Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on May 31, 2017, in Nuremberg:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

4 June 2017 · General Assembly of the German Association of Cities · Nuremberg, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the General Assembly of the German Association of Cities on May 31, 2017, in Nuremberg, discussing municipal governance and federal priorities.
Main themes
Subsidiarity and federalism, municipal governance, digitalization of public services, European Union and Brexit, refugee and migration challenges, climate change, fight against terrorism, human rights, federal-state financial relations, Nuremberg's historical significance, citizen engagement, international criminal law
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,366
80th percentile
Sentences
185
87th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%31%
  • Social 26%23%
  • Economic 17%15%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 11%

185 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

The federal government, the states, and the municipalities each take care of the issues that are best resolved at their level. We call this lived subsidiarity in Germany. This is the core of our federal system. That is why I am of course happy to be here with you today, because you are, by definition, very close to the people. When I say "you," I mean the representatives of the German cities and, of course, the representatives of the other municipal umbrella organizations, whom I welcome just as warmly as the colleagues from the German Bundestag who are closely connected to the municipalities.

It is very important that we remain in conversation. That is why I – as Ms. Lohse has already mentioned – quickly stated in the challenging situation when many refugees came to us that we need direct contact with the municipalities, fully aware that according to the Basic Law, the states are responsible for the municipalities. Nevertheless, there are situations in which the exchange of information must happen quickly.

In light of the many interdependencies, as one might say, we repeatedly have to answer the question of who is responsible for what, and we pay close attention to that. But, to be honest, the citizens do not really care about that. They want to know how things work. I have often said that I hold municipal politics in high regard, especially because one cannot escape local issues; one is confronted with local concerns every day. That is the big difference. I come by every few years, except for the city where I live. But for you, the debates start in the morning at the bakery and end in the evening at the pub, and they are also held in various places in between. That is what characterizes municipal responsibility. Sometimes you also sit in the office. In any case, you simply have a lot of contact with citizens. That is what I wanted to say.

I know that you also follow federal politics very closely – what we do in Berlin, not only with regard to your municipal challenges but also, for example, with regard to the European Union. That is why I would like to begin by reminding you once again that we commemorated the signing of the Treaty of Rome 60 years ago in the spring. We are aware of the great value that the European Union brings us. We live in peace, prosperity, and stability. That is why it must have affected you just as much as us in Berlin that the decision was made in Great Britain to leave the European Union. We will, of course, conduct the separation negotiations in the spirit that Great Britain remains a good partner.

But we must also ensure that Europe strengthens its strengths and that we are not only occupied with the exit negotiations of Great Britain but also with the issues that can be better resolved at the European level than at the national level. There is no shortage of common challenges – let us think of climate change, let us think of the digital internal market, let us think of the fight against terrorism, which I had to address today due to current events. Let us think of the challenge of flight and migration.

I say this also because we are here in a city that is very much shaped by history and because, as for the whole Federal Republic of Germany, the founding of the European Union meant the opening of a new chapter in history. The Nuremberg Trials took place here after World War II. The Nuremberg Trials and the Nuremberg Principles became cornerstones of modern international criminal law. The fact that the Franconian metropolis today maintains good partnerships with 14 cities worldwide, that there is a Street of Human Rights, that there is the International Nuremberg Human Rights Award – all of this speaks to how life has changed. I believe it is always worth remembering and being grateful for the treasure we hold in our hands, which must also be further developed from generation to generation.

Of course, today you will not only walk in the footsteps of history when you undertake excursions on site, but you will also deal with the wide range of practical municipal challenges using the example of Nuremberg. I believe the mayor can show you some things that the city has to offer. But perhaps you will also find things that are even better in your own cities. In any case, I am pleased that you are approaching the matter practically. We are meeting here at a time when incredible changes are taking place.

I would like to begin with digital changes and challenges. Tomorrow, we will decide on the reorganization of federal-state financial relations in the German Bundestag and on Friday in the Bundesrat. I hope everything goes well. Part of the amendment to the Basic Law could be of great significance for the people in Germany, as it concerns the willingness of the federal and state governments to cooperate when it comes to the establishment of citizen portals. The majority of citizens' interactions with their state naturally take place at the municipal level. That is why we will need to have intensive discussions with the municipal umbrella organizations in the next legislative period about how we design these citizen portals so that citizens then have a uniform access to all state services. I am also quite aware that this will likely be a financial challenge. We will, of course, need to discuss that as well, because in terms of administration and digitization, we are at best in the lower midfield compared to other countries. We are not at the forefront. Therefore, I simply ask that we approach this topic openly and intensively.

I see the head of the Federal Employment Agency here. This also reminds me of the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees and the new president, Ms. Cordt. I just want to say that at the moment we have a preference for refugees in administrative practice because refugees are recorded in a unified core data system and because the data is available across all levels from the immigration authorities to the central office. I am waiting for the day when citizens say: We also do not want to provide everything a hundred times; you have our data once or twice, that should be enough. So, there is still a lot of work ahead of us.

In connection with digitization, we are, of course, also responsible for providing the infrastructure. I believe that broadband connectivity is part of the public service for citizens. For this reason, we must connect rural areas just as well as urban areas. At the German Association of Cities, this may not be the central topic, as cities are usually already well connected. But we have in the Basic Law "the establishment of equivalent living conditions in the federal territory." This means we must support rural regions – also so that cities are not completely overwhelmed when the influx into cities continues to rise as rural areas become less attractive as living spaces. This is, of course, interconnected.

We will achieve our goal by 2018: to provide every household with at least 50 megabits per second. But it is becoming clear that this will not be enough. We need connections for industrial areas, we need connections for schools, we also need connections for the administration – and we must enter the gigabit age. We need a uniform, preferably also European uniform 5G technology. There will be another auction of frequencies, from which we will receive funds that we can then use to better develop rural areas. We have a large discussion about free Wi-Fi and free access to Wi-Fi in as many German cities as possible. This is, of course, also a location factor. We have struggled with this for a long time and had to make further improvements. But I believe we have also made some progress here.

Of course, entire professions and habits are also changing due to digitization. You all know about the changes in the retail sector. We have around three million employees in retail, who are facing completely new challenges. For example, next year the new training occupation of merchant in e-commerce will be introduced. You can see from this that the job profiles are changing significantly.

I believe we are on the right track when we have an "Interministerial Working Group on Sustainable Urban Development" that asks how the changing situations in cities are manifesting. And I believe I can say that this work is functioning very well. I would also like to thank the municipal umbrella organizations for their intensive collaboration and for sharing the fundamental idea of development in a sustainable sense. We could not realize much in climate protection and with strategies for efficient resource use without so many municipalities working alongside us.

One issue we have repeatedly discussed in connection with the many refugees who have come to us is the topic of housing. In many central, inner-city residential areas, housing is scarce. This has consequences not only for construction prices and rents but also for cultural and social structures. For this reason, the federal government has placed special emphasis on the topic of housing construction and urban development. We have established the "Alliance for Affordable Housing and Construction" and decided on a housing construction offensive with various focal points. I was also pleased to see the head of the Federal Agency for Real Estate Tasks here. This indicates that today you are also discussing land issues. We want to make land available from public hands at reduced prices. Yes, I know that this is not always ideal. I am aware of the discussion. But I hope it has improved a bit; right? Good, so you can clarify the rest with Mr. Gehb.

We are also strengthening social housing construction. We have tripled the funds for this to currently 1.5 billion euros annually. Nevertheless, in connection with social housing construction, we also have conflicting or opposing tendencies. We have had intensive discussions in the coalition about new building regulations, particularly regarding thermal insulation. Such regulations make the creation of social housing more difficult. So we need to find a balance.

This year, we have made another 790 million euros available for urban development funding. We have improved legal requirements, facilitated the densification of residential areas, simplified the planning of construction projects, and introduced the new building area category "Urban Area" for this purpose. All of this must, of course, be done in cooperation with the states. I am also aware of the complex discussions you have to endure. It is well known that I was in Trudering on Sunday. I am not mentioning this because of the speech I gave there, but because this visit also made me deal with the conflicts in such an urban area. On one side, there are those who have lived there for a long time and are happy about every piece of green land that still exists. On the other side, there are those who want an influx and then higher buildings and a denser residential area. This conflict must be endured and resolved. So, I mean, on paper, it can be done nicely – urban development area; bam, done. But when it has to be implemented on the ground, it also requires a great deal of skill to ensure that it meets with acceptance.

In this legislative period, we will likely complete more than one million new apartments. But when one thinks solely of the number of refugees who have come to us and then also knows that part of our open positions can only be filled by quite a few people from European countries working in our labor market, one also realizes how unevenly housing conditions are distributed. My constituency in Vorpommern suffers more from people moving away. In Germany, we have completely different conditions. In some regions, classes are empty and schools must be closed, while in other regions, classes are full. These disparities are quite difficult to balance. This cannot be solved quickly. But I would say that the highly regarded Königstein key is only partially suitable for leading directly to the equivalence of living conditions in Germany.

We had, so to speak, a valve for housing costs. With the assumption of housing costs, we were able to draw the conclusion from the necessity that municipalities with a large number of socially disadvantaged people should be particularly supported. However, we have also reached a point where we could essentially act as a federal administrative authority, which we as the federal government do not want, because we believe that local responsibility suffers somewhat, which we urgently need, as you naturally have local knowledge. We essentially need distribution mechanisms that clarify need and necessity.

Your budget situation, on the whole, is good: a surplus of 5.4 billion euros. But I learned from Mr. Ude: It does little good if there is a decent average temperature, but one has a deep freezer and the other a hot oven. I have kept that in mind; it immediately made sense to me. When you see the discussions we are having about how the funds from the Federal Municipal Investment Promotion Fund, twice 3.5 billion euros, are distributed for the renovation of schools or for municipal infrastructures, you see the difficulty, because even among those who are financially weaker and could actually use allowances, the circumstances are completely different. In North Rhine-Westphalia, we have treasury loans, I believe in Rhineland-Palatinate as well, but in many other federal states, they do not exist. So suddenly those who have the option of treasury loans receive money, while others who may have saved a lot and do not have such options receive nothing. So there is a fierce struggle. What are the criteria? Perhaps we can talk to the states again about not always distributing everything according to the Königstein key, because that ultimately increases the differences rather than bringing us closer together, which I believe you also want. If the municipal umbrella organizations could work constructively on this, it would be very, very important from my perspective.

We have restructured the federal-state financial relationship. That was a Herculean task, to put it very cautiously. The agreement of the states was possible because the federal government took on more responsibility. We were happy to do that. But I also say, we only do it gladly if, in the end, something from the federal funds actually reaches the municipalities. I do not want to make excuses here and criticize the states in their absence. But I want to – especially since many representatives in the state parliaments also sit in district councils or city councils – at least say that significant knowledge is needed to understand the web of how anything that arrives at the state is passed on to the municipalities. Because the financial equalization and the financial flows from the state to the municipalities, the levies, and so on are so complicated that even in times of digitization, it is not easy to find out exactly what arrives where and to what extent the states are comparable.

I believe the German Association of Cities has already tried to provide some answers to the probing questions of the Budget Committee. I simply ask you for complete transparency. It is indeed an intellectually exciting task to find out how this works. I am also not yet completely through with Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, but I am still working on it. However, I am one hundred percent sure that there are still twelve other methods to calculate all of this. Therefore, it is often very disappointing for us as members of the Bundestag when, for example, five billion euros are provided by the federal government in connection with the reorganization of integration assistance, but when you then ask in a city what has arrived from that, and then add everything up over the cities, you end up with the impression that five billion euros have not come out of it.

Increased transparency is necessary. We need to be able to explain to citizens how the financial mechanisms work and according to what pattern they function, because otherwise, we as members of the Bundestag also become unbelievable. We tell how much money should be somewhere, but in total, it simply is not there. When we also consider what arrives in the richer cities and in the poorer cities according to the distribution mechanisms, we must also ask whether that is appropriate. So, we have huge problems there.

I say this also because – we have seen this in various elections – the acceptance of citizens is being queried in a much more individualized manner in times of digitization. In the past, there was so to speak one size fits all, and then it was somehow accepted. Today, as people receive tailored offers in everything and anything over the internet – from ordering muesli to ordering cars and individual selection of all possible consumer goods – politics is also expected to provide professional and appropriate offers tailored to each individual life situation. This cannot be reversed. It is not possible to convince with just one motto, four guiding principles, or five points in a nationwide election campaign or in nationwide arguments. People live locally, are proud of the differences from other regions in Germany, and want responses tailored to their respective living environment. Dealing with this has something to do with overall political acceptance. So, we have a lot to do in this regard in the coming years.

I know that you have a great need for investment and that we must ensure that investment opportunities are also available. We cannot do this all alone. You also have a time now when you have more tax revenues than less. And I say, when I see what we have been able to do additionally at the federal level with that, then something must have arrived at the municipalities as well. So, it cannot all have been lost. But we cannot assume that this will remain the case; harder times may come again. The better it would be if we had reasonable mechanisms for how we distribute things.

In conclusion, I want to thank you. I want to thank you for what you do every day. But I also want to thank you for bravely tackling the challenge we faced in 2015. You had practical tasks to solve on the ground. I know that you had sleepless nights. I know that you had people in your administrations who had to work to the brink of their capacity or perhaps beyond. I know that you have encouraged an incredible number of volunteers through your actions. Only in this way has it been possible to manage this enormous challenge to some extent. We know that now, as fewer refugees come to us, the task is certainly not over. I believe Ms. Lohse also said that we need a long breath on the issue of integration. The worst thing now would be to simply forget things and return to business as usual.

For this reason, I not only respect your wish to know how finances will continue after 2018, but we will also have to talk about this immediately after the Bundestag election when preparing the budget for 2018. To do this now before the election would be reckless. In the end, you could gain nothing from it, because we do not know the majorities that will determine the budget. But I tell you, as soon as I have something to say, I will. I have to say that. Tomorrow Mr. Gabriel will be here; and he will say how he can promise you something. So, he can only promise something like I can promise. But in any case, we are aware that integration requires a long breath.

Thank you for your work – I say this with full conviction. Have a good conference, all the best, and here’s to good cooperation.