Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration of the 125th birthday of Walter Eucken on January 13, 2016, in Freiburg:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 January 2016 · Celebration of the 125th birthday of Walter Eucken · Freiburg

Context
Merkel addressed a celebration in Freiburg on January 13, 2016, marking the 125th birthday of ordoliberal economist Walter Eucken.
Main themes
Walter Eucken's legacy, ordoliberalism and social market economy, freedom and economic order, competition policy and anti-monopoly thought, state power vs. economic power, Freiburg School of economics, resistance to National Socialism, post-war economic reconstruction, international terrorism, individual freedom in society
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,029
86th percentile
Sentences
194
88th percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
12.3
48th percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
47th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 58%55%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 4%

194 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Marianne Eucken and Mr. Christoph Eucken,

Esteemed Professor Feld,

Magnificence, esteemed Professor Schiewer,

Esteemed Mayor, dear Mr. Salomon,

Valued assembly,

Ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to sincerely thank you for the invitation and I was very happy to make my way here.

But before I address the occasion of our gathering today, I would like to say a few words about what has filled us all with horror yesterday. We are all still under the impression of the terrible suicide attack that, as we now know, took the lives of at least ten Germans in the heart of Istanbul. I mourn, like you, for our fellow citizens. We think with deep sympathy of the families who have been inflicted with immeasurable suffering by the loss of a loved one. We also think of the injured, of their pain and suffering. And we hope that they may recover physically, but also emotionally.

What we witnessed again yesterday and what is happening in so many places around the world is international terrorism. The goal of international terrorism is to attack our free lives in free societies. But we are convinced: Our free way of life is stronger than any terror. Our determination to combat terrorism together with our European and international partners, and our freedom will prevail against terrorism. I am convinced of that.

The idea of freedom also leads us to what has brought us together today in Freiburg. This city stands for the most important place of work of Walter Eucken. As has already been mentioned: In a few days, we will commemorate the 125th anniversary of his birth. We remember a convinced and convincing ordoliberal economist, a pioneer of the social market economy. We remember a courageous fighter for freedom and a great humanitarian. That is also the reason why I am truly pleased to be here.

Walter Eucken was already active at the University of Freiburg when the great economic crisis of the 1920s and 1930s struck the world. As a young professor, he wanted to get to the bottom of its causes. He was driven not only by his scientific ambition. Above all, he was concerned about the fates of the many people who had been driven into unemployment and hardship by the crisis and hyperinflation. Walter Eucken identified monopolization and concentration – that is, strong concentration or cartels – in the economy and society as essential causes of this economic catastrophe.

Indeed, after the First World War, cartels dominated economic activity in Germany on one side. For example, the Rhenish-Westphalian Coal Syndicate controlled over three-quarters of German hard coal production in 1925. On the other side, the state increasingly intervened in economic processes during the Weimar Republic. It tried to manage these on a case-by-case basis through cyclical policy measures. But it failed to organize the economy with general rules.

By addressing this problem, Walter Eucken, together with his colleagues in Freiburg, took an academic path of his own. This was typical of him. He walked off the beaten paths, without allowing himself to be swayed by advocates of extreme positions. As more and more people followed the promises of National Socialism in economically difficult times, Walter Eucken sought a free path. He sought an order that would limit excessive economic and state power. It was important for him to consider both equally: economic and state power. For him, not every means was acceptable to put a stop to cartels and monopolies. He held the view that – I quote him – “a policy of central economic control or nationalization does not solve the problem of economic power.”

With such an attitude, Eucken contradicted and resisted the spirit of the times. He described economic reality in clear, understandable words without regard to political moods – and that even in times of totalitarian rule, when he wrote, for example – I quote him again –: “The economic order as it exists today in Germany will not continue. Its total reconstruction will be necessary.” Walter Eucken put this down on paper in 1942. We all agree: It took courage to express such criticism at that time.

Even after National Socialism and the Second World War, Eucken's ideas were hardly less audacious. When he described his order of freedom, many could hardly relate to such a concept of freedom. A free economic order seemed to many Germans too bold and too demanding in the tense and scarcity-ridden post-war situation. Yet Eucken remained true to his convictions. For he saw the danger that an interventionist economic policy by an overly powerful state would lead to less freedom. He also saw the danger that a lack of competition would lead to more private power. As a result, the freedom of the individual would be doubly threatened: by private power and too much state power.

With his ordoliberal concept, Eucken countered these dangers. It provided for state intervention only in certain cases of market failure. Fundamentally, however, politics should not intervene in economic processes in a controlling manner, but rather shape the economic order. This means, in detail: enabling competition, ensuring a functioning price system and monetary stability, creating open markets, guaranteeing private property and freedom of contract, enforcing liability, and avoiding uncertainty through reliable policies.

Walter Eucken also recognized the social power that lies in a free and fair competitive order. Instead of privileges for a few, functioning competition opens up opportunities for all. In this sense, his ordoliberal principles form the basis for reconciling growth and social justice.

However, even the best idea only bears fruit if it can also be put into practice. One might say that it was a stroke of luck in German history that Eucken's correct principles met the right politician after the Second World War, namely Ludwig Erhard. The economic model outlined by Eucken also proved to be a solid support in practice when the Federal Republic was still in its infancy.

However, Ludwig Erhard also had very exciting confrontations with the Allies when he came up with the brilliant idea of freeing prices during times of rationing, thereby sending signals of scarcity to stimulate economic initiatives. This fundamental decision to turn away from a distribution and rationing economy and to rely on free activities proved to be a groundbreaking paradigm shift. The miracle happened: The successes of the social market economy did not take long to materialize. The store shelves filled up, the economic cycle gained momentum, and the German economic miracle, as we call it today, took its course.

Moreover, the social market economy was to prove itself over decades – although there were already considerable struggles at the beginning, particularly regarding the design of social systems. Even today, it is the best framework for our economy, which – as Professor Feld has also said – is currently doing well, especially in international comparison. We are on a solid growth path. This provides sustained momentum in the labor market. The unemployment rate is as low as it has ever been since reunification. Employment is breaking record after record. This is good for those affected, good for domestic demand, and of course also good for the social security systems. We can – without being able to see too far into the future – also expect a similar development for the year 2016.

We are, of course, in a time of upheaval. What must shape our thinking today is the fact that the scope for action has changed. While decisions are still made in national politics, much must be thought of in European terms and much also globally. This includes that we highly value international cooperation and that we Germans also contribute to addressing global challenges; I want to mention climate protection, sustainable development, conflict resolution, security, and stability – I have already pointed to the dangers of international terrorism.

We feel that globalization in Germany is no longer only showing itself from the side we have known so far: Large and medium-sized German companies are venturing into emerging and developing countries, establishing businesses there, making good deals, and thereby securing jobs in Germany. Now we are experiencing, as Wolfgang Schäuble beautifully put it, a different “rendezvous with globalization”; namely in the form of the influx of refugees.

Globally, we have become more mobile, benefiting from the blessings of digitalization, we have smartphones and therefore know how people are doing elsewhere in the world. Therefore, our political scope for action today must extend far beyond our national and even European borders if our liberal values – also regarding the nature of humanity – are to be valid. We find ourselves, with regard to our own values – of which I assume we do not refer to them solely for ourselves, but that they apply to all people – in a time of incredible challenges.

In this context, I would like to briefly address one point. I cannot give a lesson on refugees here now; I just want to say: I deeply believe that we must address the root causes of flight and that we must improve the living conditions of people. We Germans cannot do this alone. We certainly cannot take in all the people who are in a worse living situation than we are. But we must ensure that we fulfill our responsibility not only by taking in refugees but above all by advocating for the fight against the causes of flight and for creating conditions under which people in their homeland have the impression that they also have good chances of living there. This is a task for the century, but in an open economy, in a time of digitalization, we must not continue to shy away from this task. The solution to the tasks cannot, of course, be achieved in such a way that flight essentially takes place through illegal means. Rather, we must find legal pathways for exchange. This is also what the project we have to tackle is about.

One last sentence on this, Mr. Mayor Salomon. Yes, I also believe: A country like Syria is not infinitely far from Germany; it is certainly closer to Europe than, for example, to Australia. If there are seven to eight million internally displaced persons in such a country and five million have left the country, if, as in Jordan – where Queen Rania of Jordan visited me today – 1.5 million Syrians and a total of three million refugees live in a country of seven million inhabitants, if in Lebanon 1.5 million refugees live among five million inhabitants, if in Turkey over two million refugees live among 75 million inhabitants, while a continent like Europe with 500 million inhabitants is not able – perhaps only temporarily – to take in, for example, one million Syrians, then that is not right and cannot be reconciled with our values. In doing so, I am not saying that those who do not have a prospect of staying must not also leave our country – we have legal procedures. But I want to point to something else.

What does this challenge mean for us in Europe now? We not only have a German internal market, but we also have a European internal market and a common currency. The definition of the market plays a very interesting role in the question "How do I apply Walter Eucken's regulatory ideas?" – I will return to this later. If our market definition is now primarily based on a European internal market and a single currency in large parts of this European internal market, then, I must say, it is relatively naive to believe that we could simply return to the old border control regime and that we would not need the Schengen area as an element of the common internal market. The reference that we lived with border controls in Europe 20 or 25 years ago is too short-sighted, as it does not take into account a single currency or the current interconnection of economic activities – you know this here in Baden-Württemberg just as well as others in border regions. Therefore, it is worth fighting very intensively for the maintenance of freedom of movement within European borders. In part of the search for a European solution to the refugee issue, it is now, when we also include economic aspects, precisely about the question of the internal market, about the question of the common currency, and about the necessary conditions to make both truly effective.

Now it is our task – I will try not to talk too much about national politics – to anchor regulatory principles in times of globalization. This is also what generates a great deal of discussion. I want to start with the international financial crisis that we had to deal with in 2008/2009. Because financial markets quickly embraced the possibilities of globalization, financial markets were, so to speak, the pioneers of further globalization, which is currently being further developed through the digitization of the real economy. A fundamental regulatory principle has completely gotten out of control in the financial markets, namely the principle of liability. "Whoever benefits must also bear the damage" – Walter Eucken wrote this decades ago. Yet in the financial crisis of 2008/2009, the damage remained in many cases with the taxpayers – for the most part, even with the taxpayers who had not caused the damage at all. Actions and responsibilities, profit opportunities and liability risks often fell apart. When this happens frequently, a general attack on politics is to be expected. Politicians must ensure or do everything possible to ensure that the principle of liability is fulfilled as well as possible. Otherwise, the sense of justice will be profoundly disturbed.

We are striving to learn from the misdevelopments. The establishment of the G20 format at the level of heads of state and government would not have been conceivable without these misdevelopments. We are working to develop general rules. We must take precautions. The approach of "too big to fail" in connection with banks – that is, those who are too big must not go under and will be rescued at all costs by the taxpayer – must not triumph. However, we also feel how difficult this is. We have found international financial rules for systemically important banks. There are repeated attempts to shift the so-called "level playing field" and to gain small advantages on each side. I would say: The market power of certain institutions still has a certain definitional power today. But overall, we have achieved improvements through much better capital provisions and stricter state controls, through resolution plans and much more that applies to systemic banks. However, the so-called shadow banks remain a concern for me, as their regulation has not progressed as far as that of traditional banks.

Immediately after the international financial and economic crisis, there was – essentially as a reaction to it – a kind of stress test for the Euro system and what was also referred to as the Euro crisis. Again, the question of a crisis solution was on the table. Essentially, the crisis arose because the principles of the Stability and Growth Pact were not sufficiently adhered to, also because there was hope that, so to speak, the own risks that a state incurs would one day perhaps be borne by the community as a whole, and because the fundamental structure of the system on the financial markets – who stands in for whom, who is liable for whom? – was tested.

Thus, we held discussions for many months: Why no Euro bonds; why solidarity on the one hand to hold the financial system together, but on the other hand, individual efforts? We have seen: Most countries have now exited the aid programs. Greece is still in the program. But overall, I would say that the approach has proven itself. If it had not existed, then with a mutualization of all risks, without having the necessary foundation, without having a European responsibility for national budget policy and for national social policy, everything would fall apart again in such a way that, according to Walter Eucken, it is completely clear that nothing reasonable and nothing good can come of it.

The Germans have sometimes been criticized for their adherence to rules. Some may have even attributed obsession to us. But a certain framework, a certain regulatory principle, especially the necessity of liability, that is, standing up for risks, is absolutely necessary in my conviction. Without this fundamental principle of Walter Eucken, this path would not have been found – although it is always only walked with finite precision in practice; there are still enough deviations for those who want to criticize something. In any case, we must be able to rely on common agreements and commitments; this applies nationally, this applies European-wide.

Reliability, trust – this plays a central role in Eucken's conception in general. Let us think of the goal of monetary stability: People should be able to trust that their property does not lose too much value. Or let us think of the protection of private property and the freedom to enter into contracts: Trust in this is, according to Walter Eucken, a fundamental prerequisite for a functioning competitive economy. And trust, in turn, depends significantly on adherence to Eucken's principle of a constant economic policy. This is easy to say, but in democracies with regular changes of government, new coalition formations, and various interests, it is quite a challenge. Naturally, the theoretical-economic science comes into a certain tension with real politics; this is unavoidable. However, I believe that in the Federal Republic of Germany, over the decades, it has generally been possible to return to certain principles time and again. That we have a common thread with Eucken's regulatory policy provides, I believe, a great deal of security.

Walter Eucken was always concerned with reliability, calculability, and planning security. However, this does not mean freezing in the old ways. Rather, it is about a reliable compass with which one can also tackle new challenges. This means that I can apply this compass to the national market, to the European market, and to the global market. Thus, I also come to the principle of open markets. In Europe, we see that in a time of globalization, we must better exploit the potentials of the internal market.

For example, we need a capital market union. It is an interesting finding that in a European internal market, where many member states have the same currency, the capital markets are still largely separated and there is hardly any cross-border lending. This will only really change if the risk distribution in the individual segments of the Euro market is similarly reliably regulated.

We need an energy union that ensures Europe-wide supply security. With the Pyrenees, we have a geographical border where there is still hardly any interconnection between the energy systems of the Iberian Peninsula and the other part of the continent.

We need a digital internal market that increases the attractiveness of the location of Europe for digital actors. At the moment, we are having some of the longest discussions about how we should shape this digital internal market. The Justice and Interior Ministers have now succeeded, after long discussions, in agreeing on a uniform European data protection with the European Parliament. Whether it allows enough freedom for big data management will remain to be seen. Given that the raw material of the 21st century will be data, we are certainly at the lower end of what I consider necessary.

Of course, it is also about Europe engaging in a free global trading system. A classic example of major discussions is the planned Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership. The interesting question is why it is so fiercely contested. I believe it is so fiercely contested because this agreement is supposed to regulate more than just the reduction of tariffs. It also includes regulations on social and consumer protection standards, that is, so-called non-tariff trade barriers. This is associated with a very interesting process because one must, of course – but this is what the social market economy demands of us – say how to dismantle barriers without lowering one's own level of protection.

I am personally troubled that this free trade agreement between the largest free internal markets in the world is so contested. Because if we succeed in introducing regulations on non-tariff barriers – which affect consumer, environmental, and other areas of protection – into classic free trade agreements, then we would certainly have incredible definitional power for fairer agreements in the world. Because a simple tariff-reducing free trade agreement is not actually a fair agreement if there is competition over wages and environmental standards. In this respect, a larger agreement is much more valuable and could set standards for many others. Therefore, I will continue to advocate for it.

Once again, to a topic that occupies me greatly – without me always being able to express it in the right economic terms –: What market definition do I apply for fair competition? There is a great debate about this in the European Union. The question is: How must I act in globalization when I have market powers in the world – for example, two or three large telecommunications companies in a country like China with over 1.3 billion people – and how do I define "market" within the European Union, where we have more than 20 telecommunications companies and still have to fear with every European merger that a dominant market power will be defined?

This means that the space in which I define my market is of utmost importance. It is also known from other sciences that the boundary system can change the results. I fear – and I would like to discuss this with Walter Eucken if he were still alive – that our market definition is too narrowly defined and that in globalization itself, the European market definition is not sufficient to create the right structures for global competition.

If one cannot apply Eucken's principles in the same way elsewhere as we do – because we cannot define the American and other markets – then we may need to adjust even more to a global perspective in some areas due to the interdependencies in globalization. – But there must also be something left for the Walter Eucken Institute to engage with. – I would certainly like to direct increased research efforts towards that.

I am therefore firmly convinced: The ordoliberal principles of the Freiburg School have lost none of their relevance and significance. The principle of liability, a functioning price system, monetary stability, protection of private property and freedom of contract, open markets, and the constancy of economic policy – these principles are and remain success factors for, as Eucken put it, "a functioning and dignified economic order." It would also be interesting to know how Walter Eucken would have reacted to disruptive technological innovations. How do I create a broadband infrastructure system that does not fall under public services, that is, is no longer simply invested in by the state; how often can I subsidize there and where can I subsidize so that fair competitive conditions arise? – So questions upon questions.

Much of what is current today builds on the work of great economic thinkers, among whom Walter Eucken undoubtedly occupies a very special role. His principles of order policy help time and again to maintain a view of the whole. They are understandable and provide orientation. The unbroken interest in the work of Walter Eucken and the Freiburg School is therefore not surprising. This is primarily due to the Walter Eucken Institute, which has made it its mission to preserve the legacy of its namesake and to translate his ideas of order policy into the present day.

Walter Eucken's wife, Edith Eucken-Erdsiek, wrote after his death: "I am satisfied if Walter Eucken's thoughts inspire further reflection and new examination of reality, and if they thus have an effect over the years and decades." Yes, we could hardly honor Walter Eucken's memory better than by fulfilling this wish of his wife.