Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the VDZ Magazine Days 2007 on November 16, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 November 2007 · VDZ Magazine Days 2007 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the VDZ Magazine Days 2007 in Berlin on November 16, 2007, speaking on media transformation, press freedom, and the future of print journalism.
Main themes
Freedom of press and opinion, digitalization and media transformation, print media and magazine industry, democratic culture and debate, German reunification, reading culture and literacy, public broadcasting disputes, European Union's global influence, Richard Florida's Three T Theory, coal mining subsidy exit, Helmut Kohl legacy
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,880
74th percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.04
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 26%26%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 9%8%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

143 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Professor Burda,

dear Mr. Fürstner,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here with you again today. I still remember my brief presence at the "Publishers’ Night" last year when Franz Beckenbauer was awarded the "Goldene Victoria." I believe you have made another good choice with your two awardees this year.

I do not want to go into the history of the development of RAG into a new company. This path has cost us a lot of strength and time. However, it was one of those almost unnoticed turning points, because the Grand Coalition has now put the exit – or at least a scenario for the exit – from subsidized hard coal mining, a topic that has been discussed for decades, on a path that guarantees both reliability for those affected and acceptance of the situation.

Regarding the second awardee: Helmut Kohl. The fact that I am standing here has to do with his political foresight. Yes, if the matter of German reunification had gone wrong, things would have turned out differently. That Germany managed to integrate into NATO in friendship with the Americans and the then Soviet Union is indeed a tremendous historical achievement.

But I also want to compliment you here, because through your work, you are essentially distinguishing yourselves time and again. Mr. Professor Burda just spoke about the new market conditions. You have to position yourselves in a difficult environment. Mr. Burda has repeatedly pointed out that we are essentially in a time that represents a qualitative change, much like the invention of the printing press. In such times – similar to the shaping of German reunification and the end of the Cold War – one often does not yet see the other shore.

I want to say something to mitigate the harsh discussions that are currently taking place between public broadcasting and your association – discussions that are justified. Essentially, all media providers do not yet see the new shore clearly. We are experiencing disputes over guidelines in Brussels and over press law frameworks here. In this respect, it is indeed a very exciting environment, to which I want to say first: Even in times of increasing digitalization, magazines are indispensable in the media landscape and will continue to be so in the future. Many millions of people in Germany rightly consider them essential.

However, this requires that we preserve the cultural skills of reading and concentrating on a sheet of paper. I am now experiencing even in politics that when we write to our members, grasping new ideas through written communication has become incredibly difficult. Therefore, we must really fight for the preservation of what Gutenberg made possible, starting with school education, because I believe that a digital media landscape built on this could be a gain for society, but one that has, so to speak, illiterates as customers could also mean a loss of quality, of cultural quality in our society.

Nevertheless, due to the omnipresence of digital media, you must also adapt in your magazines, bringing much more flexibility, creativity, and inventiveness. You have a time problem to some extent; this is evident time and again. In this respect, online offerings for certain magazines and newspapers are now completely indispensable. I certainly belong to a generation that cannot imagine life without newspapers and magazines. But we also want future generations to be educated in the same way.

Print media are also something like pace-setters for opinion formation, because informed opinion formation is, of course, a prerequisite for a democratic culture of debate. In this respect, we are highly interested from the political side that the culture of debate in our country does not become impoverished, stunted, or only takes place in flashes, but that the complexity of the world is also reflected in a qualitatively reasonable discourse. And even there, magazines have their very essential place.

Freedom of opinion and press as fundamental prerequisites for a democratic community – you just quoted Mr. Florida. I think his Three T Theory – Talent, Technology, and Tolerance – reflects very well what the fundamental advantage of our Western democratic societies can be in major confrontations. During our EU Council Presidency, I repeatedly pointed out: We must not forget that Europe is a continent that is not per se the most dynamic, youngest, most visionary, and forward-looking, but we must defend our position and continually reclaim it.

We are almost 500 million people in the European Union. In a few years, there will be nine billion people in the world. This means that, on average, one European must convince 17 others of us and our ideas before we have convinced the world. At the beginning of the 20th century, it was three others; back then, one in four people in the world was European. Today, only one in twelve to fourteen people is European. Therefore, a lot is at stake in our understanding of freedom of opinion and press in terms of how our society will assert itself in an increasingly interconnected world.

Given the great societal significance, we must continually ask: How can we win young people for print media? There are many initiatives – for which I also extend my heartfelt thanks – to facilitate access to magazines and newspapers for students of different ages. The "National Network of Newspapers and Magazines in Democracy," initiated by State Minister for Culture Neumann, is one such initiative. We want to promote reading and media competence and bundle the various projects together with the publishing industry, journalist unions, and press wholesalers in a network. I think this is a good joint action.

Print media can only fulfill their role if the distribution structures are also appropriate. In this regard, the Grosso system, with a market share of 50 percent, is of crucial importance. I believe we all agree on that. I think it has paid off that the Grosso distribution system was maintained, which the VDZ, the BDZV, and the Federal Association of Press Grosso agreed upon in 2004. This is a future-proof structure.

Now, of course, the competitive situation arises – Mr. Burda spoke of broadband and new technical possibilities – which simply results from the fact that previously some were in the area of printed media, others in television, and thus were quite far apart, while they are now meeting in overlapping areas, which is why the new battles are taking place in this former vacuum zone. This is not surprising, as the media sector and the telecommunications industry will merge. It is not yet entirely clear who will actually be the winner. In this respect, we have a rather difficult situation. We have sometimes already philosophized about the role of the computer and the classic television and who will win the race.

The task of politics is to ensure that providers are not discriminated against, which in this context means: the publishers. Because we must ensure that content-wise reasonable products have a secure place in the new structure. We must take a close look at this new competitive situation. I have already expressed my commitment to newspapers and magazines.

For the media, the reduced VAT rate of seven percent will continue to apply. We will also maintain this in relation to the European Union. You can rely on that. In comparison to other European countries, you are not yet the best positioned, but at least. We need to review how electronic press – we are already approaching the blurred areas – is treated, because here too one could certainly consider whether the reduced tax rate should also be extended to this area.

Now we hear about discussions and debates – some of which are contentious – with the public broadcasting institutions. The EU Commission has decided that public broadcasting in Germany can fundamentally enforce its mandate across all transmission paths, including the internet. We respect this decision. The Federal Constitutional Court, in its ruling on the GEZ fee in September, once again clearly emphasized the independence of public broadcasting from state influence. This independence encompasses not only programming issues but also economic issues. This also somewhat restricts the scope of action of the state. But that cannot mean – I want to make this very clear – that there are no limits to the basic service mandate of public broadcasters. They must be defined – that is completely clear – although the details can certainly be debated.

Now I want to point out a point that may sometimes be forgotten. The basic service mandate is a mandate that is only valid – as I understand it – if a high percentage of the population is also reached. This does not concern a niche channel for continuous news broadcasts that only three percent of the population is interested in. Such a situation would also undermine the basic service mandate.

If you briefly put yourself in the position of a director at ARD or ZDF, you would of course also have to contend with an audience whose interests are changing. It is said that public broadcasting should not simply go by ratings, but on the other hand, one must see: If a certain, representative part of the population is no longer reached, this basic service mandate will be questioned from another corner, just as it can be questioned if everything or nothing is done, as must be the case in the private market. In this respect, I would not view the roulade recipe so critically.

I believe that one is entitled to timely news broadcasts in public basic services. I discuss this with the gentlemen, but that is not the point. The point is actually the sprawling internet concepts. Where public broadcasting is very concerned about the quality of the German newspaper landscape, I would say that while this is an interesting charitable message, I lack faith that this is the only thing driving them. In this respect, we need to look a bit more closely. Even dating platforms or non-program-related chats are far removed from public basic services.

I believe we now have a starting point, namely the announcement from ARD and ZDF that they want to subject the new digital offerings to a kind of trial run under the new three-tier review process before implementing their entire structural decisions. We need to focus on this before engaging in wild battles and see how we can proceed. I also believe that the boundaries must be more clearly defined where the influence of public broadcasters ends. They too are dealing with a changed situation in today’s digital world.

We are also facing the topic of the European media landscape and a legal framework for it, although cultural and media policy interests in Germany often present themselves differently than those of other countries. The first question is: What needs to be regulated at the European level? Where do we need to retain our national decision-making capabilities? Here in Germany – and the federal government also tends to say – we believe that only what really needs to go to Brussels should go to Brussels. The octopus-like claim of all regulations undermining the entire German press law is not what the federal government represents.

However, we must also look at how we can set international standards. This means we are in a permanent tension between press and opinion freedom and universally valid cultural values. I believe we have made some good steps during our presidency, for example, the revision of the Television Directive. It has been possible to maintain the greatest possible diversity of opinion and information for all audiovisual media services. We have achieved a lot in youth protection. We have repeatedly advocated in the telecommunications sector that the balance between media diversity and market interests is also maintained within the European framework.

We also need to do our homework at home. The issue of antitrust law is still not satisfactorily regulated; I must say that very clearly. We also need to think again about the extent to which we actually want to allow the acquisition of large media companies by foreign providers without any consequences, or whether we should impose restrictions here – similar to what the Americans do. We will have these discussions with you again.

On the part of the federal government, we supported the decision made by the state premiers this spring to call on the EU Commission to take adequate account of media and information freedom in the further development of European telecommunications regulations. I believe that European telecommunications law must not contradict national provisions for ensuring plurality. This also means that the refinancing options for print media must not be adversely affected by European regulations.

So we have a lot to regulate. We are watching closely to ensure that initiatives for new regulations from the European Union do not have a detrimental effect on our press landscape. I think we will make progress in close cooperation. The European Union – this must be said repeatedly, because through its competence for coordination, Europe is always trying to conquer new areas – has no authority to interfere in national press law. Therefore, we will reject all such attempts at this point.

The technical questions are currently very much on the minds of media creators due to new technological possibilities. That is right, and we understand that. But we also need to address the cultural and qualitative level. Therefore, I want to make it clear that we are very grateful that you are addressing the fact that one-fifth of the population now has a migration background very proactively. Through the discussion about the "National Integration Plan," we have gained a new sense of self-understanding, telling the society of those who have long lived here: You must also be open; you must accept people with a migration background. On the other hand, certain requirements must also be placed on migrants, especially regarding language skills. Because access, for example, to German magazines depends crucially on language competence. Therefore, I thank you for considering integration aspects, including aspects of cultural diversity, more strongly. Many very interesting experiences are being made in connection with this integration discussion.

If one puts oneself in the situation of fellow citizens of foreign origin who have German citizenship but simply represent through their appearance that they come from other countries, and observes the roles such people play, for example, as actors or moderators in our television offerings – when, for instance, a person of color says: I would also like to play a mayor role; I have been a German citizen for 20 years, but I am always only assigned to criminal cases and not even to their resolution – then one feels what the life experience is like from the perspective of migrants. Therefore, I believe that the media have a very, very decisive task here.

We know that your industry can only develop well if, on the one hand, the specific regulatory framework is correct and, on the other hand, the overall conditions are right. Regarding media diversity, the consumer must also have the opportunities to participate in it. This means they must have reasonable purchasing power. This is the main discussion that we have to keep having in the Federal Republic of Germany. This federal government has achieved a lot through reforms in the past legislative period. I want to conclude by saying once again that I am deeply convinced that this does not mark the end of the reform story. Just as your media continue to develop, the world continues to evolve.

Recently, I attended an award ceremony focused on social projects. A film was shown about a call center from which young foreigners, who cannot afford a mobile phone, call home. A young man from Eritrea spoke with his mother, describing the cold here in autumn, and said: "If you were to come here – there are so many elderly people; you would just need to sit on a bench, and an older person would immediately sit down next to you." For me, that was the personified expression of what we have: on the one hand, countries in Africa and Asia, where 50 percent of the people are under 20 years old, and on the other hand, us, with a completely different age structure.

If we do not succeed in preparing for this, if we do not manage to maintain dynamism through lifelong learning, through lifelong access to new things, through a clear commitment to science and technology, as this federal government aims for, with the goal that the state and economy invest three percent of gross domestic product in research and development, if we do not succeed in inspiring people to pursue engineering and technical professions, new developments will pass us by. Then comes the point where even you will have no one left to administer your systems with which you make your digital offerings alongside the newspaper.

So, we are dependent on continuing down the path of reform, so that people have jobs and so that we can keep pace with the global speed of development. I will advocate for this. I know that I have allies in you. Thank you very much, and all the best for your work.