Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the anniversary event "30 Years of Co-Determination Law" of the Hans Böckler Foundation on August 30, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

31 August 2006 · 30 Years of Co-Determination Law anniversary event of the Hans Böckler Foundation · Hans Böckler Foundation, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Hans Böckler Foundation anniversary event in Berlin on August 30, 2006, marking 30 years of Germany's Co-Determination Act.
Main themes
Co-determination law, social market economy, history of German co-determination, trade union relations, works councils, supervisory board participation, social partnership, Weimar Republic labor rights, post-war West Germany, Hans Böckler Foundation, Konrad Adenauer legacy, Biedenkopf Commission
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,094
86th percentile
Sentences
234
92nd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
45th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 60%59%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

234 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Sommer,

ladies and gentlemen!

I am pleased to accept the invitation to deliver the keynote address on the occasion of the event celebrating the 30th anniversary of the Co-Determination Act. Co-determination – and I want to emphasize this at the outset – is an essential element of the social market economy. 30 years of the Co-Determination Act is therefore a proud number. Before we talk about 100 years, perhaps we should first focus on the 50 years. But one can always think beyond the day. 30 years of the Co-Determination Act is truly a reason for a grand celebration, as is being held here today at the Hans Böckler Foundation.

To begin, I would like to take a brief look back and recap the history of co-determination in Germany in a sort of time-lapse. There were already early beginnings of co-determination in the 19th century. Interestingly, they were viewed quite critically by the trade unions at that time. They seemed to fear a bit that co-determination might have been conceived as a deliberately created competition to their own organizations. This was actually an interesting line of thought. I would not say that this can still be found today between works councils and trade unions, but it was interesting.

However, this attitude changed completely after the First World War. Now the trade unions abandoned their reservations against separate workplace representation bodies. The Weimar Constitution provided for a right of employees to participate equally in certain areas, such as the regulation of wages and working conditions. The participation of employee representatives on supervisory boards also dates back to the Weimar Republic.

After the Second World War, the idea of social partnership gained a completely new significance in West Germany. Both employees and employers advocated for a legally enshrined co-determination of employees in companies after the horrific experiences of the Nazi dictatorship. After two years of discussion – Mr. Sommer just pointed this out – the Federal Government under the responsibility of Konrad Adenauer decided in 1951 on the parity co-determination of employees on the supervisory board in mining companies. This decision also stemmed from a resolution – as has just been mentioned; and since we are here today at the Hans Böckler Foundation, we should remember – of two great men, namely Konrad Adenauer and Hans Böckler. This was truly a demonstration of political wisdom, as I can only say in retrospect.

In his first government statement on September 20, 1949, Konrad Adenauer made clear the great importance of a – I quote – "reasonable social balance of social contradictions" for Germany's success. When one considers that this was mentioned in the first government statement during the founding period of the Federal Republic of Germany, these words were truly groundbreaking. They came, as one must sometimes remind today, from the mouth of a Christian Democrat. Much of the pessimism that is currently being expressed can be revised at such points.

A year later, the Adenauer government passed the Works Constitution Act. In addition to workplace co-determination, a key component was a one-third participation of employees on the supervisory boards of public limited companies outside the mining sector. – Just think of all that already existed in the Federal Republic!

In 1968, the government of Chancellor Kiesinger established a commission – the Grand Coalition has also been mentioned – which was to present a proposal for the reform of corporate co-determination within two years, and it did so. The chairman at that time was Kurt Biedenkopf. I am very pleased that Kurt Biedenkopf is not only present today but has also not completely relinquished the topic of co-determination. I will return to this later. We can say without exaggeration: Dear Kurt Biedenkopf, your commitment ultimately led to us achieving a result. This would not have been conceivable without your engagement. For that, a heartfelt thank you!

Those who were also involved will remember – we younger ones are certainly told this repeatedly – that there was hardly a topic that was debated with such passion, even within the Christian Democratic Union. The report of the Biedenkopf Commission then formed the basis for the Co-Determination Act of 1976, whose anniversary we are now also celebrating. One can say that the name Biedenkopf stands for quality, as his commission succeeded in uniting opposing positions at the parliamentary level. With only 22 votes against, the law was passed in the German Bundestag. It was the result of what was likely a very exciting legislative process. Lively criticism was part of it, as were intense controversies. From the cabinet decision to the adoption, it took over two years. I almost feel like having the newspaper reports from those two years brought back to me.

But that was just the beginning, because as great as the agreement was on the part of the parliamentarians, so great was the dissatisfaction on the part of the trade unions and employers. This led to the then DGB chairman Heinz Oskar Vetter being quoted as saying that he viewed the law as – I quote – "the greatest disappointment of his term." True equality had not been achieved, and the employee side on the supervisory board was, among other things, factually underrepresented due to the double voting right of the supervisory board chairman. Mr. Sommer has pointed out in a somewhat more polite manner that this was not the idea of the trade unions.

The other side, namely the employers, took the matter to the Federal Constitutional Court. The employers saw the foundations of a free economic order endangered by the law. The reaction followed swiftly, as the trade unions announced their withdrawal from the concerted action. This had already existed only on paper.

So there were indeed lively debates. Thus, the very law that was supposed to reconcile capital and labor initially led to a low point in the relationship between the social partners that was hardly thought possible. This continued until 1979. The Federal Constitutional Court confirmed, on the one hand, the constitutionality of the law in full, while on the other hand, it rejected further participation demands aimed at full parity between employees and employers. After that, as is sometimes the case with major political decisions, there was, to put it casually, 20 years of calm. Things developed reasonably further. It may also be an example of the necessity of courageous parliamentary decisions. So, in fact, the members of the Bundestag from that time deserve a small word of thanks.

However, since the late 1990s, corporate co-determination has once again become the subject of scientific and political controversies as well as various reform proposals. A new commission was established under Chancellor Gerhard Schröder. The new federal government has very consciously renewed this mandate. The aim is to develop proposals for the modernization of corporate co-determination. I can only say that grand coalitions are obviously predisposed to deal with this issue. The leadership of the new commission is again in the hands of Kurt Biedenkopf.

I hope – I could say that I actually expect it – that we will achieve results and that we will succeed in overcoming the divides that are, of course, present. I say this very seriously. A failure and no result from this commission would not be a good contribution to political work. In this respect, we will wait with anticipation and where support is needed, we will provide it. I also know that it is not an easy task.

The Hans Böckler Foundation and the German Trade Union Confederation have themed today's anniversary event "More Democracy in the Economy." They are addressing what I consider to be a central aspect, as it has always shaped the entire co-determination discussion. Article 14 of the Basic Law shows us the entire tension field of the topic of co-determination. For it is stipulated there that employee co-determination can only go as far as the rights of the owners are not undermined. So far this article. But in the concrete implementation, difficulties arise. The entire discussion in the 1970s took place exactly between these two poles. I believe we can say that today the discussion is once again taking place in this tension field.

But despite all the criticism – and I want to emphasize this here – we can say that there is hardly anyone in Germany who fundamentally questions workplace and corporate co-determination. I consider this to be correct. I say: I belong to those who do not question this but regard it as a great achievement.

Thus, it can be said that co-determination is an indispensable part of our social market economy, which has proven itself in Germany. I also recommend to the critics that they occasionally keep in mind the advantages, especially of workplace co-determination, as they may be more visible in daily life.

I will mention just a few key points:

First:

The participation of employees in corporate decisions naturally contributes to employees identifying more strongly with these decisions. This is, of course, a contribution to the motivation and commitment of employees and promotes the economic success of the company.

Second:

In recent years – and I want to take a special look at German unity – employees naturally endure painful and structurally unavoidable cuts more readily when they are involved in the decision-making process. This was the case during German unity in many places in the new federal states. This was, of course, also the case in the old federal states and throughout Germany in light of globalization.

Third:

Co-determination also promotes the responsibility of employees for their company, as employees and trade unions on the supervisory boards, just like the employers, must keep an eye on the long-term development. One cannot only focus on the day, but participation in the supervisory board simply requires seeing the long term.

Fourth:

Another advantage, especially of workplace co-determination, is that conflicts are ideally resolved through dialogue and joint decision-making. Accordingly, no industrial action can be taken in matters of co-determination. In a European comparison, Germany therefore has among the fewest strike days. I believe one can rightly assert that this is a consequence of co-determination.

What social peace means as a location factor has also become clear in many corporate decisions. Perhaps it is not always discussed when it comes to the advantages of the location Germany. But I am quite sure that it is taken into account when considering where to go. It is precisely the wonderful aspect of the social market economy that it is always designed to bridge conflicts through dialogue and joint decision-making. We must definitely preserve this ability in Germany.

However, all those who now bear responsibility must not – and they do not – walk through the country with blinders on. We do not close our eyes to the criticism that is sometimes directed at co-determination by companies, even on a day like today. I will also mention a few key points here. I believe this is part of it. The discussion is ongoing.

Some employers find the procedures too bureaucratic, time-consuming, and costly, and the legal systems too inflexible. Some find the supervisory boards too large. The appointment of often external individuals leads, from their perspective, to decisions that are often irrelevant. There is much to be said about this. But I do not subscribe to this, as I will now name the points of criticism.

Co-determination comes under discussion particularly when supervisory boards have been unable to prevent poor decisions in companies. This must also be seen. Through their participation in the supervisory boards, employee representatives naturally take on a great responsibility.

From these points of criticism, in my view, something very sensible has developed, namely a discussion about good corporate governance. This led in 2002 to the creation of the German Corporate Governance Code. This contains internationally and nationally recognized standards for good and responsible corporate governance and places a particular emphasis on the work of the supervisory board. I, for my part, appeal to all those responsible to ensure that the code is implemented seriously and comprehensively.

I advocate for not simply dismissing these and other criticisms on a festive day like today, but rather for seriously weighing them, always keeping in mind the principle of a positive attitude towards co-determination as a whole. Co-determination is and remains – I want to reiterate this point – an important part of the social market economy. On this basis, and this must be clear as a starting point, all further discussions must be conducted.

I believe that discussions can indeed be held on this basis, as the German model faces significant challenges. As is the case in many areas, it is my conviction that only those who are willing to change will preserve the substance of what is valuable and important to all of us. Only in this way can we secure the participation of employees in corporate governance in the international context.

I do not believe that this celebration is the right setting – at least not in the morning; in the afternoon, there will be a very detailed discussion, which I think is very good – to go into too much detail. However, I would like to mention a few points.

I currently see German corporate co-determination under pressure from several directions. On the one hand, the already mentioned discussion about the German Corporate Governance Code has revealed the lack of control options through supervisory boards. I am explicitly pleased that there is a willingness on the part of the unions to discuss the size and composition of supervisory boards. We expect proposals – let’s see if that will happen – on how to increase the independence of the supervisory board, strengthen its competence, and improve its ability to work.

Another point – and this is probably the more difficult one – is globalization and the integration of Europe. This is, of course, a factor that has implications for our national regulations on corporate co-determination. The creation of a European internal market raises, in my firm conviction, a large number of problems anyway. The interface between social and economic concerns, if it can even be defined in a social market economy, is still very imperfectly resolved in the European internal market. I see this particularly in light of what is not even being discussed here today, namely social security systems and similar matters.

I also recommend that we engage in a very fundamental discussion here – and I am always ready to do so – because the question of where the elements of competition begin and where the protection zones are is, in my view, not fully answered in the jurisprudence of the European Court of Justice, and this dividing line should not be left to the European Court of Justice for definition. We, as politically and socially responsible individuals, should intervene here and truly retain the authority of definition in politics. We are in a complicated situation here.

But back to co-determination. In the European Union, co-determination, the responsibility of employees, is regulated very differently. The German model has a special status. It has not been adopted by any other country. About half of the old 15 member states have some form of employee co-determination. In other EU countries, it is virtually unknown. Among the newly joined member states, the picture is mixed. There is still much in development. But not only in Europe is co-determination unevenly developed: German corporate law also uses a dualistic model of management board and supervisory board. Many of our neighbors, on the other hand, prefer a model with a single administrative board. The parity representation of the supervisory board according to the Co-Determination Act is tailored to the dualistic system of corporate management. I believe this is undisputed. It presupposes the separation between the management board and the supervisory board with clearly defined competencies. It is evident that this cannot simply be adopted in a monistic system, as is the case in other countries.

In addition, the European Court of Justice has granted a very high priority to the freedom of establishment in several rulings. This is, by the way, one of those cases where I see that facts are simply being established through jurisprudence. Therefore, it is already observable today that companies are establishing themselves in Germany using a foreign legal form without applying the German co-determination rules. For example, in Germany in 2005, every seventh newly founded limited liability company was registered in the form of a British "limited." This must also be seen as a development that cannot simply be overlooked.

I describe all of this to highlight the dual challenge we face in Europe. On the one hand, we want to preserve German co-determination. On the other hand, we want to ensure that German companies do not face disadvantages in mergers due to the co-determination regulations in place here. Finally, we want to avoid – this must be our common concern – that companies, when in doubt, do not choose Germany as their country of establishment but instead opt for neighboring countries. This not only costs us tax revenues, but we can also lose jobs as a result. We cannot simply allow this to happen passively. I am very pro-Europe. I also believe that we should boldly shape globalization. But for people who have been elected to political responsibility by the citizens of this country, the charitable reasons for others play a lesser role; rather, it is primarily about the well-being of our country. That must be our standard.

I do not want to say that it is akin to squaring the circle to bring all of this together. But it is a pretty dramatic and almost Herculean task. I want to remind you that we have already incorporated two European regulations into German law. The federal government has also clearly influenced these each time, as they also touched on the German system of co-determination. These are the Directive on the European Company and the Directive on the Cross-Border Merger of Limited Liability Companies.

The instrument of the co-determination agreement is the answer we have found to the question of how to design co-determination in a future-oriented manner in light of these directives. The participation of employees in these cross-border cases is primarily shaped through negotiations between employers and employees. It must be said that we are dealing here with a novelty in the history of German co-determination culture.

The opening of such negotiations suddenly creates enormous flexibility. One could also say that a wide field remains unfilled. It takes into account the different co-determination cultures in the member states. It can address the very specific situation in individual companies. Here lie the positive opportunities for the modern development of co-determination.

In the event of the negotiations failing, there is a fallback solution, namely the continued application of co-determination at the highest level. This is, of course, something that is also a very specific regulation that is not unimportant for Germany. This regulation initially faced significant criticism. Even its compatibility with the Basic Law was called into question. In a monistic system, certain constellations are conceivable in which the owners could find themselves in a minority position on the administrative board. Whether there is really a need for action here – I say this calmly – will be shown by practice. One should not engage in the most extreme theoretical discussion but simply accept the instrument.

Companies are now beginning to take advantage of the opportunities presented by the negotiation solution. This is evidenced, for example, by the approved merger of the Italian RAS with the German Allianz and the transformation of the group into a European company. This will be discussed again this afternoon on one of the "thematic islands," as it is beautifully called, according to the program. I do not know who the sea around it is, but I wish for successful discussions on this "thematic island."

As an important missing building block for the redesign of European corporate and co-determination law, the adoption of the seat transfer directive is still pending. It is being pushed forward by the Finnish EU presidency. I do not want to say that it is quickly approaching the German presidency. Perhaps the Finns will finish it.

Through cross-border seat transfers to another member state, employee co-determination must not be lost against their will. Therefore, the federal government advocates that negotiations on co-determination should always take place here when the law of the new country of establishment does not guarantee the same level of co-determination that existed in the company before its transfer.

With this, we are right in the midst of the tasks ahead of us. It is a goal of the federal government to secure and shape the participation rights of employees at the European level. We have explicitly anchored this in the coalition agreement. Co-determination must face the described challenges of internationalization and the internal market. We must jointly seek ways to design co-determination so that it can unfold its positive effects and remain competitive internationally.

Therefore, we eagerly await proposals for a modern, but also European-compatible further development of German corporate co-determination. The position is nice that we can wait. But I also believe that it will not be possible without changes, but that the task shows that there is a need for change. It is about making our co-determination systems more flexible and thus future-proof. Perhaps the path we have taken at the European level is an approach we could live with.

We should not shy away from achieving an internationalization of supervisory boards, which I consider essential for cross-border German companies. With increasingly global companies, it is certainly worth examining whether foreign employees should also be given the opportunity to participate in the supervisory board. Completely new things are coming our way. When one considers that at Siemens, of 460,000 employees, only about a third are German employees, but only German employee representatives sit on the supervisory board, then that is a fact that cannot simply be overlooked.

On the other hand, we are of course concerned that the needs and interests of the German location – I return to our obligation – are not neglected. I believe that the connection to the country in which one has grown as a company is a virtue and not a business folly. This too must sometimes be said in these times.

In this festive speech, I have it relatively easy because I can always refer to the Commission and only need to ask questions. These are questions particularly regarding the negotiation model. Should open-ended negotiations be possible? What line do fallback regulations take? Who is the negotiating partner on the employee side? What legal character should an agreement have? These are all things you should engage with – and you are relatively numerous here today. But I say again that it would not be a good sign if the result of the Commission were a multitude of proposals, none of which finds approval. This would present politics with a rather complicated task. Inaction – I say it again – could cost us dearly later.

Therefore, let us work together to further develop German corporate co-determination so that in another 30 years – I do not want to go as far as you – we can experience a similarly beautiful event and say: We have recognized the signs of the times. We have done the right thing in a time of change based on what we have successfully achieved in 30 years and thus – and I say this in the presence of the International Trade Union Confederation – also contributed to shaping the international economic order in a socially acceptable manner. Globalization will challenge us to provide answers on how we can incorporate what has functioned nationally as a social market economy, what we can still shape somewhat together at the European level – but difficulties are already emerging here – into the ideas of a humane global economy.

The greatest danger I see today is the danger that people no longer have the impression that politics and organizations can shape economic processes. But if we remember that the starting point of all these regulations – and this is wonderfully enshrined in our Basic Law – is ultimately the dignity of each individual person, then it is also our mandate to shape globalization in a humane way. In this regard, I ask for your cooperation and thank you for the commitment you show.