Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress "Africa and Germany: Sustainable Partnership on Equal Terms" on June 17, 2009 in ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

20 June 2009 · CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress "Africa and Germany: Sustainable Partnership on Equal Terms"

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU Parliamentary Group Congress on Africa and Germany in Berlin on June 17, 2009, outlining Germany's commitment to African development amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Germany-Africa partnership, development cooperation, Millennium Development Goals, global financial crisis impact on Africa, G20 and multilateral response, private investment withdrawal from developing countries, World Bank infrastructure guarantees, good governance, refugee movements, win-win economic interdependence, CDU/CSU Africa policy
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,931
91st percentile
Sentences
207
90th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%30%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Geopolitical 23%22%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

207 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

dear Volker Kauder,

dear colleagues,

dear guests, who are here today in high numbers and with high rank,

I am very pleased to have come to this Africa Congress. I would like to extend my heartfelt thanks to Christian Ruck and Hartwig Fischer.

Yesterday, another picture hung in our parliamentary group room. It depicted a cow in a German meadow. Volker Kauder was so enthusiastic about it. I then said: I hope that it will be replaced again for the Africa Congress. Thank God that has happened.

I hope that when you see Africa on the map, you can easily outline the over 50 states and know how they are positioned relative to each other. Hartwig Fischer, Christian Ruck, and Arnold Vaatz, I suspect, would manage that quite well. I checked again yesterday to confirm that Togo is indeed next to Benin. When I received the President of Togo, I asked him about his relationship with his colleague in Benin, whom I also know quite well. He promptly replied that the relationship is better than the German-French friendship, to which I had to tell him that he, as I believe, does not know as much about the German-French friendship as to make such a simple statement. There is much to be said about that.

In any case, I believe that this is an important congress at a time when there is every reason to continually affirm Africa's concerns and not to lose sight of Africa. For we are in a time of significant economic difficulties, indeed global economic difficulties. I have often said that the question of what the international financial market crisis and the international economic crisis will bring emotionally affects me deeply, because so many hopes can be destroyed by it. These are also hopes that we had here in Germany. Many workers here have foregone wage increases, accepted reforms so that we can become more competitive, so that our economic situation improves. We then experienced – we had fewer than three million unemployed – that even we, in a country with relatively much prosperity, are now facing a situation where, from the perspective of many people, everything starts all over again due to the crisis.

When one focuses on the African continent and looks at what is happening there now, one finds that there are countries for which what Prime Minister Tsvangirai from Zimbabwe said applies, whom I asked about the effects of the crisis. He said: When you are as low as we are, this crisis cannot harm you anymore; but it will probably make it harder for us to rise and find a reasonable path.

Other African countries have been on a very exciting path. Africa has had good economic rates recently. We have concluded very important agreements regarding development cooperation. We have developed the Millennium Goals together. It requires the greatest efforts to achieve these goals. Nevertheless, it is true that this will not become easier now, because we must ensure that the sums we spend on development cooperation are not reduced, but rather increased, which will not always be easy in the coming years, also because much private engagement, many private investments will no longer be as available. We are experiencing something that I have not encountered before, but which evidently happens in many crises, namely that at the moment when there are declines in global economic growth, capital is withdrawn very quickly from emerging and developing countries. We must counter this.

That is why I have also advocated strongly – although this was one of the more difficult parts of our stimulus program – that of the 50 billion euros that the stimulus package II encompasses, an additional 100 million euros be made available for our contribution to development cooperation for the World Bank, because the World Bank wants to establish an investment guarantee program, essentially a guarantee umbrella, to ensure that already promised infrastructure projects in Africa or in developing countries do not fail, but can continue to be realized through guarantees.

I am deeply convinced that it is important for us to do these things. I am also very pleased that we have succeeded in agreeing on a significant part of measures at the G20 summit in London that also benefit developing and emerging countries – out of the awareness that this is not only a charitable good deed, but represents a win-win situation for us, because our markets of the future are in emerging and developing countries. Therefore, our fate in Europe is closely linked to the fate of, for example, Africa. We also see this in the movements of refugees. If we do not succeed in bringing the countries of Africa to a reasonable standard of living, to good governance, then we will not be able to live in Europe as peacefully as we might have during times when globalization had not yet tightly bound us together. Therefore, it is certainly important to keep the idea of development cooperation in mind, but of course also to always ask the question: How do we do this?

What I was just briefly informed about from the discussion already highlights two important aspects. One aspect is: One must be able to rely on our commitments. I know that Germany is not so bad, but we also objectively and individually have all the trouble in keeping our international commitments. I always say: I apparently belong to the political generation that must implement the commitments that others could perhaps still give relatively easily. When 0.51 percent and 0.7 percent were mentioned, that seemed quite far away. We have a benchmark regarding the share of gross national income and ODA cooperation, which can also be questioned. If Germany has a minus six percent in gross domestic product, then we can, of course, perhaps increase our percentage in the ODA quota with correspondingly less development aid.

Another specificity of development aid is that debt relief is counted just like the money that is actually made available for the future. This means that if you no longer have a country that needs debt relief, it is much more difficult to meet the ODA quota than if many African countries are in debt. Then one can always make a debt relief rhythm.

However, this cannot mean that we wish for many African countries to become indebted now so that we can more easily meet our ODA quota in ten years. So, the matter has its pitfalls and edges. I always advocate at the OECD that not only development politicians should determine what development aid is, but that perhaps other policy areas should also occasionally be involved, because otherwise the question of what we do where is treated very strangely. That we have supported stable elections in the Congo with the help of our armed forces is not a development policy chargeable achievement. But that should not mean that if we do something else – for example, build two roads in the Congo – and if the elections go awry, causing the roads to fall into disrepair, we can then say that we have increased our ODA quota. From my perspective, that is still not logical.

A second logical problem: We have the Millennium Development Goals that we must implement, but we have a development aid structure in Germany that does not make the coordination of the approaches to achieve these goals easy. Parliament, the Bundestag factions largely say: If we are already doing development cooperation, we would like to do it bilaterally and want to know from Germany's side: What is happening with our money?

One must always try to put oneself in the perspective of an African head of state. I recently spoke with the President of Mozambique and asked him: How can it succeed that when many well-meaning countries – 40, 50 in the world, each with a host of non-governmental organizations – want to fulfill their Millennium Goals and come to you with 150 preconceived opinions and want to do this and that, all of this can be brought together?

If you are lucky, you have good relations with UNEP or other organizations that organize such things for a country. If you are unlucky and do not have that, then you have to try to coordinate these questions with many government agencies. We could, in this context, think again about the mechanisms of our development aid in the next legislative period and also need to enter into a friendly dialogue with our NGOs. Because if we set state goals and, for example, say we want to achieve the Millennium Development Goal of primary school attendance in ten countries, it may well be that we have non-governmental organizations that say: But we have something else planned; we want to focus on water supply, agriculture, or health.

This means it is about the question: How can we reconcile the generally pledged things with the internal activities, wishes, and historical ties to certain countries so that what we have all set out to achieve really comes to fruition in Africa? This is one of the most wondrous processes for me. I have found that the Norwegians do this relatively systematically by concentrating on certain countries. But that also means that we must coordinate among the countries and develop certain types of partnerships. We have now found a way to do this in the German Bundestag. However, this has been decided more according to our ideas. If now all European countries were to come to the same conclusion about which countries they want to maintain partnerships with and which not, there would be a multitude of African countries that could not participate at all. Therefore, I always advocate in the European Union that we also set certain priorities so that not some countries fall through the cracks.

In the meantime, we have foundations that operate worldwide, which can often pursue goals more clearly because they have money without parliamentary control mechanisms, without a multitude of NGOs clinging to them. We must be careful that the reputation of states does not end up being worse than the reputation of – whom I greatly appreciate – foundations.

There are various development approaches of states. We know that our partners in China pursue a development policy that partly follows different principles than ours, but is also partly more effective. I have spoken with many African heads of state and always asked about China. It is known that China also does not give anything away, that China has interests. But if you need a stadium, need to electrify a city, or need a road, you are dealing with a very results-oriented implementation with China, while in Europe you have to be careful not to lose another process over the third tender and still have nothing happen after five years. In private conversations, many already tell you: Be careful, when the need is greatest, I will send my minister to Beijing. Then he calls me from there and tells me when it will start.

We Europeans should be interested in achieving comparable framework conditions for development cooperation. We are partly in discussions with the Chinese and also with other emerging countries about this. India is also becoming more engaged. By the way, there is a lot to learn from Japan as well. This means that if we mean well with Africa, we coordinate ourselves a bit before we start and also develop a mechanism that does not make it impossible to ultimately achieve the Millennium Goals.

However, there are difficulties with multilateral organizations. Many are extremely inefficient. We have provided significant funds to the UN and a food fund from Europe for this year and next year – after last year's high food prices. If you want to know after half a year how that went exactly, where the money ended up, and what became of it, I can only say: A labyrinth is nothing against it. One hopes that everything has arrived where it should have. But that is far from transparency.

When I look at how foundations, for example, the "Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation," report on what they do with their money and how it goes, and everyone can transparently follow it, because otherwise no one would donate anymore, then, I would say, they are much further along. We had organized a large foundation congress in another context. From the American foundations, perhaps also from others, one can learn a lot about how to set incentives to make development aid transparent. That is now our part.

Now comes the question: How is this actually supposed to work on the African side, for those who receive aid? I find it right to involve the partners to a large extent and let them express how they would like it to be. Because there is often the danger that we believe we have a correct idea of it. Certain mechanisms – government negotiations, discussing projects – are very important and correct. I believe it is also of no small significance that the African countries in the African Union – for example, with the African Peer Review Mechanism – have developed a control system for themselves to also question: How well are we actually doing? It is about the fact that we – so to speak, the richer side of the world – are not always the donors and evaluators, but that the evaluation is carried out from another perspective.

Now, in long discussions with our African colleagues, we have often talked about the fact that it is a very difficult and, for us, partly unimaginable path that there is suddenly a neutral institution beyond one's own government that – I say this a bit loosely in German – spits in the soup, that criticizes, evaluates, praises, or admonishes. After decades or even longer periods of colonialism, one was glad to have first achieved self-determination over one's own country. And now we Europeans come and say: Yes, but if you want to do it really well, then you need to set up a group that will tell you whether you were good or bad. Some initially perceived this more as an insult or as a constant application of distrust towards their own governmental responsibility. We in Europe have become more humble in this regard. From the Federal Court of Auditors to countless expert commissions, we are criticized every day. When there is a lot of criticism, there is also the danger that it is no longer taken seriously. There cannot be too many groups, otherwise they will never find a common opinion. But I find this process very, very important.

I find the establishment of the African Union equally important, which is, of course, a difficult matter. We in the European Union have slowly grown from six to 27. That is already not easy today. You are 51. If everyone wants to speak, it takes even longer than in the European Union; for us, it is already extensive. In this respect, this is certainly an important experience. But I can only encourage all African states to continue on the path of the African Union. They must pool their voices.

Discussions in Africa must also be conducted controversially. This is not always easy either. The question of how much I interfere in the national sovereignty of another also means: If the other does not like something about me, he will also interfere. This is a permanent problem that has accompanied us as Europeans for many years, since the over 50 years of existence of the Treaty of Rome, and which can only be overcome if there are very firm rules, if one does not insult each other, has respect for one another, does not define every disagreement as a matter of honor and then reacts emotionally, and if one also knows that one must yield to majorities. That is worth the sweat of the noble.

And I think that when we talk about our future missions beyond development cooperation, for example, also about creating peace, I would always prefer the idea that we as Europeans, with our European Security and Defense Policy, empower Africa to carry out its own missions rather than getting too involved ourselves and ultimately not being able to cope with many specifics. But for that, a much more structured collaboration would need to take place. We must honestly say – the Bundeswehr has done this outstandingly in the Congo, for example: We often know too little about the cultures, the history, the ethnicities, the tribal relations. We have an incredible amount to learn when we talk about Africa. Some blanket judgments completely fall apart when, for example, Hartwig Fischer takes the floor and tells us something about the Congo, for instance, about the differences between East Congo and the capital.

This means that the success of globalization and development cooperation, as well as the acceptance of development cooperation, will depend on whether we succeed in bringing development cooperation a little out of the niche in our own parliaments, in our own political public, and making it a very classic necessity for knowledge that one has in the 21st century. In this regard, I ask our African partners to speak openly with us – for sometimes we do not even know how to ask the right questions – and then also to report on what drives them.

In our work in Afghanistan, which is anything but easy, we have essentially approached an understanding of cooperation with countries that need support, which we summarize in the term of interconnected security. This has led to ministries in Germany having to work together that have not done so for decades – the Ministry of the Interior due to police training, the Ministry for Development Cooperation, in the case of Afghanistan also the Ministry of Defense, and of course the Foreign Office. I believe it will be very important, also from the German or European side, to overcome the reservations that have grown and been nurtured between a Ministry for Development Cooperation and a Ministry of Defense over decades, so that we do not unload our own complexes onto you when we work together.

We have a certain idea of foreign policy, a certain idea of cooperation. We know: police training is necessary today. We are doing this in several countries. – I looked at this with great interest in Liberia. – This must be advanced.

In this context, I also ask that we develop a benchmark system. What is achieved in the respective country with every dollar or euro that we give as development aid? If we want to achieve the Millennium Goals, we cannot avoid looking at what really comes out of it. I have already spoken – perhaps not understandable for non-experts – about the fact that this also requires some changes in our development organizations. The GTZ receives a mandate, okay, but the NGOs have their own ideas. We must think regionally or country-oriented. One cannot advance school education but neglect health. This means that one must essentially develop a development plan for a specific region and then find organizations that can implement it.

Then there are, of course, infrastructure services that cannot be easily provided by smaller aid organizations. There must also be a commitment to this, then it must be said: To develop an area, one also needs a major road. In Afghanistan, they have now managed to build a large ring road through the entire country and piece together many small sections so that the ring road closes in the north, thus forming a ring. That was an eternal puzzle.

If one asks who the most convenient partner is, it is of course always those who can also deploy strong partners with a strong government grip if necessary, who then get started and create something visible. Therefore, it will be very important that we also talk with the African countries about how they envision all of this, and perhaps sometimes also point out the wounds and insist that we need to make some progress.

What I always admire in conversations with African colleagues is that they have an incredibly good knowledge of questions such as: How much is electrified, how many school children are there, how is the health care? And so on. Therefore, one should actually have a good basis to say: Come, let’s sit down and make a plan for how we can really make progress in the coming years. I believe we can still significantly improve efficiency.

There is now the danger that with the international financial market and economic crisis, the situation could arise that we are all preoccupied with ourselves and that we see many things only from the mercantile, economic perspective. But thank God we have people like Rupert Neudeck and Bob Geldof and others who remind us and our development politicians that we should not focus solely on that.

What worries me is the question: How is Africa represented, for example, in the G20 discussions, where a future cooperation structure could already be established? South Africa is involved, Saudi Arabia is involved. But not everyone in Africa is convinced that Africa is well represented by this. Now Gordon Brown did the right thing and included NEPAD with its chairman, Prime Minister Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia. I believe this is very important. The AU presidency is now held by the Libyan president. I sometimes hear from Africa that this is not yet the epitome of African representation in every matter. I do not want to interfere, but in short: If NEPAD is involved, that may not be a mistake. Because we must, if we now establish important rules as G20 – you know that I am working on this, that we do not just say that hedge fund A must be regulated in this way and rating agency B must function in that way and financial supervision must be like this – tackle the evil at its root and say: Ultimately, we have lived beyond our means, have perpetuated that, have taken on ever greater risks, and have thus plunged the world into quite a bit of misfortune.

So we need not only sustainable biodiversity protection and sustainable climate protection, but we also need a charter for sustainable economic practices. I envision that we develop such a charter through the G20 process – that does not look so bad; the willingness to do so is there – and then feed this into a UN mechanism through the many regional alliances that exist in the world. I believe that just as we have a World Security Council that deals with security issues, we essentially also need a World Economic Council that deals with the fundamental principles of economics. No one should now think that I want to revive ECOSOC; it will not manage that. But there is a need for an institution. In my opinion, it can only be based at the UN so that it really gains legitimacy. This is a tough nut to crack. It will not happen tomorrow, but I will advocate that especially the countries of Africa show themselves open to this.

Now comes a point that I also want to address: Many developing and also emerging countries are afraid that when we come with thoughts of sustainability, we only intend to cut the growth of those who still need and want to grow. That would be far too short-sighted. We must change – that is completely clear – in terms of sustainability, energy consumption, and much more. But a continent like Africa will suffer increasingly under climate change and should therefore do everything possible to bring the entire world into a community of responsibility, and not consider at every step: What do they want to prohibit us now? Otherwise, their development will be much more severely affected than ours. When you travel to South Africa or other countries, you can see that today the costs for adapting to climate change are already immensely high – added to that is population growth – so it is in the fundamental interest of Africa to reach agreements at this point and to force the world community into shared responsibility.

I believe that we need to learn to think anew in various respects. It is a fundamental task of our political generation and perhaps even the next to shape globalization in a humane way and also institutionally. Since the environmental agreement of Rio in 1992, when for the first time the representatives of the world came together in the form of heads of state and government, we have concluded various agreements that, from the perspective of many, are essentially situated in a limited and rather perceived as a side area. I am not saying that it is a side area; I am just saying that many have thought so, along the lines of: Let them do it – Rio, biodiversity, a bit of species protection and biopatents and climate, well.

What we are experiencing now with the international financial market crisis shows us that globalization is also hitting hard in the core areas of the industrialized countries. When one behaves improperly, the damage is passed on to everyone, which is always associated with the danger that those who were less involved in causing the damage will pay more. Therefore, it is, so to speak, completely clear in the fundamental areas of politics, as we understand them, that we cannot do without a managed globalization – in Germany, we call this Social Market Economy – thus an order of the international community, something like guardrails, so that not everyone can do whatever they want.

In this context, the G20 process is very important. It is also important that Africa is included in a comprehensive sense. For this, it is crucial that Africa defines its interests collectively. Because we are also experiencing this in the European Union: When we are not united, both a large country like China and a large country like the United States regularly take this as an opportunity to weaken our position. However, when Europe is united, it can achieve something. Therefore, for me, the cooperation between the EU and the African Union is of great significance, because I believe that you can also take something from us and learn how to represent your interests collectively. Otherwise, you will be played off against each other quite harshly. And that will not benefit the continent, nor will it benefit us. In this sense, development cooperation will remain a very exciting field in the coming years.

I would like to add: I am not in favor of mixing this with foreign policy, because I believe that foreign policy is a very interest-driven policy and is shaped from the perspective of one's own country, while development cooperation should take the interests of others more into account. I rather believe that the entire area of environment and development cooperation could be brought even closer together, that there is much to be done, and that the partnership approach of development cooperation should not be undermined. – Polite, restrained applause from my development policy colleagues; I can see that we will certainly need to discuss this further.

Overall, this congress – I want to make this clear again as the German Federal Chancellor – is meant to tell you, who are either engaged in Africa, have a heart for Africa, or come from Africa: For us, the African continent is part of the future of the world. We are neighbors, we are all sitting in the same boat, relying on each other in a comprehensive sense, and we can learn a lot from one another.

Anyone who reads the biography of Barack Obama, as I have just done, and learns that his sister from Kenya studied in Heidelberg, that they talked about Heidelberg when he visited Kenya, and how we Germans are perceived there, will find it incredibly interesting, as I do, because we can all learn something from it. On the one hand, the sister describes that everything in Germany is so orderly that one has to take care of everything alone, and while this works quite well, it can also be quite lonely.

On the other hand, she describes the sadness when the entire extended family descends upon her as someone who has studied abroad and is somewhat better off than the rest of the family, bringing expectations and wishes to her, and she somehow feels desperate and says: My God, if only you hadn’t gone abroad, then you would be standing here like everyone else and wouldn’t have to constantly fulfill all these wishes and ask yourself: Was it even worth it? Perhaps one could also be led to the point where, if one comes from Africa, one no longer wants to learn certain things because one might have more problems than if one had stayed where one was.

I am concerned with mutual understanding, with the happiness of the large family of Africa, where we often ask from our prosperity: How can they manage that there? Understanding that with our prosperity we have also sometimes become quite lonely people, but that we want to help you in Africa so that prosperity can prevail while still preserving a bit of family togetherness, is one of the most exciting civilizational tasks that is enjoyable to work on. I thank everyone who is committed to this and wish us many more successful Africa congresses.