in Turkey. The situation there cannot go unmentioned in this debate, and it will certainly not go unmentioned at our meeting on Saturday, although I must point out that discussions regarding Turkey must officially take place in the Council of the 28 member states, as the United Kingdom is still a member of the European Union with all rights and obligations, meaning that the actual discussion cannot take place on Saturday.

First of all: Of course, we respect the right of the Turkish citizens to decide freely and democratically about their own constitutional order. I believe this is self-evident for us. However, we must take note of the joint report of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) and the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe regarding the conduct of this vote with even greater concern. At this point, I would like to thank the participating members of parliament as well as the head of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, Michael Link, for their important work. Their assessment is of particular significance, as it comes from independent observers.

The Turkish government must be held accountable to this report and must answer the questions raised within it. The accusation in the report that there was no equality of opportunity for the various camps in the referendum campaign is as serious as the finding that fundamental democratic rights have been restricted under the state of emergency. We will closely monitor how Turkey addresses any potential irregularities.

The same applies to the further steps of the Turkish government in the concrete implementation of the constitutional reform and in its cooperation with the Council of Europe. This also includes the comprehensive monitoring procedure that the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe decided on this Tuesday. The serious concerns expressed by the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe regarding the process and content of the constitutional reform carry significant weight. Turkey must take these concerns into account—as a member of the Council of Europe, as a member of the OSCE, and as a candidate for European Union membership. It is—let me be clear—irreconcilable with the rule of law if an executive— in this case, the Turkish executive—makes prejudgments, as has publicly happened with Deniz Yücel. The Federal Government will continue to demand compliance with the rule of law standards, not only with regard to his fate but also concerning the many criminal proceedings in Turkey, including the high value of freedom of opinion and the press.

There is no doubt that the developments of the past week have put a significant strain on German-Turkish and European-Turkish relations. In this situation, we will continue to strive to return to a constructive German-Turkish and European-Turkish dialogue. The foreign ministers will meet today and tomorrow and will also come together with the Turkish foreign minister. A definitive distancing of Turkey from Europe, but also—and I say this with caution—of Europe from Turkey would not be in the interest of either Germany or Europe. Therefore, both wisdom and clarity are required. And likewise—with wisdom and clarity—we will discuss within the European Union what precise consequences we consider appropriate and at what time; the Federal Government aims for a joint action of the European institutions in this regard.

The special meeting of the European Council on the coming Saturday was convened after the United Kingdom officially announced on March 29 that it wishes to leave the European Union. The British government is implementing what a majority of British voters decided a little over ten months ago in a referendum. To be very clear: We—Germany and the other member states of the European Union—did not wish for this exit. But here too, we—Germany and the other member states of the European Union—respect this democratically made decision and now look forward.

With the official letter from the British government, the two-year period has begun. After this period, the United Kingdom's membership in the European Union, as described in the treaties, will end. It is now up to us, the future 27 member states and the European institutions, to define our own interests and goals for the upcoming negotiations. To this end, the European Council will take the first step on Saturday and adopt common guidelines for the negotiations in the format of the 27.

The President of the European Council, Donald Tusk, has presented a very good and balanced draft text for this purpose after intensive preparations, in which, of course, the Federal Government has also participated. I would like to sincerely thank Donald Tusk for this, as this draft not only fully takes into account the concerns of the 27 member states but also the overarching interests of the European Union as a whole. My many conversations in recent weeks have shown that there is now a great consensus among the 27 member states and the institutions regarding our common negotiating line towards the United Kingdom. Therefore, we can assume that the European Council of the 27 will send a strong signal of unity the day after tomorrow.

The guidelines of the European Council will form the basis for the negotiating mandate that the 27 member states will likely grant to the European Commission in a further step at the end of May. This negotiating mandate will be significantly more comprehensive than the guidelines we will adopt on Saturday. However, I would like to emphasize that I share the expectation of the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, that the actual political negotiations with the United Kingdom will only gain real momentum after the British general elections on June 8 and can only gain real momentum then. In these negotiations, the European Union will be represented by the European Commission with its chief negotiator Michel Barnier.

From the very beginning, I have also advocated that during the entire negotiation process, all important decisions should only be made with the consent of the member states. This applies, of course—this is also the position of the entire Federal Government—and it is also ensured, as the exit of a member state from the European Union directly affects the interests of all other member states.

For us, three concerns are at the center of the negotiations:

First:

We must safeguard the interests of our German citizens. This particularly concerns the very concrete everyday issues that many people directly affected by Brexit are facing. This is especially true for those who currently live in the United Kingdom as German and European citizens. It is estimated that this currently applies to about 100,000 Germans, all with individual biographies and very personal concerns about an uncertain future.

Let us think, for example, of a retiree who may have moved from Germany to the United Kingdom years ago for professional reasons, bought a house there, and is now facing significant legal uncertainties in retirement. Or let us think of a young student who lives the dream of a borderless Europe and is now worried about whether he can stay in the United Kingdom after his ongoing higher education in Scotland. Or let us think of a German couple living in London whose children have grown up in the United Kingdom and who rely every day on access to school, employment, and health insurance.

Many more examples could follow. They all stand for the fact that the Federal Government will work intensively in the negotiations with the United Kingdom to achieve clarity and planning security in all these matters as quickly as possible in the interest of all affected German citizens. We will, of course, do everything we can to ensure that any potential negative impacts on the everyday lives of our citizens are minimized. In return, we are, of course, also willing to make a fair offer to British citizens living in Germany and in other EU member states. They are, of course, an important part of our coexistence and should remain so.

Second:

We must prevent damage to the European Union as a whole that a failed transition of the United Kingdom to its future status as a third country could bring. Entrepreneurs, for example, want to know whether they can continue to bring their products to each other's markets. Scientists are asking whether they can continue to collaborate with their British colleagues. Therefore, it is essential to create legal certainty about the consequences of the exit from the outset. Where our interests require it, we will, of course, continue to strive for close cooperation between the EU and the United Kingdom. This applies, for example, to the joint fight against terrorism and organized crime or to cooperation in security and defense policy. At the same time, we will always ensure that we preserve and strengthen the achievements of European integration in this cooperation. I am firmly convinced that the European Union will remain a unique community of values and one of the strongest economic areas in the world even after the United Kingdom's exit.

Third:

We must strengthen the cohesion of the European Union of the 27. Just a little over a month ago, we celebrated the 60th anniversary of the signing of the Treaties of Rome in Rome. On this occasion, all parties once again explicitly affirmed that and how much we are united for our happiness. Sixty years of European integration is a unique success story, and this success story must continue to be written with the future 27 member states.

I will do everything I can to ensure that we, the 27 member states, continue to stand together on all difficult issues as we have done so excellently since the British referendum ten months ago, because we have managed to present a united front despite sometimes divergent individual interests. That we would achieve this was by no means a given on the morning after the British referendum, and we should explicitly acknowledge that. All 27 member states, the European Commission, and the European Parliament have adhered to what we agreed upon back then.

We have not conducted any preliminary negotiations with the United Kingdom, nor have we prioritized individual aspects in advance; instead, we have prepared well for the negotiations as the European Union and coordinated closely. Of course, there are a multitude of very specific interests. Just think of the Republic of Ireland and its shared space with the United Kingdom or the issues in Northern Ireland. Therefore, it was a good achievement to stay united. As a result, we are now well prepared both substantively and organizationally.

I explicitly welcome that the resolution of the European Parliament from April 5 also aligns with the same substantive line that we want to adopt the day after tomorrow in the European Council. Such an approach is, however, also indispensable, as we must prepare for very complex negotiations between the European Union and the United Kingdom, which, by the way, must ultimately be approved not only by the Council but also by the European Parliament.

In 44 years of Britain's membership in the European Union, a dense web of relationships has developed, which now needs to be unraveled piece by piece. This also includes clarifying all financial obligations that Britain has entered into as an EU member state, which extend into the period after its exit. We believe – I would like to add this; I hope there is support for it – that these negotiations cannot be conducted only at the very end, but must be one of the important aspects that need to be addressed from the very beginning.

The order of our approach is clear, even if it will not always be easy to adhere to: We can only conclude an agreement on the future relationship with Britain once all exit questions have been satisfactorily resolved. This means: The sooner the British government is willing to find constructive solutions, the sooner we can address their desire to discuss the future relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union during the exit negotiations. But first, we need to know how Britain envisions its future relations with us. It can and will only proceed in this order, not the other way around. This is the order that we, the 27 member states, will pay attention to and insist upon.

Without progress on the many open questions of the exit, including the financial questions, it makes no sense to negotiate details of the future relationship in parallel. The European Commission, led by Jean-Claude Juncker and its chief negotiator Michel Barnier, has made this position clear time and again. Jean-Claude Juncker was in Britain just yesterday with Michel Barnier and reiterated this there. The Commission has the full support of the Federal Government for this. It is also clear: A third country – and that will be Britain – cannot and will not have the same rights or possibly be better off than a member of the European Union. All 27 member states and the European institutions agree on this as well.

You may think that these are actually self-evident points. However, I must unfortunately state this so clearly here, as I have the feeling that some in Britain still have illusions about this. That would be a waste of time.

Of course, there must also be a balanced relationship of rights and obligations in the future relationship between Britain and the European Union. If Britain is willing to do this, then nothing should stand in the way of a close and long-term partnership with the European Union. We, as the European Union, certainly strive for good, close, and trusting relations with Britain. We also have an interest in a prosperous and successful United Kingdom. In one word: We will conduct the negotiations fairly and constructively, and we expect exactly that from the British side. Our goal will always be to achieve the best outcome for Europe and its citizens. This is how we, as the EU of 27, will conduct the talks, and this is how we hope to successfully conclude them.

Of course, in the coming two years, the parliaments will play an enormously important role. The regular exchange of the respective national governments with the national parliaments is, in my view, crucial to ultimately reaching a viable negotiation result. The Federal Government and the German Bundestag will handle this within the framework of the usual close cooperation. I would like to emphasize here how much it strengthens the Federal Government in the demanding negotiations when the parliament supports it within this cooperation. Therefore, I am extremely pleased that the German Bundestag is preparing a resolution proposal on the guidelines, which is scheduled for a vote today and aligns with the same substantive line that the Federal Government represents and which we want to adopt on Saturday at the European Council.

We are aware of the magnitude of the task, especially its complexity. We are well prepared, but it will still require a lot of work. Our goal is to continue the success story of the European Union. Being able to live well in Germany and Europe is and remains the goal that guides us. We know that the times are overall demanding. The crises and conflicts in Europe's immediate neighborhood are far too serious, too profound, and too diverse; the global challenges of flight and migration, of hunger – when we think of Africa these days – and need, the challenges of world trade, and climate protection are too great for Europe to afford to only focus on itself in the coming two years – Brexit or not.

We 27 want to assert our values and interests worldwide in the future as well. We want to do this for the benefit of the citizens of our unique, large community of values. It is precisely about them, the citizens, who will be the future 450 million Union citizens. It is about our shared good life in Germany and Europe in the coming years and decades. For this, I ask for your support.