Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Annual Congress of the Federal Association of Energy and Water Industries (BDEW) on June 12, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 June 2013 · Annual Congress of the Federal Association of Energy and Water Industries (BDEW) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the BDEW Annual Congress in Berlin on June 12, 2013, speaking on Germany's energy transition, water supply regulation, and ongoing flood emergency response.
Main themes
Energy transition, renewable energy expansion, EU Concessions Directive, water supply management, nuclear phase-out, Renewable Energy Sources Act, municipal self-administration, flood emergency response, European procurement law, energy market reform, solidarity in crisis
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,250
79th percentile
Sentences
172
85th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.5
38th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%31%
  • Economic 28%28%
  • Environmental 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

172 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Woste,

dear Hildegard Müller,

dear colleagues from various parliaments,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen,

I truly did not want to miss the opportunity to be at your congress this year, after I had to decline last year. I also thank you for your flexibility in adjusting your program, as I will be traveling to Schleswig-Holstein and Lower Saxony afterwards. I will gladly convey greetings to the emergency services, local politicians, and utility companies who are currently working day and night in large parts of Germany. We are experiencing a major flood wave that affects many, many people. As the Minister-President of Saxony-Anhalt said today, there are currently 40,000 people in emergency shelters. However, we are also witnessing a great wave of solidarity. Especially in substations, where local energy supply is at stake, outstanding work is being done. I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to all those involved. I am also happy to convey your good wishes during my visits today.

Before I address the energy transition, I would like to say a few things about water management, as there is also a European discussion underway here. The so-called EU Concessions Directive is stirring emotions. When one considers how central water is as a resource, this is understandable. However, I believe we need to look closely now: What is up for discussion and what is not? The EU Concessions Directive is not about privatizing water supply. Such an obligation is explicitly not provided for in the EU texts. It is also not about the quality of water. Quality is and remains regulated by the state. Procurement procedures cannot change quality aspects.

The aim of the directive is rather to ensure more transparency and legal certainty in concession awards. This objective does not come out of nowhere. In recent years, there have already been a number of court decisions at both the European and national levels. This has not made the legal situation regarding concession awards any clearer – on the contrary: it has made it more confusing. Therefore, a uniform text is intended to consolidate the relevant regulations and thus make the work easier for companies and public procurement authorities. In this respect, the goal is to be welcomed.

Against this background, we also say: Simply exempting water supply from this would not be appropriate. However, we advocate for preserving the specific and proven structures of water supply in Germany. These must be taken into account in the work on the Concessions Directive. We have had extensive discussions with the Commission and with our colleagues in the European Parliament on this matter.

In Germany, organizing water supply is the responsibility of the self-administration of municipalities. There are cities and municipalities that successfully collaborate in this regard. This must also remain possible in the future. This is precisely the point we have been working on as a federal government. With all the caution that must always be exercised before everything is finalized – to stay in the language of water – the signals from Brussels give us confidence. We are also engaged in an intensive dialogue across party lines with our colleagues in the European Parliament. I believe we can find a solution that is acceptable to all parties involved.

I thank the BDEW for contributing its expertise to this process. This has been very helpful to us as a federal government. Therefore, I would like to acknowledge this here explicitly.

This exemplifies that the Federal Association BDEW, which is not yet a long-established federal association, is always in tune with the times and keeps an eye on the important issues. Your motto for the annual congress – "Markets and Systems in Transition" – also indicates what is on the agenda in the supply sectors. Of course, the topic of energy transition is a central issue. Transition and new beginnings, but also some uncertainty and ambiguity currently characterize the mood in the energy sector.

It is true, Mr. Woste: This legislative period is significant. However, we have essentially returned to a decision-making situation that we have had for some time. This means we want to phase out nuclear energy by 2022. The fact that we have agreed on this across party lines is a good foundation for joint work. This was achieved in light of the reactor disaster in Fukushima. We are now also striving to clarify the issues surrounding final storage together. That would also be a very important step.

But what occupies us at the moment is less the foreseeable exit from nuclear energy. While that is also a concern, what primarily occupies us now is the very rapid expansion of renewable energies. The Renewable Energy Sources Act, with its priority for feed-in, has essentially led to a great success story regarding the extent of the expansion of renewable energies, but it has also created huge problems for the system that have not yet been solved – I will come back to that shortly.

If we want to successfully complete the energy transition, we must also place energy efficiency at the top of the agenda. The more efficient our structures are, the less energy we need, the easier it is to address certain issues of supply security, affordability, and environmental friendliness. I must say: It is disappointing that we have not succeeded in launching a building renovation program that also allows for tax incentives. I know that you, together with environmental associations, business associations, and many others like consumer protection groups, have advocated strongly for this. However, the federal states have not been convinced that the loss of tax revenue from the orders that would have been generated would have been compensated by the additional VAT revenue. Therefore, the federal government had to act alone. We have done this with a new grant program with a total volume of 2.4 billion euros. That is also valuable, but the other route would have been even more successful. If representatives of other parties are here with you, perhaps a gentle reminder could be given that we could achieve much more in this area.

It shows that we can do something in the field of efficiency technologies that advances the German economic location. Germany is already a leader in many market areas regarding building materials and efficiency technologies. Of course, energy efficiency is also closely related to climate protection. In 2012, Germany had 25.5 percent fewer greenhouse gas emissions than in 1990. Thus, we exceeded our Kyoto target of 21 percent. We want to continue on this path. The mere fact that the share of renewable energies in energy supply has risen sharply is a contribution to climate protection. Nevertheless, we must also keep in mind the unity of the three concepts of supply security, affordability, and environmental friendliness in the entire area of energy supply. Since the decision on the energy transition, we have achieved quite a bit, but crucial building blocks are still missing.

What I would like to emphasize is that we, together with the Minister-Presidents, have found a working structure, namely two special conferences of Minister-Presidents with the federal government per year, where we discuss the next steps. This has brought us much closer to what constitutes a strategic joint approach. Because several of the questions cannot be decided by the federal government alone; some questions cannot be decided at all. Therefore, it is very important that the federal and state governments work very closely together in this regard.

However, the states have very different interests. There are states that are located more to the north, which are at the forefront regarding the expansion of renewable energies because they can produce renewable energies most efficiently – especially in the wind sector. And there are southern German states that host large industrial structures, for whom the issue of supply security is of utmost importance.

What we must achieve in the coming years is to advance the expansion of renewable energies to reach our long-term goals, but also to better harmonize this with the expansion of the grid. Furthermore, the issue of supply security means that capacity management is gaining significant importance. Achieving all of this under the overarching concept of affordability is a considerable challenge – especially in an international environment where natural gas prices in the United States are currently about half as high as in Europe due to fracking. This is also a motivation for me to say: We must fit our national energy policy even better into a European energy policy.

At the European Council a few weeks ago, we discussed for the first time, based on the Commission's proposals, how we can complete the internal energy market in Europe. In the medium term, we will certainly also move towards more coordination in the promotion of renewable energies in Europe. The Commission – I think this is good news – will now examine very intensively to what extent subsidy criteria apply in the individual member states – especially regarding industrial electricity prices. I have the impression that our German Commissioner is also very keen to ensure that not only individual countries are scrutinized – against Germany, there is currently a procedure regarding network charges and levies – but all of them. We are also pushing for this.

Regarding the Renewable Energy Sources Act, we as a federal government have proposed an amendment. The Federal Minister for the Environment has faced a lot of criticism, although everyone actually says: Of course, we need an amendment to the Renewable Energy Sources Act. In the discussion, we have come to the conviction that we should avoid retroactive contributions. This is a difficult decision, as the EEG levy is already 18 billion euros today. However, the uncertainty of those affected when interventions are made retroactively is so high that we have decided not to revisit this part of the EEG amendment. This has also been discussed with the states. However, the necessity to change something in the EEG remains.

Fortunately, we have built a cap into the funding for solar energy, specifically for photovoltaics. This cap is set at 50 gigawatts. We will likely end the year at around 30 gigawatts. You all here in the room know that we need to have between 60 gigawatts and 70 gigawatts available in Germany on normal days. If we now add the 25 gigawatts or 28 gigawatts from wind energy to solar energy, there are hours and days when almost the entire energy demand of Germany can be covered by renewable energies. However, there are, of course, many, many hours when this is not the case.

What does this mean? I do not want to abandon the priority for feed-in in an amendment to the Renewable Energy Sources Act, as it is already an incentive to drive things forward. However, it will be necessary for those who receive funding for renewable energies to participate more in grid expansion, overall supply, storage development, and other matters. This means we need to achieve an interconnection of the individual elements of the energy system if renewable energies are to make a relevant contribution to our overall energy supply – and they do today with almost 25 percent. This means we can no longer think in separate compartments – here the promotion of renewable energies, here grid expansion, and here base load supply – but that we must increasingly interlink all of this. This means it must succeed in harmonizing the pace of the expansion of renewable energies with the pace of the expansion of the grids. This is currently not the case, but we have made important steps in this regard.

The first step was that we passed a Federal Needs Planning Act, which has also been accepted by the Bundesrat. This Federal Needs Planning Act will, of course, be adjusted repeatedly in light of the development of the EEG – that is clear. But we have now laid a foundation stone. The remarkable thing about it is that we have succeeded in convincing the states that the federal government will receive new responsibilities not only in spatial planning but also in planning approval procedures, of course in consultation with the states. This is a guarantee that things will go faster.

Our experiences with the EnLAG, the Energy Line Expansion Act, show that we are behind schedule on many projects. However, we have committed to regular reporting in the meetings of state secretaries together with the head of the Chancellery. We can report some initial successes. The so-called North Line, the wind collection line, has been put into operation between Schwerin and Krümmel. In addition, Bavaria and Thuringia are working hard to ensure that the power bridge in Thuringia is built as quickly as possible, so that this power bridge is available when the relevant nuclear power plant is shut down and supply security is guaranteed.

However, if the EnLAG projects are not completed, then the major transmission lines according to the Federal Needs Planning Act cannot be built either, because they are partly linked to the EnLAG projects. Therefore, it will be very important that the EnLAG projects progress not only in the north and not only in the south, but also in the federal states in between; otherwise, we will have a problem. But we are paying attention to that.

I would like to thank everyone who is committed to the expansion of the lines. Of course, we must try to involve the population. Of course, we must keep advocating. I know that the representatives of the BDEW are doing this as well. We do not want to make decisions over the heads of the people, but anyone who wants an energy transition and who wants to base the energy supply of the future on renewable energies must also be willing to accept the necessary infrastructure. There is no way around that.

One last point regarding the expansion of renewable energies: We need a comprehensive understanding. This means we need to understand that not every federal state pursues its own energy policy. We also need acceptance when it comes to making every effort to design the promotion of renewable energies in such a way that where market proximity is greatest, for example, wind energy is expanded particularly quickly – and not uniformly across all of Germany; regardless of how strong the wind blows and how high the subsidy costs are. A common understanding of cost efficiency leads to a stronger expansion of wind power plants in the north while simultaneously assuring the southern German federal states that we will take care of their supply security and the expansion of the grid.

This brings me to a third point, which concerns the future market design. The BDEW has been very actively involved in the discussion and has repeatedly emphasized that the process of securing base load, that is, supply security, must be a transparent process, a comprehensible process. Therefore, the enthusiasm for the regulation on reserve power plants that we approved today in the Cabinet is not yet as pronounced as I would wish. Let me say this: The regulation is a first step. It must be replaced over time by more transparent mechanisms, by a complete market design and capacity mechanisms that work well together. We must be careful not to make decisions too quickly that we will later regret. In this respect, we need a little more time. The regulation passed today has a validity limit until 2017. This means we cannot simply rest on our laurels; we must continue to work.

Thus, the amendment to the Energy Industry Act – the so-called Reserve Power Plant Regulation, which is very important for the states – has been initiated with today's Cabinet decision. We have also already amended the Combined Heat and Power Act. This makes investments in modern plants easier.

However, I know that there are situations due to current developments that we cannot maintain in the long term: newly built municipal gas power plants that have a utilization rate far below profitability. Therefore, in connection with the amendment of the Renewable Energy Sources Act, we need to take another look at how the mechanisms for CO2 certificate distribution in Europe work. The German economy has mostly indicated that it does not want a scarcity of certificates – no backloading, as it is so nicely called nowadays.

However, if we have too many CO2 certificates in a quantity that is no longer adequate to the given economic situation – these CO2 certificate quantities are based on assumptions about economic growth rates that we do not have at all – then there are distortions at the electricity exchange that lead to coal power plants being much better off than newly built gas power plants. That cannot be right in the long run. Therefore, we must ensure that we also achieve more synergy effects in connection with an EEG amendment. But I also understand those who say: The core issue is first and foremost the amendment of the Renewable Energy Sources Act; as long as you do not deliver anything to us in this regard, please do not start messing with the certificate prices, because otherwise the effects will become completely unclear.

There is always a call for a master plan to have a clear idea of the steps we need to take. But the key is – this applies equally to the federal and state levels; and I especially ask the representatives of the municipal level to apply pressure – the willingness to amend the Renewable Energy Sources Act. If the EEG surcharge rises in the same way it has in recent years, because the number of those benefiting from the subsidies for the promotion of renewable energies is so large that a majority against it can never be achieved, then we have a problem with energy supply in Germany. The federal government will make clear proposals for a solution. We are also ready to make further proposals.

What cannot happen, however, is that some always say they need new exceptions, while others say the price must not rise, while the third group wants to change nothing at all. This means that the truth is really concrete at this point when we talk about it. Substantial changes must be made.

I thank all those who make proposals for this. I know that energy suppliers are thinking very intensively about how we can better interlink the various areas of the energy transition. I also rely on your expertise in the further work. But we must really come to action, because the issue of promoting renewable energies is, in my view, the most pressing among the topics of the energy transition.

The network loads have been significantly different in recent years due to the expansion of renewable energies and the shutdown of eight nuclear power plants than one could have foreseen earlier. That we have been able to ensure supply security over all these months, even in the most difficult weather conditions, is thanks to a very, very good collaboration among all those who work in the industry and the Federal Network Agency.

Thank you for not complaining, but for simply saying: We fundamentally support the energy transition project. Therefore, here’s to further good cooperation – both in terms of water management and energy management. Germany is a country with the highest quality in terms of public services. This association represents two very important areas. Therefore, I also look forward to further collaboration.