Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebratory event "50 Years of the Council of Economic Experts" on February 20, 2013 in ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

23 February 2013 · 50 Years of the Council of Economic Experts

Context
Merkel addressed the 50th anniversary celebration of Germany's Council of Economic Experts on February 20, 2013, honoring its role in economic policymaking.
Main themes
Social Market Economy, Council of Economic Experts anniversary, economic freedom and responsibility, scientific economic expertise, price stability and growth, the magic square of economic goals, Ludwig Erhard's legacy, role of independent advisory bodies, political and economic governance
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,321
79th percentile
Sentences
177
86th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%55%
  • Institutional 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

177 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Professor Franz,

dear members of the Council of Experts,

dear Dr. Schröder,

dear state secretaries,

dear representatives of society and former members of the Council of Experts,

I also warmly welcome you all to this festive event and take, Mr. Dr. Schröder, the opportunity to make a few remarks in this wonderful place here. The Council of Experts is indeed stylish in its choice of locations. It has also chosen this one, which I find to be a good choice; although I do not know if it is dependent on my praise.

The economist Friedrich August von Hayek held the conviction: "Freedom is essential to allow space for the unforeseen and the unpredictable." We know that not everything can be foreseen and planned. Therefore, freedom is a crucial prerequisite for companies to find suitable investment opportunities and appropriate ways to realize their ideas for productions and services, so to speak. Freedom allows people to choose their profession according to their own ideas and to fulfill it. It allows entrepreneurs to undertake something that is not already prescribed. Freedom is one of the foundations for satisfying diverse needs in a society. Therefore, freedom is also a driver of innovation and progress.

But when one asks what kind of freedom this is, I believe we all agree in this room that freedom is not freedom from something, but freedom to something, and specifically the freedom to take on responsibility. This also expresses the essence of the Social Market Economy. The Council of Experts, whose 50th birthday we celebrate today – congratulations – is committed to the Social Market Economy, this understanding of freedom and responsibility, which certainly also entails a relationship of tension. It is committed to the goals of the so-called magic square – stability of the price level, high employment, external economic balance, and steady and adequate growth. It is rightly called "magic," which suggests that it is rarely present in its highest perfection. The designation of the square has left sufficient room for the distribution of angles within this square, which can also shift a bit over time.

To give sufficient space to the goal of freedom as a prerequisite for the realization of the Social Market Economy, a Council of Experts was established – that was Ludwig Erhard. Federal Chancellor Konrad Adenauer is said to have warned him at the time: "Erhard, do you want to put a louse in your fur?" I leave it to your free interpretation how we see you. Today, out of respect for creatures and out of respect for public escalations, one is more cautious with animal comparisons. I will leave that as a historical curiosity.

The insight into the necessity of scientific expertise prevailed. The Council of Experts for the Assessment of Overall Economic Development was established by law in 1963. There are no proposed changes from the current federal government. I am also not aware of any changes being planned in election programs. So you can look forward to the 60th birthday with peace of mind.

Former Bundesbank President Hans Tietmeyer, then still working in the Federal Ministry of Economics, described the intention as follows: "Particular interests, which are unfortunately often loudly expressed in the political arena, should be countered by a neutral advocate for the long-term common good; no more, but also no less." To what extent you would now be proud to be a neutral advocate – especially since I also hear from your ranks that there are sometimes different assessments of the same real situation – is up to you. In any case, I can say: That particular interests are loudly expressed in public is indeed undisputed. And that is a good thing.

The Council of Experts proves to be a kind of regulatory conscience. I believe it has repeatedly fulfilled this responsibility over the past 50 years. From this regulatory conscience as a fundamental understanding, a degree of orientation for politics naturally arises. We use this orientation with critical distance, which must be acceptable to you. But of course, the ideas of the annual reports, the interim reports, as well as the meetings we have regularly are important events for the relevant ministries and the Federal Chancellery. If it has been complained that one has received too little praise from predecessor governments, I simply want to say: We are only human; since we work diligently all day, it is nice when someone says: You are not doing everything wrong. I want to say that explicitly, even though we have learned to be spurred on by your critical remarks and to understand them as such.

Whether in politics, in business associations, or in academia – your word carries weight far beyond the respective federal government. Therefore, it is also interesting that after the presentation of your reports, you also stand ready to answer questions from us, for example, from the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau and many others. The economic forecast always attracts particular interest. However, the Council of Experts is aware of its own limits, which simply lie in reality. The first annual report in 1964 stated: "Contrary to some ideas that may exist here and there, one cannot expect that anyone – not even a committee – is capable of predicting future economic developments." With that, you have, so to speak, already subjected yourself to a self-restraint at the beginning, which is wise.

I believe that the increasing globalization has further complicated the possibilities of forecasting. We are dealing with complex systems. I do not even know whether you are all convinced that the economic sciences provide sufficient tools to make forecasts as accurately as possible. I have the impression that today, so to speak, one does not get very far with deterministic systems and that a small chaotic element should be included in statistical research. But now I am venturing into areas that I no longer understand. However, the expectation of forecasts, regarding their qualitative accuracy, should be such that crises must not occur approximately a hundred times more frequently than they can in theoretical models. I would say that part of this still needs to be worked on in global economic contexts. The Federal Republic, on the other hand, is a manageable sub-segment of its forecasting reality and is therefore easier to handle.

The Council of Experts has always also dealt with the increasing effects of the world economy on Germany and has therefore, because part of the magic square also concerns balance of payments imbalances, always considered external interconnections. I would like to say at this point that we need to engage with this issue very strongly again at the moment. Certainly, we are trying – this is currently our policy – to contribute to ensuring that imbalances do not get out of hand by stimulating domestic demand. However, the corresponding stimulation of growth must – this is my conviction – not arise from debt, as has happened in many years, but must be linked to a solid financial policy.

When I speak of a solid financial policy, it always sounds as if we are paying off debts every year. This is rather the exception in Germany. I believe this is currently happening in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Saxony, and Bavaria. The federal government is not doing it; nor are the other federal states. This means that we are actually working towards a point where we learn to live with what we have. That would already be a huge success. In this respect, our possibilities to stimulate domestic demand are, of course, limited.

It is also important to ask in the European context: How far is it still sensible to take sub-segments in a single currency area and ask about imbalances? This is, of course, sensible as long as I have politically independent steering units. But the fact of a common currency also changes the overall perspective. When I look at the imbalances between Bavaria and Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, they are more dramatic than the imbalances we find in the Eurozone. Furthermore, it is important that we do not forget that imbalances can also be an indication of different competitiveness. This element must not be overlooked, as otherwise one arrives at completely false conclusions.

This discussion is, of course, being conducted intensively in Europe. My deep conviction is that the prosperity of the European Union and the Eurozone can only be guaranteed if we are overall globally competitive. Currently, 90 percent of the world's growth is taking place outside the European Union; it is probably even more than 90 percent. With the increasing development of emerging markets, the regions of growth are shifting. We must be capable of exporting to these regions. This is actually the great task that lies behind the questions of combating unemployment and many other goals.

You, as the Council of Experts, have always opted for free trade, for free exchange, for the free play of forces. Therefore, I believe that for the Council of Experts, the message that we may come to more free trade efforts in the transatlantic relationship is something that aligns with the Council's views. Unfortunately, there is a standstill in the efforts for global trade agreements. Germany has long resisted accepting this. But we must simply see that we are not making proper progress in the Doha Round.

The world has decided to organize itself in a multitude of bilateral free trade agreements. The question of a transatlantic free trade agreement would, of course, be a good message. We are close to concluding an agreement with Canada, and we have such agreements with Central America. Agreements with Peru and Colombia are in ratification. In relation to South Korea, we see that shortly after the ratification of such an agreement, there are dramatic increases in mutual trade. It is urgently necessary that we also reach further agreements in the Asian region, especially since China has such agreements in its own region and prefers these trade relations. Therefore, we still have a lot to do here.

A second point, where fair competition is currently at stake in international exchange, is the issue of exchange rate policy. The Council of Experts has often dealt with this in its history. In the meantime, the circumstances have changed. With the introduction of the Euro, we have, so to speak, completely rigid exchange rates in a large part of the European member states. But we see that there are always efforts in the world to create better export opportunities through certain monetary policy measures that lead to devaluations of one's own currency. We also see concerns and fears, for example, in the southern European countries, which have made great efforts to reduce their unit labor costs and now see that this advantage can melt away under certain conditions like snow in the sun. On the other hand, it must be said: Euro rates between 1.30 and 1.40 dollars are part of the normal history of the Euro.

We, on the part of the federal government, advocate for a free development of exchange rates. But we also advocate that all participants must adhere to this. Therefore, the statement of the G20 finance ministers was an important signal. We have until September, until the next G20 summit of heads of state and government, to see whether everyone adheres to this properly. To avoid any misunderstanding: We certainly do not support an active exchange rate policy.

Thus, it is always about creating a meaningful regulatory framework. I believe we have some differing viewpoints, also in the context of combating the Euro crisis. However, there are also many commonalities. You have, I believe, always said that both the fiscal treaty and the establishment of stability mechanisms are reasonable. As for the debt repayment fund, we have differing opinions. But fundamentally, it is also about the question: How do we actually manage – and the Council of Experts is not against this – to bring more political bindingness into the European discussion?

We are trying to make economic policy coordination more binding by June. We are trying to make not only fiscal policy binding, as that alone will not be sufficient for the stability of the euro. It is, of course, important to have sound budgets. But sound budgets are at best a part of the magic square. We also need an agreement on how to design growth-oriented policies, and on questions such as: What do we understand by imbalances? How do we create future investments? How do we structure our budgets – how much is consumed and how much is invested? Answers will not be found through new competencies at the European level, but will be created through the coordination of member states that agree on certain parameters that are crucial for the development of competitiveness, such as labor costs.

You have experienced very dramatic times in recent years, just like the federal government and all of us – starting with the international financial crisis, through the economic crisis, to the instabilities and lack of trust in the euro area. In this respect, it should be very interesting and exciting times for the current Council of Economic Experts. We are gradually overcoming these problems step by step. But we see that we essentially live in a world where there are certain phenomena that are so globalized that we also need a new form of cooperation at the political level.

We have international, global financial markets. The feeling of most people in the country, as well as in all of Europe and large parts of the world, is that there is currently no political force that can establish a regulatory framework for these financial markets that does not make people feel like they are being driven, but rather sets guidelines for these financial markets and avoids injustices in the sense of a social market economy. How we achieve this global regulatory framework will also be one of the crucial questions for the acceptance of politics. That is not your task; you are the reviewers. But we fundamentally do not have the binding nature of global institutions that we would need at this point. The G20 is an attempt. But the G20 also showed in many places that, when the acute danger was hardly over, the efforts significantly waned. We are now, five years after the outbreak of the international financial crisis, perhaps at the point with the Financial Stability Board where we can better regulate shadow banks. We have actually made quite a bit of progress with banks regarding capital adequacy. But whether the Congress of the United States of America will ever ratify Basel III – which I wish for – is uncertain based on the experiences with Basel II.

If we look at what tax havens are like around the world, there have been many pieces of advice from Mr. Issing and others who have told us: Make a map; write down where financial market actors do not submit to any regulation. The willingness among G20 countries to show their own map and say, "We are completely transparent and create a common 'level playing field,' as they say today, is not very pronounced. The thought of achieving a short-term advantage prevails. This is a tough nut to crack. I really ask for your cooperation here, as it is crucial for the acceptance of democratic societies. If people have the impression that human beings play a subordinate role in the context of the economy, they will not be able to win people over for the political order. Therefore, I see this as a huge and, in a way, shared task. I say this quite honestly: Here we need – perhaps even more than elsewhere – expertise, because the development of financial products and the development of financial markets are taking place at such a rapid pace that it requires significant expertise to manage the whole thing.

You belong – I think rightly – to the warners who repeatedly say that the European Central Bank must be protected in its independence. You have found words regarding the ECB in your review of the overall situation that are inherently forbidden to me, as it is independent. It is so independent that you can also say something to other independent institutions. In this respect, that is correct.

We now need to be careful – this applies to politics and to all institutions that have an influence on overall economic development – that we do not too quickly exploit short-term successes to avoid doing the right thing in the long term. One can buy time. But the time that can be bought is always finite. Certainly, some difficulties require time to overcome. But the historical experience of your 50 years also teaches: Once one has seen that by buying time one does not have to do certain things for a while, the danger that one will not do them at all anymore is very great. That is the real crux. And perhaps it is also one of the conflicts of interest in political advice and political action that, when a crisis is acute, political action is easier, while the economist says: It is best to act when there is no crisis at all. Reconciling this will remain a tension for the next 50 years.

You have – whether implemented by us or not – repeatedly given important impulses. Sometimes you had to wait until what you had long considered necessary happened – for example, the merging of unemployment and social assistance, many parts of the Agenda 2010, the increase in the retirement age. In science, one knows that one must have a long breath. I do not know if, upon critical reflection, you find anything that you once did not see quite correctly. That remains hidden from us. You are not legally obliged to inform us of that. But I suspect that it always plays a role in the preparation of your reports.

When one looks at how these reports of the Council of Economic Experts are composed, one gets a sense of the work that goes into them. There is the secretariat, the staff members who, alongside their main duties, invest a lot of time in this. I simply want to say thank you for that, as you do not have to take this upon yourselves by nature. Somehow, it still seems to be an honor in the profession to be part of it. That can and should remain so.

Therefore, I would like to extend my heartfelt thanks today, especially to Professor Franz. After 15 years as a member and four years as chairman, you will be leaving at the end of the month. You have co-written a piece of this 50-year history; 15 years is nearly a third of the time. You have also contributed to the fact that Germany is currently – I know that this is a snapshot – not doing so badly. Certainly, the warnings and proposals of the Council of Economic Experts have contributed to this as well.

We are always pleased to welcome new representatives. Professor Wieland has already impressively demonstrated his expertise at the central bank and the EU Commission. I am pleased that we were able to win you for the Council of Economic Experts. I wish you much success.

Professor Buch, when one looks around the room, I would say: By the time of the 100th anniversary celebration, the gender ratio should be balanced, even without us wanting to introduce a quota for the Council of Economic Experts. We are, of course, pleased that after Professor Weder di Mauro, Professor Buch is now here. Mr. Bofinger, Mr. Feld, Mr. Schmidt – I thank you all very much and hope that you will continue to give us good advice and not just be advisors, but reviewers of a hopefully good cause.

Thank you very much. A nice birthday celebration, all the best, and much strength.