Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel to the European Council on March 17/18, 2016, in Brussels before the German Bundestag on March 16, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 March 2016 · European Council (March 2016) government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on March 16, 2016, ahead of the EU Council summit in Brussels, outlining Germany's position on refugee policy and economic reforms.
Main themes
Refugee policy, EU-Turkey cooperation, European solidarity, structural economic reforms, migration management, root causes of displacement, pan-European approach, Greece humanitarian crisis, Western Balkan route, asylum policy, fiscal responsibility, European unity
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,359
80th percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
12.7
54th percentile
Syntax
3.17
69th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
34th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 49%47%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Social 15%15%
  • Economic 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

157 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen!

The European Council in March is classically an economic council. Even though other issues are currently at the forefront in Europe, it is important to continue strengthening the economic foundations of the European Union. Because only if we are economically strong will we be able to tackle the pressing challenges of our time in the future.

As part of the so-called European Semester, the European Council taking place tomorrow and the day after will address the economic situation across the European Union, and we will urge the member states of the European Union to strengthen their economies through structural reforms and investments, as well as to pursue a responsible fiscal policy.

However, the focus of the European Council taking place tomorrow and the day after will again be on refugee policy, particularly cooperation with Turkey. For Germany and for the European Union as a whole, the refugee issue is the greatest challenge in decades. Conflicts that once seemed very distant to us now affect us directly, and they will continue to affect us directly in the future. We see this in Syria, we see this in Afghanistan, and we see this in Iraq.

We are experiencing that the refugee issue is a task that demands a great deal from all of us, requiring all our strength and full attention. Because our handling of the refugee issue will shape Germany as well as Europe for a long time, both internally and externally. And the more I advocate for it, the more I want us as a wealthy continent to show that we are capable of mastering such a challenge together.

We must never forget: Germany can only thrive in the long term if Europe thrives as well, that is, Europe as a whole. For me, this means that we must continue to work at all levels on sustainable solutions: nationally, European, and internationally. We must start from the approach that we combat the root causes that drive people to leave their homes. With this approach, we will also succeed in significantly and sustainably reducing the number of refugees coming to Europe and Germany; because this way, people can live safely from war and persecution, as well as with a perspective for themselves and their families, in their home regions or nearby. Let us think of issues such as health, education, work, but all too often also nutrition. And with this approach, we will also succeed in truly helping those in the future who are genuinely dependent on our protection.

I believe that we have come a good way closer to both goals, both in Europe and at home in Germany. Here at home, our regulatory and steering measures – from the controls at our national border that have been in place since September to the asylum packages I and II – have begun to take effect, just as the many changes, for example, in the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees.

Without a doubt, we are currently benefiting in Germany from the fact that the influx of refugees has come to a standstill, albeit due to unilateral decisions by Austria and the countries along the Western Balkan route. But I cannot warn often enough against being deceived by this; because the current relief that Germany and some other member states are feeling is one thing, the situation in Greece is another; and this must cause great concern for each of us, as it will not remain without consequences for all of us in Europe. The situation there cannot and must not be permanent; otherwise, we would go from a short-term relief to a worse situation.

Therefore, the crucial question remains how we can succeed in reducing the number of refugees not just for a few, but for all of us, sustainably and permanently, without weakening the essential achievements of our lives in Europe.

These are precisely the goals of the pan-European approach.

First

, because Germany, as a country in the center of Europe, benefits like no other from the freedom of movement in Europe. This also applies to our economy.

Second

, because we can only prevent the rerouting of flight paths with a pan-European solution; because if new, even more complicated and dangerous routes were to emerge, only the criminal smugglers would benefit. The highest price would be paid by the refugees, often with their lives. But we Germans and Europeans would also pay a high price, as it would become evident that previous measures were merely superficial solutions that only addressed the symptoms of the crisis, not the causes. Consequently, the disappointment of the citizens would be much greater than some concerns today.

And

third

, we can only develop solutions with the pan-European approach that do not leave the last member state in line alone, in this case Greece. Once again: Germany can only thrive in the long term if Europe thrives as well, that is, Europe as a whole. Therefore, it is right and important that the European Union now offers humanitarian aid to Greece and also provides the necessary 700 million euros from the EU budget for this purpose. Germany has also offered assistance to Greece. I am in close contact with the Greek Prime Minister, as is the Federal Minister of the Interior with his Greek counterpart, and the Federal Foreign Minister as well.

Equally important is that Greece fulfills its own obligations. This includes the full operation of the hotspots and thus comprehensive registration of refugees. We have made significant progress in registration and in the admission to the Eurodac database. This also applies to the provision of refugee accommodations, after there had previously been far too many delays. We only need to remember that we have been discussing this since last autumn: In October, we had a conference of the countries of the Western Balkans and Greece, and it was agreed that each of these countries would provide sufficient accommodation capacities. But even here, progress is now clearly visible in Greece.

Greece wants to solve the crisis humanely in cooperation with the other 27 EU member states and the UN Refugee Agency UNHCR, that is, with safe and dignified provision and accommodation. We are helping Greece with this, both financially and on-site with concrete support. This approach distinguishes the situation today from that in and with Hungary last summer. Certainly, many refugees are disappointed when they cannot travel to where they want, because we in Europe agree that there is no right to asylum in a specific country. However, people are entitled to humane treatment. That is exactly what we are working on together with Greece, also for the people who are currently stuck in Idomeni and who should trust the Greek government that they will be much better off in the newly created accommodations in Greece than they are now in Idomeni.

However, we have only achieved a truly viable solution when fewer people are entering illegally not only into Germany but into the entire European Union permanently than before. To achieve this, we are currently having important discussions with Turkey. Turkey is by far the most important transit country through which people – at least at the moment – are entering Europe illegally. The maritime border between Greece and Turkey is our European external border. It must be protected. This includes a determined fight against smugglers and traffickers.

In cooperation with Turkey, we have initiated various steps. We are also relying on the NATO reconnaissance mission in the Aegean, for which the Minister of Defense has tirelessly advocated, and I would like to thank her very much for that. I want to say this openly here: This mission is also only getting underway step by step. We have so far established initial monitoring capabilities regarding the island of Lesbos. We need further access to Turkish territorial waters so that all islands can be monitored; because it has already become evident in recent days that now, where Lesbos is very well monitored, more refugees are arriving in Chios. And that is also not a sustainable solution. Therefore, we need access to all areas of Turkish territorial waters.

So far, it has been a major problem for Europe that people who entered illegally could not be sent back to Turkey, even if they had no claim to protection in Europe. This is precisely the problem that the proposals presented by Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu on March 7 at the summit with European heads of state and government in Brussels are addressing. His basic idea is that Turkey commits to taking back all refugees who previously entered Europe illegally via the Aegean. Whenever a Syrian refugee is returned to Turkey, a different Syrian refugee should be allowed to travel legally from Turkey to Europe, according to the proposal of the Turkish Prime Minister.

It is quite evident: The aim of such an arrangement is to remove the incentive for refugees to board a rubber boat of criminal smugglers and embark on the life-threatening journey to Europe. Implementing this proposal could therefore lead to the criminal smugglers in the Aegean losing their business basis. Instead, there would be a legal alternative that would be safe for refugees and controllable for Europe. However, since our goal is to quickly bring illegal entry to a halt, this proposal will later be supplemented by voluntary quotas that European member states will take on to also accept Syrian refugees. This would finally put an end to the cruel deaths in the Aegean. Already this year, 2016, over 350 people have drowned in the Aegean; last year, it was 800 people.

Undoubtedly, the Turkish proposal involves very far-reaching considerations. It was therefore important not to make a final decision on March 7, but to take the time to thoroughly and carefully examine the legal and political questions related to this proposal. For example, we have also consulted with UNHCR to utilize its expertise. But – and I consider this very important – the Turkish proposal also reflects – as was already the case with the approval of the NATO mission – that Turkey has its own interest in organizing and managing the influx of refugees into its own country together with Europe, so that the smuggling structures do not spread further than they already are, as we all know. This is a situation that is also not sustainable for Turkey itself in the long term. The goal is therefore a fair distribution of burdens.

That Turkey also articulates its interests in connection with the accession process to the EU within the framework of negotiations should not surprise any of us. What is crucial here is how we deal with this, whether and how we can create a balance of interests that aligns with our values.

Turkey has been a candidate for EU membership for many years. For me as Chancellor and for the federal government, the principle has always been: Pacta sunt servanda. This has meant so far and will mean in the future: If we should open new negotiation chapters in the case of deepened cooperation, it is and remains crucial that the EU accession negotiations with Turkey are conducted in an open-ended manner. From this, it follows that Turkey's accession to the European Union is really not on the agenda right now.

Even in the negotiations on new chapters, there can and will be no compromises on our own principles.

I would like to make two remarks:

First

. The opening of new chapters is not difficult because of us, but because of the unresolved Cyprus issue. This means we still have work to do before tomorrow's council. I cannot predict the outcome either.

Second

, I ask that especially in the opening of chapters 23 and 24, which deal with legal and judicial issues, we also see the opportunities to enter into an important dialogue with Turkey, which is very urgent.

Currently, the topics of "the return of third-country nationals from the EU to Turkey" and "visa liberalization" are being intensively discussed. In this regard, the leaders of the coalition agreed on a resolution on November 5 of last year to advocate for the acceleration of the implementation of the return of third-country nationals from the EU to Turkey and, in parallel, to expedite the negotiations on visa liberalization. Consequently, I agreed on behalf of Germany at the European Council on November 29 of last year, together with the other 27 member states of the European Union, in the EU-Turkey agenda that the return of third-country nationals would come into effect in June of this year and that visa liberalization would take effect no later than October of this year. All 28 member states of the European Union had unanimously decided on this.

Regarding visa liberalization, Turkey now wishes to accelerate this process and complete it by the end of June of this year instead of in October. In return, Turkey offers to take back all refugees, including those with residency rights – which concerns more than just ordinary third-country nationals – and all of this immediately. For this, it also wants to achieve visa liberalization three months earlier. It commits – this is absolutely essential for us – to create all the necessary conditions. All of this must be considered in context. It is therefore crucial that the conditions that Turkey must fulfill for visa liberalization do not change. These remain unchanged. Moreover, there is still much to resolve. We will ensure that these conditions are fully met, and we will, of course, consult you all repeatedly on all of this.

Last but not least, Turkey is requesting additional financial support until the end of 2018, as it understands that the already approved three billion euros for refugee projects were only a first step. It is also crucial for Europe that refugees who are sent back to Turkey are treated there according to our humanitarian criteria and those of the UNHCR; because if Turkey provides people with safe care and an adequate life perspective in accordance with international obligations, it removes an important reason for people to embark on the life-threatening journey with smugglers and traffickers.

I find Turkey's request for more financial assistance completely understandable. The European Union is also willing to do so. It is crucial that these funds actually flow into meaningful projects, specifically the most meaningful ones – in housing, in schools, or in medical care. We will also ensure this. Turkey requests that this happens as quickly as possible. However, to achieve this, the mechanisms in the European Union can sometimes be a bit complicated.

The first 95 million euros have already been disbursed. They help enable 100,000 Syrian refugee children to attend school, specifically in Arabic, and provide food for 700,000 Syrians in Turkey.

With all the necessary care with which we are currently conducting and must conduct discussions with Turkey, we should not overlook one thing: What Turkey has been doing for well over two million refugees, to be precise about 2.7 million refugees, in its country for years cannot be praised highly enough. It does not honor Europe that, as a union of 28 member states with 500 million citizens, it has so far struggled so much to share the burdens. Therefore, it is all the more important that we are now making at least gradual progress.

The far-reaching proposals of the Turkish Prime Minister show that we have reached a decisive point in the European negotiations to resolve the refugee issue. A deepened cooperation, as we seek with Turkey, is always a matter of give and take, of compromise and balancing interests; and this applies equally to both sides. It goes without saying that we will assert our convictions towards Turkey, for example regarding the preservation of press freedom or the treatment of the Kurds, while always considering the appropriateness of actions concerning all Kurds in the necessary fight against the PKK terrorism.

A deepened cooperation, as we are now striving for, for example also in the discussion about opened chapters, can provide the right framework for this, provided we do it based on the clear criteria and conditions I just mentioned. We sense that there is a serious willingness on both sides to jointly solve the problems in refugee policy. And I consider this a significant progress.

However, the result has not yet been achieved; there are still extraordinarily difficult legal and political questions to clarify so that the balancing of interests becomes a genuine balance. The Commission has published a communication today regarding the legal questions. At the same time, the balancing of interests must serve the goal of the European-Turkish approach to permanently and sustainably reduce the number of refugees for everyone and to continue to provide protection to those who truly need it. Therefore, at the European Council tomorrow and the day after, it is about whether we can reach an agreement that could give us a real chance for the first time at a lasting and pan-European solution to the refugee issue.

This pan-European solution also includes, in addition to Turkey, partnerships with our other neighbors, such as in North Africa. I thank Interior Minister Thomas de Maizière, who has made far-reaching agreements during his trip to Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia. I also thank Development Minister Gerd Müller, who has done this in matters of development aid. Thomas de Maizière has agreed that in the future, returns of non-protected migrants to these countries will be facilitated.

A pan-European solution crucially includes that we jointly combat the root causes of flight. Here, the peace talks for Syria are of great importance, and I wish the Federal Foreign Minister every success in this. It is a long and difficult road; but in recent weeks, we have seen a number of events that at least give us more hope than we have had for a long, long time.

Of course, it is also part of our agenda that we implement the conclusions of the Valletta Summit with our African neighbors, and do so consistently.

A pan-European solution also includes, in the long term, reforming the Dublin system. The EU Commission will soon present proposals. It wanted to do so today. Given the intense debates about the legal foundations of the Turkey questions, it has postponed this, but it will do so; because we need to know how to adapt the Dublin system to the changed circumstances and make it future-proof. These proposals will then also serve as the basis for further considerations. I say very clearly: Only with a reform of Dublin will we be able to maintain Schengen in the long term. Because a pan-European solution also includes, not least, that we can gradually return to open internal borders, from which we benefit so much in the Schengen area.

Nine Schengen states, including Germany, have been forced in recent months to introduce temporary internal border controls. I therefore welcome that the Commission has presented a very ambitious roadmap that includes the goal of lifting all temporary controls by the end of the year. But of course, the conditions must be met for that as well. Otherwise, we cannot do it. This means we must get the situation at the European external borders under control by then, and all member states must again comply with their obligations under the Schengen Border Code.

Mr. President, dear colleagues, if all these building blocks come together into a comprehensive strategy, then we can indeed achieve a sustainably viable pan-European solution. This is what we outlined together as heads of state and government at our meetings in February and early March. And the European Council starting tomorrow is another and, I would say, quite decisive milestone for this, although I cannot yet foresee exactly what the decisions will look like.

I am and remain convinced: We need a Europe in which common challenges are mastered through European solidarity and through joint action. This is the only way that promises long-term success for Europe and will lead to Europe, and thus all its member states, emerging from this crisis stronger than they entered it.