Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Congress "Industry 4.0 – Opportunities for Germany" of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group on November 4, 2015, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

6 November 2015 · Congress "Industry 4.0 – Opportunities for Germany" of the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group congress on Industry 4.0 in Berlin on November 4, 2015, discussing digitalization's impact on Germany's economy and industry.
Main themes
Industry 4.0, digitalization of industrial production, Germany's economic competitiveness, digital technology and society, Digital Agenda, IT Summit, financial markets and digitalization, infrastructure and broadband expansion, innovation and regulation, CDU/CSU economic policy
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,538
68th percentile
Sentences
132
76th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.98
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 35%29%
  • Economic 24%20%
  • Institutional 20%17%
  • Social 13%11%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 17%

132 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Dear Michael Fuchs,

dear Volker Kauder,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag and dear guests of this congress,

You have already heard quite a bit; and we will also discuss further later. We are indeed experiencing – whether we are witnessing an evolution or rather a revolution, I do not know – a lot of new things: cars that drive themselves or at least can already park themselves, refrigerators that know what is missing, smartphones that have answers to many questions. Much of this we perceived as fantasy just a few years ago. And today it is close to reality or already reality.

Digital technology is the driving force behind a rapid development. When one considers that Leibniz invented the binary code, one realizes how long it lay dormant before anything could be done with it. Konrad Zuse built the first computer. It is almost forgotten in Germany that we had the first computer. And then the development of the digital took off, penetrating nearly everything – industrial manufacturing and especially our personal lives. It has impacts on communication overall, on the shaping of life.

On the one hand, as with any new technological development, there will be great blessings. On the other hand, there will also be things we must learn to live with, for which we must exercise caution and take preventive measures. This means that technology itself is not simply good or bad. It is there. And the expectation of people is that we make use of this technology, but that it does not dominate us. In this sense, we certainly have a lot to do, both positively and negatively.

We have seen that many impressive products, especially for consumers, no longer come from Germany, from Europe, but from the United States of America or from Asian regions. We have now reached a crucial point regarding the question: How does digitalization also penetrate industrial production? This is of utmost economic importance for us, as it is not yet decided whether classical industrial production will one day become the back end of the extended workbench or whether we can achieve a balanced coexistence of digital technology and classical industrial manufacturing, with which we can continue to succeed globally. Because we are a country with a relatively high industrial share – still over 20 percent. And that is our strength.

Moreover, digital technologies – apart from our personal experiences with mobile phones and smartphones – have also encountered us in international finance. The digital possibilities for processing financial market products have intensified the opacity of financial market products. The fact that digital information transmissions know no borders has made globalization in finance a reality, even before we could establish national or supranational regulations. In principle, the entire G20 process at the level of heads of state and government is a lagging process of rule-making after we experienced the first major crash due to the misuse of financial market products. It is completely impossible to respond quickly to new financial market products. Of course, the entire stock exchange system has changed dramatically due to digital possibilities.

The federal government, in the current Grand Coalition, has developed the Digital Agenda as part of our coalition agreement. We are trying with this Digital Agenda to address all aspects in order to create the necessary framework conditions and also to promote necessary innovations.

In just under two weeks, we will have the IT Summit in Berlin. This congress here also serves, to some extent, as preparation for this IT Summit. The IT Summit process is a well-established cooperation of telecommunications companies, startups, government, and of course users. I want to explicitly state that something has emerged in this cooperation within the framework of the IT dialogue that we do not know from the classical collaboration with the economy. It is a very equal dialogue. It is a process of very flat hierarchies. It is not a process of demands like “You in politics, please do this and that” and expectations from politics about what the economy should do, but it is a very cooperative process, where one always enters new territory together and tries to advance political framework conditions and technological innovations simultaneously.

We are dealing with the hardware question as part of our Digital Agenda – that is, the ability to transmit information at all. We already have our hands full with that. You know our goal: by 2018, 50 megabits per second for every household. That is good, that is right.

We now also have funding available through a comparatively swift frequency auction and have outlined a funding framework; the funding regulation has just been passed in the cabinet. This will move us forward significantly. Alexander Dobrindt has also created a discussion forum with the Network Alliance, which is driving private innovations forward well. I believe we have every reason to assume that we can achieve this self-imposed goal.

Moreover, through the auctioning of frequencies, partly also to public broadcasting providers, we now have a frequency spectrum available that is not only suitable for 3G and 4G but will certainly also be usable for 5G in the future. However, we will still need to work on the frequency spectra.

With 50 megabits per second, quite a bit can already be accomplished. That is also quite sufficient for classical private use today. For future applications, that will not be enough. When thinking about telemedicine or other high-precision data transmissions, one knows that larger bandwidths are needed. Above all, large bandwidths are required to enable parallel uses.

To address the issue of net neutrality, which has been addressed by the telecommunications package of the European Commission, which has just been passed by the Council and Parliament: You can only seriously consider net neutrality if you have a large bandwidth that allows access to everyone and still permits a small number of special uses. We need that, because the thought that during telemedical examinations or one day even remote surgeries the data transmission does not function properly is not particularly pleasant. I do not want to talk about security issues now, if the endoscopic operation goes differently than planned. One must, of course, have high security standards.

We have ensured that the use of Wi-Fi in public spaces is improved through a change in the Telemedia Act. This means we will improve the possibilities of Wi-Fi use in hotels, restaurants, and other public places. That was also a long and complicated discussion, where, as always, many things had to be considered. Of course, we also have to be careful that free Wi-Fi access does not lead to the appropriation of content that fundamentally represents value creation for which one must also pay. But I believe we have created a pretty good access.

We have made progress regarding the IT Security Act. Here, our economy is still somewhat hesitant; I believe for the wrong reasons. The economy often fears that if it has to report attacks on its infrastructure, it will damage its reputation. But I believe we must simply know that we live in a world where this can happen to anyone, which is why the state needs a certain overview of what attacks we are exposed to, because otherwise we cannot learn from the nature of the attacks. This will be absolutely necessary. The federal government is also working on cyber defense strategies in various areas, which are of great importance to us.

All questions of the Digital Agenda are deeply European questions. If we have a single market, then we also need a digital single market. Achieving that currently presents itself as quite difficult. But Günther Oettinger, as our Commissioner, has put forward a bold agenda. The first success was the telecommunications package, which, however, has been stripped of some elements. We have retained net neutrality and eliminated roaming fees after a certain point, which is of course also consumer-friendly.

We still face major questions of competition law in the European Commission. We have very, very many telecommunications providers in Europe, compared to those in China or the United States of America, so legitimate questions arise as to whether such small companies will ever develop the investment power and impact needed globally. Therefore, we already consider it a success that we have persuaded the competition commission to conduct an investigation into the relevant markets, so that perhaps as a result of this study or investigation, merger possibilities will arise and the fragmentation of the European market will not be so great, which would then also give us more clout.

We have significant problems with frequency management. Everyone has their frequency ranges. However, we need to come to common frequencies in cross-border areas. And if I can believe Günther Oettinger, then a uniform frequency framework in the European area is a prerequisite for being able to use 5G properly.

We have conducted intensive negotiations on the General Data Protection Regulation. This has been handled by our Federal Minister of the Interior in the Council for Justice and Home Affairs. The General Data Protection Regulation, which has been agreed upon by the Commission and the Council, is now in the trilogue process with Parliament. Here, we must ensure that the right balance is maintained between big data mining, that is, processing large amounts of data, and data protection. In my view, the compromise between the Commission and the Council is already at the end of what still allows for reasonable big data management. If this is now changed again to the detriment of data protection through the trilogue, we will have a problem.

There is much talk about a level playing field with the United States of America. We have the Safe Harbor ruling, which plunges us into a state of legal uncertainty because there are no transition periods. I am very glad that the Commission has made it clear that it wants to try to create legal clarity in negotiations with the United States within three months. That is very ambitious, but we urgently need it. There are examples of companies, American companies in Europe, in Germany, that process their payroll in America, who currently do not know on what basis data transmission can occur; and that is not very pleasant.

Here it becomes clear that a very high level of data protection is expected through the judiciary. We live in a certain dichotomy, because in the United States of America the entire approach is different from ours. It is rather everything allowed that is not explicitly prohibited, while for us everything is initially prohibited that is not explicitly allowed. Finding overlaps here is not so easy. Therefore, there is also a cultural component. If it is now demanded that one can only work with companies that pursue the same philosophy of data protection, then that naturally raises problems. However, I must say that it is also very important – and this is what the Commission still needs to achieve – that in Europe, product processing – this concerns the General Data Protection Regulation – can only take place according to European standards. Because today we have a situation where data from individuals is transferred to America, processed there, and products are developed that are then used here in Europe, while our own telecommunications providers cannot produce the same products because information processing in that area is not permitted. It is as if we were receiving products in the real economy that can only be manufactured based on ingredients that are not allowed here, but that can still be sold. This naturally creates entirely different possibilities for value creation; and thus we have a classic competitive disadvantage.

The French President and I maintain regular discussions with the European Round Table, that is, with leading European companies, in which the President of the Commission also participates. There we try to promote a unified European approach to all questions of the Digital Agenda.

I would like to briefly mention that significant industries in Germany – particularly mechanical engineering and especially the automotive industry – are developing increasingly towards merging with the digital world. The "Digital Test Field Autobahn" on the A9 is an example. I am very relieved since I understood that along the highway, bandwidths do not need to be permanently available, but the cars communicate with each other, so there is no need to worry about available internet along the highway. However, we will have a multitude of definitional questions, starting with the question: What is a car when there is no driver behind the wheel? But we will somehow manage to answer such questions.

Above all, we will – and we are still at the very beginning of the discussion – also have impacts on the world of work. We will have impacts on the collective bargaining landscape. If you look at the culture of startups today, at the way startups operate, you will find that it is no longer taken for granted that negotiations between a works council and management are conducted first, because hierarchies are very flat there, and the necessities of creative activity are very clear. As long as this only affects younger employees today, that may be fine. But how this will develop over 10, 20, or 30 years, what consequences it will have, is unknown. And at some point, questions will also arise about the finiteness of working hours, about the availability of employees. All of this must be resolved again in the spirit of the social market economy. I believe we can only solve all of this if we truly understand what changes are taking place in a technical sense. If one does not have a sense of this, it is, of course, difficult to create the necessary social framework conditions.

It would be good if we were not surprised again, as we were with the financial industry, when the product was only really understood when it was already causing a crash. The broad parliamentary engagement with derivatives as financial market products only began when the financial market crisis had already broken out. Citizens expect us to also proactively create a certain legal framework. In such an innovation-driven time as the current one, this is anything but easy, and sometimes certainly not sensible. But at least a temporal parallelism should be present.

So you see: There is much to think through, much to regulate. In some places, there is also a need for courage to leave gaps, so as not to set limits to creativity before it has even begun to unfold. And it is anything but certain that we will be at the forefront. This is something we have not experienced with such intensity for decades. When you consider how many horse-drawn carriage manufacturers eventually became car producers, you know that it is not certain that all car producers today will necessarily participate in the next technical revolution. However, our automotive industry is quite well positioned, as far as I can see. But the technical revolution essentially begins in all areas. And that is why it is good that this congress is taking place today and that we are discussing these questions again and again, in order to arrive at decisions, of course.