Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the Day of Internal Security of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group on April 26, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

29 April 2017 · Day of Internal Security of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group's Day of Internal Security on April 26, 2017, in Berlin, outlining Germany's security priorities ahead of federal elections.
Main themes
Internal security, counterterrorism, police and security services support, legislative security measures, deportation and migration policy, societal cohesion, data protection, intelligence services, security personnel recruitment, CDU/CSU security policy
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,652
70th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%37%
  • Geopolitical 24%21%
  • Social 16%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%10%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 13%

134 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Dear Volker Kauder,

dear Gerda Hasselfeldt,

dear colleagues from our CDU/CSU parliamentary group,

dear guests who have come here in large numbers today,

I believe that the number of those gathered here at this so-called parliamentary level speaks to the significance of the topic. We, the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, and of course the federal government – the Federal Minister of the Interior has already spoken to you – have turned our attention to this issue, and we are committed to it because we know that it concerns a core question of the relationship between citizens and their state. People expect – rightly, I say – that the state does everything humanly possible, everything feasible, to ensure the safety of its citizens. We know that freedom can only be lived when security is largely guaranteed.

In recent months and years, but especially recently, we have been confronted with terrorist attacks that have understandably unsettled many people and raised questions. Just earlier this month, a man drove a truck into a crowd in Stockholm. This is not just a German phenomenon. We know from France and other countries about such terrible attacks.

There are always many people who make it clear: We want security, we also want the necessary legal order for it. Societal cohesion also means that we remember the victims, that we provide support to the injured and their relatives, and that we repeatedly send a signal that we will not allow our way of living in free, democratic societies to be destroyed. There are always people who set such a signal. The way the population in Sweden reacted was particularly impressive. One person said: "When darkness surrounds us, it is more important than ever to respond with light and warmth." This means that, overall, we as a society must demonstrate cohesion, but of course also provide the right answers to the challenges.

Our discussion is repeatedly shaped by the fact that those who defend our security, who guarantee it and work for it, receive our support. On the one hand, this involves legislative support, but on the other hand, it also involves advocating for the entire society to support them. However, when one experiences the discussions that take place in some areas and with differently structured governments – for example, at the state level – and the amount of distrust with which police officers are met, I can only say: Everyone should put themselves in the situation of young men and women who are willing to put their lives at risk every day for our safety. Therefore, we cannot be grateful enough that there are people who feel committed to this work, who enjoy doing it, and who do it with great enthusiasm and passion – thank you for that. This applies to our federal police, to the police in the states, and also to the intelligence services that we need.

In recent months and years, we have also often talked about the necessary protection of individual data, also in connection with the NSA incidents. However, we have also recognized how important the services are – whether it is about foreign services like the Federal Intelligence Service (BND), the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution, or the Federal Criminal Police Office (BKA). Therefore, a heartfelt thank you here as well. The work often takes place in secrecy – it must also take place in secrecy. Thousands of people are working hard on investigations. We have just seen, with the example of the attack on the Borussia Dortmund team bus, what absurd constellations can arise. Therefore, a heartfelt thank you to our security authorities.

You have already spoken in detail today about our legislative initiatives, about questions related to flight and migration, about the question of who has a right of residence with us and who does not, about the necessary instruments we need. I will only mention, for example, the extension of detention for deportation and the facilitation of deportation custody. The question of threats, preventive measures, electronic ankle bracelets – you have already discussed all of this in detail. Therefore, I will only mention three pillars that are very important for the security architecture in our country.

The first is: We need enough people who are willing to take on the task of guaranteeing security. We have set standards on the part of the federal government regarding budget law and the budgetary resources we have made available, and regarding the growth in the authorities. I believe that the BKA, the federal police, and the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution are now faced with the enormous task of finding suitable employees and training them as quickly as possible – in other words, utilizing the resources we provide them. Fortunately, we have seen similar developments in many federal states – I say: in the union-led federal states more than in others; we are proud of that. We are here at a congress of the CDU and the CSU. We want to encourage young people to engage in the security sector, to educate themselves, and to see their professional future there. Therefore, societal support for the people who work in these areas is so important.

But personnel alone is not enough. The discussion is often narrowed down to the personnel issue. We consider that to be wrong because we live in a time when the communication possibilities of people are changing dramatically. Everyone experiences this with the possibilities that smartphones and computers bring. However, those who remain mentally stagnant in the debates about telecommunications surveillance in landlines do not provide those working in the security sector with what they need. Therefore, I consider it to be the second most important task to approach the question of what possibilities exist today in a pragmatic manner, rather than constantly ideologically debating what can and cannot be.

From equipping with cars to means for monitoring information exchange, our security authorities need the most modern possibilities to be able to act successfully and to thwart those who want to destroy our free democratic basic order. This is our benchmark for what we have developed in recent months.

I see the member of parliament Mayer, who names new laws in every parliamentary group meeting, and Lisa Winkelmeier-Becker, who has been following changes in the legal area in long lines. I admit, it is not so easy for every member of parliament to say what the latest innovation was in their constituency. But we cannot stand still because the technical possibilities are also constantly evolving. Therefore, it makes no sense to draw a line at some point and say: "Now we have done everything." Rather, we must always be ready to provide the authorities and the people who guarantee security with the necessary tools to make it clear: The rule of law cannot be taken lightly; it has the means to enforce what security-conscious citizens expect. In this context, technological development is our companion. Therefore, we must always learn and listen to those who need certain things.

The third point, which weighs heavily on us and about which the Federal Minister of the Interior has thought a lot and to which he has also proposed controversial discussions, is the question: How do we achieve a uniform level of security throughout the Federal Republic of Germany? People have little understanding, rightly so, that there is a different degree of security when, for example, in North Rhine-Westphalia, checks are not practiced, while in Bavaria they are, or when we have differences in monitoring, for example, of threats. How do we want to explain that?

Therefore, we as members of the Bundestag or as the federal government will not be satisfied with having 16 different levels of security in 16 different federal states. We need a uniform level of security, and it must be a high one. We will continue to push for that. The less we have it, the less the voluntary agreements work, the stronger the call for centralization will naturally become. I can understand the criticism from the federal states that are doing very well. But on the other hand, if one comes from federal states that are not doing so well, one says it would be nice if we also had more enforcement options at the central, federal, or federal level. This question will continue to accompany us.

We have some good exchange opportunities when it comes to centers for counter-terrorism and others. However, it is also important to ensure that responsibilities are clearly defined. For example, we need – this is clear to everyone – a uniform definition of threats for the entire Federal Republic of Germany. How can a federal authority discuss with states where different definitions of threats exist and where arguments are made differently? And if something happens, there will rightly be no understanding in the population. Therefore, we must repeatedly point to this wound. I believe everyone understands that.

One question that the federal government is increasingly addressing – I suspect the Federal Minister of the Interior has also commented on this – is the question of the security of our infrastructures. This involves cybersecurity, security in times of increasing possibilities for digital cyberattacks, access to sensitive data systems, espionage, and sabotage in both the economic sector and in state infrastructures. In response to the heightened threat situation, we have developed a new cybersecurity strategy and have reorganized ourselves both technically and organizationally. For example, we will establish the Central Office for Information Technology in the Security Sector – short: ZITiS – which was launched at the beginning of this year, to keep our security authorities up to date through research and development. It is appropriate to involve all security authorities in these research results.

In this entire context, we also need much stronger networking within the European Union. I do not want to list everything here in detail, but I will just say: We have created a space of freedom, the so-called Schengen Area. In it, we can move freely; goods, services, and capital can flow freely. We want a digital internal market. All correct, but a space of freedom and security has borders. And if these borders are no longer the national internal borders, then we must be able to protect the external borders.

In recent months, we have made a fundamental experience – especially in 2015 – namely that the practiced protection of the external borders did not withstand the requirements at all. However, we have fortunately achieved some important things – very much through German and French measures – such as a common border police. But we have not yet achieved everything we need. Work is being done on this intensively, for example, on a uniform entry and exit register. We have let this run for years, it must be said, which is why it was not clear who enters and exits the Schengen Area. Just as it is completely normal in the United States, we must also enforce border protection measures and transparency measures for our common area of freedom of movement so that we know who is with us. This will be the next major important step.

Europe is therefore facing a central challenge. We have not yet fully addressed this central challenge, I want to state that explicitly. We must also admit that Germany has not always pushed to the forefront to address this challenge. But the future of the European Union depends significantly on this. It is about a lot. It is about the question of whether we can maintain freedom of movement, the freedom of movement of citizens, in the long term, or whether we will have a gradual change, with national border controls reappearing everywhere with increasing intensity, which would of course have serious economic consequences.

But accepting this Schengen area as the space that defines the external borders means thinking completely anew. Then our neighbors are no longer Poland, Austria, Switzerland, France, Luxembourg, Belgium, and the Netherlands, but our neighborhoods are – I like to say this; you already know it from me – Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, Turkey, Georgia, Syria, Lebanon, Israel, Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, and the North Pole, because Norway is part of the Schengen area. That is where the external border lies. We must think in this category. This will make the question of which conflicts we address and which threats we must confront quite different than if one is regionally anchored in the middle of the Schengen area and deals with national borders. But if this rethinking does not succeed, the citizens will have no understanding of it. They expect a rethinking from us. And that is why this is an outstanding European task.

Now I have talked a lot about terrorist threats, less about what concerns people just as much. And those are, for example, issues of burglary or, as it is sometimes called, everyday crime. Especially burglaries, the intrusion into private spheres, are, in my view, not sufficiently considered in their psychological significance for people and not taken seriously enough. On the one hand, it is right to have very intense discussions about telecommunications surveillance, but on the other hand, to regard burglaries almost as a kind of natural phenomenon, we must not accept that. That is why Volker Kauder and others have repeatedly pointed out: We must help people to protect themselves better. That is why there is also a funding program from the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau.

But we also want to be able to properly pursue those who commit burglaries. This includes an increased penalty. We have agreed on this in the coalition. This also naturally includes that one can really pursue the offenders. And that also means that one should not use data protection as an excuse and thereby reduce the possibilities for clarification. This is something we are currently discussing in the coalition. In this regard, we as a Union will also take a tough and clear stance. I think that is right because we want to act in a way that really brings success, because people do not live on words, they do not live on laws on paper, but they live from the fact that their real situation improves.

As Federal Chancellor and thus also as the person responsible for the Federal Government, I cannot promise you that we have no threats to face. They are there, and they are not only nationally localized. We must confront this. But what I can promise you is that we will not bow to the challenges, but will face them courageously – that we are ready to think anew where new thinking is necessary; and always with the awareness that freedom and security are closely linked and that as a state, in order for people to live in freedom, we must ensure security.

In this sense, I would like to thank everyone who is involved. The most difficult legislative projects have been tackled in a short time. This means that the security authorities are also faced with the task of carrying out comprehensive renewals, restructuring, and training programs in a short time – this also disrupts such apparatuses – while simultaneously delivering peak performance. The Federal Police had to incredibly expand the scope of its tasks, for example, when thinking about border controls in the south. Many officers are permanently away from home, working overtime, and facing huge challenges. And that is why this congress – in addition to considering the legal situation – is simply also an expression of our respect for the performance of those who implement what we pass as laws every day.

Thank you to the faction for organizing this congress. Thank you to everyone who participated. Thank you to everyone who is interested. We will continue to work with all intensity to protect the high good of security. Thank you very much.