Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel to the European Council on February 18/19, 2016, in Brussels before the German Bundestag on February 17, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 February 2016 · European Council, February 18/19, 2016; government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on February 17, 2016, previewing her position ahead of the European Council summit in Brussels on the UK's EU membership demands.
Main themes
Brexit negotiations, UK membership in the European Union, European competitiveness and bureaucracy reduction, Economic and Monetary Union, free movement and non-discrimination, subsidiarity and proportionality, role of national parliaments, social systems and welfare abuse, European integration, UK-Germany relations, David Cameron's EU reform demands
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,493
81st percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 45%44%
  • Institutional 30%30%
  • Social 12%12%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

166 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Dear colleagues,

The future of Great Britain as a member of the European Union will be a dominant topic at the European Council starting tomorrow. We will address the expectations that British Prime Minister David Cameron has presented to the European Union on behalf of Great Britain.

As the federal government, we have always made it clear that we are working for results that will ultimately benefit not only the United Kingdom itself but also Germany and all of Europe. For the concerns of David Cameron are by no means just British individual interests. In some facts or questions, one must even say: Quite the opposite. In many respects, they are also concerns that are legitimate and understandable. Just as David Cameron does, I also believe it is necessary for us to advocate much more for competitiveness, transparency, and the reduction of bureaucracy within the European Union. Germany and Great Britain have shared this conviction for many years.

I also share with David Cameron the view that member states that have a different currency than the euro must not be overlooked in matters that are important to them. Our goal must therefore be to avoid discrimination while allowing differentiation where it is necessary in substance. This is not in contradiction to the fact that the European Economic and Monetary Union can, of course, continue to make the necessary decisions independently in the future – and will do so. Because the experience from the European sovereign debt crisis has shown how quickly additional steps towards integration can become necessary.

I would like to remind you that not all the problems that have become visible due to the crisis have been permanently resolved. For this reason, Germany and France want to develop joint proposals on how the European Economic and Monetary Union can be sensibly further developed. That is why it is so important that the President of the European Council, Donald Tusk, has clarified in his proposals that no additional obstacles may be created for deepening the Economic and Monetary Union. Because if some want to move forward in the European Union, then that must continue to be possible in the future.

This is, by the way, not in any way contrary to David Cameron's concern to find a common interpretation of the goal enshrined in the European treaties of an – as it literally states – "ever closer union of the peoples of Europe." Here, too, we agree: There must always be the possibility of further integration, but there is no obligation for each individual member state to participate in every step. An ever closer union means for me, above all, that the European Union fulfills its essential tasks with full force and takes the necessary steps to do so. The principles of subsidiarity and proportionality, which we have firmly anchored in the European treaties, express exactly that.

It is, of course, also important that Great Britain points out the significance of national parliaments in this context. In Germany, there is already a very close cooperation between parliament and government on European issues. In the upcoming negotiations with Great Britain, it is now about further improving the involvement of national parliaments at the European level. This is especially true when national parliaments see the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality, which I just mentioned, as being at risk.

The issue most publicly discussed from the British perspective is the elimination of perverse incentives in social systems. This concern is also understandable and legitimate; because the responsibility for the respective social systems does not lie centrally in Brussels, but with the individual member states. Therefore, it is self-evident to me that each member state must also be able to protect its social system against abuse.

I would like to recall the discussion we are having here in Germany. The rulings of the Federal Social Court, for example, have shown that there is also a need for action in our national legislation, which has been more driven by the rulings of the Federal Constitutional Court than by European jurisprudence. I am very grateful that Federal Minister Nahles will take legal steps that will provide a solution here.

So there is no point of dissent between Great Britain and Germany when it comes to social systems. However, this debate leads to a higher-level point. It leads us to insist that in making adjustments at the European level, the fundamental achievements of European integration must not be called into question. In the current discussion with Great Britain, these are primarily the principles of free movement and non-discrimination. In this respect, I would like to make it clear once again: These two principles are not up for negotiation. Reconciling this fundamental attitude with the British concerns is the task that needs to be solved; and that is our common goal, even if the devil, as so often, is in the details. There are proposals from the Commission; but we will certainly have intensive discussions in the Council about this.

Of course, we will not decide on any treaty changes at the European Council this week. Rather, it will be about agreeing to take into account the substantive content of our agreement with Great Britain in the next revision of the European treaties. This next treaty change must then, of course, be carried out in accordance with the relevant procedures and constitutional requirements in Germany; that goes without saying. So when the time comes, it will be necessary to establish agreement with the German Bundestag and to pass a consent law.

Overall, I consider the proposals put forward by the President of the European Council, Donald Tusk, to be a very good basis for negotiations. Germany will contribute to achieving a satisfactory result for all sides, if possible already at the European Council starting tomorrow.

At this point, I would like to thank all my colleagues in the Cabinet and the German Bundestag who have sought dialogue with their British partners and advocated understanding on both sides. I am convinced that it is in our national interest for Great Britain to remain an active member of a strong and successful European Union.

Germany has an ally in Great Britain when we advocate for the internal market, for more competitiveness, and for free trade in Europe. Furthermore, Europe needs Great Britain's foreign and security policy engagement to assert our values and interests in the world. In the awareness of these common interests and values, we conduct the negotiations, but in the end – we know this – it will be the British voters who decide. Before that, we Europeans have the task of doing our best so that the British government can advocate convincingly for the United Kingdom's continued membership in the European Union. An agreement on the British reform concerns is an important step in this direction.

At the same time, we must prove far beyond that that the European Union is capable of finding common answers to the great global challenges of our time. This includes, first and foremost, the movement of refugees, which is putting Europe – one might say – to a historical test. This question will be the second major topic of the European Council that we will discuss tomorrow evening.

To say it right away: Whether the Council will be a success or a failure will truly not be determined by the question of quotas. The Council is not about agreeing on quotas. We would make ourselves ridiculous in Europe if we decided on quotas on Friday, after the agreed distribution of 160,000 refugees has not even begun to take place; that would be the second step before the first.

The upcoming European Council is about something else. It is about this question: Have we made sufficient progress with our European-Turkish approach based on the EU-Turkey agenda, which we jointly adopted on November 29 of last year, for the comprehensive fight against the causes of flight and for the protection of external borders, that it is worth continuing down this path because it can significantly curb illegal migration, which is the decisive prerequisite for legal quotas? Or must we give up and instead, as some are now vehemently demanding, close the border between Greece and Macedonia and Bulgaria with all the consequences for Greece and the European Union as a whole? That is the assessment situation for the interim evaluation that I would like to make after the Council.

It goes without saying that I will use my strength to ensure that the European-Turkish approach proves to be the path worth continuing. What is this about, and what can we achieve with this approach? Our common goal is to significantly and sustainably reduce the number of refugees, so that we can continue to help those who truly need our protection. The contentious issue in the debate is the way in which we achieve this goal.

The federal government is focusing on three points:

First

. We combat the causes of flight.

Second

. We restore the protection of the EU's external border between Greece and Turkey, that is, at the Schengen external border, which is currently crucial for the movement of refugees, and share the burdens.

And

third

. We organize and manage the influx of refugees.

Regarding the

first

point, combating the causes of flight. In Germany, we have primarily experienced globalization through our exports and the success of our companies. Now – we feel it – we are seeing a completely different side of globalization. Islamist terrorism also threatens us; we have known this not only since the terrible terrorist attacks in Paris. Right at our European doorstep, bloody wars and conflicts rage, costing hundreds of thousands their lives and uprooting millions. Many of them seek refuge in Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, and Europe. There is no doubt that permanently fewer people will come to us only if we address the root causes that drive them to flee. We see and hear it every day. This task is particularly urgent in light of the tragedy in Syria. Last week, the international contact group in Munich agreed on the conditions for a possible ceasefire in Syria.

I would like to take this opportunity to sincerely thank our Federal Foreign Minister. When I follow his schedule from last Thursday to last Sunday and see how many discussion forums the Foreign Minister participated in, all of which dealt with conflicts in our immediate vicinity, I can only say: Diplomacy and political solutions are needed in this time. They require incredible perseverance. You experience setbacks time and again; but it is always worth trying again. – Hence the thanks.

After this agreement, hopefully, some cities in Syria can now be supplied with humanitarian aid. Nevertheless, without in any way questioning these efforts, the situation remains depressingly unchanged. Instead of less fighting, there is more fighting in some regions these days, and instead of less suffering, there is more suffering in many places, not least triggered by the attacks of Russia and the Syrian government forces, as we unfortunately see in and around Aleppo, also in the area up to the Turkish border, in the city of Asas, and elsewhere.

The current situation is therefore still intolerable. It would be helpful if there were an area in Syria that none of the warring parties attacked. We cannot negotiate with the terrorists of ISIS; but if it were possible to reach an agreement between the anti-Assad coalition and the Assad supporters on a kind of no-fly zone as a protection area for the many refugees, it would save many lives and also serve the political process for the future of Syria. I believe we should leave no stone unturned.

In addition, improving the living conditions of Syrian refugees is at the center of our efforts – in the besieged areas along the Syrian-Turkish border as well as throughout the region. The Syria donor conference on February 4, 2016, in London set important milestones for this. A total of 5.9 billion dollars was raised for humanitarian aid – that is, for the World Food Programme, schools, and jobs – for people in Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, and Turkey for 2016, and 5.4 billion dollars for the years 2017 to 2020, amounting to over eleven billion dollars in total. The Secretary-General of the United Nations has reminded us once again that this was the most successful donor conference in the history of the United Nations; for no other donor conference has so much money been raised in one day. We are making a significant contribution here. I would like to thank the Minister of Finance, of course also the Minister of Development, and the Minister of Foreign Affairs.

We have decided to focus on this issue because we have been very engaged over the past year in examining what drives people to flee, and we have seen that the cuts to the World Food Programme were one of the main causes. With our contribution, we are now placing a particular emphasis on the World Food Programme alongside the very exciting "Cash for Work" program, which provides people with jobs. As the Federal Republic of Germany, we will contribute half of what the World Food Organization has set as the need for food aid for Syria and the surrounding countries for this year. Another part is already secured, and we will ensure that it is clear soon that the rest is also available, so that the staff of the World Food Programme do not have to fear month by month that they will have to cut rations again. I believe this is in all our interests.

During the visit of Iraqi Prime Minister al-Abadi, we decided to provide the Iraqi government with a loan, an unbound loan, of 500 million euros, particularly for the implementation of infrastructure projects, especially in cities that have been liberated from ISIS; these have been brutally destroyed, and they need to be rebuilt quickly so that people can return to their homes.

And we have finally released the three billion euros that have long been discussed, with which the European Union supports Turkey in improving the living prospects of refugees on the ground; I hope that projects can be realized very quickly. Because if we consider that in cities like Kilis there are as many refugees as there are local residents, it is clear that new schools and new hospitals are needed. This must now be implemented quickly.

Turkey, for its part, has issued work permits for Syrians in Turkey – albeit in different forms, but at least there is now a perspective that Syrian refugees or guests, as Turkey calls them, also have job opportunities.

This leads to the second point that the federal government is addressing, the restoration of the protection of the EU's external border between Greece and Turkey, and thus to the legitimate wish and concern of Turkey to share burdens. I want to remind you: There are currently 2.5 million Syrian refugees in Turkey, and Turkey has 70 million inhabitants. We in Germany have a rough idea of what this means – even for a country like Turkey. Therefore, it is right and good that we try to share burdens between the European Union and Turkey.

Turkey, for its part, has introduced a visa requirement for Syrians from Jordan and Lebanon, as well as regarding Iraq, Iran, and Afghanistan. If we advocate a visa requirement for Syrians from Jordan and Lebanon, it means that the living conditions of refugees in Jordan and Lebanon must indeed improve. I also want to remind you: Lebanon has five million inhabitants – I spoke with the Lebanese Prime Minister in London – and there are significantly more than a million refugees there. One can imagine what this means for a country like Lebanon, which is, by the way, caught between regional conflicts and regional powers. Therefore, "Cash for Work," the creation of accommodation options, and all the other things we are doing are important.

We have agreed on bilateral cooperation with Turkey in many areas, particularly with the Federal Minister of the Interior. This involves police cooperation; the corresponding MoUs are ready for signature. It also involves the Technical Relief Agency, which is ready to help, especially now at the Turkish-Syrian border, if desired. This bilateral cooperation – I may say – is developing very well, by the way.

Furthermore, we have decided that we need to improve the situation in the Aegean; that means we need to enhance monitoring there. There is a NATO operation for this purpose. Why a NATO operation? There are the corresponding maritime units. There is a great need to systematically monitor a coastline that is 900 kilometers long and to intercept boats that illegally transport refugees from one side to the other. This mission can, of course, only be carried out in cooperation with the Turkish Coast Guard – here, data exchange must be quickly ensured so that the Turkish Coast Guard can begin its work – and it must be conducted in cooperation with the European Border and Coast Guard Agency, Frontex. Turkey has agreed to bring back the refugees who are rescued by Frontex, but also by NATO ships, when they are in distress.

We have a readmission agreement between Greece and Turkey, which functions sufficiently poorly because it is very bureaucratic. Work is being done to simplify this bureaucracy.

The third point that the federal government is addressing seamlessly connects to the international and European level. By the way, I believe that what I have said about the second point justifies continuing down this path.

Of course, Turkey, on the other hand, expects us to revitalize the accession negotiations. By the way, I also want to say: In the discussions we are having with Turkey, it is not only about these points, but also about journalistic freedoms and the questions: What will happen with the Kurds? How can we give the youth in the regions of Turkey that are currently heavily involved in conflicts opportunities for the future? – So it is not the case that we only talk about some issues and not others. But without discussions, it will not work.

I believe it is worth continuing this agenda; because we as the European Union must learn to protect maritime borders as well. This is more difficult than protecting land borders. If we do not learn this, we will not succeed next time with Italy, which is located opposite Libya. This means: A continent that does not learn this, also in balancing and in dialogue with its neighbors – with Libya, it is admittedly difficult as long as there is no unity government there; that is why we are working hard on it – that does not succeed, that only reacts with isolation shortly behind the maritime border and says: "Whoever is behind the fence does not interest us," cannot be the European answer – at least in my firm conviction.

Nationally – you know – we have achieved a lot: The arrivals at the Austrian-German border are now being registered and controlled. There is a uniform refugee identification card that is being gradually introduced. We are discussing the asylum package II this week. You know the content: removal of obstacles to deportation, acceleration of procedures. We have made a cabinet decision for further safe countries of origin, which I hope can come into force soon. And we have quickly created conditions in response to the events in Cologne that allow us to realize faster deportations of criminal refugees. All of this is always under the same heading: Those who need and seek protection should receive protection.

By the way, I want to point out that despite all the critical surveys, over 90 percent of the German population still say: Those fleeing from terror, war, and persecution should have the opportunity for admission and protection in Germany. I find that wonderful.

The European Council on Thursday and Friday has two outstanding topics: Britain in the European Union and the refugee issue. This shows that the European Union is currently facing tremendous challenges. It must do everything it can to represent its values and interests in such a way that citizens in Europe and people outside Europe have the impression that the problems can be successfully overcome without Europe and, as a result, all member states of the European Union suffering harm.

The discussion with the Council will not end with both topics. It is a stage on the path on which Europe has become stronger after every crisis so far. I hope that this will be the case this time as well.

This, in turn, serves Europe and – I am deeply convinced of this – also the well-being of Germany, in order to truly succeed in the "rendezvous with globalization," as Wolfgang Schäuble puts it. That guides me. I ask for your support for this.