Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebratory event "50 Years of the Advisory Council on Issues of Internal Leadership at the Federal Ministry of Defense" on June 4, 2008 in ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

6 June 2008 · Celebratory event '50 Years of the Advisory Council on Issues of Internal Leadership at the Federal Ministry of Defense'

Context
Merkel addressed the 50th anniversary celebration of the Advisory Council on Internal Leadership at the Federal Ministry of Defense, held at the Jewish Museum in Berlin on June 4, 2008.
Main themes
Internal leadership (Innere Führung), Bundeswehr democratic principles, German constitutional values, lessons from National Socialism, civic-military culture, human dignity and Basic Law, parliamentary army concept, advisory council contributions, historical responsibility, Jewish history in Germany
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,342
80th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
12.4
49th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 42%40%
  • Social 28%26%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

159 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Federal Minister, dear Franz Josef Jung,

dear Parliamentary Commissioner for the Armed Forces, Mr. Robbe,

dear Professor Pommerin,

esteemed members of the Advisory Council on Internal Leadership,

esteemed representatives of churches and religious communities,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen!

I am – even though it is a premiere; something new must always happen from time to time – very grateful to be able to participate in this anniversary celebration "50 Years of the Advisory Council on Internal Leadership at the Federal Minister of Defense." I believe that Internal Leadership has truly become a constant of the Federal Republic of Germany and the Bundeswehr, which is why I am happy to be here.

Regarding my being here for the first time: That may also have to do with the anniversary; this has not happened before. In that respect, other Federal Chancellors faced different challenges. For the 100th anniversary, I would say there should be another Federal Chancellor here. I am happy to be here because the Advisory Council has made a special contribution to the democratic culture in our country.

I believe you have chosen a particularly suitable venue for your event with the Jewish Museum to honor these contributions. The Jewish Museum stands for the richness of Jewish culture and Jewish history in Germany. It represents the unprecedented civilizational break of National Socialism. But it also stands for the lessons that Germany must draw from history in order to shape a good future, which Germany has also drawn. Anyone who visits this museum feels – at least I do – the incredible loss that we have to mourn in Germany due to this civilizational break. We can say: We can be glad that there is Jewish life in Germany again today.

Therefore, we are confronted in this building with a constant reminder: It is the indivisible and inalienable dignity of man that we must respect and protect under all circumstances. That is why human rights are the focal point of our Basic Law. Society and politics, people and institutions of public life in Germany are equally committed to the values of freedom, democracy, and the rule of law. This applies permanently and without exception. On this common foundation of values rests, from the very beginning, the Bundeswehr – with its internal order and its leadership philosophy.

As a consequence of the lessons from German history, it was clear to all involved at the founding of the Bundeswehr in 1955: The Bundeswehr must be a parliamentary and alliance army, soldiers must remain citizens with all constitutional rights upon joining the Bundeswehr, and the human image of the Basic Law must also be a binding guideline for the soldiers of the Bundeswehr. With the concept of Internal Leadership, the human image of the Basic Law was anchored in the armed forces. All Federal Ministers of Defense, all Chief Inspectors, and all those who take on responsibility in this Bundeswehr feel this obligation. This also constitutes the great strength of our Bundeswehr.

This means that the reference to our Basic Law is an integral part of the self-understanding of the Bundeswehr. Therefore, orders are also bound by law and regulations. That is why the soldier of the Bundeswehr receives political, historical, and ethical education. This allows him or her to always see their actions in a broader context, to understand it, and thus to take responsibility from this broader context. This, if I may say so, embodies the spirit of the Bundeswehr.

I believe we all agree: Soldiers need an ethical compass for their activities. That is why not only the Federal Minister of Defense and the Chief Inspector commit to the principles of Internal Leadership, but also the entire Federal Government. My presence here is also a reflection of this fact. This means that Internal Leadership is part of and a means of political leadership responsibility in the Bundeswehr and thus a contribution to the democratic-civic culture in our country, which consists of many elements.

One must say today, when looking back at history, that among the great pioneers of the development of the concept of Internal Leadership were also former Wehrmacht officers – individuals who drew lessons from history. Wolf Graf von Baudissin, Johann Adolf Graf von Kielmansegg, and Ulrich de Maizière are names that stand for this. They paved the way for Internal Leadership – from painful experience, from deep conviction, and with great perseverance. They laid the foundation for the Bundeswehr to be what it is for us today.

A few years after the founding of the Bundeswehr, an Advisory Council on Internal Leadership was established at the Federal Minister of Defense. It convened for the first time in June 1958. The composition of the Advisory Council was subject to constant change. This may say something about the developments in the history of our Republic. Yet despite all the changes, it has always been clear: The necessary exchange with the various groups and intellectual currents of society must be reflected in the Advisory Council.

This principle, this cooperation, continues to this day. We need the close networking of the Bundeswehr with societal and political actors. Only in this way can as many insights and broad experiences as possible be made usable for the everyday life of the armed forces. Conversely, only in this way can the acceptance of the tasks and the necessity of the armed forces be conveyed into society. This means that only a free and democratic civil society enables the social integration of the armed forces. Therefore, I would also like to thank all those who have agreed to dedicate themselves to this task today and in the past.

The critically constructive connection between the armed forces and the state, society, churches, and religious communities has, of course, also advanced Internal Leadership. That is why the Advisory Council not only plays a decisive role in the success story of Internal Leadership, but one can also say: It is itself a success story. Thirteen Ministers of Defense have been able to rely on its expertise and commitment since the founding of this Advisory Council.

Therefore, I would like to take this opportunity to express my gratitude and recognition to all former and current members of the Advisory Council and simply say: You have all – regardless of how critical or harmonious the contributions were – made a valuable contribution to the Bundeswehr. I can also say: The Federal Government will continue to rely on the Advisory Council in the future, not only to take note of its ideas but also to consider them, especially at a time when we are, of course, once again facing central questions for which we must continually find new and convincing answers together.

What further path can and must Internal Leadership take? What are the future tasks of a modern and value-based Internal Leadership in a world with societal changes and completely new security policy challenges?

Whatever the answers may be in detail, I would like to highlight above all three aspects as fundamental.

First:

Internal Leadership must actively incorporate societal developments into the armed forces. Only in this way will the Bundeswehr continue to be an attractive employer in the future. It must be, because the Bundeswehr competes with other employers for qualified young talent in all career paths, especially when it comes to temporary and professional soldiers. This is a significant challenge; I recently had a very interesting conversation with the inspectors about this.

What does attractiveness mean? It naturally means solid social security and provision for soldiers. It also means equality for soldiers – a topic that the Bundeswehr must address somewhat belatedly compared to other areas of society. It also means the issue that will have serious implications for the future of the Bundeswehr, namely the compatibility of work and family. The classic representation rule for temporary soldiers has not been in place for long. But it cannot be the case that the Bundeswehr is the employer of the Republic where the issue of young talent is statistically underrepresented. This is an interesting challenge. I think there will, of course, be solutions, but we must think about it again.

When it comes to attractiveness, this also means, not least, allowing and fostering an open culture of discussion within the armed forces as well as an open dialogue between society and the Bundeswehr. This applies, for example, to the transformation of the Bundeswehr, which is being controversially discussed in politics and society. In the meantime, the service must, of course, be carried out and shaped. Therefore, pro and con arguments cannot stop at the gates of the barracks. But on the other hand, a soldier must also know every day what he or she is supposed to do. There must be a good culture of discussion in the Bundeswehr.

The principle of command and obedience does not replace the responsibility of military superiors to genuinely convince soldiers of the purpose of a specific mission – there have been more missions in recent years. When I say this, I do not say it in a condescending manner, but I say it from the experience of many visits to the Bundeswehr, where I have witnessed in truly impressive ways how this responsibility is shaped and lived. The superiors in the Bundeswehr do this because they know that only a well-informed and mature citizen in uniform can navigate safely in the tension between politics, society, and the Bundeswehr.

That is why I say: It is worth every effort to invest in political, historical, and ethical education at all levels. That is why every educational opportunity that is possible is truly welcome to meet this task in an increasingly complex world with new global challenges. A soldier who is politically educated and morally grounded also grasps the essence of Internal Leadership and can embody and implement this in everyday service.

This brings me to my second thought: We must understand Internal Leadership as an obligation for daily action. This means that everything we postulate in terms of values – I spoke of the human image – must also be experienced in everyday life. This means that service and operational everyday life are a constant test of what is conveyed in educational offerings. I believe this is a significant task for the superiors in the Bundeswehr and will, I suspect, be constantly put to the test by the very informed soldiers today. Young people need role models with whom they can identify. This means that Internal Leadership also means living and acting as a role model.

Internal Leadership thus stands for a holistic view of the soldier – as an individual in the military community, as a person who has a family, and as a soldier who is also a citizen. Even though significant achievements have been made here over more than five decades, this remains – especially when there are deployments outside the alliance territory, when there are completely new challenges – a task to be tackled anew time and again. This is not something finished or completed. This must be discussed. Pure appeals are, of course, not enough; rather, this is an attitude that must be supported by society as a whole.

Especially in deployment situations abroad, the challenge of what Internal Leadership means plays an important role.

This is my third fundamental thought. The new security policy challenges require a comprehensive concept of security. What does that mean? We live today in a multipolar world. The bipolarity of the Cold War is over. We are all glad about that. Nevertheless, with a certain distance from what is now almost historical – we are approaching the 20th anniversary of the end of the Cold War – one sometimes thinks: The world of the Cold War had a certain comprehensibility. It was predictable in its structure. It was bipolar on the one hand – that can still be grasped quite well – and on the other hand, it had the character that neither side intended to destroy itself. This means that one could create an order within this bipolarity with a difficult principle that has strongly influenced our lives, the principle of deterrence, and then relatively orderly transition from the principle of deterrence to disarmament and openness.

Multipolarity presents us with completely new challenges. Of course, the United States of America continues to play a significant role, but I have said many times, from deep conviction: A single state can no longer solve the problems we face in this world. Asymmetric threats are characterized by the fact that they involve people who put their own lives at risk to disrupt certain forms of society. Therefore, it is our task to define the concept of security much more broadly than we have done so far.

The Federal Government has adopted the White Paper at a Cabinet meeting in the Ministry of Defense and made this new concept of security, the concept of networked security, the core of the White Paper. I may say: We are already living this in our daily lives, for example, in the Afghanistan cooperation, where we no longer leave the entire responsibility with the Ministry of Defense. Rather, there is a permanent discourse on this matter between the Foreign Office, the Ministry of Defense, the Ministry of the Interior, and the Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development.

What is happening there and has happened in recent years should not be underestimated. Because when you come to Mazar-i-Sharif, for example, and realize the level of knowledge there about development aid and how much non-governmental organizations seek support there, you must conclude: This did not exist 15 years ago. I say: It benefits the non-governmental organizations, but it also benefits the Bundeswehr that they respect each other, appreciate each other, know the different roles, and understand that nothing can be achieved against each other.

That is why it is also so important that we have a constant feedback with this comprehensive concept of security, and that is why it is also so important that not only the Federal Government has these structures, but that every foreign deployment by the Federal Government and the Bundestag is prepared with the utmost care. Decisions are made based on international law and the mandates of the United Nations, based on the Basic Law and the Parliamentary Participation Act.

Of course, our decision-making structures – this must also be said – are not the fastest in the world in times of a comprehensive concept of security. But that applies to Germany as a whole. Federalism, with its various responsibilities, has repeatedly posed the challenge of going through comprehensive procedures to reach decisions. I do not want to say that this must be seen as right at every moment, but it has given our community incredible stability overall. When a difficult situation arises, it is indeed the case that we stand together.

Therefore, I want to express my heartfelt thanks not only to the representatives of the governing factions in the German Bundestag but also to those of the opposition factions, who have constructively participated in many decisions and hopefully will continue to do so. It is better to ask certain questions in advance than not to ask them at all and then to appear know-it-all in the event of a difficult situation. The Federal Government has always placed great value on obtaining as broad a parliamentary majority as possible because our soldiers have the right not to find themselves in a conflict situation that could have been avoided in the most difficult situations.

That is why it is important that the soldiers know that we make our decisions to the best of our knowledge and belief. This is also the basis for promoting as broad support as possible in the population for foreign deployments. This is difficult, and I do not want to beat around the bush. I therefore ask all members of the Advisory Board to contribute to this, as this is, of course, a concrete piece of internal leadership in everyday life. We still have much to do. One cannot believe that it is sufficient for us in Parliament and Government to make the decision for a deployment of the soldiers. When they return home, they are exposed to a barrage of arguments to which no one else in society has an answer. This poses enormous challenges for the soldiers in their private lives.

We know that we can best pursue our security interests in NATO, in the European Union, and in the United Nations. We are highly engaged in ensuring that the integration of German military contingents into multinational contingents is a regular or at least a normal case. This, of course, presents the Advisory Board for Internal Leadership with completely new tasks, as not everyone acts against the backdrop of the same historical circumstances and because we cannot abandon our principles.

A multitude of discussions that we need to have today are, of course, directly related to the fact that the cultures, histories, habits, and traditions, as well as the self-understandings of individual associations – including our allies – are quite different. Therefore, I predict: There will also be much to discuss in the future about what defines us and to what extent we are seen as comrades by others in a joint deployment. But I can already say that other countries listen very carefully when Bundeswehr members or we as politicians speak about the principles of internal leadership and our self-understanding. Just as we may need to learn some things, there is also good reason to take our experiences seriously, to incorporate them, and to integrate them into multinational behaviors.

We know: Only soldiers who are convinced of their mission will give their best. That is why it is important that we continue to advocate for this. Internal leadership must provide sustainable answers on how to deal with the stress situations of deployment life – with stress situations and their consequences, the burden of long separation from family and familiar social environments, and the handling of injury and death. Here, politics and society must not leave the soldiers alone.

However, I believe it is time to extend a heartfelt thank you to the military chaplaincy of the churches. It also encompasses a broad and completely new field of discussion after German reunification, in which many questions and prejudices, as well as much skepticism, have been reflected. The military chaplaincy is a huge task in times of increasing secularization. How do I speak with people who have heard little about God and church-related questions in their lives but suddenly realize that this is important in fundamental life situations beyond political directives? I believe that the military chaplaincy is taking on this task with great openness and willingness, as well as with great passion.

Whenever politics, society, and the Bundeswehr seek a common understanding, the Advisory Board is called upon. When I look back on my political time – whether in opposition or in government – I find that you, as Advisory Board members, take on this task with great naturalness and inner willingness, and with a low emphasis on placing public interest before the actual work. This is no longer normal today, as there are many rounds whose purpose seems to be derived only from the subsequent publicity. Therefore, it is nice that we do not hear from the Advisory Board every day. Because then one can assume that you are solving your task with all due care.

Therefore, a heartfelt thank you and the request: Remain together as a guarantor of the integration of our armed forces into the state and society. I wish you foresight, insight, will, strength, willingness to compromise, the ability to listen, and, as I said, the ability to remain silent when possible, but of course also to speak clearly when you deem it necessary as citizens.

In this sense: All the best, congratulations on 50 years of successful work, and here’s to many more!