Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Bundeswehr Conference on May 14, 2018, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

14 May 2018 · Bundeswehr Conference · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Bundeswehr Conference in Berlin on May 14, 2018, reflecting on military reform, defense spending, and the evolving security landscape.
Main themes
Bundeswehr reform and modernization, defense spending and NATO two-percent target, Cold War legacy and post-Cold War restructuring, security environment and geopolitical complexity, military personnel recruitment and retention, work-life balance in the armed forces, suspension of conscription, tribute to fallen soldiers, multilateralism and international cooperation, Arab Spring and regional instability, Germany as reliable partner, societal recognition of military service
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,106
92nd percentile
Sentences
258
93rd percentile
Readability
52
70th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 63%61%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

258 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Dear Minister, dear Ursula von der Leyen,

dear General Inspector,

dear Parliamentary Commissioner for the Armed Forces,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

dear Parliamentary State Secretaries!

I warmly greet all those present who will be dealing with the situation of the Bundeswehr today and tomorrow!

It is a great honor for me to be here again today, after 2012, when I was in Strausberg. I would like to express my appreciation for the work of the Bundeswehr through my presence – in an environment that is anything but simple and in a time of lively discussion, where societal debates are vibrant and sometimes also the debates within the Bundeswehr. This shows that the Bundeswehr is a part of our society; and that is as it should be. I also want to express my appreciation because I believe that you make a tremendous contribution to ensuring that our citizens in Germany can live in safety – a tremendous contribution to our country being recognized as a reliable partner. The changes in our world must always be recognized as a challenge and a task for the Bundeswehr.

I would like to thank all soldiers as well as the civilian employees of the Bundeswehr. And I would also like to take this opportunity to remember the soldiers who have lost their lives in service, who have fallen. We will not forget them and the painful loss that their families and friends have suffered. We know that being a soldier is a very special profession. And that must also be reflected in the recognition of society as a whole.

2012 seems, when looking at the challenges, almost like an eternity ago. However, the Bundeswehr has been subjected to a permanent process of change since the end of the Cold War. Those who have been involved since that time could probably publish a multi-volume work on reforms by now. It almost shows a piece of history. At that time, it was thought that the great confrontation was over and that there was an opportunity to look forward to a time that was less conflict-ridden. Instead, one must note that the world quickly became more complex and anything but conflict-free. The bipolarity of the Cold War seems, in retrospect, to have been an extremely difficult phase, but also a relatively clear phase. In comparison, although it is sometimes not easy to say, multilateralism actually appears to be something beautiful. But a world with unclear power relations is also a very complicated world. We must prepare for this world.

At that time, after the end of the Cold War, restructuring was rightly undertaken. It was also said that we had a so-called peace dividend. It is indeed important today to tell people and also to discuss in Parliament: During the Cold War, one – I was not there, but sat on the other side of the Iron Curtain or the Wall – provided about 2.3 percent of the gross domestic product for defense spending without complaint in West German society. That was worth it for security. Therefore, the demand that we must eventually spend two percent of our gross domestic product again in a very dangerous world is not completely outside the realm of imagination. We have already spent over 2.3 percent of the gross domestic product under very different conditions.

To show how things have changed: In 2015, we ended up at 1.2 percent of the gross domestic product and thought we could manage quite well with that. Many things had preceded this. Everyone in Europe reduced their defense spending after the end of the Cold War. Then came the great international financial and economic crisis. I still remember very well the budgets with many billions of euros in new debt. We were far from the black zero. I also remember very well that we said: We must reduce the large personnel increase after the reunification of Germany. Today we know that the Bundeswehr made a huge contribution to that. For a decade, almost no new personnel were hired in the civilian sector. There were significant cuts. Added to this was the decision to suspend conscription; a profound decision that – I was recently able to discuss this with leading representatives of the Bundeswehr – opened doors for a new approach in a modern army, but also posed completely new challenges for the Bundeswehr in terms of personnel recruitment. In the coming years, we must also ensure that the Bundeswehr remains an attractive employer – and that in a competition for young people that is really tough given our demographic changes and many other attractive career fields. Therefore, it was right that the Minister, when she took office more than four years ago, placed a strong emphasis on an attractive working environment. When one knows what role work-life balance plays today in the planning of many families – the Bundeswehr wants to be a part of society – then that must also be reflected in it.

In 2011, other things were also happening in the world – for example, what we call the Arab Spring, which subsequently led to massive problems, as we remember the developments in Libya. On the one hand, it is good that there is no longer dictator Gaddafi in Libya. On the other hand, we also had to learn that the absence of dictators alone does not lead to a stable society. We have already experienced this in Iraq. We are still experiencing it today in Libya.

This was followed by the civil war in Syria, which also revolved around the question of how to get rid of Assad, perceived as a tyrannical dictator. The war has since developed into one of the major conflicts. It has only slowly become clear to us that conflicts do not take place somewhere in the world, but right at Europe's doorstep and that these do not necessarily lead to more democracy immediately. We have seen that during the civil war, ISIS spread in Syria and Iraq. In the meantime, it has become a religious conflict between Shiites and Sunnis – and a conflict over spheres of influence in a strategically extremely important region, in which Turkey, Iran, Russia, and of course Saudi Arabia, the USA, and at some point also Europe are involved.

If we thought we could detach ourselves from these events, then the refugee movement in 2015 taught us otherwise. We did not sufficiently care for the situation in the refugee camps. There is an incredible disaster in Syria. Half of the country – over ten million people – are fleeing either within the country or to neighboring countries, such as Turkey – or even to us, although not to a great extent. But this has posed enormous challenges for us. Let me take this opportunity to express my heartfelt thanks to the Bundeswehr – both for the rescue of refugees at sea and for what the Bundeswehr has accomplished internally when help was needed. That is unparalleled. Thank you very much for your quick and unbureaucratic assistance. I still remember my discussions about this with Ursula von der Leyen or with State Secretary Hoofe. That was a great thing; thank you for that.

As if that were not enough: ISIS spread in Iraq and Syria. In March 2014, the occupation of Crimea followed, and then the conflict in eastern Ukraine and its destabilization, so that by September 2014, when we had the NATO summit in Wales, the world had changed. Suddenly, conflicts were taking place right at our doorstep again. Not us in the middle of territorial Europe, but those who are geographically on the edges suddenly faced completely new tasks and also completely new fears and concerns. Thus, the situation was completely different from 2006, when the penultimate White Paper was written. One had more or less resigned oneself to the fact that there would be a lot of foreign deployments, for example in Afghanistan and Kosovo. Since the 1990s, it has been a huge developmental path for the federal government that we no longer – as in the first Iraq War – pay 20 billion Deutsche Marks, but make an active contribution ourselves.

At that time, everything seemed to focus on foreign deployments. And suddenly, the second pillar, which after the end of the Cold War had actually not played a prominent role anymore – national and alliance defense – came back into focus. This was also reflected in the decision made in Wales, according to which defense spending should develop towards two percent over the next ten years. This decision was made by all of us. And that raises the question: What about Germany's credibility? This question is not only posed to the Federal Minister of Defense, but I also get it served on a platter. So we must deal with it.

A discussion has now arisen in which we all – I now address all parliamentarians – need to be a little careful that the development towards two percent is not possibly interpreted as a militarization of Germany. Those who are familiar with the facts – and that includes everyone here in the room – know that these two percent are not a fetish, but that fulfilling the tasks – international deployments plus alliance and national defense – makes this value necessary. This means that a functioning Bundeswehr, a Bundeswehr that does not receive bad news every day, requires more equipment. That is simply the truth.

I also did not know from the beginning, I say quite openly, but I first worked it out with the active help of people who understand defense better than I do, that to fulfill the tasks of a foreign deployment, even for a small part of the troops, very, very good, precise, and secure equipment and supplies are required, but the questions of national and alliance defense are much broader, which is why much better equipment is needed across the board in all areas. There are keywords from which we had strayed quite a bit: for example, the so-called full equipment. As a layperson, one imagines that everyone who serves has their pack of equipment and supplies for what they could be deployed for. One had strayed quite far from this idea. Now, one first needs a mission-appropriate equipment. And that is in national and alliance defense as it is. If one has to deploy quickly, if one has to take on all the new tasks, then one must practice more, must do more things together. This also means that one needs much more material and equipment across the board. I believe that cannot be said often enough. I am not saying this because I think you do not know it, but because my speech is of course also directed at the public.

The decisions made in Wales, in which national and alliance defense plays a larger role again, have also found their way into our White Paper 2016, which the federal government has adopted. They have primarily found their way into very practical measures in which we are actively participating, namely in airspace surveillance in the Baltic States, for example, in the reassurance of Poland and the three Baltic States. We are leading the enhanced forward presence and are working as a framework nation in Lithuania. That is a significant contribution. And we have also strengthened our engagement in the Multinational Corps Northeast in Szczecin. We are engaged in Romania and Bulgaria – always at the edges, where it is about alliance defense. All of this is a great effort. Thank you very much for that.

I want to highlight something else, because this has been a very long deployment – it still fits into the philosophy of 2006 –: the deployment in Afghanistan. Here, something is shown that Germany can be proud of. Some say it takes forever for you to decide where you are going. Yes, sometimes it may take a little longer than with others. But once we are there, we also stay as long as necessary. We have decided – I have politically fought very hard for this; also with President Obama – that there should be no hasty withdrawal from Afghanistan – Afghanistan experienced this once in connection with the Soviet Union – that we should not repeat this mistake – because that would have been exactly what Russia might have wished for – but to stay there.

Our work in northern Afghanistan cannot proceed without the United States of America, that is true. But we are also the framework nation there for around 20 nations, with whom we work very, very well and reliably. Thank you very much for that as well. There, the change in philosophy is clearly evident, which I will address again later, namely that we also take care of training so that the Afghan troops can take their fate into their own hands. But without our support, without our help, they will not succeed.

We still have soldiers in Kosovo. We have just experienced it again in the last few days: One thinks it is quiet and nothing is happening; and suddenly someone is arrested again and the waves rise. I recently had both the President of Kosovo and the President of Serbia as my guests to urgently urge them to advance measures for stabilization. – Christian Schmidt is here; he knows well how much love and attention to detail is required to keep small conflicts small so that they do not escalate and violence does not break out again.

I want to mention a motive that has occupied me greatly in the entire refugee issue. It was clear that Greece could not cope with many refugees on its own. But there was also the danger that the entire Western Balkans would be destabilized if we did not address the problem together with Turkey. This danger has always been present. And that is why the EU-Turkey agreement was absolutely necessary. It was necessary to support Turkey in its care for three million refugees.

In the meantime, the situation in Syria has also worsened further. We are part of the coalition in the fight against ISIS with all the contributions we make both there and in Iraq. Thank you very much for that. This was also associated with a turning point in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany, because until then we had always said: We do not go directly into conflict areas. This time, however, we supported the Peshmerga in their fight to save the Yazidis. And we are involved in airspace surveillance – first in Turkey, now in Jordan.

However, it shows that especially in Syria – we can also take Afghanistan or Libya as examples – there is still a need for other efforts. A conflict cannot be resolved purely militarily. You depend on us to act politically as well. The search for a solution to the conflict in Syria has now reached proportions that a comparison with the Thirty Years' War in Europe is almost not presumptuous, as it has become a deep regional conflict over spheres of influence. To find a political solution, Russia, Turkey, Iran, Saudi Arabia, the USA, Jordan, France, the United Kingdom, and also Germany are needed. At the moment, there are two groups – on the one hand, the so-called Small Group, which includes France, the United Kingdom, Germany, the USA, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. On the other hand, there is the so-called Astana Group, which includes Iran, Turkey, and Russia. All of these are actors that must be worked with. There will be no political solution coming solely from Syria. And only when a solution is found will we have some stability in this region again.

As this year marks the 400th anniversary of the beginning of the Thirty Years' War, I want to point out that the Peace of Westphalia was not created in two months. It took years, long years, during which some parties never spoke to each other. Even when they were in one place – in Münster – not everyone was allowed to speak to everyone. From this, we can draw lessons on how to resolve conflicts. This knowledge will also be needed.

In the meantime, our focus has once again turned strongly to Africa through Libya. The unity government in Libya is weak; it does not have access to the entire territory. Therefore, the conflict has also shifted further into Africa: through a lot of weapons, through the strengthening of numerous terrorist attacks. That is why we are now also engaged in Mali.

I still remember well: Shortly after I became Chancellor, President Chirac asked me if we were ready to secure the elections in Congo. There are certainly people here who remember that well. At that time, I was quite apprehensive, I say quite openly, because Congo was not the field we were particularly familiar with. However, the Bundeswehr managed the mission there wonderfully. But we also made sure that we returned home after the elections were over. And that was not wrong.

You can see from our mission in Mali, especially from the MINUSMA mission, but also from the training mission, how things are going. Terrorist attacks planned by ISIS in Syria harm France – like the attack on "Charlie Hebdo" and other terrorist attacks. France declared a kind of alliance case for the first time in Europe and asked us to help. And suddenly we are in Africa and thus confronted with a completely new challenge. This mission is anything but simple. It must be carried out with great care. The Minister of Defense keeps reminding me that the reconnaissance drones are flying flawlessly and stably there. One can also say something good amidst all the horror news; that is why I am very reassured, because that certainly helps MINUSMA.

Currently, there are a total of twelve foreign missions, 7,100 soldiers, plus operationally equivalent tasks with about 13,000 soldiers – the Bundeswehr is therefore permanently contributing important work in national and alliance defense as well as continuing in foreign missions.

I believe that in light of the events we have heard about in recent days, for example, the termination of the Iran agreement by the United States of America, it is now important that we stay the course and be reliable in our stance and convictions. What does that mean? First, that we do not treat the decisions of 2014 as if they had never been made. But it also means that we should politically strengthen and reaffirm our commitment to alliances, to be a reliable alliance partner, and that we also say: Yes, we are a country that politically stands for multilateralism as the best form to resolve conflicts in the world. That is no longer so clear today. Russia has felt aggrieved by the interpretation of the UN Security Council resolution on Syria, which led to military action in Syria. The Iran agreement was endorsed in the UN Security Council, adopted unanimously in the UN Security Council, but is now being unilaterally terminated. The United States of America has also withdrawn from the Climate Framework Convention. In trade conflicts, we see an increase in protectionism; this means a weakening of the World Trade Organization.

We are now faced with the question: Should we give all this up because it has become more difficult, or should we continue to stand by it? I advocate standing by multilateralism, even if there are crisis-like phenomena in it. This means, however, that we must be all the more reliable in what we promise. Because there is a perspective in the United States of America: We spend 3.4 percent of GDP on defense; we help you protect yourselves, give you security; you have a huge trade surplus with us and are therefore also in a good economic position. Is that actually fair from the American perspective?

We must engage with these questions. That is why I am also not averse to saying – the last major trade agreement was concluded in 1994; since then, the international community has not been able to negotiate new tariffs at all –: Why should we only negotiate trade issues with Canada, Singapore, Japan, and South Korea? We can of course also negotiate with the United States of America; and we are indeed discussing this in the European Union. But we are under pressure and must also be consistent ourselves. That is the task we are currently facing.

Reliable alliance partnership primarily concerns NATO. Germany's firm anchoring in NATO is indispensable. I believe I do not need to convince anyone here of that. Even if there are disagreements on certain issues – those regarding the Iran agreement are not trivial – our firm conviction must be that transatlantic friendship is one of the essential foundations of our security and remains so. This applies to military security. I can say the same for the area of intelligence services; it also applies in a corresponding manner there. Our entire fight against terrorism would be extremely weakened if there were no transatlantic connection. That is why I also thank everyone here very warmly, who contribute through daily actions, through integration into the structures of the alliance to be a good partner in NATO.

The decision of the British to leave the EU is indeed very regrettable. Nevertheless, I am very glad that – sometimes negative events do provide a certain impetus – we are finally tackling a few things that we have not been able to manage in Europe so far. Better defense cooperation in the form of Permanent Structured Cooperation is an important, necessary, long-overdue fulfillment of the Common Security and Defense Policy of the European Union. I would like to sincerely thank Ursula von der Leyen and everyone who has worked on this. This has been set up in a short time – Germany and France were the driving forces here – as an open project for all member states of the European Union. And significant achievements have already been made. That Germany is responsible for four of the seventeen projects that have been agreed upon so far also shows that we are contributing. Perhaps our capabilities are not always sufficient, but what we have, we gladly share within the alliance. And that is why we are also the second-largest troop contributor, if I understood correctly, and are always quite active when something is needed, and are reliable.

This European cooperation is not designed to question or weaken NATO in any way. However, it is necessary. And when Ursula von der Leyen reports on how many weapon systems we are contributing on the European side to the alliance, it shows that there are great inefficiencies and that money could be better spent and new weapon systems could also be developed together. That is absolutely right and important. And if you, as Chancellor, are fighting for the Eurofighter all over the world, but there has always been someone before you talking about Rafale, then that is sometimes almost anachronistic. So, if it should succeed – which one could almost smell at the International Aerospace Exhibition in Schönefeld – that there will soon be a joint development, then that would certainly not harm Europe's reputation in the world, but rather strengthen us. That is how we should operate together.

What is sometimes not fully understood is that the development of weapon systems has a rather long, almost generational history. And just as the bulletproof vest should perhaps be procured a bit faster, one must have the long breath and also the predictability in financial resources when embarking on new projects. It has really made sense to me what Ursula von der Leyen has repeatedly said in recent days: If one is committed to long-term international community projects and they may also take on their own price development, which we want to prevent in the future, then again – the Bundeswehr has such a nice term for it – prioritization must be adjusted. This is actually an anachronism because then everything that can be postponed for another six months is pushed back again; and that is of course not good. Therefore, reliability must be integrated into the entire planning to achieve both things: the daily matters and the long-term matters.

In addition, as everywhere in our society, digitalization is an additional driver of change within the Bundeswehr. Anyone who has ever dealt with the standardization of data processing structures in their ministry can imagine what that means for such a large organization. I would say: The German Bundestag is also not an unrestricted front-runner in all innovations, and it is still a small entity compared to the Bundeswehr. There, one must also be able to work reliably.

In addition, there is a new pillar that is also reflected in a new command, namely the engagement with cybersecurity issues, of which we know that other countries, which obviously include hybrid warfare in their military doctrine, are very, very active. We cannot wait in this regard; rather, in order to be defensible, we must also be involved in the area of cybersecurity. I want to congratulate the Bundeswehr for having accomplished a great deal in recent years that is absolutely necessary.

We must therefore be loyal alliance partners. We are friends of the networked approach. This is also why European security and defense policy is so important, as it allows us to better connect the military component, the development component, and the good governance component. We know: Mali, Afghanistan, Syria – all these countries can be maintained militarily in a security, albeit a fragile one; but lasting security only arises when development is possible. Security and development are interdependent. That is why in our coalition agreement for this government, the 1:1 coupling of ODA and defense expenditures is not just a nice thing – so that one knows who receives how much money – but it also reflects the philosophy that security and development are closely linked. Therefore, I consider this stipulation to be very, very important.

One area that has also sparked many discussions, but is perhaps not currently in focus, which is also very important to me: the empowerment of others. We have experienced that German soldiers are good in Mali, but they are best when they are deployed to train Malian soldiers, and that we have made better progress in Afghanistan since we have been training the soldiers ourselves, and that we will not enjoy long-term acceptance for our engagement if the countries themselves are not empowered. Therefore, I very much hope that Europe will accept capacity-building initiatives much more strongly – and that we will also be a bit more honest in this regard. When soldiers are trained in Mali, receive shoes from us, and get a transport truck from us, the question arises: Do they also receive rifles from us? Training soldiers who have no weapons to counter the opponents they must fight – in this case, very often terrorists – and then saying that perhaps France will take care of that for us is not a very honest approach. I believe we need to continue this discussion.

Of course, we also need to build in securities so that, for example, the Peshmerga do not sell their "Milans" or that they do not fall into the hands of enemies. This again leads back to the development aspect, because if one ensures that the soldiers receive decent pay, that they are paid in a way that their families can live on, that they are practically not forced to engage in illegal activities to secure their own livelihoods, then one can also insist that the weapon systems remain where they are. That is why we are now also working with France and many others to support the soldiers in the G5 Sahel states in the fight against terrorism. They say: Look, MINUSMA has a mandate that is not sufficient; it is Chapter 5, but it is not Chapter 7. In their opinion, a Chapter 7 mandate is needed; they have not yet received that from the UN. But they now want to establish an anti-terror force. We must and want to help them with this anti-terror force with the know-how we can provide.

In principle, that is correct. But when you speak with the president of one of the poorest countries in the world – Niger – he says: Look, you give me development aid, you – the World Bank, Europe, Germany – give me everything, but no one gives me anything for the security of my country; I need to maintain security and be able to fight terrorism, for which I receive very little financial support. Therefore, collecting financial support is also part of the initiative led by Europe, so that the soldiers can be paid and their equipment financed, so they can fight terrorists there. And I believe them that the people from the African states – I do not want to offend anyone – are at least as good as the soldiers of MINUSMA, who, by the way, do not even have the mandate for that. This is also a very important part that, in my opinion, will gain significance and in which Germany is also very, very strongly engaged.

You keep the whole thing running continuously. We have a lot of work ahead of us. You will discuss all of this. But I believe we must now be careful – I want to contribute to this, and the entire federal government wants to contribute to this – that we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Bundeswehr in a balanced and reasonable discourse and do not rush from one alarming report to another. This means that there is medium- and long-term reliability.

You can be assured that the federal government does not rely solely on the Bundeswehr. Of course, we are proud to have it, but we also rely on reducing conflicts through political contributions, thereby making deployments unnecessary. This is also behind the candidacy for a non-permanent seat on the UN Security Council for 2019/20, where we believe we have quite good chances.

I want to tell you: You enjoy recognition. Of course, you are challenged. Be of good courage. I consider the principle of internal leadership to be a great principle even in the 21st century. You have young people who are very motivated. And we know that you must be an attractive employer. In this sense, I wish your conference much success and us continued good cooperation. Thank you very much.