Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Congress of the Federal Association of Energy and Water Management e.V. (BDEW) on June 24, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 June 2009 · Congress of the Federal Association of Energy and Water Management (BDEW) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the inaugural BDEW Congress in Berlin on June 24, 2009, speaking on energy, water management, and climate policy before the German energy and water industry association.
Main themes
Energy and climate protection, water management, European Union energy policy, CO2 emissions reduction, export opportunities in environmental sector, public services, German industrial competitiveness, international climate negotiations, wastewater management, BDEW association founding, European Commission cooperation, good governance
Duration
~36 min
87th percentile
Words
4,263
87th percentile
Sentences
215
90th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%41%
  • Environmental 17%17%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

215 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Schmitz,

dear José Manuel Barroso,

dear Hildegard Müller,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here today at the BDEW Congress, which is a premiere, as your association has not been around for long. It took a long time for you to come together under one roof in autumn 2007 with very different actors in the fields of electricity, gas, water, wastewater, and district heating. I believe the decision was the right one, at least from a political perspective. This way, it is possible for us to speak with a few representatives of your interests, and therefore these discussions are more productive and easier in the hope of achieving a somewhat more orderly picture in the event of conflicting interests.

However, I know that describing the association in its diversity means that the bundling of interests will not always be straightforward. But the fact that the founding took place shows good will and also the recognition that a unified negotiating line is necessary at both the European and national levels in order to achieve something.

The areas you are dealing with are not only current but also comprehensively describe what people understand by public services. On the other hand – as Mr. Schmitz has just hinted – these are highly innovative and economically exciting fields. They are areas in which our country can increase its prosperity if we tackle this correctly.

It is always nice when one can say to someone: Let us be. Nothing could be further from my mind than not letting you be. I just told my neighbor, the President of the European Commission: If he lets me, I will let you. We are not here to find a scapegoat when something does not work, but simply to discuss how we can develop our common interests. It is perfectly clear that important decisions in the areas of energy, water, and wastewater are made not only internationally but that the industrial location Germany also depends nationally on the type of policy we pursue here.

I would like to take a closer look at the various areas and say upfront: In almost all areas, but especially in the field of energy and climate protection, we are working intensively with the European Commission. I believe we also agree: If we want to achieve something internationally, we need the united voice of Europe to defend our concerns together against those in the world who, for example, have significant backlogs in climate protection.

I would therefore like to start with a thank you to José Manuel Barroso, who has motivated the 27 member states, especially in the area of climate protection, to enter international negotiations with a clear common position. Europe is a pioneer in this field. Europe can also make demands on others. But we do this with the awareness that we cannot be so much of a pioneer that we create significant distortions of competition to the detriment of the German economy or the European economy. Taking this into account will always be part of our negotiation strategy.

In this context, I would also like to say something about climate protection. Currently, around 15 percent of global CO2 emissions come from the European Union. Even if we were to emit no CO2 within the European Union, the world's climate problem would not be solved. This means: Yes to being a pioneer, but inclusion in international negotiations.

Let me start with the topic of water management. I believe that Germany is an outstanding guarantor of high-quality drinking water supply and wastewater disposal, and we therefore have a very good reputation internationally. This means that we can and should use this as an export hit.

We know that in the entire environmental sector – which also includes the question of the type and quality of wastewater disposal – legislation and investment opportunities are closely linked. We will need to continue working to ensure that we have close cooperation between politics and water management, especially in emerging and developing countries, where modern water management is still beyond realization, so that we can implement our models, including "Good Governance," meaning good legislation, and thus also open up export markets for ourselves.

We have traditionally had a bit of a catch-up to do in the Federal Republic of Germany because others are very keen to use our studies and then open up export markets for themselves. Theory and practice must therefore come closer together here. I am ready to establish the necessary contacts for the federal government so that we can better utilize the export opportunities we have in this area in the coming years.

I believe that you have taken the right path with the modernization strategy for German water management. You are willing to conduct a voluntary performance comparison and further develop the industry image of German water management, which provides a comprehensive overall picture of the performance of German water management. I believe that the cooperation platform "German Water Partnership" bundles interests towards foreign countries very well.

The question of water and wastewater prices has already decided some municipal elections. Therefore, I would not shy away from a performance comparison but would always consider how I can best handle it. It is important for citizens to have a secure supply. But it is also important to have an affordable supply. In this regard, one should not hesitate to make comparisons repeatedly in both rural and urban areas.

Recently, at least in our regions, we have talked less about water and more about gas. The President of the European Commission will have said something about this. He spent the turn of the year making many phone calls to Russia and Ukraine. We have managed to find a temporary solution. However, we cannot currently give a complete all-clear regarding supply security concerning gas supply to Europe and thus also to Germany, as well as to many other countries. We will need to continue talking with Ukraine. We will need to continue talking with the Russian side. Of course, we have become very aware of the dependency in which we live.

Two weeks ago, your association invited companies and government representatives to a European gas conference. The aim was to find means and ways for Europe to better prepare for gas crises. We, as member states, feel extraordinarily committed to this task together with the Commission. This includes that if we want to be a unified energy market, in my opinion, we need different companies that secure their sources in different ways. It also includes that we have a network in Europe that enables solidarity within the European Union – which does not yet exist today – and that we procure as diversified offers for the European Union as possible. This means that we do not rely on a single supplier but establish supply on various pillars.

Germany has always done well with having an energy mix. It is equally important to open up many supply sources. Therefore, I believe that we do not need a competitive struggle between the various pipelines. The Nord Stream pipeline, the South Stream pipeline, and the Nabucco pipeline can coexist very well. The scenarios regarding the dependency of the member states of the European Union on gas supplies from outside in the next ten, 20, 30 years clearly show: Due to the depletion of classical gas sources, it will be necessary to open up new sources. Therefore, we should work with equal energy on the various pipeline systems.

We need to change a number of political convictions when we look at how difficult it is, in part, to make the Nord Stream variant acceptable among the member states of the European Union. I want to make it very clear today: We are ready for energy solidarity with our neighbor Poland. We have offered that the Nord Stream pipeline could possibly supply gas to Poland again, and we will create the technical facilities for that. Where this cannot be done by the providers for economic reasons, we are ready to help and support in both the electricity and gas sectors to build connection pipelines that are truly necessary. Therefore, individual infrastructure projects should not be played off against each other. This is of utmost importance for the gas sector.

But we also face enormous challenges regarding electricity supply. Here, the topic of a unified European electricity market is a very important issue, which culminates in the fact that we need to better expand the interconnectors in many cases. We still have significant difficulties when we think, for example, of the Iberian Peninsula and its integration into the European electricity grid and the question of how we can supply energy from Poland or Germany to the Baltic countries. In the question of how the Scandinavian countries can help the Baltic countries, there are a number of necessary investment projects that we are working on, for which we are very grateful to the Commission for making proposals. It has also made a number of proposals in connection with the stimulus programs that we are implementing, and we say: Let us accelerate infrastructure projects that we will need anyway in the next ten, 20 years and thus establish the uniformity of European providers.

In this context, I want to make it clear: Germany should stick to its idea of an energy mix. As a major industrial nation, we should not only focus on supplying our own needs. If we are integrated into the European electricity generation system and occasionally export electricity, that is nothing to be ashamed of. We are a major exporting nation. We do not need to count our electrons that we produce to ensure that we do not produce one more than we might consume ourselves.

Moreover, we should also be aware that as the country with the highest share of renewable energies in continental Europe, we are of course also dependent on actively participating in the European trading of electricity exchanges. Renewable energies have improved in terms of base load capability, but they are still not so base load capable that we would not rely on close exchange with other European partners.

I do not need to emphasize again that I am in favor of extending the operating time of existing nuclear power plants. This will certainly play a role in the political debates of the coming months. Germany has the safest nuclear power plants. We should use the safety of our nuclear power plants as an opportunity to think about extending their operating time. I say again: I am in favor. But there are differing opinions on this within the federal government.

We have seen in the case of Sweden that they have rethought their position, that they have decided differently today than they did years ago, and are now renewing their nuclear power plants. However, I also say: Nuclear energy alone will not solve our electricity generation problems.

Therefore, it is necessary to save energy with energy and vigor. This includes, above all, the renovation programs in the area of building renovation. The entire heating market is still in its infancy regarding CO2 savings. We can achieve a great deal here. I believe that the funding programs of the federal government in recent years have significantly motivated investments. They are part of our stimulus programs.

By increasing the generation of renewable energies – after all, we have the goal of covering 20 percent of our total energy consumption with renewable energies by 2020 – we will achieve a shift in the locations where electricity is generated and the locations where electricity is needed. This means that we will have significant shifts regarding investments in networks and electricity transmission. This means we need – and the legal foundations have been created for this – a rapid expansion of new energy transmission capacities.

We are at a point where I have spoken a great deal with the European Commission in recent months. Not only have I spoken with them, but many others have as well. We encounter very different traditions in the European Union. I want to make it clear: We want a competition of providers. This means that customers must have the opportunity to choose their electricity producers.

However, we do not believe that simply unbundling will necessarily lead to better competition than a combination of generation and transmission, although we absolutely support the demand for transparency that prohibits the calculation of energy generation and energy transmission as a single entity.

We have succeeded in finding a third way of unbundling that envisions independent network operators, but does not mean a complete legal separation of ownership. I would like to advocate that we do not call this into question with next steps, for example by looking at municipal networks and going through the same procedure there.

It is very, very important to make it clear at this point that we want competition, but that we also need investments in transmission networks. Of course, I am concerned when we get entangled in many discussions about how our future energy transmission network will be structured, whether we will have a German Network AG or something similar, and in the end, this might lead to the state having to acquire shares in such a network AG again because we would not trust the conceivable capital-rich owners. We would really be trading with lemons if that were to happen. To be honest, I want a private sector solution to these questions and not a state solution. I certainly do not want that at the federal level. It is different at the municipal level.

We have passed the Energy Transmission Expansion Act. I hope that the promised investments will finally be made. I want to say that quite clearly. We have been promised many things for years. Now the legal foundations are in place. There are also many points of contention there again. I do not want to dwell on the topic of underground cables today.

It is evident that there are a multitude of concerns and fears in the population regarding the entire energy sector that we must address in shaping our energy mix. I am somewhat astonished – I want to say this today – that the entire discussion about climate protection has somewhat led to the impression that energy generation without the creation of CO2 will be possible in the foreseeable future. That is not possible in Germany in the foreseeable future. We are working to increase this share. But we will not be able to completely exit the coal industry. We will also need coal-fired power plants in the future, specifically new and efficient coal-fired power plants. I strongly advise that this be stated at this point.

Here, I ask the municipal representatives to speak uniformly in their association. On the one hand, of course, one wants to have efficient power plants. On the other hand, municipal parliamentary meetings, district councils, or similar bodies in the region often strongly oppose the construction of such power plants across party lines.

On the other hand, there is also the discussion about CCS technology, that is, the storage of CO2, which we are currently discussing with great vigor. This technology will certainly not solve the entire CO2 problem. That is beyond question. But if Germany is unable to participate in the pilot projects for this because we encounter barriers again, we must understand at the national level that this poses a significant threat to coal technology as a whole. The issues are very closely interconnected. However, I also say that it makes no sense to create a legal basis for CCS technology that complicates everything we have just made easier in the construction of other infrastructure projects. This means we must be consistent in the way we implement infrastructure projects in Germany regarding CCS technology, otherwise we will end up in a situation where we might agree to things regarding CCS technology, but then we are told that we have to rethink everything again regarding underground cables, high-voltage lines, and roads. For example, this includes the reversal of the burden of proof and similar issues. These are profound questions regarding infrastructure expansion.

Therefore, I say: If we can no longer clarify these questions, it is better to leave them alone than to introduce a flawed infrastructure law that will not get us anywhere. We should aim to address this at the beginning of the next legislative period. It is still being heavily discussed. I cannot say this afternoon how it will turn out exactly. But it is important that we view CCS technology and coal-fired power plants as highly accepted components of our energy policy for the coming years. We cannot exit nuclear energy and coal while simultaneously lacking high-capacity transmission to direct offshore wind energy to the south, where the industrial base is. That would not work and would severely harm Germany's industrial location. I do not want that. That will not happen with me.

There are, of course, very exciting and also visionary projects. Among them is a project that has been heavily discussed in recent days, namely "Desertec" – a project that would fit very well into the Mediterranean strategy of the European Union. Germany has strongly advocated that cooperation between the Mediterranean countries and the European Union, for which we have 13 billion euros available until 2011, is directed towards future-oriented investments. This could include, for example, solar energy projects.

We have the technical prerequisites and the know-how in the field of solar energy. I am pleased that, among others, Munich Re, Siemens, Deutsche Bank, and RWE are showing interest in participating in a project, without giving the impression that we no longer need to care about our local energy generation at all. That would also be wrong. These are future projects; one should think visionarily, but one cannot use this as an excuse for not building a lignite power plant in the coming years.

I want to remind you that the export of state-of-the-art coal-fired power plants is one of Germany's major export successes and that countries like China and India will think three times about whether it is still sensible to buy such technologies from Germany if we no longer build these things ourselves. That would also be a significant weakening of our energy and economic location.

We need clear investment conditions in all areas. We have made progress in this legislative period, both in terms of energy transmission construction and in terms of the reliability and dependability of renewable energies. I want to remind you once again of the EEG amendment, the Renewable Energy Heat Act, and the facilitation of biogas feed-in. These are reliable frameworks for investments. Who today has such reliable frameworks for investments where completion takes up to 20 years? Nowhere are there such clear return expectations as, for example, in the field of renewable energies. Therefore, I believe that we belong to those who have truly advanced things with market-based incentives.

Now one might object: The electricity customer has to pay for all of this through a levy system. That is correct. But I also tell you that, in my view, it is still one of the efficient variants to advance in these matters of renewable energies. We cannot all know exactly how global raw material prices will develop. It is not so easy, even for those who want to build coal-fired or gas-fired power plants in the coming years, to assess the price developments in the coming years. Regarding how CCS technology will develop and what costs will arise from it, it must be said that the classic forms of energy generation, including gas and oil, will not become cheaper in the coming years compared to renewable energies. It will be very exciting to see at what point and in which year the points are reached where it no longer balances out.

In the area of wind energy, we have experienced developments in the last ten years that I could not have imagined when I was Minister of the Environment, especially regarding the utilization of wind power plants and the possibilities for degression. In other areas, of course, we are at the beginning, such as with offshore technology. But we have already seen significant increases here.

The area in which you operate is one where people can measure their quality of life in a very special way. Therefore, we are aware of the responsibility of the entire federal government to develop a consistent policy here. We know that it is also about setting the right course for the future. In this respect, I want to emphasize once again that we will certainly do everything we can to keep the middle of this century in mind.

We will have to assume that we need significant CO2 reductions, and that globally. I would also like to point out that the question of how free we are in this regard, at what speed we do this, is not decided solely by us. I believe we should certainly listen to science, which at this point says that we would pay a very, very high price for an increase in the average global temperature of more than two degrees. The question of what it costs us if we do not engage in climate protection is often somewhat pushed into the background. But if we look at the impacts of climate change in Africa, the resulting refugee movements, and the costs that arise from them, and if we consider the climate extremes occurring on our continent, then it is correct that the model calculations by Stern regarding the economic damages resulting from neglecting this issue are very, very interesting to consider.

I know that during the economic crisis, the question arises: Is this the right time to deal with such issues? When I look at the United States and China, I notice that these countries, with their very extensive stimulus programs, are keeping both things very much in mind: the renewal of their economy towards more efficient energy use and simultaneously addressing the crisis by creating domestic demand. Therefore, we should also pursue this path.

That is why, in our stimulus program, we have not only prioritized building renovation and infrastructure programs for education, schools, and kindergartens, but we have also specifically addressed the issue of mobility. Especially in public transport, we have opportunities to save significant energy with new forms of mobility.

We should therefore use the time of the international economic and financial crisis to gain strength for the right future investments. Certainly, efficient energy consumption in all its facets, including efficient water consumption, to return to the first topic, is the right answer to this crisis. Because I believe that even after the crisis, we will depend on being one of the leading export nations, it makes sense to invest in the development of modern technologies in all the areas for which your association is responsible and to provide examples here.

It is often discussed now whether we are too dependent on exports. What are the alternatives? We might be able to generate a bit more domestic demand if we say that the savings rates are a bit too high. But we know exactly: With the demographic changes we have, much will also go into retirement security and health care. This means that there will not be huge consumer areas opening up. Therefore, exports are the key to our prosperity. We will only be able to export at our wage level if we are better than others. Therefore, research and innovation, as well as companies that implement them, are the key to our prosperity.

This brings me to what you said at the beginning, Mr. Schmitz, namely: If only we are allowed to. It is politically in our inherent interest to allow you to do so. However, just as you sometimes have differing opinions, we sometimes have to politically struggle to find out where we should allow you more and where we should allow you less. But I am here today with the deep awareness that we can only achieve this together, that you are committed fighters for good public services and that you have not shied away from new paths in many areas.

I encourage you in this association to allow benchmarking, to compare with each other, and to seek the best solution. You should know that we want to support your efforts through reasonable framework conditions and that we want to bring our interests into a European internal market, but also again with the awareness – and that is why it is nice that the various levels are represented here together today – that Europe as a continent can only be strong if each one also has a strong infrastructure.

Germany has always had a large part of its exports within the European Union. We are the ones who have benefited immensely from the expansion of the European Union. Therefore, we want to offer what we develop and test here in the country to other countries as well. In this sense, a united Europe is also a good, an outstanding platform for us to remain an exporting nation.

I would like to wish you: Come together, do not hesitate to admit when you do not fully agree. That reassures us as well, because we sometimes also struggle politically with each other. Rest assured that we always rely on good cooperation with your association.

All the best for your further consultations.