Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Publishers' Summit of the Association of German Magazine Publishers (VDZ) on November 2, 2015, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

2 November 2015 · Publishers' Summit of the Association of German Magazine Publishers (VDZ) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the VDZ Publishers' Summit in Berlin on November 2, 2015, speaking on press freedom, media diversity, and the challenges of digitalization for the publishing industry.
Main themes
Press freedom, media diversity, digitalization, democracy and free media, independent journalism, publishing industry economics, German history and censorship, freedom of expression, advertising and competition, media landscape challenges
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,875
85th percentile
Sentences
232
92nd percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 33%33%
  • Social 24%24%
  • Economic 22%22%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 6%6%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

232 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Professor Burda,

dear Mr. Scherzer,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

ladies and gentlemen,

yes, 20 years ago, all of this was not so foreseeable for some. But you, Mr. Burda – I may say this – pointed out the revolutionary change from the very beginning and repeatedly said: Digitalization will change our world just as Gutenberg did with his printing press. This has also been recognized in the current federal government. Our Digital Agenda speaks to that. But first, I would like to thank you for the invitation.

Publishing companies are, of course, dependent on economic criteria being met. Economic success is necessary. But it is also about something that actually concerns every citizen. You have said that 95 to 97 percent of people in Germany have contact with magazines. Therefore, the question of publishing diversity and the independence of journalism is a central one. You are the ones who ensure information for everyone. You broaden horizons. You help people to be informed citizens. The essential prerequisite for this is press freedom. That is why democracy and free media are inextricably linked. Free media are unthinkable without a functioning democratic state and societal order that provides the framework for it. That is why I am pleased that this year's conference is giving special attention to the fundamental right of press freedom and thus also to freedom of expression.

We have experienced times without a free press in Germany. You are meeting here in a building that stood on the side of East Berlin before the fall of the wall. I still remember very well how newspapers became more or less the mouthpiece of a party. However, one also learned to read between the lines. This is no longer as necessary with today's magazines. Usually, you are already informed in bold print in the headline about what you are supposed to understand. But even there, it is sometimes worth reading between the lines, though it is no longer quite as vital for survival.

The Federal Republic of Germany was fortunate that the Nazi propaganda was a very clear lesson for the mothers and fathers of the Basic Law to prevent the misuse of the press through constitutional safeguards for media freedoms. And even in reunified Germany, we now have 25 years of independent journalism and media diversity. I believe we cannot value this enough. Because when we look at the world, we find that press freedom, despite digitalization, is anything but a given.

Today, you will honor Daniel Barenboim and award him the Golden Victoria for his life's work. – I am also pleased that the Ambassador of the State of Israel is here. – Barenboim recently wrote in a press article: "Freedom is not a privilege, but a fundamental right of all people." This certainly applies to press freedom as well. However, it is lacking in many states or exists only on paper, so that independent journalism cannot be spoken of. It starts with the fact that research is only possible under state observation or that interview partners and information sources are subjected to intimidation. In extreme cases, journalists are persecuted, imprisoned, and even killed. That is why I want to take this opportunity to thank everyone who contributes to the content of your magazines and often exposes themselves to very difficult situations, as we fortunately do not have in our country today.

The experience, for example, in the GDR or in the states behind the Iron Curtain in general was: In the long run, free speech cannot be suppressed. This has never been fully achieved and is even less achievable today in light of digital possibilities. That is why I am pleased that the Association of German Magazine Publishers is making a special statement for free reporting this year by awarding a Golden Victoria for press freedom for the first time. The award goes to two female journalists and one male journalist who, despite all pressure and threats, continue to pursue their topics. Their personal stories, their work may be different, but they convey a message of courage and hope: Press freedom always finds a way; there are always brave people who refuse to be intimidated.

Therefore, I want to emphasize again: Press freedom and media diversity are a value in themselves. This is not in contradiction to what I said at the beginning, namely that press work or journalistic work must also be economically successful. This also requires reasonable framework conditions so that small publishers can assert themselves alongside large ones. Many smaller publishers also contribute to media diversity and enrich the media landscape.

I know that the advertising business still plays a major role. Advertising is a central source of revenue. This is not only the case for magazine publishers. There is also competition between them, television broadcasters, and internet providers. I suspect that this competition will continue to intensify. Therefore, cooperation in advertising and its antitrust facilitation are important topics for the press publishers. As the federal government, we are currently examining how we can best implement a corresponding regulation. However, we are also encountering European legal restrictions.

At this point, I want to say about competition law in Europe overall: You are right; the questions of the scope of the area are indeed necessary. We have now achieved that they are being reviewed. After long debates in various contexts, we have succeeded in getting the European Commission to conduct a study on this. The study may then provide the opportunity to draw appropriate conclusions. In any case, we have been applying pressure on this issue for some time – and not only with regard to press publishers but also concerning competition law in Europe overall and in relation to globalization. We also have significant complications with telecommunications companies, as can be seen when looking at the competitive situation elsewhere. Diversity in Europe does not always have to be a value in itself if one wants to succeed in global competition. From our perspective, there is still much to be done. And we are trying to make this clear in Brussels.

European legal restrictions – and that brings me to the topic of data protection. Here, a fundamental balancing act must be made. You need sufficient freedoms to utilize new data, new possibilities of data management, big data mining, or the cloud for your business models. I believe this is a form of value creation that has not yet been properly recognized, at least in Germany. Data are the raw materials of the 21st century. The way of linking and creating new products will significantly change our world. On the one hand, we have products that can be derived from anonymized data. This works reasonably well in Europe. However, on the other hand, when it comes to individualized data, it becomes quite difficult. But in the future, people will want individualized products while also wanting protection of their privacy. And that will present us with many considerations.

The balance of security and freedom on the internet raises the question of a unified European data protection law. We know this question from the debate on the EU General Data Protection Regulation, which the interior and justice ministers have adopted. I believe that this data protection regulation, as it stands after discussions in the Commission and Council, is relatively balanced. However, we now have a trilogue with the European Parliament, where we must ensure that data protection does not take precedence over the economic processing of data. We welcome any support you can provide us in this regard. We need a compromise. The decision is now in what could be called the hot phase, but it has the advantage – keyword basic regulation – that we will then have directly applicable law for all of Europe. This means we will not have a difficult implementation phase of directives into national law, but a uniform point of applicability.

On the way to a modern legal framework, there are various concerns. You have legitimate business interests, but it is always also about compromises. For example, there is the issue of direct marketing. The rules in direct marketing looked quite different in the original Commission draft. The press publishers have advocated strongly for improvements. We believe that some have been achieved.

The same applies to data retention. However, you are not so interested in having as many traffic data stored as possible. This is viewed with suspicion, especially by journalists. I understand that. But I want to point out again that the law passed by the Bundestag in October sets extremely narrow limits for data retention from the perspective of the federal government. The right to unobserved communication is and remains intact. The respective telecommunications companies collect the data. And if someone wants to access them – that is, law enforcement agencies – a judicial order is required, within which the special protection of certain professional groups – including the protection of journalists – must be taken into account. Moreover, the retention periods are very short. I believe that is justifiable. The judicial reservation further emphasizes that in the sensitive tension between freedom and security, the balance is maintained and the legitimate interests of independent media are adequately considered.

Digital technologies are radically changing communication. As a functioning state, we must of course respond to this. Therefore, we must provide fair competitive opportunities for all media providers. It is not entirely easy in a country where both the federal and state levels decide, and where there is also a European decision-making level, to put everything on new footing. But I believe it is right that the federal and state governments have established the Commission for Media Convergence. Your association actively contributes its opinions there. We want to achieve with this commission that the path for a contemporary change in the media order is paved. As already indicated: The responsibilities between the federal and state levels are different. That does not interest you; you want a proper framework. But it must of course interest us as the federal government. That is why this federal-state commission is the right place and the right format to achieve this.

There are plenty of questions: How do media supervision and antitrust law fit together? How do we deal with platforms and intermediaries? How do we envision the revision of the EU directive on audiovisual media services? This already indicates: The convergence of media and the changing usage behavior also put the relationship between broadcasting and press providers to the test. I have not even mentioned that we have public and private broadcasting, which approach the matter with different interests.

Everyone has reacted to the digital transformation. You as press publishers have developed online offerings just like the broadcasting institutions. You provide applications for mobile use. It was quite interesting to learn today about videos in magazine offerings. One is almost disappointed when one has online offerings from magazines but cannot constantly see a little film. You can see for yourself how media communication is changing. The new business fields are, of course, already well established. Today, we have the choice to read newspapers or magazines on a tablet, in printed form, or sometimes in both versions.

Now I come to the value-added tax rates. It is relatively difficult to understand why printed books or magazines are subject to the reduced value-added tax rate, while e-books and e-papers are subject to the full value-added tax rate. The idea behind the tax concession for printed press products is, of course, to protect cultural goods and to keep the access threshold for users as low as possible. However, I believe that the decisive criterion cannot be whether a text or an image is printed on paper or whether it is viewed electronically; rather, the quality standard of the content must be the determining factor. Therefore, we believe that the reduced value-added tax rate should apply to both electronic and traditional press products. For this, we need to change European tax law, which is always very difficult in Europe because tax law can only be amended unanimously. But we advocate for a uniform taxation. Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker is willing to take this path and has announced a corresponding directive proposal. We are not alone; a whole number of member states share our opinion. But we still have a lot of convincing work to do. And I simply ask you to join in on this.

Now, it is not only about financial factors but also about the dissemination and thus the findability of content. The attention of the internet user is a matter of survival for certain media. Since user behavior is also very much tied to the major search engines, the question arises: How is the findability of media ensured there? A lot depends on the position among the results that the search engine provides. It must be prevented that powerful search engine providers exploit their dominant position by placing their own content better than that of others. Therefore, I am grateful to the EU Commission for independently examining how practices in antitrust proceedings can be taken into account more consistently than before. This is also a very emotional terrain, but I believe the Commission is handling it with great calmness and objectivity. And I consider that to be correct.

With that, I am not far from copyright. You naturally wish for greater dynamism when it comes to adapting copyright to digital developments. You, Mr. Burda, have said that with Commissioner Oettinger we have a very knowledgeable and committed contact person for all the areas I have mentioned. Jean-Claude Juncker does not like it when I refer to "our German Commissioner," but he wants all commissioners to feel responsible for everyone and not just for one country. But: Günther Oettinger is doing a great job.

In copyright, only smaller steps are currently emerging, but there is agreement that the copyright directive needs to be reviewed. There are three important consultation processes underway: regarding the satellite and cable directive, on geo-blocking, and on the work of online platforms. These three processes are intended to pave the way for legislative steps towards the planned digital internal market in the European Union. We have repeatedly pointed out that time is of the essence. The Commission has now also made its work planning more ambitious.

The year 2016 will be a decisive one. We have also brought together, I believe very successfully, the Commission and the European Round Table, that is, important European companies. A meeting recently took place in Paris. It was already the fourth. These congresses, which the Commission President also attends, are always held alternately in Paris and Berlin. We need a better decision-making basis for our regulatory projects. We need to achieve a uniform understanding of the law in Europe; otherwise, we will not be able to fully utilize the advantages of the digital internal market or even fall behind in the global market.

However, the harmonization of copyright will take time – you know that yourself – because the interests are very, very different. It will not be voted on by qualified majority; rather, all member states must agree equally. Therefore, our approach as a federal government is correct: to make the copyright issue a scientific question and to show scientifically based ways to bring as much objectivity as possible into the entire debate.

At the national level, we have two reform projects regarding copyright. Our national debate is anything but simple, if I may say so cautiously.

First, there is a proposal for the reform of the law on collecting societies. I assume that we will soon decide on this in the Cabinet. Of course, we want the German collecting societies to continue to fulfill their cultural and social mandate with the implementation of the relevant EU directive.

The second project concerns copyright contract law. There is also a first draft. The coordination within the federal government is ongoing. We are also in discussions with the states and associations. This is about improving the position of authors. Professional creative work should be adequately compensated. – There is also the Alliance for Content, the Content Alliance. – We already tried this during the reform of copyright contract law in 2002. But the wheel has continued to turn. Digital technologies have opened up many new ways for content to reach users, which is why we need a new reform.

Now the question arises: How should, against this background, the remuneration for, for example, the same article be structured? Uniformly or separately depending on the print edition and online edition? It would be nice if you all said the same thing, as far as you are active in the journalistic field. But opinions differ; there is a need for discussion. But I ask you: We must not lose sight of the overarching goal. Quality and diversity in our cultural and media landscape should guide us.

At this point, I want to say a little about the level playing field with the United States of America and also about the question of Safe Harbor. Politicians should not comment on court rulings. Nevertheless, the Safe Harbor ruling of the European Court of Justice raises a multitude of questions and is not exactly a direct contribution to the unification of the level playing field. We now have a relatively high degree of uncertainty for many companies – also outside of journalism – because no transition periods have been set. However, the Commission is negotiating intensively and aims to present a proposal within three months.

But at this point, the very different approaches of Europe and the United States are once again evident. In America, there is the tendency: What is not prohibited is allowed. Here, the tendency is rather the opposite: What is not allowed is generally prohibited. Making a common level playing field out of this is not trivial, as the initial impulses are different. Therefore, we will certainly need many, many regulations in Europe for a level playing field in the transatlantic area. But it is all the more important that we create the necessary leeway in processing data – see the General Data Protection Regulation.

The last point I want to address is the planned Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership. I must also say again: This is, of course, aimed precisely at achieving a level playing field between the United States of America and Europe. At the same time, the question arises in your circles about what this means for cultural issues.

The special thing about the planned trade agreement with the United States of America is that tariffs, the classic contents of free trade agreements, play a rather subordinate role; they are not the bone of contention. The discussion revolves more around so-called non-tariff trade barriers, which touch on technical standards, among other things. I believe we can handle this quite well. Whether it is about orange lights or yellow lights on cars – much has to be done twice; regarding what is safer, at least mutual recognition can be achieved or an agreement can be reached on how to proceed collectively. Very important for avoiding non-tariff trade barriers are new technologies for which no standards have yet been set – for example, nanotechnology. The goal is to try to set common standards in Europe and the United States in the future so that we do not later face the question of how to deal with different ones.

Now I come to the so-called "soft" areas such as environmental protection and consumer protection. There are great concerns about how an agreement could affect this. Do we have to make concessions on our known environmental and consumer protection?

To this, I say as a first point: Nothing that we have today in Europe in terms of consumer protection and environmental protection will be lowered.

Secondly: We have reluctantly noticed, as in the case of VW, that the emission regulations in the United States are not so bad either. The so-called chlorine chicken had always been used as a symbol of American practices. The chlorine chicken is out. As I said, nothing will be allowed in Europe that is currently prohibited.

Of course, this is uncharted territory, as the classic trade experts have not dealt much with non-tariff trade barriers. But I tell you: If you want to achieve a level playing field in the data area – I am not talking about culture and content, but about the data area – then TTIP, a free trade agreement, is more helpful than not.

Secondly, the great opportunity of this trade agreement is that we can define standards in the two largest economic areas, which together will form a truly large economic area, that others, who today still know few consumer and environmental protection standards, will not be able to easily bypass.

This means that the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership can make history in that an agreement is not only based on tariff reduction but also addresses the question of social standards, consumer standards, and environmental standards, which of course leads to an improvement in our competitiveness because we have a lot of these standards that may initially seem cost-increasing but will have a sustainable effect over time. Therefore, we as Europeans would make a huge mistake if we blocked this and were not willing to do so. I tell this so comprehensively because it might also pique your interest to write something interesting about it in your many magazines – of course, taking into account journalistic freedom.

The federal government recently published a position paper in which we emphasize our stance that the free trade agreement should not contain any provisions that would impair cultural and media diversity in our country. Public cultural funding will continue to be possible. The book price fixing will remain in place. And our legislative leeway in cultural and media policy will be preserved. Therefore, we should consider what added value we have under the established framework conditions and seize the opportunities, of course also discussing the risks, but not placing them disproportionately in the foreground compared to the opportunities.

Federal Chancellor Adenauer once said: "The purpose of the state must be to awaken, bring together, nurture, and protect the creative forces of a people." This fundamental claim has not changed for us as a developed cultural nation to this day – regardless of the various digital technologies we work with today.

Media, art, and culture inform, provoke, and inspire. They make us think. We cannot and do not want to forgo these intellectual and creative impulses. Therefore, the federal government sees it as its duty and responsibility to ensure good framework conditions so that creative forces can unfold and the works of creatives can find dissemination and resonance.

I have tried to convey to you our media policy activities on several issues. Of course, I could have also raved about the wonderful content that delights me in both work and leisure when I pick up a magazine. I prefer not to talk about unpleasant matters. In any case, thank you again for inviting me. We will remain in close contact to manage the changes in these times properly.