Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the ceremonial assembly of the Max Planck Society on June 9, 2011, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

14 June 2011 · Ceremonial assembly of the Max Planck Society · Capital representation of Deutsche Telekom (former Imperial Telegraph Office), Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the ceremonial assembly of the Max Planck Society on June 9, 2011, in Berlin, marking the organization's 100th anniversary.
Main themes
Max Planck Society centenary, history of Kaiser Wilhelm Society, scientific excellence and top-level research, National Socialism and science, ethical responsibilities of science, Nobel laureates and scientific achievement, private research funding, individual scientific creativity, postwar renewal of German science, science and society
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,101
77th percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
42
40th percentile
Grade
12.2
48th percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%35%
  • Social 24%24%
  • Technological 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Environmental 5%5%
  • Not in focus 0%

160 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Dear Professor Gruss,

dear Minister Barañao,

dear Mr. Zöllner,

ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to start by complimenting you on the choice of venue for this event. The location for the festive assembly is excellently chosen. The building of the German Telekom's capital representation remarkably unites old and new into a cohesive whole – both figuratively and literally. The core of the building is the former Imperial Telegraph Office. It represents the origins of telecommunications in Berlin. Today, the house is a showcase for an exceptionally innovative industry. The wise and thoughtful combination of the experiences of tradition and the aspirations of modernity is a recipe for success that the Max Planck Society has continually embraced.

The traditional organization today stands for top-level research at the highest level. It has a good reputation worldwide; and even at home, it is highly regarded. The fact that its roots go back a hundred years is anything but ordinary. In January 1911, scientists, industrialists, and politicians met at the Royal Academy of Arts on Pariser Platz and, under the patronage of Kaiser Wilhelm II, established a completely new type of research organization: the Kaiser Wilhelm Society – the predecessor organization of the Max Planck Society.

The fundamental idea from the very beginning was to specifically support top scientists by providing them with the freedom for their research. The initiative to establish such an institution goes back to Adolf von Harnack. The well-known theologian and influential science manager was also the first president of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society. It established its own institutes for outstanding scientists. Free from the obligations of teaching and administration, they were to be able to concentrate on their research work; and this was also to apply in financial terms. Thus, the idea of private research funding was also brought to reality.

The innovative concept relied entirely on the power of individual creativity. It created space for scientific work that found no place at universities, thereby enabling entirely new areas of fundamental research to be explored. The successes did not take long to materialize. A total of 15 Nobel laureates worked at the institutes of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society. It quickly developed into a strong pillar of the international scientific community.

However, the glorious development of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society was not without dark shadows. The ideology and crimes of National Socialism left deep scars. Jewish scientists such as Albert Einstein, Fritz Haber, or Lise Meitner had to leave Germany. In total, one-third of the scientific members left the Kaiser Wilhelm Society. Additionally, regime-loyal researchers directed their work towards inhumane National Socialist goals. Whether in medical institutions or in institutes for biology, psychiatry, genetics, and eugenics, or for brain research – here, scientists have incurred great guilt upon themselves and their institution. Thus, the Kaiser Wilhelm Society also contributed to the darkest chapter of German history.

The role of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society during National Socialism only became a topic of discussion late – much too late, we must say from today’s perspective, as it took a good 50 years for the history of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society to be addressed by its successor organization, the current Max Planck Society. It is the former president of the Max Planck Society, Hubert Markl, who deserves credit for having established an independent commission in 1997 to investigate the role of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society during National Socialism. For this, he deserves great thanks.

After the end of World War II, the Allies ordered the dissolution of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society. However, they allowed for a reorganization under a new name. In Göttingen, a new beginning was achieved in 1948. The successor organization was named after Max Planck, the father of quantum theory, who had passed away shortly before. The physicist and Nobel laureate was president of the Kaiser Wilhelm Society from 1930 to 1937. The growing pressure from the National Socialists had forced him at that time to forgo his re-election. Therefore, it was certainly a very symbolic choice of name; it was also a fortunate one, as the Max Planck Society quickly managed to establish itself and significantly contribute to the scientific renewal of the young Federal Republic. Today, it is already among the most respected research institutions worldwide. Professor Gruss has already mentioned it: 17 Nobel Prizes awarded to researchers from its institutes speak for themselves.

Science, when it is responsible, never takes place solely in the so-called ivory tower, but always strives anew to recognize the ethical boundaries of scientific action alongside the researcher’s drive for new scientific knowledge. Every day brings new discoveries. Our level of knowledge is expanding rapidly. The world of technologies is growing and growing, and seemingly unlimited possibilities keep opening up. That is precisely what is exciting about science: an infinite potential for growth. However, it is all the more important to engage with the question of conceivable consequences at every step. Not everything that is feasible is also ethically and socially desirable. I am not giving an anti-lecture to Professor Gruss, but I say that feasibility must of course be questioned time and again.

We have a constitution that protects the freedom of science and research; that is a tremendous success. This freedom opens up the spaces that are essential for successful scientific work. But all articles of the constitution are closely linked to Article 1 – that the dignity of man is inviolable and therefore the freedom of science, like all other freedoms we have, is also subject to limitation. This means that the freedom of the researcher can never be separated from the responsibility of the researcher, just as freedom and responsibility cannot be separated in any other human domain. A person is not an isolated individual. They are embedded in a community of individuals with their own interests and equal rights and – most importantly – their inalienable dignity.

The well-known Max Planck researcher Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker aptly stated in this context: "Science is only mature when it takes responsibility for its consequences." We can now incorporate this into the question of risk and say: Of course, the pursuit of progress is absolutely necessary for a high-tech and industrial country like Germany to secure its future and also to ensure prosperity in the future. If we also look at the demographic questions we have to deal with, we know that curiosity must be an ever-nurtured quality and virtue in our country. Germany is not simply a land of fear; it is also a land of ideas, a country that stands for new technology, pioneering spirit, and the highest engineering skills. Sometimes, interesting thoughts arise from the consideration of risks. Sometimes we may also be, when we consider all consequences, people who think about everything, question much, and take nothing for granted. And thus, all qualities, perhaps also typical qualities of a people, have their shadow sides, but also their bright sides.

Equating the necessary pursuit of progress with limitless progress would be fatal. The ethical dimension must always be kept in mind. We certainly experience the entire spectrum of tension in the field of embryonic research. Here, the question of what we are allowed to do, what we can do, and what is responsible is one that is repeatedly discussed with great intensity and passion in the German Bundestag. And I believe – I can at least say this for myself – that some of the most exciting sessions we have are when it comes to fundamental, moral questions. There are the most serious debates, where it is no longer so easy to distinguish between the parties. It is always very moving when we discuss such fundamental questions. It is research in these areas that brings about beneficial developments on the one hand and always carries the risk of the instrumentalization of human beings on the other.

We have also repeatedly experienced that the state of knowledge and understanding is constantly changing and that the weighting of pro and con certain technologies can change completely. Often, it is only the success of certain technologies that makes them acceptable. I think, for example, of the genetic production of insulin – a question that occupied us for years, almost decades, until the moment when it was almost too late to utilize the process industrially in our country. When it became possible, it led to complete acceptance. No one would today raise the questions that were once raised.

Now, Professor Gruss has spoken for good reasons about energy research as an example, because the disaster at the Fukushima nuclear power plant has certainly occupied all of us, which, by the way, I believe has occupied the whole world, albeit in different ways. I spoke with the Japanese Prime Minister. At least he, like many others, believes that the risks of nuclear technology can also be mitigated by seeking alternatives for energy generation.

Professor Gruss also pointed to the ethics commission, in which politicians or at least people with political experience, scientists, and representatives of the academies have discussed very intensively in a short time. For me, it was a very interesting debate – also about the question: How do I classify risks? I believe, like Professor Gruss, that this ethics commission has contributed significantly to objectifying the debate by ultimately stating: There are risks that we see in connection with nuclear energy that go far beyond our own generation, also far beyond the local application of the respective technology, which is why one should try to exit this technology in a reasonable manner, thus not risking, for example, having to import electricity from nuclear energy or having to forgo electricity supply and thereby putting prosperity into question.

I believe – at least the ethics commission tells us this; and that should also be our goal – that we can achieve, within the next ten years, no short-term increase in CO2 emissions in the country. However, this requires that we do much more in other areas alongside the search for other forms of electricity generation. If we only focused on electricity generation, we would see an increase in CO2 emissions; that is beyond question. But it is the case that 40 percent of our total energy consumption goes solely into heating supply, and we have significant potentials here that we also want to tap, for example, by significantly advancing the renovation of existing buildings. I believe that we must conduct the energy policy debate in such a way that more people understand what it is about. Because energy supply in a highly industrialized country is indeed a core issue for prosperity.

Today, we discussed in the German Bundestag the implementation of the resolutions that the ethics commission has set out for us. We primarily talked about the fact that, if we take such a path, we should not only say what we do not want, but above all say what we want and how we will do it. Because if Germany now dedicates itself to the research of renewable energies and, for example, also to the storage of energy in full breadth and intensity, then future options can also arise from this that offer us great new possibilities.

I know that the path we are now taking is not without risk. Therefore, we will also have to analyze very strictly and verifiably year by year: Where do we stand? A country that does not manage to build 100 kilometers of high-voltage lines in ten years will struggle to reach the age of renewable energies. Therefore, something must change at this point. But I believe that we could also show, as an offer to other countries – without wanting to be morally arrogant – that one can be a highly developed industrial country and still not necessarily need nuclear energy.

Now we find ourselves in a relatively comfortable starting situation. We generate only 23 percent of our electricity from nuclear energy; other countries have a much higher share. Therefore, we can responsibly take this path. But when one imagines the world, when one considers the terrorist threats and regional conflicts, then, I must tell you, it would not be bad to show that one can have good economic development and prosperity without necessarily relying on nuclear energy. I can envision many regions of this world where significant dangers exist. Therefore, it will also be very important in the future to discuss the safety standards of nuclear energy.

The Max Planck Society has recently turned its attention to energy research to a great extent, although Professor Gruss has said that there are, of course, many other areas as well.

I want to say one last word about nuclear fusion: I believe it offers potential. However, I must say that the cost explosions in certain areas do not leave me completely unconcerned, especially when I think about what we hear from the ITER front, for example. We cannot pursue a one-dimensional research focus; I say this with all my commitment to ITER, to the Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics, which is located near my electoral district and which I must love for that reason alone. But we need a balanced approach. There are also many other very exciting, highly interesting research fields.

The Max Planck Society is always in tune with the times and yet steadfast, incorruptible, regarding the pursuit of certain research areas, as that is also important. With everything one must have in terms of media presence today, with everything one must explain to people – hip-hop in research is not the answer to what is needed. Often, things arise unexpectedly, unplanned; and therein lies the charm of a scientist's freedom. Therefore, the right measure and balance must always be found. A topic that was quite interesting six months ago may not be so interesting today. That is why the breadth of research, as it is laid out in the research institutes of the Max Planck Society, is truly important.

Recently, alongside the comparatively predictable financial commitments, even in times of crisis – also stemming from the conviction as a federal government that we, as a society that is aging on average, must invest in research and development – we have found relatively good mechanisms for dialogue between basic research, applied research, and industry-related research. I particularly appreciate the innovation dialogue between science, business, and politics. We expect helpful insights from this on how we can better identify technology lines with high potential for value creation and employment and how we can succeed in placing such technologies in the markets. However, we also see how necessary it is to give basic research time to develop and not to want to predict everything from the political side. I always say: When a topic appears on the culture section of a major newspaper, we all, who are no longer in active research, tend to regard it as particularly important. But one should always respectfully consider that there are many other topics that do not make it there and can still be important.

I am very grateful to you, Professor Gruss, for participating in our innovation dialogue. I believe that the Max Planck Society – and I speak for the entire federal government – is a competent, reliable partner in our research and innovation policy. We try to support you, we try not to interfere too much. Therefore, we also want to build on the successes of the Pact for Research and Innovation. We are increasing the financial resources by five percent each year. Because we view research and development as tickets to the prosperity of tomorrow.

We also need to change the structures – Professor Gruss kindly pointed that out. The Science Freedom Act, bureaucratic hurdles – much needs to be reconsidered repeatedly. Regarding the Science Freedom Act, I can only say: I am in favor. We just have to be careful that those who always work successfully at an institute do not end up being the worst off in the end. One should not promote hopping by making it particularly advantageous with each change – especially when returning from abroad to Germany – otherwise, everyone will first go abroad before coming back. So, the questions of balance must also be considered here. This means that support must be based on strict scientific performance criteria and not solely on the question of whether someone comes from as far away as possible.

We are trying to give you enough breathing room from the political side. However, I also ask you not to create more trouble for yourselves than necessary regarding reporting obligations and other matters. But to retain just as much as is needed to keep an overview – that is always a difficult question of balance. However, if one sometimes has the impression that evaluations take up almost the entire day, that would be bad. In this regard: Have some understanding for all your directors, who sometimes also need to conduct their own research. But that is just a side note; in the end, it is always us who are blamed for it. Therefore, you may develop a certain resistance potential there.

Knowledge, skill, creativity – these are the keywords with which the Max Planck Society has repeatedly won the hearts of the country. Remain a bastion of science, a source of innovation. Continue to be curious. Delight us with new insights and with the fact that the Max Planck Society also has a good reputation abroad.

The presence of the Argentine Minister of Science here today speaks to the fact that you truly have a good reputation on various continents. Science also offers opportunities to live globalization. Germany wants to contribute to this. I may also tell you: There are now diverse opportunities in Germany to study and earn a doctorate not only in German. People in science can usually speak a second language. It does not necessarily have to be Spanish; it is more likely to be English. One does not always have to go to Great Britain or America. Every scientist and student is warmly welcome in Germany. If you could convey that to my colleague, President Kirchner, along with a warm greeting – on behalf of all the other countries from which we would also gladly have guests with us – that would be nice.

Thank you very much for allowing me to be here today. Continue your research, continue to be so successful. And do not believe that you must live only with a "German fear." There are many curious, cheerful people outside the Max Planck Society who take risks.