Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration event "125 Years of Statutory Health Insurance" on June 11, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

11 June 2008 · 125 Years of Statutory Health Insurance celebration · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a celebration event in Berlin marking the 125th anniversary of Germany's statutory health insurance system on June 11, 2008.
Main themes
Statutory health insurance, history of German social policy, solidarity and social insurance, Bismarck's social reform legacy, social market economy, healthcare system development, personal responsibility, German reunification, long-term care insurance, financing of healthcare, medical progress, social partnership
Duration
~22 min
69th percentile
Words
2,593
69th percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 44%44%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

142 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Huber,

dear Mr. Hundt,

dear Mr. Sommer,

dear Mr. Schwanitz,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased and deeply convinced to be here today for this anniversary celebration of "125 Years of Statutory Health Insurance." I believe such a day provides the opportunity for us to become aware of something that, despite all the contentious discussions in the health sector, could easily be overlooked: Our German healthcare system is one of the most comprehensive healthcare systems in the world. The fact that it can look back on 125 years of history also shows that Germany has paid great attention to this area very early on.

I say this because, if you look at the discussions in all industrialized nations, the health sector is certainly the most sensitive area where people are anxious, have concerns, and where it is good for them to feel secure in a functioning healthcare system. On such an anniversary day, we can truly rejoice together – despite everything that still needs improvement and what we have to discuss.

Chancellor Otto von Bismarck has already been mentioned here. The first beginnings of statutory social insurance date back to his time in office. The provision of security and necessary care in the event of illness, accident, and old age should not be provided through state welfare benefits, but within the framework of social insurance. That was the fundamental idea, which incidentally also influenced the Social Market Economy. I would like to mention that the federal government will commemorate 60 years of the Social Market Economy tomorrow. The principle of social partnership – it is no coincidence that Mr. Hundt and Mr. Sommer are here today as keynote speakers – was introduced very early in Germany and has proven itself, in my opinion.

The idea of health insurance was not fundamentally new at that time. There were already guilds, insurance associations, or miners' associations that were supposed to protect their members in case of illness. But Bismarck established the entire coverage on a much broader foundation with his system. One can say: On this foundation, the Statutory Health Insurance still stands after 125 years, even if some financial circumstances have obviously changed. – Mr. Hundt just told me that he will also say something about this later.

In retrospect, one can say: The introduction of health insurance was a milestone in the history of German social policy. It enabled care in the event of illness for all workers. Wage replacement and medical treatment were no longer alms, but counter-performances for insurance contributions. The workers secured their health care independently within a solidarity community with the support of their employers.

Health insurance – this has already been hinted at – appeared quite modest at that time compared to today. This was also due to the fact that the possibilities for medical care were far more limited. The medical possibilities we know today did not exist at that time, of course. Therefore, the benefits were initially provided predominantly in the form of wage replacement – that is, sick pay and fewer treatment services. This overall limited scope of benefits made the financing of health insurance relatively simple compared to our current problems.

The fundamental idea of securing the major life risks of illness, accident, and old age through social insurance – we have held on to this idea to this day. It forms the understanding of what we describe with the term "solidarity." This solidarity system has not only survived two world wars, various political systems, inflation, and economic crises. The social insurance system has also been continuously developed. For example, unemployment insurance was added in 1927, and in 1995 – many of those present here participated in the debates – the long-term care insurance was introduced.

With the population growth, the circle of beneficiaries also expanded. It should not be forgotten that with German reunification, 16 million people were added. I believe this also speaks to the effectiveness of this system, which connects solidarity – and this is often debated – with a degree of personal responsibility.

Now, alongside the expanded circle of insurance, which also includes family members, we must also consider medical progress and the growing prosperity over time. This has also changed the demands on the Statutory Health Insurance.

There has been ongoing discussion, particularly in connection with German reunification, about who is responsible for providing benefits for the solidarity community. You know that we have decided to finance health care services for children from tax revenues in the long term. I believe this is a consistent decision when one considers that these have nothing to do with the direct costs incurred by employees in the healthcare system.

Today, we experience the legitimate but high demand that all citizens can adequately participate in medical progress. This is anything but a simple task in a world of growing medical advancements and the demographic changes in our society. Therefore, one can predict, without any special prophetic gift, that the financing of the healthcare system will continue to be tested in the future – especially under the conditions of international competition in the labor market, where the issue of wage-related costs plays a special role.

All of this does not change the fundamental insight and my deep conviction: Solidarity and personal responsibility go hand in hand. Both are hallmarks of our successful Social Market Economy. Therefore, we must ensure that in a time of social change and medical progress, solidarity and personal responsibility continue to stand in the right relationship to each other. This regularly causes heated debates. I do not know of any political field that is as contested – if I may say so – as the healthcare system. All those who work in the Federal Ministry of Health can certainly attest to that.

Today, we can effectively treat and cure a multitude of diseases. But all of this costs money. Therefore, one can say: Health is a precious good in both senses. But it should also be a good that should not be too costly.

Therefore, we need two principles.

First:

Only the benefits in the solidarity community that are truly medically necessary may be claimed.

Second:

The benefits must be provided efficiently, that is, economically.

Both are self-evident criteria, but in practice, they are not so easy to implement. The economic provision of health services alone could lead to hours of lectures – whether one addresses the issue of free choice of doctor, the ratio of outpatient to inpatient care, or the question of what economic efficiency means in relation to the proximity of a hospital to one's residence. These are many, many questions that will arise even more frequently in a world of globalization in the future.

Therefore, we have also strengthened the principle of personal responsibility in recent years. This means that for certain services, a politically acceptable degree of self-payment is required, because otherwise, the solidarity we desire is no longer financially viable.

Our solidarity system can only function if two areas of responsibility are guaranteed.

First:

Responsibility for the people who need services.

Second:

Responsibility for the people who pay for these services.

I would like to add a third dimension: Responsibility for the people who provide these services.

It is easy to imagine that this is not always a conflict-free field. As much as one’s heart beats for successful collective bargaining on one side, one is also aware of what that means for wage-related costs on the other side. This means there is a mutual responsibility – and this in a system that is organized in self-administration by employers and employees.

In fact, politics can almost lean back. It only needs to create the framework, and from that moment on, all principles will be automatically implemented by the self-administrators. This works quite smoothly. Sometimes it also results in contribution increases, which are then more often blamed on us in politics than being actively represented by the self-administrators. I encourage everyone to stand by their actions when they announce the respective contributions for each fund every year. It is not always clear whether the public knows exactly who it was. – This should not disturb the festive tone. I am sure that Mr. Hundt will know how to defend himself when I am no longer here; I hope Mr. Sommer will as well.

While politics sets the framework for how our healthcare system should fundamentally look, much is regulated by the representatives of self-administration, not least through the Joint Federal Committee.

After making some half-ironic or mocking remarks here, I would still like to thank the representatives of self-administration, as they are the cornerstone of this solidarity insurance. Self-administration contributes to ensuring that healthcare in Germany can be provided at a high and, in many cases, truly the highest level. It keeps an eye on ensuring that solidarity and personal responsibility can be lived within the Statutory Health Insurance.

I would also like to thank all those who dedicate themselves day after day to the irreplaceable service of health: the doctors and dentists, the nurses, pharmacists, and many other service providers. Thanks also go to the representatives of the health insurance funds and those who advance medical progress.

I believe that gratitude and recognition for the contributions to a high-performing healthcare system rightly take center stage in today’s anniversary celebration. However, this should not obscure the fact that this anniversary falls into a very busy time for the health insurance funds. – Mr. Huber nods. I am satisfied. – Significant restructuring and realignment await health insurance. I encourage you to continue your work and to see things with great curiosity and with their opportunities. The Statutory Health Insurance has always been distinguished by its ability to implement new framework conditions.

The Health Fund will come into effect on January 1, 2009. I am firmly convinced that this will create more transparency in the financial architecture of the Statutory Health Insurance, that the reorganization of self-administration will streamline decision-making processes, and that it is right that there will be a reform of medical remuneration. It brings more reliability for the doctors. Not least, there is more freedom of contract in many areas.

Of course, this is now uncharted territory, and it will be developed. And there is a lot of unrest about it. I also understand that. Since we are celebrating "125 Years of Statutory Health Insurance" today, I would also like to say: All these measures will lead to a relationship that has become somewhat anonymous over time, namely the one between patients and their respective health insurance, being able to be re-established more closely. I fundamentally consider this to be correct.

We must now take the final steps in the coming weeks and months to implement this health reform. We have already initiated the establishment of the insolvency capability of health insurance funds as well as the release of the states from liability in the event of a health insurance fund's insolvency. By the way, we have also made huge progress in recent times – I thank everyone who participated – in the debt relief of health insurance funds. All of this has to do with the future viability of our social security systems. For a long time, we did not build up any reserves for old age or undertake debt relief in many areas. I believe it is very important that we prepare for the future in a time of demographic change.

There will be progress in establishing the so-called convergence clause. They are becoming apparent. I know that this regulation does not meet with approval from everyone. But it was, on the one hand, an important political prerequisite for the introduction of the Health Fund, and on the other hand, there are indeed very different conditions and developments in the individual regional areas of Germany – whether it concerns a city like Berlin, which still has structural problems from the time of German reunification, or whether it concerns traditionally different wage levels in the various federal states. This cannot be changed overnight. Therefore, I believe we have found a reasonable solution with the convergence clause.

The core of the reform is: We are improving the foundations for competition among health insurance funds. The differences in contribution rates and benefits will be more transparent than ever before. I know that many of you here have significant concerns and are asking questions. Nevertheless, I believe the overall approach is correct. I am not entirely sure whether every fund is interested in attracting as many customers, that is, patients, as possible. The discussion about this will ignite when there will be optional tariffs and possibly additional contributions in the future. This is, of course, related to our desire to make clear how the health insurance funds offer their services. Despite the criticism that is being expressed now, I know from many conversations with funds that they are considering how to become friendlier, more open, and also more interesting for their respective insured individuals.

I believe we can say that our reform will bring more transparency and more incentives for efficiency and competition. We also need an informed insured individual who can compare the offers from funds and choose the ones that suit them, thus being able to make some decisions for themselves.

This chapter on health reform is not yet closed. For one of our greatest challenges remains our task in the coming years: that is the fortunately and truly gratifying increase in life expectancy. We must not shy away from this task. It is about taking responsibility for future generations. Because they want and have the right to receive equally high-quality medical care as the current generation.

Participation in the medical progress of the future will – I will say this in a northern German way – not become cheaper. This is a reality we must face. We can decide in each case whether we want to finance this in solidarity or whether we want to give people personal responsibility. But to believe that one can simply reduce health costs in the medium term through better efficiency would be a fallacy. Therefore, we must not propagate it. This has nothing to do with the health fund, which is now being blamed for some things, but we must try to address this task in a reasonable manner.

The discussion about this will continue in the coming years. This applies even more to long-term care insurance. Therefore, I am also deeply convinced that we need a capital-funded provision in the context of long-term care insurance – unlike in health insurance.

I am here today to express my gratitude for 125 years of a successful system, for your work in a challenging time, for your openness to new ideas, and for the fact that, even though we may sometimes clash in many critical situations, the spirit is palpable in each of these discussions that we have a shared responsibility for our social system. Therefore, the principles of self-administration, the principle of political framework setting, and the principle of mutual dependence are the right principles for a social insurance system like the statutory health insurance, which should continue to develop successfully over the next 50 years until its 175th anniversary.

I wish you much strength and courage to forge new paths, to involve your insured individuals in what you do, and to provide them with many opportunities. I assure you that we will always remain in constructive dialogue with you.