Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Annual Dinner of the Industry Club Düsseldorf e.V. on November 4, 2015, in Düsseldorf:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

6 November 2015 · Annual Dinner of the Industry Club Düsseldorf e.V · Düsseldorf, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Industry Club Düsseldorf annual dinner on November 4, 2015, focusing on Europe's refugee crisis and its root causes.
Main themes
Refugee crisis, causes of flight, EU-Turkey migration dialogue, burden sharing, Syria conflict, Islamic State, neighboring countries' refugee situation, international community responsibility, German industrial history, crisis management, humanitarian aid funding
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,498
81st percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
8th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 37%36%
  • Social 23%22%
  • Institutional 19%19%
  • Economic 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

166 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Scheele,

dear Mr. Grillo,

ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to thank you for the invitation and I am very pleased to accept it. As well-intentioned as the remark may have been that I might have been spared additional burdens, I do not know how I would have received that. In any case, I am very grateful to be here today.

The Industry Club Düsseldorf is an institution. It has existed for over 100 years. Perhaps the most remarkable thing is that it is deeply rooted in the region and has always brought together outstanding personalities under its roof. I would like to thank all those who are here today; it is indeed an impressive force that has gathered here.

Over the years, you have dedicated yourselves to the topics that reflect the recent history of our country: the First World War, the Great Depression, the Second World War, reconstruction, and industrial structural change. Just from this brief enumeration, it becomes clear how tumultuous history is and how grateful we can actually be to live in a time when the history of Germany also shows its good face.

However, we know that every era has its trials – of course, our time as well. Mr. Scheele has already pointed out in great detail the trial that has occupied us for weeks and months – in fact, longer than we may have perceived – namely that there are many, many people who are leaving their homeland to escape war, persecution, and poverty. There are as many people fleeing worldwide as there have been since the Second World War.

Some of the conflicts are also taking place right at Europe's doorstep. The war in Syria, the terror of the Islamic State, the dire situation in Libya – all of this seemed, until recently, to be far away from us in Germany. We have observed it on television; and it has of course saddened us that 100,000, 200,000, 250,000, now over 300,000 people have died in Syria. But we have not felt the consequences directly.

To successfully manage crises, one must address their causes. That is why I believe that, in light of the many, many people coming to us, it is very important that we also address the causes here. The problem of many refugees will certainly not be resolved at the German-Austrian border. The causes lie elsewhere. The causes lie in the countries of origin – I have spoken about Syria; I could talk about the Islamic State in Iraq – and they lie in the neighboring countries of the countries of origin.

We have seen that the situation of refugees, for example in Lebanon, has dramatically worsened. Lebanon has fewer inhabitants than Hesse, just under five million, and hosts 1.5 million Syrian refugees. Jordan also hosts a very large number of refugees. Classes in schools there are held in the afternoon in two or more shifts. It was a failure of the international community that the international UN programs – World Food Programme, UNHCR – were not adequately funded. We have now made up for that. The fact that the food ration for one person in Lebanon and Jordan had to be cut from 27 US dollars per month to 13 US dollars per month is certainly one of the causes of flight.

The situation for refugees in Turkey, which has been hosting over two million refugees for years, is also not easy. They are referred to there as guests. Turkey has only signed the Geneva Refugee Convention with respect to European states, but not with respect to non-European states. Syrians are welcome there, but they do not have access to the labor market or other things. In this respect, the situation there is also very difficult, especially since there are medium-sized Turkish cities where there are more Syrian refugees than residents. This has naturally also led to developments that have increased the pressure on us – especially because the Islamic State has emerged. The hope for many Syrians to quickly return to their homeland has, so to speak, dwindled. Their savings have been exhausted. Thus, a pressure has built up that has supported the emergence of refugee flows.

Now the question is: How do we deal with such challenges? I did not speak of the causes of flight by chance first. We must address the causes in order to organize and manage the flows. We must combat the causes in order to subsequently reduce the number of refugees coming to us. That is the task we are working on. However, I believe it will not be the case that we will have no refugees at all.

However, I actually find it unbearable that the narrow sea between Greece and Turkey – after all, two NATO member states – is currently dominated by traffickers and legality has little chance there. This means we must legalize. Our EU-Turkey migration dialogue serves this purpose, for example. And we must also share the burdens – financially; perhaps also with certain legal quotas of refugees. For this, we need to have discussions about Turkey's expectations regarding its neighborhood with the European Union and openly exchange ideas, for example, about the question: How can we initiate a reconciliation process with the Kurds again? Because the number of conflicts in Turkey and around Turkey is large. The challenge posed by the Islamic State alone is significant.

We now have the task of welcoming the refugees arriving with us and doing what is necessary. I know that many people are getting involved. And knowing that is a great joy. But I also know that it is a huge task, that some must push themselves to the limit of their strength or perhaps even go beyond themselves to do this work, and that the question of where this will lead is, of course, in the room. Nevertheless, we must also return to the question in such a situation: How and where can we solve this problem?

What applies to us? For us, it is true that we are, of course, challenged regarding our values. Article one of our Basic Law states: "The dignity of man is inviolable." This guides us in Germany. But the content of this Article one applies not only to Germans, but also in Europe. We have a Charter of Fundamental Rights in Europe. According to our understanding, every person has dignity that must be protected. This also characterizes our foreign policy and our development policy.

In this context, the question now is: How do we deal with the fact that so many refugees are coming to us? I believe the most important thing is that we – even if there are so many – never refer to them as a mass, as a large quantity, but that we see each individual as a person. This may not be easy in light of the many, but every person must be treated with dignity, regardless – and here I come to my second point – of whether they have a prospect of staying or not.

We are obliged to grant protection to people fleeing from war, persecution, and terror. If we want to achieve that, it means that we must tell those who come for economic reasons: You must return home. The decision about this takes place in a rule-of-law process. What people in Germany rightly expect is: If our rule-of-law processes are well trained, if they are fair, if they are just, if one can appeal against them and then the matter is reconsidered, then the rule of law must, on the one hand, grant protection to those who need it; on the other hand, it must also make clear to those who do not need protection that they must return home, and ensure that this is carried out. One must simply say: There has been a recurring lack of this in recent years. When we had few refugees, we were ultimately able to grant a certain right of residence to all or very many of them. Now, however, we must be much clearer on the issue of repatriations and also improve the enforcement significantly.

Another point: The fact that many want to come to us is, of course, also related to our country. It has to do with the fact that there may still be jobs here, that there is good treatment here, that there is a ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court that states that the minimum existence must be granted even according to the Asylum Seekers Benefits Act – only with slight deductions compared to Hartz IV. But this country is also what it is because it has certain rules – because it has this constitution, because the dignity of man is inviolable, because women and men are equal, because we have freedom of expression. We must also say from day one that we expect those who come to us to adhere to these rules. This must also be demonstrated and enforced again and again in practical daily life. This brings us back to a discussion about our values: What defines us, what is important to us? I believe this benefits both sides: both those who have come to us and us, if we perhaps talk more about our self-understanding in these days than in normal times.

I would like to make a brief remark on the question of borders. European asylum law, as it has been developed since the early 1990s, is a law that is based on the fact that we have essentially shifted border protection to the external borders of Europe – at least to the borders of the member states that are part of the Dublin Agreement and the Schengen Agreement – and that the benefit we derive from this transfer of responsibility for border protection to the external borders is the practicability of the internal market for us. The fact that there are no border controls means that the movement of goods can take place freely to an extent that was not possible before. The reintroduction of all border controls would, of course, significantly hinder us; and the more stringently we would implement them, the more so.

This means that the task of managing the refugee crisis is ultimately a profoundly European task. Even if some member states say that they do not want to participate in this task, one must know: The transfer of responsibility for the protection of borders to the external borders of the European Union was a transfer of sovereignty. Regardless of the fact that we can temporarily reintroduce border controls, it was essentially a vote of confidence. This can only go well if we are also jointly willing to draw the necessary conclusions when this system does not work.

One thing is clear: The Dublin Agreement has weaknesses, so we must definitely make changes.

First, we notice that in the event of an influx of refugees, as we are currently seeing, external borders must be protected on land. We have a fence or a wall between Greece and Turkey; we have a fence between Bulgaria and Turkey. But at sea, we have major problems with protection when it is only one-sided – not when two or three illegal refugees come; but when thousands come, it becomes very, very difficult. Therefore, I am deeply convinced: We need cooperation with the respective country from which the refugees depart in order to jointly organize border protection there. That is why cooperation with Turkey is so essential at this point. Turkey naturally says: There needs to be a sharing of burdens between us.

The situation is even more complicated on the Italian Mediterranean coast because Libya lies on the other side. It all worked well when Gaddafi had border agreements with Italy. But now, as there is essentially no statehood visible in Libya, that no longer works. We must also talk about how we deal with this. There are missions – first and foremost the mission for the rescue of people in distress at sea. I want to remind you that the European heads of state and government came together in the spring for a special council after a ship with several hundred refugees sank, all of whom perished. At that time, we all said: It cannot be that something like this happens in the Mediterranean. Since then, the German Navy alone has rescued 9,000 people. The further steps of the mission consist of combating human trafficking. For this reason, there are also intensive diplomatic efforts to create a unity government in Libya. We must ensure that we can again conduct cooperative border security and a cooperative fight against traffickers from there. Otherwise, a lot of money flows to traffickers, but little money goes into development aid and legal migration.

It is therefore a European problem – a problem that has a lot to do with the freedom of movement within the internal market. That is why Germany holds the position that we need to establish a fair system for the distribution of refugees in Europe. Of course, one can take into account the economic strength, the number of unemployed, and the number of migrants already accepted. Spain has already experienced very high migration movements in recent years. At that time, we in the Federal Republic of Germany were very glad that we had no external border, and we said: This is a problem for Spain, Portugal, Italy, or Greece, but not our problem. Only a few hundred arrived at Frankfurt Airport. Now we realize: In light of the number of refugees, it is of course completely impossible for Greece to take in all the refugees arriving from Turkey alone.

This means that without a fair distribution, which is not currently provided for in the European asylum system, it cannot work at all. We probably need a European border protection, agreements with our neighbors, and a fair distribution in Europe. This means we need a change in the existing asylum system – a change that strengthens Europe, and not a change that weakens Europe.

Since the freedom of movement in the internal market is one of the important pillars – alongside the pillar of the Euro, where we have had crisis situations in recent years – we see that two very important pillars of Europe have been attacked. I believe we have the Euro crisis under control, but we have not yet completely overcome it because we still have not addressed the founding flaws of the Economic and Monetary Union. We need to achieve greater economic coherence. This cannot be about economic coherence in the sense of a median – that is, an average of all the competitiveness of the Euro member states – but it must be about defining competitiveness in terms of the best in the world. We have implemented rescue programs, which one must say have worked quite well. Ireland today has an economic growth of six to seven percent, Spain has economic growth again and more jobs, Portugal has economic growth again. And if the conditions we agreed upon are met in Greece, then we can expect that economic growth will also return there.

This means that for me, in these years and also in these days, it is not only about the question of how things will continue in Germany, but it is also about how things will continue in Europe. Do those who have the most refugees – by the way, Sweden has more refugees per capita than we do; and Austria has at least as many as we do – now have to take more care of Europe, or do the others have to take more care of Europe? I believe: Germany, as the largest economy and the most populous country in Europe, also has a great responsibility for Europe. We know: Our prosperity, our abilities and opportunities to assert ideas and interests in the world are certainly greater with 500 million Europeans than if we were to try it alone with 80 million Germans.

In this respect, it is important for a solution to the problem that we look at it from the outside and say: We must tackle the causes – knowing that Europe alone cannot, of course, cope with global refugee movements. It requires cooperation, the collaboration of all, I would say, democratically or at least peacefully oriented forces in this world. When one says this, some lower their heads and say: Well, we have been observing this for years; and the successes are limited. That is true. But is that a reason to say that we should not try further?

I believe the number of refugees has now led to peace efforts in Syria that we have not seen in the last five years. The mere fact that last Friday, from Iran to Saudi Arabia, Russia, and America, everyone sat at the same table is not a solution to the problem, but at least a sign of hope. If we do not take this path, then I believe there will be no good way forward. Therefore, we will have to take it; and I will take it together with others, with the Federal Foreign Minister and the entire Federal Government, with full conviction.

Overall, one must simply say: We are experiencing a piece of globalization that we have not experienced before. Until now, globalization for us meant that German companies established businesses abroad, in emerging countries, in developing countries, created jobs, and thus also secured jobs in Germany. This has, on balance, been good for us in most cases. This has – together with digitalization – also led to people in emerging countries and also in African countries being better off in some ways. However, it has also led to people knowing that others elsewhere are better off; and therefore they are interested in that.

Where there are wars, we are co-responsible for protection. This means we are now seeing a piece of globalization of a different kind. We must deal with this globalization in the same way, understanding it more as an opportunity than as a risk. And we must try to find answers – which of course cannot mean: We can accommodate 60 million refugees in Europe alone or even solve the problems of the 60 million refugees.

So, I believe we should talk about this topic. We should also reassure ourselves: What can we do, what do we want, where do we stand? But the fact is that it is becoming increasingly obvious that we cannot isolate ourselves from the world – and that we cannot just flip a switch and everything will be as it was yesterday.

Personally, I believe – also through the experience of German reunification – that changes, new situations always carry many opportunities within them. Until I was 35 years old, I did not seriously expect that my work as a physicist at the Academy of Sciences would lead to a role as a politician. The wall fell; and, to be honest, the then old Federal Republic of Germany was also not perfectly prepared for this situation, even though people had talked about it for 40 years, saying it should happen tomorrow. This means that even back then we had to roll up our sleeves and come up with new ideas.

Today we have a different problem; entirely different cultures are coming to us, entirely different tasks are coming our way – every comparison has its disadvantages. But still, in the last 25 years, we have also had experiences that can give us courage. There were times when Helmut Kohl, when he spoke of blooming landscapes in the new federal states, was looked at quite strangely. Today, it rolls off the tongue relatively easily – for example, when I am in my constituency.

In this respect, I simply ask that you also try to see what we are now facing more as an opportunity – without downplaying the risks – but also as a great challenge, which is about more than just Germany, which is also about Europe, and which is also about the question of how earnestly we can stand up for our values outside of Europe.

The chairman of my faction, the CDU/CSU faction, is concerned about persecuted Christians in the world. We often talk about this: How credible can we actually be in caring for the persecuted in other countries if we do not find the right answers to our tasks here? That also resonates.

I have now left out everything I wanted to say about the energy transition, digitalization, and much more, because you, Mr. Scheele, have also prompted me to speak on the topic you addressed.

I thank you for inviting me, and I hope that both your work in the economy here in Düsseldorf and in the region, as well as your work in the sense of the social market economy, will continue to have an impact.