Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 43rd Munich Conference on Security Policy on February 10, 2007, in Munich:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 February 2007 · 43rd Munich Conference on Security Policy · Munich, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 43rd Munich Security Conference in February 2007, speaking on global crises, security threats, and international responsibility.
Main themes
Global security responsibility, climate change as security threat, comprehensive security policy, Israeli-Palestinian conflict, two-state solution, transatlantic partnership, NATO, international cooperation, multilateralism, human development, good governance, Palestinian unity government
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,413
88th percentile
Sentences
226
91st percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 80%80%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

226 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Teltschik,

ladies and gentlemen!

All of us in this hall and far beyond know: Our world is threatened in many ways, and our world has many opportunities. That is why this conference, dear Mr. Teltschik, with the theme "Global Crises – Global Responsibility" is perhaps more important than ever. Our world is threatened, and yes, our world has many opportunities. We must recognize both equally and also accept them for ourselves. To do this, we must first understand what characterizes these threats in our present time and what the nature of appropriate, acceptable responses might look like.

We must answer the question: Is it not the case that countries and peoples have repeatedly come together under the impression of crises when they wanted to overcome and manage these crises? Did not, for example, the idea of European unification arise from the experience that the European nation-states could never break their centuries-long cycle of war and destruction alone and that they could only serve their respective national interests in an increasingly interconnected world in community with others? Was not the founding of the transatlantic partnership, the founding of NATO, also an expression of this understanding, in order to assert common values and enforce common interests?

Starting from these questions that I pose regarding the past, I ask: How is it today? – When we look at our planet, there are many threats. I would like to begin with an ecological-economic one that has nothing to do with the classic threats being discussed here: If we are to believe the reports of climate researchers, then global warming is one of the great medium- and long-term threats that could have dramatic consequences such as refugee flows and armed conflicts. One thing is completely clear: This threat is global, it affects everyone, no one can run away from it, and we can only manage it together. This therefore requires action against threats that are global and that leave no people, no country, and no continent untouched. These are threats that do not allow us to evade them either. This means we must communicate with each other and come together. That is precisely the philosophy of international agreements, in this case, for example, on CO2 reduction. It is exactly as you said, dear Mr. Teltschik: Global threat – global responsibility. This holds true even though I have not yet spoken about the classic conflicts that naturally concern us.

I believe that accepting global crises with global responsibility requires a new, comprehensive understanding of security. Our security policy neither begins nor ends with military operations within NATO or the European Union or with financial and personnel contributions to UN peacekeeping forces. To put it even more sharply: Those who want to prevent crises, who want to sustainably overcome crises, cannot act alone; they must also have the ability to invest in hope and confidence, in justice and the rule of law, in good governance and economic development, in education and health. In short: They must invest in human development in a comprehensive sense. In my view, that is global responsibility towards global challenges.

The necessity of this approach is particularly evident in the Near and Middle East. For decades, efforts have been made there for peace and the vision of a two-state solution between Israel and Palestine. Also for decades, generations of politicians from the region itself, from the United States of America, from Europe, as well as representatives of the UN have repeatedly experienced setbacks and disappointments. The question is: Can we afford to give up despite these setbacks and disappointments? Can we impose that on the suffering people in the region? Conversely asked: Can we afford this in our own, comprehensive security interest in this world – I will say now: in Europe? For me, the answer is a very clear no. The Palestinians and the Israelis have a right to a self-determined life in two viable, prosperous states, side by side, in peace, dignity, and secure borders. The people there have a right to a life free from fear of terror and violence and with the prospect of a better future.

For this reason, the results of the negotiations for the formation of a Palestinian national unity government in Mecca are encouraging. I know: Much remains to be done. I also know that it must be ensured that the three prerequisites for international support of the new Palestinian government are met: A renunciation of violence, the recognition of Israel's right to exist, and adherence to the agreements made so far. But – I say this as the German Chancellor and also as the President of the EU Council – there is a result from Mecca. We should view it as a first step in the right direction, thank the Saudi leadership, and above all appreciate that it is an initiative from the region. Mecca shows nothing more and nothing less than that something is possible. I know that much more must follow. I will just say once again: An important sign would be, for example, the release of soldier Shalit.

But we know: Ultimately, a solution must also be desired by the region itself. We also know: We must never leave this region alone. That is why it was so important for me and for many others that just over a week ago, after a long time, the Middle East Quartet met again for the first time and that it will meet again shortly. I know that progress is slow and that many ask: "Is it worth it?" But I say very clearly: What would the alternative be to trying again and again? The character of the Quartet, which consists of representatives from the United States of America, the European Union, Russia, and the UN, again shows what is so important from my perspective: We come together, we tackle things together, we send coherent, joint signals. We intertwine this with activities on the ground.

Again it becomes clear: The global challenges – whether it is climate protection or asymmetric threats from terrorism – cannot be mastered by anyone alone, no matter how strong they are. I believe that if we recognize this, then, but only then, we come closer to solving conflicts, at least conflicts between Israel and Palestine or the conflict over the future of a sovereign Lebanon. I believe we agree that Lebanon has a right to stability and sovereignty and that it is urgently necessary to help it rebuild together. The Paris conference a few days ago was a very important signal.

When I speak about Lebanon, it inevitably leads to the question of Syria's role. Federal Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier was in Damascus a few weeks ago, like others, to encourage Syria to adopt a constructive stance for peace in the Middle East. It must be noted that Syria has not yet seized the opportunity. I therefore say very clearly: The door for Syria is not closed. But I also say just as clearly: Syria should have no doubt about the determination of the international community to protect Israel and to support Lebanon.

During my recent trip to the Middle East, I had an experience: The threat that many countries feel regarding what is happening in Iran is dramatically visible and recognizable. That is why Iran must comply with the resolutions of the UN Security Council and the IAEA Board of Governors. There is no way around this, it applies without ifs and buts, without tricks. This is a very sensitive technology, and therefore the nuclear program must be presented with high transparency, which Iran has not done. If Iran does not comply, then the alternative is a further slide into isolation. I say again: The word of the international community counts. We have made an offer of cooperation to Iran. We have invited Iran to do what is right for its own people. Iran is a country with a proud history and a great culture. Therefore, it would be good if Iran aligned itself with the community of nations and also submitted to it.

But our word regarding Iran – that also means global responsibility – applies in another direction as well: We do not accept the outbursts of the Iranian leadership against Israel in any way. I have also made it clear in my conversations and have received agreement for this: We are all determined to prevent a threat from a military nuclear program in Iran. The last UN resolution addressing sanctions was clearly adopted in the UN Security Council. Europe, the United States of America, Russia, and China were involved. In my view, this signal of unity must also be maintained in further steps. That means global responsibility: Even when things are not easy, to represent the same principles together and to follow the same path.

When we talk about the threats and, of course, also about the opportunities of our time, then I believe that three elements of our actions become evident: They are freedom, security, and responsibility. For me, they briefly outline the goals of a modern security partnership in the 21st century. These were also the coordinates of the European-Atlantic security partnership of the past, namely NATO. For these goals, we Europeans stand together with the USA and Canada in NATO.

Therefore, for me, the Atlantic partnership and European unification remain the cornerstones of German security policy. Strengthening the European security identity, detached from the Atlantic security partnership – that is an unthinkable path for me. Both cornerstones are, so to speak, two sides of the same coin. For me, NATO is also in the future the strongest expression of jointly responsible security policy. Despite all the difficult discussions in detail, the NATO summit in Riga and also the defense ministers' meeting in Seville have shown exactly this unity and determination of NATO to face the increasing challenges.

We already know that this is not a gray theory and not just a headline, but that it is of course also concretely questioned every day and that everyone must contribute to it. The Federal Government decided last week, subject to the approval of the German Bundestag, to send reconnaissance aircraft that can be deployed as part of the ISAF mission in Afghanistan. I believe there is no doubt that the alliance, NATO, is under particular scrutiny in Afghanistan. On the one hand, the reconstruction efforts can show considerable successes. We should not overlook that in everything we discuss. So much has happened there for the people: The children who can go back to school and the women who can venture out onto the streets. But it is also undeniable that the Taliban are testing our resolve and continually putting us to the test. Therefore, everything must be done to make this mission a success.

The German Federal Government is convinced that success can only lie in a holistic approach, in which both civilian and military elements find their place. It is now important – Afghanistan is a good example for this – to implement this holistic strategic approach and to ensure optimal interaction between civilian and military activities. I believe that if we implement this consistently and in every direction, then we are on the right path, even if it may be more difficult than we had imagined.

I believe the example of Afghanistan shows: To prevent, deter, and avert dangers, NATO needs two things: On the one hand, assertiveness, and on the other hand, persuasiveness. The result of both, for me, is "networked security." This means it is about the inseparable connection of our military approach with civilian measures. I do not want to advocate for a "civilian NATO." But I do want to speak of NATO's self-understanding as part of a civil-military overall profile. That is the role of NATO in the 21st century.

This concept of "networked security" is also the core idea of the white paper that the federal government adopted last year. This means for us concretely: In each of our military engagements – in whatever region of the world – military-stabilizing measures must go hand in hand with political and civilian processes from the very beginning. Both must interlock. We believe that if this is not the case, success is not possible. "Networked security" – this requires the establishment of structures that correspond to the broad spectrum of political, diplomatic, military, civilian, economic, and development policy instruments. We must better coordinate our crisis management and develop concepts for efficient cooperation among international, national, governmental, and non-governmental organizations. Most importantly: This must not happen somewhere in the distant capitals of the sending countries, but it must take place on the ground.

I am very glad that this very path is now increasingly being taken in Afghanistan. We must not delude ourselves: This is also the connection between the activities of NGOs and military capabilities in a way that has not been customary in our country for decades. There was development policy here and military engagement there. Each side had sufficiently many prejudices against the other. That success is only possible through interaction and that neither stands above the other is a new way of thinking that we must learn, and from my perspective, it depends on success.

We Europeans know at this point that our responsibility has not diminished with the end of the Cold War, but rather has increased. That we accept this – even if there is always criticism regarding whether we are accepting it quickly enough – is, in my view, quite clearly visible. Let us think of the Balkans and the support for Lebanon. Time and again, we have developed concepts and capacities that closely link civilian and military operations. For just over a month, the so-called "battlegroups," that is, the European combat units for operations in crisis areas, have been fully operational. We are active as the European Union in Aceh in Indonesia and in the Gaza Strip. We support the Palestinian, Bosnian, and Congolese police. Our common interest, especially with regard to Iraq, is, of course, that the country returns to calm, that the stabilization of Iraq succeeds, no matter how difficult that may be. Because otherwise, we will all feel the consequences together.

In Kosovo, the European Union is ready to take on a central security task with its largest civilian mission to date. We want to help secure the status talks and the status solution that is currently being discussed. Former Finnish President Ahtisaari has made his proposals, but we feel that the process is difficult. Serbs and Kosovo Albanians need time to gain clarity. On the one hand, I advocate keeping a close eye on the fact that the problem of a solution is on the table and that wasting time also carries explosive potential. But on the other hand, I also say: For the Serbs, it will be of utmost importance whether this is a process they can also engage in with a sense of dignity. Therefore, all those responsible know that the prerequisites for this must be met, that we must proceed with greater sensitivity, but that, of course, a solution must also be found. We cannot wait until the end of time.

All of this is, of course, also very clearly related to the question: What will happen next in Bosnia and Herzegovina, where now, twelve years after Dayton, it is slowly time to reduce the international presence? However, we must also say – I advocate for this – that we should still allow the High Representative to operate there for a while with a smaller office while simultaneously strengthening the position of the EU Special Representative, so that we have security for the transition. I would like to remind you that there is currently no constitution in Bosnia and Herzegovina that allows for effective governance. Therefore, I believe it is very important that we, as the European Union, say that there is a European perspective for all in the Western Balkans and that we tie this perspective to a certain development. But I believe that without this perspective, there will only be increased military engagement. This is again an example of how things interlock.

We also want to further develop the European Security and Defense Policy under the German EU Presidency. It has become a matter of course for us, even though it is still a relatively young child. We have learned, partly from difficult experiences: Where Europe does not speak with one voice and where Europe is divided, we have little or no weight; that means we cannot even assert our European interests. But we must also look beyond our own borders. Today, we need a space of common security that extends far beyond the area of North America and Europe. Therefore, we want to strengthen relations with the Mediterranean countries. This also played a role at yesterday's Defense Ministers' Conference.

We also want to expand relations with our neighbors in the East and Southeast in order to shape the future together. Undoubtedly, the partnership with Russia is of particular importance in this regard. I am very pleased that President Putin is with us today, participating in the conference and will speak to us. I am deeply convinced: The answer to the question of how the future relationship between the European Union, NATO, and Russia will be shaped has a decisive impact on the stability of the common security space in Europe and a very significant impact on the relationship with our neighboring states. It is true: Russia already shares responsibility with us in many cases, such as with its contribution to resolving the Middle East conflict – I spoke about the Quartet – regarding Iran – all resolutions would have been less effective without Russia's involvement – and regarding the Balkans. Therefore, our experience is: Together with Russia, we can achieve a lot and accomplish much.

This means we must seize the opportunities that arise from the coming together of peoples and continually seek them out. This means: Shared responsibility between Russia, the European Union, and NATO is in our interest. Therefore, I am also very keen that we can soon begin negotiations for a cooperation agreement with the European Union and that we must resolve the existing differences.

We know that Russia is an important partner in energy supply. I have repeatedly felt in the conversations we have had, Mr. President, that Russia wants to be a reliable and predictable energy partner. Where we can and must improve this further, we will speak openly about it. It is of no use to sweep things under the rug. I believe we also need a closer partnership between NATO and Russia. There have also been discussions about this in recent days. We must also continually push for more stability in the difficult regions in Russia's neighborhood. We must have very open exchanges about this. The perspectives are sometimes different. This must be discussed. But this can only happen if one speaks to each other at all, and therefore I consider this very important.

I say this also in regard to new military installations, regarding which I always believe it is important to remain in conversation and not to speak against each other; that has never benefited us. There may still be areas where one does not come together at a certain point, but to pretend that one is not highly interdependent in this world would be self-deception.

When we talk about the global security partnership, it is correct that NATO is expanding its cooperation with countries like Japan, South Korea, Australia, and New Zealand and that we also see strategic partners in China and India. We are facing completely new challenges regarding non-proliferation and arms control. In this regard, we must also see that the world has become significantly more complex. I believe that particularly China, with its growing role in the world economy, is also taking on more political responsibility. It will be the case – when one looks at how economies are growing differently worldwide – that many emerging countries will experience and we expect that they will take on a bit more political responsibility. Things are shifting here.

Then it is of course said: We must encourage China to take on such responsibility. We must clearly state when we do not share developments. This means, as I believe: Inclusion and not exclusion is also the right approach in dealing with China. But in all openness, there must also be room for discussion about the things on which we do not agree or cannot agree. This includes human rights, as well as the approach to development policy. This applies particularly to China in relation to Africa. I believe it is important that in everything we do, good governance and adherence to minority rights are part of what is necessary. When we, as the Federal Republic of Germany, turn our attention to the African continent as our neighboring continent in our EU Council Presidency – also together with Portugal – and in our G8 Presidency, then an open discussion with China about the respective approaches must also be possible.

I believe we all feel that in this post-Cold War world, problems and local crises can incredibly quickly become international threats. Therefore, I am convinced that the idea of prevention will play an increasing role. Last year, we unexpectedly engaged as the European Union in the Congo. We achieved that elections could be conducted peacefully. All of this would not have been possible without years of development cooperation beforehand. But it is also true: Perhaps the elections as an interim step in this development would not have been possible if we had not also resorted to military action. I add: We have talked a lot about the duration of our stay. It was also right to apply time pressure. Because in the Congo, as in many other places, assistance is also assistance for self-help. We must also be able to let go a bit and demand responsibility from others, as far as possible.

There are great concerns in Africa. I can only remind you of Sudan and the responsibility of Sudanese President Bashir. Hundreds of thousands of people have died, and more are dying. The international community cannot simply stand by. Somalia is a country where reconciliation and reconstruction are urgently on the agenda. For Africa, in my view, we must do everything we can to strengthen its own structures and regional organizations, especially to support the African Union, to strengthen it, to help it, and to stand by it, but also to say: There is shared responsibility.

All of this leads me to the conclusion that we need the United Nations. In my view, the United Nations is the place where legitimacy for global responsibility can be created. But I also say: The reform of the United Nations is progressing too slowly, to put it mildly, or rather to say: unfortunately, only very little is moving forward. Therefore, I tell the new Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon: We will support him. But I also say: We need reforms so that this body can be capable of action.

It has often been said: With the end of the Cold War, the bipolar system and with it the balance of terror have disappeared. But this has resulted in the fact that the security policy threat has not disappeared, but rather has completely changed its character. Today, individual people are willing to throw away their lives, to give them up, in order to take as many innocent people with them to death as possible. This means that the classic deterrence mechanisms no longer work. When some states today prepare to acquire weapons of mass destruction and their delivery systems, conflicts escalate and the risk of chain reactions increases, without the classic deterrence mechanisms functioning as they used to. Therefore, it is clear: Our world is threatened. But this world also has many opportunities.

No one can perceive and tackle opportunities and threats alone. No country in the world today has enough power, influence, and credibility to face the challenges on its own. In my firm belief, this can only succeed through security partnerships and alliances. I know that each of us must step out of our comfort zone in this regard, and that this is not entirely easy in national discussions. For Germany – this may seem quite unusual to some outside the Federal Republic of Germany – the decision to station maritime forces off the coast of Lebanon was an unusually emotional and difficult decision.

I believe we have taken a step beyond our comfort zone in the past year, moving away from the thinking that we are convinced: it is always better when two do something than when only one does. A union of common interests is better than a bilateral alliance. A continent acting together is better than individual regions acting differently. A transatlantic alliance is better than the Atlantic separating us. Joint action by great powers is better than the dominance of their rivalries.

Therefore, I would like to return to the beginning of my thoughts, to European unity. Europe is today more peaceful, freer, and more stable than most of us here imagined in our youth. At least I did not expect to be able to leave the Eastern Bloc before my retirement age 17 or 18 years ago. And so I ask: Is it really so unthinkable that something like what we have experienced could also be experienced by a 20-year-old Israeli and a 20-year-old Palestinian in the future? Or is it really so impossible that we can jointly address the dangers of climate change in order to stop it? Is it so impossible that we can manage to decouple economic growth from energy consumption, thereby enabling the foundations for the existence of future generations?

I believe we must confront the worst fears and threats that are conceivable. Nothing is worse than sweeping the threat under the rug and living from day to day. But we must also retain the strength to believe that we – the states, the peoples – are capable of solving these global threats, unleashing unforeseen forces, and acting together. This requires completely new, unprecedented efforts from us. Everyone must start with themselves; that too is unusual. But I want to assure you at least that my country is ready to take on this challenge within its means and capabilities.