Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at a lecture event of the German Society for Foreign Policy on November 8, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

8 November 2006 · Lecture event of the German Society for Foreign Policy · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Society for Foreign Policy in Berlin on November 8, 2006, ahead of Germany's upcoming EU Council Presidency, at the opening of the Alfred von Oppenheim Center for European Future Issues.
Main themes
European unification, German EU Council Presidency 2007, European values, Treaty of Rome anniversary, EU constitutional crisis, internal market, speaking with one voice, Alfred von Oppenheim Center, European future, democratic legitimacy, EU enlargement
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,281
92nd percentile
Sentences
273
94th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 42%42%
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Environmental 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

273 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Oetker,

dear Oppenheim family,

ladies and gentlemen,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

Excellencies!

I am very pleased to speak to you today. With the opening of the "Alfred von Oppenheim Center for European Future Issues," you have sent a very clear signal about where our future lies: namely in Europe.

As Mr. Oetker just mentioned, the center was established by Christopher Freiherr von Oppenheim and named after his father. I consider this a good choice. Alfred Freiherr von Oppenheim made significant contributions to science. He was particularly committed to European unification. I have also felt a personal connection to him. It was a great honor for me to give a speech at his 70th birthday two years ago.

I am confident that the center will further invigorate the scientific debate on the development of Europe. Therefore, I wish the center all the best in this interesting location, with many interesting insights, disputes, and hours that will also serve the collective opinion-forming in Europe.

In a few weeks, Germany will take over the presidency of the European Union – this has also been pointed out. The Federal Government is aware of the responsibility that comes with it. On Sunday, we took the time in an extraordinary cabinet meeting at Villa Borsig to discuss the priorities intensively, beyond a fixed agenda, because I believe that a government can only bear such responsibility together if it has a common understanding of how it wants to shape this presidency. And we have the will to do so.

The European unification process has had its difficult phases, but I believe that at least we in this room agree: European unification is a success story that is unparalleled. We will have the opportunity in Berlin, on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome, to also think about bridging into the future. When one considers what it means that this divided city is the place where 27 member states will gather to remember the incredible founding idea of the European Union, the signing of the Treaty of Rome, one knows that this will be a very important day for Berlin.

During our presidency, we want to continue the success of the European Union. But we are also aware that the starting point of this presidency is not entirely easy – not because of the upcoming elections and all the appointments that play a significant role in the respective member countries, but because support for the European Union and European integration has significantly decreased in recent years. All surveys tell us this, indicating that many find things too technocratic. Questions are raised such as: Does the internal market really bring more prosperity to individuals?

Many citizens have doubts that Europe is capable of finding valid answers to the great questions of the future. We have experienced this with the failed constitutional referendums in France and the Netherlands. Such a mood also prevails in many other member states. Therefore, I believe: It is no longer sufficient to only refer to the past and to remember the bridges that were built between countries that were separated by so-called hereditary enmities; rather, it is essential to re-establish this Europe for the 21st century.

When one asks what holds Europe, what holds the European Union together, it is clear to me: Europe is primarily based on common values shared by the member states of the European Union: on freedom, justice, democracy, the rule of law, and respect for human rights. These fundamental values have grown in Europe over centuries.

A visit to the Bode Museum and other institutions on Museum Island informs us about what Europe has also endured in order to be able to live these values, to understand them as common values through the understanding of tolerance and diversity. Therefore, I would like to begin by saying: European cooperation will always be value-based in the future. If it is to endure, it must be value-based.

The internal market and the euro and many other things are undoubtedly very important for the European Union, but we should be clear: First and foremost, it is the common understanding of fundamental values that holds Europe together at its core. This foundation gives us the strength to view the communal task as a community task despite all adversities, despite all differing opinions. How can it succeed? I am convinced: Only if Europe speaks with one voice does it have the best chances of shaping politics according to our values, a politics from which citizens can then say they benefit.

This speaking with one voice is something that is incredibly difficult to achieve in individual cases. However, I would like to illustrate its importance and decisiveness with four examples, which will also be focal points of our work during our presidency, which, by the way, will be the first trio presidency, as it is called today. This means moving away from the short-term nature of six-month programs. We will – Germany together with Portugal and Slovenia – continue this presidency like a red thread.

So, I would like to mention four examples that show: Speaking with one voice makes Europe strong; being divided has the opposite effect.

I begin with the common foreign and security policy, which I am convinced will be one of the major focuses of European action in the coming years.

The European foreign and security policy is not old. It was established in 1992 with the Maastricht Treaty. It quickly became apparent: Every beginning is difficult. The first, then quite unexpected crisis, the Balkan crisis, deeply divided Europe. The result is well known: The European Union was unable to respond appropriately to the terrible events on its own continent. Only with the help of the USA was it possible to gradually stabilize the region. But we can say: We have learned from these bitter experiences. Because step by step, the foreign and security policy instruments of the European Union have been further developed. Significant progress was already made in Amsterdam and Nice.

The establishment of the office of a High Representative for the common foreign and security policy was particularly important. The creation of this office and the work of the first officeholder, Javier Solana, is important not least because it quickly became clear that the security challenges after the Cold War had completely changed. We did not always make it easy for this first High Representative. And there are still voices asking: Where is Europe's phone number, where do I call?

The experiences prior to the Iraq war also showed that Europe did not speak with one voice. Important conclusions were drawn from this. In the case of Iran, we have worked together in Europe in a remarkable way with the United States, thereby also showing that we are willing to act collectively, which has, by the way, created many allies for us in dealing with Iran's nuclear program.

The threats have changed. The time when there were two blocks that faced each other as enemies is over. In retrospect, it was a terrible time, but in a way a manageable threat situation, while today we face asymmetric threats that often come from individuals who are willing or feel compelled out of a false understanding to sacrifice their lives for the fight against the way of life of others, and are protected or supported by states. The confrontation with this threat has thus become much more difficult. Because during the Cold War, it was a constant that neither side wanted to annihilate the other, while today people manifest threats, putting their own lives at risk to harm freedom and democracy. Therefore, the classic deterrence mechanisms, as we knew them before, no longer work.

International terrorism, the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction are among these asymmetric threats. Regional conflicts, unstable states, the collapse of state orders have hardly manageable consequences in connection with these asymmetric threats. No state can master such threats alone. Therefore, it is so necessary for the European Union as a community to find answers to these questions.

The European Union has provided corresponding answers in the European Constitutional Treaty and in the European Security Strategy. It was important that it did so, and I believe we can now look back on a number of successes, at least on some of what we have achieved.

In Macedonia, we prevented the looming civil war. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, we stabilized a state that many doubted would survive. In the Indonesian province of Aceh, the European Union demonstrates that we cannot be indifferent to the problems of Asia either. In the Congo, we are currently securing the first democratic elections in 40 years through our military presence.

This regional distribution shows that we as Europe are now also in demand worldwide. This is a development of recent years. When one thinks of the discussions in the parliaments, especially in the German Bundestag – since the Bundeswehr is a "parliamentary army," meaning it is sent on missions with the mandate of the representatives – it becomes clear that we also need a developing political discussion. The following questions could also be addressed in this center: What are our interests? Where are we needed? What can we achieve? How can we further develop this?

Europe is leading a security concept that I would like to present as a comprehensive security concept, which – summarized in one sentence – states: Military crisis management can only succeed in conjunction with civilian efforts for stability and reconstruction. I believe this security concept is correct. We have many civilian missions currently ongoing – eleven at present – and we must work to better coordinate the interfaces between civilian and military elements. This will be one of the major challenges.

I can mention the example of Afghanistan, which will continue to occupy us. Regarding Afghanistan, the Federal Government has discussed the strategy very intensively and considered how we can pool our forces, as it is clear: Stability in this country cannot be achieved with a military component alone; however, without military components, it cannot be achieved either. This means we need a completely new form of cooperation between development aid, internal security instruments, what building institutions means, and military intervention. This requires coherence between previously completely different areas of expertise. It requires cooperation between the Ministry of the Interior, development aid, and the Ministry of Defense, as it has not been known before. The Federal Government is trying to make such a networked deployment a success in the case of Afghanistan – I hope we will also have the opportunity to discuss this at the NATO summit in Riga. This is difficult, but it is important to achieve this success. We must not shy away from the difficulties.

It is foreseeable that new tasks will come our way, which we cannot close our eyes to, which we cannot avoid. One is so obvious that we must not close our eyes to it: the near future of Kosovo. The international community is working intensively with the parties involved on a status solution. This work in Kosovo, especially regarding the surrounding countries, is complicated. It must not happen, of course, that we stabilize one part at the price of destabilizing other parts. The relationship with Serbia is complicated. It can have repercussions on Macedonia, on Bosnia and Herzegovina. Therefore, utmost sensitivity must be exercised here to avoid bringing the process to a standstill. If this status question were to be resolved, then the largest civilian mission of European security and defense policy to date would follow. The focus of this mission should be on the areas of internal and justice policy, as it is about making Kosovo operational.

At the same time, NATO troops are still needed in the region. This means that it is of utmost importance: We must succeed in ensuring that European security and defense policy cooperates with NATO, and that we do not have friction losses or contradictions here, but rather interlink the matters. This must be the fundamental understanding. For me, this is of elemental importance: We must never understand European security and defense policy as something directed against the transatlantic partnership. This is of utmost importance.

But we also have problems that have to do with member states – keyword Cyprus and Turkey. We must succeed – the example of Kosovo will be the first – in ensuring that the cooperation between the EU and NATO is also successful in this regard.

It is foreseeable that Germany will be called upon to continue to take responsibility in Kosovo. Therefore, one can already say today: Many eyes will be on Germany when it comes to further responsibilities in the world. We cannot shy away from this responsibility. The idea that one could give very good political advice while staying away from the difficult tasks will not be feasible. We have never subscribed to this idea, because the fact that we have taken on responsibility, for example, in the UNIFIL mission, is an example that we are aware that political action and the readiness for military action go hand in hand today.

Now we know that no presidency can choose its international challenges. I believe that our Finnish partners, when they took over the presidency on July 1, could not have calculated that just a few days later the Lebanon crisis would occur. Therefore, it was also gratifying and right that the European Union, after a certain discussion process, took on significant responsibility in this UNIFIL mission.

This event cannot pass without a word about this year's progress report from the European Commission on the Turkey report. This report documents where Turkey has made progress, but it also notes significant deficits in political reforms, particularly regarding freedom of expression and religion.

The report further states that Turkey has not yet implemented the Ankara Protocol. I must remind once again that Turkey committed itself to implementing the Ankara Protocol with its signature on July 29, 2005. A trustworthy and credible negotiation process requires that both sides adhere to their commitments. "Pacta sunt servanda" applies in both directions. I also say: I strongly support the mediation efforts of the Finnish presidency. The Finnish Prime Minister was here yesterday. We want to put all our strength into solving this problem in the remaining weeks. But I also say – the progress report is clear in this regard: Turkey must meet its obligations by the end of the year; otherwise, the European Union will draw appropriate consequences. There can and will be no "business as usual."

We can only address other future challenges beyond security and defense policy if we have a common capacity for action. I have spoken about foreign, security, and defense policy and would like to mention trade policy as a second example. Here, European countries can achieve more together than any country can alone.

The European Economic Community was founded almost 50 years ago with the signing of the Treaty of Rome. This marked the beginning of a new chapter in the history of Europe – by the way, after the failure of efforts to establish a common European defense policy. It is very interesting that it took us so many years to return to the topic of a common European security and defense policy. But Europe has always taken on another topic whenever it has not made progress in one area. That is why the Economic Community was established much earlier. This initiated a new chapter in the history of Europe. This has proven itself in recent years and decades.

Today we know, when we think of the negotiation rounds on world trade, that this is of crucial importance. It is – I admit – laborious to reach a common position on agricultural policy in these world trade rounds. The responsible commissioner has it anything but easy. But the thought that each country would have to conduct these negotiations in the World Trade Organization on its own is frightening. I believe we can present our positions much better together.

At this point, it also shows that we are willing to make international agreements and prefer multilateral agreements. I am extremely skeptical when the DOHA round does not progress and instead the development occurs or intensifies that each country concludes trade agreements with every other country separately. This does not lead to fair world trade, does not lead to more transparency, and does not ensure that those who should have opportunities in free global trade actually get them.

Germany, in particular, benefits and has always benefited from free trade. Today, we have over eight million employed people in Germany who work in the export sector. When compared to the number from ten years ago, that is 2.5 million more people. Regarding the question of where jobs are created and where we lose them, the export sector is an absolute growth area for us. Moreover, the discussion regarding the EU enlargement to the countries of Central and Eastern Europe is being conducted completely incorrectly. We benefit in many areas from the enlargement of the European Union towards Central and Eastern Europe.

This year, we are the world's leading exporter for the fourth consecutive time. Despite the strong competition, especially from the Far East, we have managed very well in recent years to maintain and expand our global market shares. Therefore, we are obliged by our own interest to advance the world trade negotiations. That is why we will vigorously advocate for the success of the DOHA round. The times are not easy. But there is still a small window of opportunity. We should at least not be accused of not having tried.

A central point in this context is the transatlantic trade relations. The economic interconnections between the United States and the European Union are very close on one hand. Here, too, millions of jobs have been created on both sides of the Atlantic through mutual direct investments. But on the other hand, when looking at the market areas of Europe and the United States, there are still many areas for improvement. I think of product standards, of capital market regulations, which we are currently developing very differently in Europe and the USA – not always resulting in making it easier for companies. When I think that we have a common interest in protecting intellectual property from third parties, then we are well advised to tackle many things together in this regard.

The Austrian presidency had already put a common EU-America market on the agenda at the EU-America summit. I believe we have a good opportunity to continue this point at the EU-America summit taking place in America during the German presidency. It must be clear: It is not, as some claim, directed against the DOHA round. It is not directed against multilateral agreements. But where commonalities arise, where they are productive for both of us as partners, we should advance this process.

Of course, especially regarding the newly emerging economic powers – I think of China and India – we also need a very unified approach in many areas. A central prerequisite for our economic development is the topic that has been on the agenda repeatedly in recent years and also in recent months: energy supply.

Therefore, I would like to mention energy policy as a third example where we have a common interest in representing a unified position. Energy policy is not a communal policy – I do not want to give the Commission any new competencies here – but it is indisputable that energy policy is a topic that will significantly influence and shape the development of the European Union as a whole.

We know: The European Union has a number of homework assignments to complete. The internal market directives for electricity and gas have not been fully implemented. There is still, in part, a mental problem in enforcing the internal market in an area perceived as a public service – in energy supply. Recent interventions by the Commission have made this very clear to us.

We must make progress collectively in the areas of energy efficiency and renewable energies, which, in my view, are not only of the utmost necessity for climate protection but are also a matter of economic and, above all, security and peace policy reason. Because when we look at where oil and gas reserves are concentrated, they are in a few countries. A large part of them has significant conflict potential in the respective region. Therefore, it must be our interest to strive for a sustainable energy supply. Of course, this requires rethinking in many areas. These questions, about how dependent we want to be, where we can reduce dependencies, should occupy and concern us. This does not mean that I want to nurture the illusion that Europe could become independent of energy imports. But in the question of energy foreign relations, speaking with one voice is of crucial importance.

Therefore, we want to ensure that, especially regarding Russia, we formulate the energy chapter in the negotiation of a new cooperation and partnership agreement with clear principles. Russia is currently not willing to ratify the transit protocol of the energy charter. However, we would wish for this.

When it comes to cooperation, we need security – not just for individual countries, but for the entire European Union. I always say: There must be no projects that are directed against others; there must be no member states of the European Union that have the impression that we are not speaking with one voice here. Instead, we should pursue the same goals. In this respect, it was of great importance that the Russian president recently participated in the discussions of the European Council in Lahti. At the joint lunch, where we prepared for this meeting, we once again explored our common interests very intensively and perhaps alleviated some fears of member states that think that everyone is playing their own card here.

I believe one cannot have a unified economic policy, a single market, where afterwards everyone has to worry about their energy supply. This must be very clear in the overall understanding of the European Union, even though the question of European networks – as we experienced last weekend – is still not completely clarified, with the most bizarre bottlenecks occurring and one does not even know who can transmit how many electrons to whom. Moreover, questions regarding the supply of natural gas and regarding fixed pipeline systems are even more difficult to handle. But I also lament that the understanding of the questions of how much energy we will need, which country is how dependent, what philosophy we pursue, and whether we should not coordinate this to some extent, is still very poorly developed.

We are currently conducting an energy dialogue in Germany. Regardless of the different views in the Grand Coalition on nuclear energy, I consider it extremely important that we think not only until the end of the legislative period but until the year 2020: How dependent will we be? Which of our companies will cooperate? How do we envision energy supply? How large can the share of renewable energies be? Where do we need to invest now to have successes in five or ten years? Developments in this area are incredibly long-term. Therefore, this topic is a real concern for me.

We will, of course, also ensure that energy supplies can never be misused for political power. Here, too, we must speak with one voice. There must be no false modesty. We must also urge our partners in the USA to adopt a sustainable approach to energy. In spring 2007, we will adopt an energy action plan in the European Union based on communications from the Commission.

Since I have already mentioned our American partners, I will now move from energy policy to my fourth example, climate policy.

I believe we should also understand climate change as a pan-European challenge. National efforts will not help at all here. Nowhere else is it more evident that this is a global challenge than in climate change. The European Union can once again speak with one voice and bring some dynamism back into the international negotiation processes.

As Minister of the Environment and President of the first Conference of the Parties to the Climate Framework Convention, I negotiated the "Berlin Mandate." This was the basis of the Kyoto Protocol. The Kyoto Protocol will expire in 2012. This means we urgently need – the conference in Nairobi is already taking place this week – a follow-up process. I am well aware that views on climate protection, the question of whether it is a real threat, are not shared equally by all, but I believe the scientific evidence is becoming increasingly compelling. If someone does not want to believe it or still sees the probability of climate change as low, I can refer them to the previous chapter and say: Saving energy, increasing energy efficiency is certainly nothing wrong. In this respect, it is worth engaging with this topic and, above all, striving for interesting instruments.

We have already tried many paths in Germany. I believe we have now arrived at the most interesting instrument, which is also loved by the economy. But which innovation is loved by the economy if it does not come from the economy itself? Therefore, Mr. Oetker, I believe that emissions trading is a very interesting instrument, where we just need to ensure that we bring the various instruments of regulatory policy, taxation, and trading instruments into harmony.

We also know that the EU can never solve the climate problems of this world alone. Nevertheless, I believe that we should be pioneers out of well-understood self-interest, because you can see – I have been able to observe this very well over the last ten years – that the discussion about environmental problems and CO2 emissions will intensify incredibly in the regions that are currently experiencing significant economic growth – China, India. Those who have environmental technologies will benefit from this. We are already partially benefiting today from having introduced flue gas desulfurization, from having high efficiency in power plants. The same will be true for CO2 emissions. Those who have the best technology today will be the export champions of the future. Therefore, I believe we should approach this topic boldly.

The British government presented the so-called Stern Report last week, which impressively shows that it is expensive to do something about climate change – yes, it costs money – but that the prices we will have to pay if we do nothing are likely to be many times higher. Now one might say these prices are delocalized. One cannot say exactly who they will hit. But that would be a very, very irresponsible approach. Considering global warming, a temperature increase of two degrees as an upper limit should really be our common goal. Thus, what we do is already not without risk.

The Federal Minister for the Environment presented to us on Sunday, when we discussed this topic, very impressively the irreversible consequences that have already occurred today. The glacier on the Zugspitze is still there, but it can no longer be saved. The same is true for many other things. If you know that you now have completely changed dry and rainy zones, then this is, for example – even in Germany – of crucial importance for an area like forestry; for the question of whether there will still be conditions in Uckermark in 40 years for oaks to grow, or whether those conditions will no longer exist. Because today, the trees are planted that are to be felled in a hundred years. Investments in the future are already not so easy to make today. Therefore, I can only urge all of us: Let us recognize this as a market-economically sensible problem; otherwise, we will have much, much bigger problems.

I believe that with my examples of security and defense policy, world trade, energy supply with the components of energy foreign and domestic policy, and the major issue of climate change, I have shown: These are all challenges that no country can face alone. For this, we need a common understanding of the European Union, which commits itself to this together. We must make this clear to the citizens and move away from the early years of internal market development, where everything essentially revolved around various directives that caused much annoyance. Now, I do not want to disparage all the nice directives, but they have led to annoyance.

The question of regulatory density – to avoid using the nasty term regulatory zeal – has not yet been fully resolved in Europe. I am very grateful to the European Parliament for having increasingly looked into whether the umbrella configuration in beer gardens needs to be regulated uniformly across Europe, because the complaints of a Spanish union about too much sun on the island of Rügen are only very conditionally shared and probably not at all in Ireland.

Therefore, Europe must focus on what cannot be done alone. By the way, if I may say this for Germany, one of the success recipes of the German federal order or the principle of subsidiarity is: One tries to solve tasks as close to the people as possible, but when a higher level is needed because only it can really solve a task, then this task must also be delegated to that higher level. Therefore, during our presidency, we will particularly support efforts regarding the so-called "better regulation" project. Behind this lies the concept of reducing bureaucracy in Germany. It is about the decision of the Europeans, the European Union – I hope including all employees of the Commission – not always just to enlarge and accumulate the Acquis Communautaire, but also to be willing to abolish something that is not or is no longer needed. National legislation works that way.

If I could fulfill a special wish, I would advocate for the principle of discontinuity to be introduced in the creation of European directives. This means that when a new parliament is elected, the not yet adopted law or, in Europe, the corresponding directive disappears for the time being and only comes back on the agenda when the new parliament finds that it urgently needs to be discussed. This does not happen in Europe today: An election can take place, and yet the directive survives and is repeatedly presented for discussion.

People have a very fine sense of whether we are focusing on the important issues or on those that are not quite as important. People also have a fine sense of whether we only talk about the unity of Europe on Sundays or whether we practice this with one voice on the big questions. The German presidency will try – I believe there is also good will from all others – to tackle the challenge in these areas, because we have experienced in other areas that it benefits us all when we stand together, and that it can bitterly harm us when we are divided.

In this sense, I hope that all of us who are interested in foreign, security, European, and other political matters will support us on this path. We will try to show people with what we do that we care about their important problems, about their important concerns.

In this sense, I thank you for your invitation and wish you much success in your scientific studies. And please formulate them in such a way that occasionally laypeople can participate as well.