Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 73rd Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks on May 31, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 June 2017 · 73rd Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 73rd Banking Conference of the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks on May 31, 2017, in Berlin, discussing regulation and cooperative values.
Main themes
Cooperative banking, financial market regulation, G20 presidency, Basel III negotiations, shadow banking, social market economy, cooperative idea as cultural heritage, inclusive growth, rural banking services, SME financing, international financial stability, European regulation
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,892
74th percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 53%51%
  • Geopolitical 14%13%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

160 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Fröhlich,

dear board members – I have now noticed how independent you are –, ladies and gentlemen, indeed, it is relatively difficult to reach you. You have more conveniently located DZ banks, but you have not dared to go there. In this respect, the closure of the Straße des 17. Juni makes things very difficult. If a state guest arrives who wants to visit me later, it becomes particularly challenging. Therefore, I have to ensure that the road is not already closed for the state guest before I can leave you. This is the task I face.

The Banking Conference is somewhat like the annual family reunion of the credit institutions that are united in the Federal Association of German Cooperative Banks. The cooperative idea makes your financial institutions something special. I say this with full conviction; that is why I am here. Worldwide, there are over 800 million cooperative members in more than 100 countries. In Germany alone, there are 21 million, of which over 18 million are with cooperative banks. One must keep this in mind to understand the dimension of commitment involved.

Germany has proposed to add the cooperative idea to the list of intangible cultural heritage of humanity. UNESCO has agreed to this. Thus, the idea has convinced not only us in Germany but also worldwide. The certificates were recently presented. The cooperative idea is thus the first German entry on this list of intangible cultural heritage of humanity. I think you can be proud of that. Perhaps this will also help us in the intangible discussions we must have regarding the expected regulations. For this proves that you are something special and that this uniqueness must perhaps also find its place in regulation in some areas.

For you contribute to ensuring that banking services are offered not only in larger cities but also in rural areas. However, you are also under pressure to improve efficiency. Nevertheless, I hope that you can continue to maintain the trademark of being widely represented. You are an important point of contact for investment-friendly self-employed individuals and medium-sized enterprises, for those interested in additional retirement provision and forms of security, and for families who want to build a house or buy an apartment.

One can say that the numbers speak for themselves. Because about one in five euros of total corporate customer financing in Germany comes from a cooperative bank. In housing finance, it is even more than one in five euros. This means you ensure that an idea can become a reality. The strength certainly lies in the firm anchoring in the regions and in the fact that you know much about what you have to judge and decide. However, there are few tangible criteria for this. This makes our work regarding international agreements not entirely easy.

We know that the global financial markets have gone through a severe crisis. Crises of such magnitude cannot be managed by any state alone; we must coordinate internationally. I think there are no differences of opinion on this. Therefore, the international financial crisis was the birth of the G20 at the level of heads of state and government. From the very beginning, we addressed questions of reforms for financial stability in this circle and stated at that time: Every product, every place, and every actor in the financial markets must be subject to regulation. Even this year, in which Germany holds the G20 presidency, the topic of financial market regulation remains a priority – primarily for the finance ministers, but also for the heads of state and government.

This is primarily about regulating not only banks but also shadow banking activities. This is much more difficult, much less tangible. There are always evasive maneuvers because new products can be invented. This means that state regulation relies on good cooperation with those who are knowledgeable in the banking sector. But regulation is absolutely necessary. Nevertheless, I assure you of support in the upcoming negotiations – both for the Basel III successor and for European regulations.

We want – this is a topic at the G20 – to make our entire growth more inclusive. This means that after the financial market crisis, it has been recognized that the type of growth where a few made the profits, which were very much globalized, while the risks were located at the national level, in the individual nations, is not sufficient to create democratic stability. Therefore, the return to the idea of the social market economy is important, which is also your guiding principle. We are trying to shape our G20 presidency in this way, under the motto "Shaping a Connected World." Our symbol for this is a square knot. Those from the northern regions know what maritime knots exist. This knot has the strength to hold even under great tension. Thus, we want to shape a connected world.

This motto is also somewhat shaped by our work in Europe. After the international financial crisis, we have made significant progress in the euro area in improving "weather resistance," if I may put it that way. There is a single banking supervision and a single resolution mechanism. There are harmonized rules for the restructuring and resolution of institutions. We have created more transparency. And we are also making progress with shadow banks, as I mentioned earlier.

However, we recognize that this is not entirely easy. In the past, it was said that taxpayers should never again be involved in rescuing banks. However, we are experiencing in some European countries that the owners of banks can also be ordinary taxpayers. This means it is not so easy to exclude the average man and woman, that is, the ordinary citizen, from involvement. Therefore, it is good that we can say regarding the cooperative banks that they have come through this crisis in such a way that we did not have to talk much about rescue maneuvers, but that they were already relatively crisis-proof.

In Germany, we are in the process of implementing the current EU directive on money laundering. It concerns a register of beneficial owners. Tax fraud, money laundering, and illegal financial flows are being made more difficult. There are also heated discussions about this, as the depth of intervention is significant. Nevertheless, I believe that all these stabilization measures I have mentioned are really important. However, we must continually examine how the rules are applied. We have talked so much about the so-called "level playing field," that is, about equal competitive conditions for all actors, and then we see that the implementation of internationally agreed standards varies greatly. Here, I believe one can also say that the assessment of who is so systemically relevant that all regulations must be applied to them varies quite a bit from continent to continent. However, we in Europe are very precise regarding these implementations, which then causes us difficulties. We pay attention to this as well.

I want to once again – I believe you expect this – make a clear commitment to the three-pillar model of private banks, savings banks, and cooperative banks. It has contributed to our relatively good navigation through the financial crisis. However, we believe that, also due to historical reasons, it must be possible for different countries to take different paths toward a goal. This is precisely the core around which your discussions revolve. It also shows that we can respond better when there are common safeguards in a common currency area. However, for the federal government, it is absolutely important in everything we do that liability and mutual assistance are always fairly distributed among each other and that one side, the European side, does not bear the risks while the others do not have to adhere to certain rules. This proportionality or reciprocal approach is very important.

We know that we need a European approach. There are many challenges that we can only face together or much better together. I will only mention examples such as digitalization or the internal market as a whole, as well as, of course, the questions of peace and common values. All of these are things that we as Europeans should clearly name together in the world.

I believe that in recent months, we have all become somewhat aware of how fragile the treasure that has seemed so self-evident to us after decades of a united Europe is. Events such as the decision of the citizens of the United Kingdom have contributed to this. Elections in Europe, where the outcomes were much closer than we could have ever imagined, have also played a role. Therefore, I believe that awareness has grown to say: The fact that we have lived in peace and freedom for decades is fundamentally linked to the fact that we have a united Europe. Therefore, it is worth – in everything one must fight for in the small – to continually advocate for this common Europe, which is worth much more than euros and cents or heller and pfennig, as we would have said in the past. I know that the cooperative banks are also doing this.

For you, the exit of the United Kingdom is, of course, also of interest from a financial perspective. Even if you are a more locally oriented banking group, there is already a great interest in how this whole process unfolds. I would like to say two things to you. The first is: The United Kingdom is a partner, the United Kingdom is a friend. The British Prime Minister has repeatedly said: We are leaving the European Union, but we remain part of Europe. In this spirit, we want to conduct the negotiations.

On the other hand, it is the case that the fact that we have fundamental freedoms in the European Union – the freedom of movement of goods, people, services, and capital – naturally has its framework conditions. It cannot be that one no longer commits to one of the fundamental freedoms but otherwise does not notice anything. Therefore, the exit has a price. It will not become universally better for anyone due to the exit of the United Kingdom, at least from the perspective of those who have benefited from the advantages of the common European Union. Of course, from a British perspective, one can say: If we are free from certain ties, it will be better for us. But this will also have implications for us in relation to the United Kingdom. Finding a wise political path there will be the great challenge. We are only at the very beginning of the negotiations.

We will first take care of the rights of non-British citizens from the member states of the European Union in the United Kingdom, as well as the rights of British citizens living in EU countries, so that at least a certain degree of security is established here.

Then it will be about entering an infinitely complicated web and drawing lines of separation in a very deeply interconnected market. Jean-Claude Juncker always gives the example that each year, 250,000 dogs and cats are transferred from the United Kingdom to continental Europe and back, for which health passports, vaccination certificates, and such things are needed. But that is still the simplest part. I will only mention a few practical examples: It concerns holiday insurance, health cost coverage, and consumer protection requirements. All of this is quite simple on day one after the exit of the United Kingdom, but after five years, we must also have safeguards in place so that the competitive field does not shift completely when the United Kingdom then pursues its own regulatory measures.

In this respect, a trade agreement must also be negotiated, although we have no experience in negotiating services. However, services – see the City of London – play a significant role. Therefore, this is indeed a complex, large task that we must solve, and we must not lose the political overview in the end.

A small side aspect is that, of course, the EU agencies will also be relocating. The European Medicines Agency, for example, is moving – a very sought-after institution that many European countries are competing for; just like the European Banking Authority, for which we also feel very well suited, as we have a proper center in Frankfurt.

In addition to Europe, the second major point I want to address is that there are currently difficult framework conditions. We respect and uphold the independence of the European Central Bank, but the prolonged low-interest phase poses great challenges for you, especially regarding your products, when I think of home ownership, for example.

Another major challenge is, of course, digitalization, because it also changes the models of your interactions with customers and because you are essentially living in a time of transformation, where you still have many customers who do not fit into the framework of new digital business models, in contrast to the emerging young customer base. There are also new competitors – I am thinking of FinTechs – that is, financial technology companies – which are not yet captured in regulation and legal and liability issues, but are already competing with you. Therefore, you have many steps to take that are still unfamiliar, and we also rely on close communication in this regard.

In addition, we need security on the internet and also in online banking. You are just as exposed to cyber threats as we all are and know what a damaging effect it can have when there are outages lasting for days. As convenient as everything is: when it doesn’t work, it is, of course, much more dramatic than we know from the earlier non-digital world. Therefore, entirely new job profiles and new skills are required. I would like to thank you for approaching this process very resolutely and not complaining or lamenting, but rather being proud of your own model on one hand, while also being open to the new times on the other.

Now we have a common interest in teaching our young people how to navigate the digital world confidently – media literacy, schools, training. These are also significant challenges, as the German vocational schools and many teachers are not yet fully prepared for these entirely new challenges.

The working world of your employees is, of course, also changing constantly. I do not know how eagerly each continuing education course is taken on or whether you need a lot of persuasion. As leaders, you can no longer be entirely sure that you know the most. Rather, the young people who are just starting to work are particularly adept in digital matters. This is true for all of us. And I find it very interesting that some large German industrial companies – Bosch, for example – have a young companion for all leadership positions, so that they can essentially coach each other to gain full insight into the new world of digitalization. I believe this is also a new cultural era, where lifelong learning is experienced up close. I did not mean to offend anyone with that. If you can do all of this on your own, then that is good.

I believe that the topic of securing skilled workers will become a significant issue – perhaps less so for the very large companies, but certainly for many medium and smaller enterprises. Therefore, we are quite proud that we can say today: Unemployment has nearly halved compared to 2005. We have many more people who can utilize longer working lives, we have many more employed women, and we also have a multitude of European foreigners who are now working in Germany.

We can also say that the situation of companies is relatively good. You can assess that as well. The number of corporate insolvencies was at its lowest level since 1999 in 2016. Also, in terms of public finances, we are in a very good position, which is ultimately likely a reassuring element regarding people's willingness to invest in consumption. The current growth driver is primarily domestic consumption, which has not been the case for many years.

This means we currently have a situation where one can say: The common forces that must operate in the social market economy are functioning relatively well. There are many shoulders on which responsibility rests. This is actually a time when you can come out particularly well. Because what you do is always a collective effort of many. Therefore, this is a time when I believe one can say that the founding fathers of the cooperative movement were indeed right, and we still see it that way many years later.

Therefore, I would also like to conclude by quoting Friedrich Wilhelm Raiffeisen: "What is not possible for the individual, many can achieve." Hermann Schulze-Delitzsch added: "Several small forces united form a large one, and what one cannot achieve alone, one should connect with others to accomplish." This should continue to be your motto. And we are also trying to incorporate this into our work, especially now in the G20 presidency. This always involves many actors.

Therefore, once again, a warm welcome to the 900 confident leaders who have gathered in the capital. I wish you a successful conference. I was pleased that you invited me. You cannot be blamed for the traffic conditions.

Thank you very much.