Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 13th Annual Conference of the Council for Sustainable Development on May 13, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

14 May 2013 · 13th Annual Conference of the Council for Sustainable Development · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 13th Annual Conference of the Council for Sustainable Development on May 13, 2013, in Berlin, discussing sustainability, budget policy, and European economic reform.
Main themes
Sustainability culture, European debt crisis and budget consolidation, German debt brake and balanced budget, austerity measures, competitiveness and structural reform, international financial crisis, European monetary union stability, intergenerational responsibility, global sustainability advocacy, right measure as guiding principle
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,281
88th percentile
Sentences
220
91st percentile
Readability
50
61st percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 41%38%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Environmental 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

220 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Thieme,

dear members of the council,

ladies and gentlemen,

I thank you for the invitation and am also pleased to be back at the conference of the Sustainability Council to discuss with you the work we are doing and the expectations you have. First of all, I would like to express my gratitude for your statements and initiatives that promote sustainability and continually demand it. I believe it can be said that your voice is being heard – not only in politics but also in society and in the economy; and increasingly so – our networking with international experts has certainly contributed to this – at the European and international levels.

This visit gives me the opportunity to take stock and ask the question: How far have we actually internalized the idea of sustainability? I deliberately speak of a "stocktaking," as we are certainly not at the end of a journey but rather halfway along the way. We have already left some stages behind us; and others lie ahead.

Your conference motto is indeed one that advocates for an entire culture – a culture of sustainability. With your conference motto "With Measure and Courage," you have essentially provided a compass to this goal. Therefore, I would like to mention a proverb from East Africa that fits well here: "A person will not live long if they do not know three things: what is too much for them, what is too little for them, and what is just right for them." It is therefore about the right measure.

There are numerous international and certainly also national events where the right measure is not achieved or maintained. Maintaining measure – this requires a look at the good and the flawed of the past; it requires thinking into the future instead of living by the motto "After me, the deluge" and only having the day in mind. We have painful examples – particularly in connection with the international financial crisis and also with the European sovereign debt crisis – to account for. We must continue to engage with these crises, which have their origins in excess or at least in a false measure. Everything we are currently doing is essentially correcting the mistakes of the past. That is why I am also deeply convinced that we must now tackle the problems in Europe at their roots so that we can achieve a sustainably stable economic and monetary union. This means we must truly address the shortcomings from the founding period, perhaps also shortcomings from the early years of the euro.

In this context, our handling of budgets is, of course, a very important topic. In the past, when one had too much debt, one spoke of a necessary consolidation of budgets. The Federal Republic of Germany has introduced the debt brake in the Basic Law with a large majority in Parliament. I would also like to inform you that we are already able to comply with the debt brake at the federal level, which should actually only take effect in 2016. Our goal is a balanced budget; that is, a budget in which we in Germany want to spend only as much in a year as we take in that year for the first time in decades. While this does not yet repay any debts, it at least shows that a balanced budget is possible. We are approaching this goal.

Now, in Europe and also in Germany, people no longer talk about budget consolidation, but have adopted the term austerity from English, which sounds, in my opinion, very aggressive; and that is probably how it is meant. Therefore, I want to point out that it is not a question of whether we reach something that is now within reach for us in Germany – namely, living off what we collect in taxes – a year earlier or later, but it is currently about whether we can even get close to the three percent new debt limit for many countries. This means that three percent of a country's gross domestic product will still be taken on as new debt. It is about us adhering to the stability and growth pact that we have set for ourselves. Therefore, it is important that we implement structural measures – not just tax increases or cuts for people who already have little – that improve competitiveness to the extent that revenues increase again. This is far more than just budget consolidation. We must face this task in the interest of the current generation and future generations.

We are not free in our decisions about what we do in Europe. Because this decision depends on how the competitiveness and capabilities of the countries around us develop. This means that Europe cannot define the competitiveness of the world; rather, we must also align ourselves with how other parts of the world work and live. We must also – and I want to state this explicitly – advocate for sustainability worldwide; I will come back to this. Therefore, we must try to change and adapt the framework conditions so that they become more sustainable. This is the task for Europe.

I believe that Germany is setting a good example in this regard, by the way, also in a measured way. We, as the federal government, are repeatedly accused: If it were only about reducing debt, we could have done much more in this legislative period. That may certainly be true. However, since we also have a responsibility for growth across Europe, and since it is rightly said that we, as the stability anchor that we currently are, must also ensure that our domestic demand is increased to the extent that others can send and sell their goods to us, we have chosen a path where we maintain measure – also with regard to growth opportunities for others. We must, of course, continue to think about the future. It will not be easy in the coming years to keep an eye on the question of the budget, which is also a question of the future viability of our country. The demographic change, the changing age structure of our society, will present us with great challenges.

There are, of course, further examples. Ms. Thieme just mentioned the topic of sustainability in connection with climate protection and climate change. She also found admonishing words for Germany. Yes, Ms. Thieme, it is true that we need, as soon as possible at the EU level, another target that goes beyond the CO2 reduction target for 2020. We are in discussions about this with the member states and especially with our Polish friends. In connection with the climate conference in Poland, I think that we may indeed manage to agree on a more far-reaching target by the end of this year.

It is not in line with the idea of sustainability if the price for the certificates in emissions trading is currently falling, as you have also pointed out. There is also a broad discussion within the federal government about the question: How should we now intervene in the supposedly market-based instrument of certificate trading? The promise was actually: We introduce it; and the rest will be taken care of by market forces. We have let market forces prevail, said nothing further about it; and now the price does not correspond to the forecasts that everyone made – between 15 and 18 euros – but is at two or three euros. Now we have, believing the forecasts about certificate prices, of course already planned the money. But now the money is not coming. Then one says: "What kind of economic instrument is this? Much less is coming out than we wanted."

Now one must consider the following: If we intervene because we are not receiving the projected revenue from certificate trading, then it would no longer be a market-based instrument; we should not intervene. Now – I am still in discussion with my colleagues within the federal government about this – I say, however: What we may not have said as clearly as we should have is that our assumptions for the amount of certificates we issue are not just plucked from thin air, but that these assumptions are closely linked to assumptions about economic growth. However, we did not state this in the explanation of certificate trading.

Therefore, the question now arises: What might we change, if necessary? To this I say: If such drastic deviations from the projected economic growth occur, as we experienced in 2008 and 2009, then it must be possible to consider the difference between the assumptions about economic growth and reality and to say which amount of certificates corresponds to the difference and whether one can possibly remove the whole thing from trading. This would likely – we cannot predict this with certainty – result in a price correction. Should growth within the projected period jump in an outstanding manner, then this can also be taken into account in the system again. Now we currently have an economic growth that is far from the assumption regarding certificate prices. However, this requires that we also explain this now, so that the impression does not arise that there is simply manipulation to get the money that has already been planned. I believe this is important for the credibility of certificate trading. I am also in discussions with the German economy, which I have not yet convinced of the change in certificate amounts.

Moreover, we must work on – and hopefully we will succeed with a reform of the Renewable Energy Sources Act – to ensure that our steering elements are unified and better coordinated. We have electricity taxes, we have EEG levies, we have eco-taxes, we have incentive regulations in the heating market, we have European requirements, and we have certificate prices. All of this does not fit together into a very congruent system. Therefore, it is important to solve some problems, especially with regard to the German energy market. Then we will also receive better support for making changes in the certificate market. We can no longer postpone this, and we will not succeed in doing so before the federal elections. Because we now have an EEG levy of about 18 billion euros, which is growing every year, and we have an increase in renewable energies that is not synchronized with the storage capacities of renewable energies and the expansion of the grid. Therefore, it must succeed in truly coordinating the individual elements of the energy transition. I am deeply convinced that we can achieve this. I also believe that the discussion has shown us that we should not interfere with the existing system. But for the future, we will not be able to afford such growth rates as we have had in recent years, especially in solar energy.

In all the joy about renewable energies, we must also not lose sight of the fact that we do not need more energy than we consume in the country. Otherwise, we need more interconnectors to deliver our energy to other countries. The expansion of solar energy is now at just under 30 gigawatts. We will ramp this up to 50 gigawatts. After that, there will be no more subsidies. On a normal day, we need a capacity of 65 to 70 gigawatts available in Germany. We have about 25 to 30 gigawatts of wind energy and about 30 gigawatts of solar energy. This means that during hours when wind and sun occur simultaneously – and this happens very often – we can already cover almost the entire German energy consumption with renewable energies. However, we still need so much base load for the times when we have neither sun nor wind available. This must remain within a reasonable scale.

We must therefore follow the principle – which also has something to do with sustainability – that wind power is promoted where wind can be converted into energy most efficiently. It makes no sense to extend the promotion of wind power equally across 16 federal states so that in the end we have wind turbines everywhere. We need to engage much more in a dialogue about this. These are new problems. We did not have these problems before because we did not have so many renewable energies. We must solve these problems. And I am quite optimistic that we will succeed. Then we will, I hope, make progress in certificate trading.

As for the international climate negotiations, we have the ambition to have a binding climate protection agreement again from 2020. Peter Altmaier, our Minister for the Environment, recently conducted the so-called Petersberg Dialogue on this. The agreement is to be negotiated by 2015. A tremendous amount of work still needs to be done to achieve this; it will not be easy.

The fact is: If we want to meet the two-degree target worldwide, the contribution of industrialized countries alone is not enough. Even if the United States, Europe, and all other industrialized countries were to stop emitting CO2 from today onwards, the two-degree mark would still be exceeded solely due to the CO2 emissions of emerging countries. This means we need not only binding commitments from industrialized countries. At the moment, it is the case that under the Kyoto Protocol, binding commitments apply almost exclusively to the European Union – I believe also to Norway and perhaps one or two other countries. All others have opted out. Therefore, I must honestly say: We should be ambitious in Europe, yes, but we must also be careful not to completely decouple ourselves from the rest of the world. Rather, we need to focus on achieving a global agreement for a global phenomenon. This is, in my view, very, very important.

Now, Ms. Thieme has also said, in essence, that we should not only manage sustainability but also have real courage. This is certainly something to reflect on repeatedly. I believe that we – at least for the federal government, I would like to say – represent the sustainability strategy with enthusiasm. That is why we have also faced the progress reports, which are evaluated by international experts. Professor Stigson is the head of the peer group; and I would like to sincerely thank this peer group. Because we do not want to hide away or stew in our own juices, but rather to take in the fresh wind of international experiences.

We want to do this especially because, as Ms. Thieme has already said, the concept of sustainability originates from Germany. It was coined 300 years ago, so it has a good history. It reminds us of the great fuel needs in Saxon silver mining, which led to a shortage of wood, threatening a source of wealth in the land of King Augustus the Strong. And that is why a clever person thought that perhaps one should only fell as much wood in a year as can be regrown.

This principle is of great importance to us, because due to demographic change, due to the change in age structure, we will be confronted even more strongly with the problem of sustainability in the future. If the population decreases, even if total debt no longer rises, per capita debt still increases. This is exactly the phenomenon we will experience in the coming years. Therefore, it is not only about getting by with what one earns; rather, it is also about ensuring that debts are reduced.

Tomorrow we will hold a congress on our demographic strategy and say what we have already achieved and how we want to move forward. This is a complex topic, but also a topic that is closely linked to sustainability. How can we ensure that the quality of life is maintained equally across all regions of Germany? How can we ensure that, with a declining population, an aging population, and an increasingly diverse population, the level of education is maintained? How can we ensure that social security systems are not overstrained? All of these are questions we are grappling with and which certainly cannot be addressed by a federal government alone. That is why we have also invited municipalities, states, employers, trade unions, and other civil society groups to dialogue.

Answering these questions will also require a change in thinking. The middle class, for example, must rethink how to extend working life. We have made significant progress in this regard, as some are considering how to retain their qualified employees longer due to the shortage of skilled workers. However, this will bring about changes in terms of job quality, health prevention, and much more.

The topic of lifelong learning will take on increasing importance. The topic of care will take on increasing importance. We have made an important step in this legislative period by providing more services for dementia patients. We have done something for better care of people in rural areas by creating more attractive career profiles for country doctors. The supply of pharmacies and much more must also be considered. We are doing something for the compatibility of work and family through the expansion of daycare centers and will have a legal entitlement to care for children under three years old starting August 1. This is a qualitative leap that also allows for the possibility that the number of employees may increase a bit further and the number of unemployed decreases.

But we currently have – we do not want to rest on this success – the highest number of employed persons. If you look at the path from the time of German reunification to today, you can see that this is indeed a success. Therefore, we will continue to work to ensure that nothing changes in the trend due to demographic change. We have also had to implement some very unpopular measures for this. Some want to soften the retirement age of 67 again; however, we want to reach it by 2029. I say: This is absolutely necessary and indispensable; otherwise, we will not be able to achieve sustainability in our social security systems. We have also changed the incentives for early retirement regulations and have – this is very observable – immediately more people who are older still in the workforce. This means that one can see very well how political framework conditions steer certain developments.

Internationally, the sustainability agenda is also something we are strongly committed to. We will – currently, this is being done by former Federal President Köhler – work on new Millennium Development Goals. However, the first priority is that the development goals we have set are actually achieved. We will not achieve all goals by 2015. I discussed with UNDP Administrator Helen Clark at the Protestant Church Day that it will be urgently necessary not to lose sight of the goals we have not yet achieved, but rather to achieve them, albeit belatedly. The next round of Millennium Development Goals will then include goals that embody the idea of sustainability even more strongly. Great energy is currently being devoted to this.

Sustainability is a societal task. Therefore, it will also be very important that we repeatedly honor people who are particularly committed to this idea and place them as role models in the spotlight. The German Sustainability Award gives us a good opportunity for this. It will be awarded for the sixth time this year. More and more companies are also beginning to take an interest in the idea of sustainability. They publish sustainability reports, some of which are based on the German Sustainability Code developed by the Sustainability Council. Among them – and we are proud of this – are companies with federal participation such as Deutsche Bahn or Deutsche Telekom – not exactly small or medium-sized enterprises, but certainly companies with many employees. What is beautifully referred to in English as "Corporate Social Responsibility" – or short: CSR – is something that more and more companies are committing to. We should encourage them to make this clear. A new award has also been created for this purpose. The federal government recently honored some exemplary companies. I would like to once again sincerely congratulate the award winners at this point.

Many consumers also honor the exemplary commitment of companies. They are increasingly asking – and I think we should encourage this –: Where does the product I buy come from; what social and ecological footprint does it leave? In light of the terrible events in Bangladesh regarding textile factories, it is also very important that we inquire and demand fairer wages in these countries. When one reads about 23 cents per hour earned for something we buy for a lot of money in our stores, that cannot be acceptable. Here, we really need to intervene. I will increasingly demand this in my international discussions. I believe that countries have already recognized that globalization today also means that nothing remains anonymous. We must pay close attention to this. However, we must also be careful that when Europe advances in the production of palm oil and demands certificates to ensure that the right palm oil is produced for Europe, unecologically produced palm oil is not exported to other countries. This means we must ensure that the standards we set in Europe do not remain singular but that we engage with these issues worldwide.

I believe the concept of sustainability is also closely linked to our concept of growth. Our concept of growth must be supplemented – we all agree on this. Gross domestic product alone is not sufficient to describe all the characteristics of qualitative growth. That is why the results of the Enquete Commission of the German Bundestag, which deals with growth, prosperity, and quality of life, are extraordinarily interesting. Therefore, it is interesting what is happening internationally regarding the definition of quality of life. I believe we are still at the beginning in this area in Germany. That is why I will invite experts who have dealt with the question of quality of life to an International Germany Forum in June. It is worth considering how we can better integrate such a definition, including the indicators of the Federal Statistical Office, into our overall assessments. Once one engages with this topic, it is very exciting. While we primarily talk about gross domestic product in Europe – which is correct, because if the difference from the previous year is negative, that is not good either – such questions will increasingly come to the fore even in a country like Germany. For many families, they are already arising today. For example, I was touched by a questionnaire that dealt with quality of life, which simply asked: How many people do you know who are willing to care for you if you become seriously ill? I think such a question will be at least as relevant as questions of pure material wealth. In the coming years, we will have to engage much more with aspects of sustainability and quality of life.

In politics, in business, in society, advocating for more sustainability requires measure and courage. I think we can best solve things collectively. That is why I am pleased that the Sustainability Council has called for a German Action Week, which will take place from June 15 to 21. It will show how diverse the commitment to sustainability can be. The federal government does not want to hold back in this regard but also wants to showcase some good examples. One example I would like to share with you today is that of administrative practice. We align the procurement of goods and the use of services according to sustainability criteria. Although German procurement law requires that the economically most advantageous offer is awarded, we believe this should be distinguished from the cheapest offer. Because life cycle costs and environmental characteristics also play a role. To raise awareness of this in the federal, state, and municipal levels, we established a competence center for sustainable procurement in 2012. It is conveniently located at the Procurement Office of the Federal Ministry of the Interior.

[Logo of the competence center is displayed]

With the appearance of this logo, the information platform for sustainable public procurement is now live. However, perhaps not all of you should check the internet at the same time, as I do not know if it can handle the traffic. I would like to thank all those who have worked for this platform. You must know: Everything that needs to be done together with the federal and state governments is a complicated matter, because people on the internet usually only use one access point, but our institutions in the country are still proud of their diversity and cannot understand that citizens do not appreciate this and might prefer it if they could reach every municipality and every region in Germany with one click. We are working on this in various areas. The phone number 115 is also only gradually becoming successful. But we are pleased that the municipalities are always cooperating very well. Test it out. Then you can inform yourself about the criteria. We are working to ensure that the understanding of what is economically viable – I think this is already a step forward; a few years ago, this would not have been the case – is not always the cheapest. If we have brought this understanding more to the people, then we have achieved a significant milestone.

In this sense, I wish you continued success in working for the idea of sustainability, hopefully sustainable work in using your own personal resources, and together, may we have much persuasive power to promote sustainability.