Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Craftsmen's Day on July 11, 2006, in Osnabrück:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

11 July 2006 · Craftsmen's Day (Handwerkertag) · Osnabrück, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Craftsmen's Day gathering in Osnabrück on July 11, 2006, discussing federal budget reform, labor costs, and the VAT increase affecting the craft sector.
Main themes
Federal budget consolidation, craft sector concerns, labor costs and VAT increase, public debt reduction, investment in future generations, budget reform and savings measures, Hartz IV social spending, pension and health contributions, black market labor, government fiscal policy
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,112
92nd percentile
Sentences
271
94th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.7
18th percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
1.93
4th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 43%42%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Institutional 20%20%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

271 sentences in 59 paragraphs

Dear President Brünger,

Mr. Mayor Fip,

dear district councilors,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag, the state parliament, and the city, and of course, a heartfelt thank you to the band from Angela School.

Mr. President, it was a good idea to invite the young people here, but because of the name, it was particularly meaningful.

I am pleased to be here today. This is, so to speak, my inaugural visit to Lower Saxony outside of Hanover. Today’s program was truly impressive for me. The Felix Nussbaum House particularly impressed me. With the building and the paintings, the city of Osnabrück has really succeeded in honoring the son of the city and impressing many people.

Being a guest of the craft sector is always a special pleasure for me. Yesterday, I spoke with your president, Mr. Kenzler, and with managing director Schleyer. We exchanged views on the situation as we find it, on what we need to tackle, what we have already achieved, and on the positions and interests of the craft sector.

The federal government, which has been in office for eight months now, has set itself a "triple approach" that fully meets the demands and necessities in our country. This is: Renovate, Reform, and Invest. We have placed renovation at the forefront because, regarding the federal budget, we are facing a significant problem, similar to many state budgets. I do not want to overdramatize it, but I want to clearly point out the structural deficit of about 50 billion euros.

You must imagine: This year we have a budget of 260 billion euros. We are taking on almost 40 billion euros in debt, which means we are only collecting 220 billion euros in taxes. Of these 220 billion euros, we have to raise 40 billion euros in interest for the debts we have already incurred in the past. This leaves us with 180 billion euros. Of these 180 billion euros, 80 billion euros go to subsidies for pension insurance – that is a huge chunk. This leaves us with 100 billion euros. And from these 100 billion euros, we have to spend another 40 billion euros on payments related to Hartz IV, that is, the merging of unemployment and social assistance, including appropriate housing. – The Mayor appreciates that. If he receives too little for it, it becomes difficult. – But I will return to this budget item later.

So, we have 60 billion euros left that we can spend to invest in the future, to pay for personnel, roads, the Bundeswehr, and security. This shows you the great challenges we face if we want to significantly reduce these 40 billion euros in new debt we are incurring this year, so that we can once again say: We are fulfilling the Basic Law without claiming any exceptions. The Basic Law tells us: You must invest at least as much in the future as you incur new debt. Of the 260 billion euros that the federal budget comprises, we are spending about 23 billion euros – just under that – on investments in the future. That is not enough. These expenditures once accounted for 13 to 14 percent of the federal budget many years ago; today they are below nine percent. We must now do everything we can so that the people who are playing in the band for us today do not one day find themselves with six or seven percent investments and living in a country that increasingly lives off its substance.

Therefore, I must also ask for your understanding that we will achieve some things through savings. You must see: We achieve 60 percent of the consolidation through savings. But saving hurts individual people. I do not want to beat around the bush: If we change something about the commuter allowance or the saver’s allowance, these are ultimately measures that represent a burden for the individual. Nevertheless, we are faced with the question: What do we do to make our leeway larger again? Incurring more and more debt cannot be the answer. This has nothing to do with whether one or the other loves numbers. Rather, it is a moral component: Are we knowingly heading into a time when we – perhaps in 20 or 30 years – will have no leeway left at all, or do we say: We have so much responsibility for the future that we want to enable the generations after us to have investments and a future as well? I believe that is why renovating the budgets is a very important task.

If you think about it carefully, you realize that we cannot achieve this solely through savings. Therefore, I come deliberately to the point: I know that the craft sector is struggling with the increase in value-added tax. We will increase the value-added tax by three percent, but we will return to you more than one percent as a reduction in labor costs. This means that despite the rising contributions for pensions and health, you can expect to pay more than one percent less in labor costs starting January 1. This is also a momentum that will come into effect on January 1.

I am completely with you. Labor costs are an important factor in the question: Do people choose to go into the black market, or do we create more legal employment again? That was one of the reasons why we said in the chapter "Investing" that we need to improve the deductibility of certain services, of craft services in households. These are those 600 euros. Now the craft sector says it expected more. However, I must report to you that your president Kenzler nonetheless said this is a significant step in the right direction. It is now our collective task to spread this. Sometimes, people in Germany do not even know what possibilities they have. It takes a while for this to spread. We must spread the fact that this deductibility exists just as we must spread the fact that household-related services, such as childcare, can now also be deducted better. These are ways in the service sector to move out of the black market and into legal employment.

Our overall goal is: We want to develop the budget in the 21st century step by step into a workplace, into an employer, because we are firmly convinced that especially in an aging society, there are huge opportunities for simple employment. Our people will not only consist of Nobel Prize winners, but it will also be important that simple work is offered legally and not just done as black market work on the side.

We have also set ourselves the goal of reforming. In this respect, I want to point out that we have made important decisions in a variety of areas from my perspective. For example, infrastructure measures will be significantly shortened in their timeline through the Infrastructure Planning Acceleration Act. We have only had such a law in the new federal states so far, specifically for the transport projects "German Unity." And now we will also have faster planning possibilities for 89 major projects distributed throughout the Federal Republic, because we will only have one court instance here. I think this will be of great importance for structural measures, such as the expansion of Frankfurt Airport, which comes to my mind as an example. When you have more than four million unemployed, it is simply not irrelevant whether a construction project is completed in three, five, seven, or 15 years. Because people are waiting for work today. We must finally succeed in speeding up the procedures in Germany. And this law is very important for that.

Before the summer break, we also passed the Small Business Relief Act. Many say that it is not enough yet. Okay. But it initially includes around 30 measures that reduce bureaucracy and that give start-ups better opportunities to get on their feet and not have to endure certain procedures.

And we will – the legal prerequisites have also been created for this – have a so-called Norm Control Council. This is something we learned from the Dutch and that the British have also adopted. The entire body of laws will be put to the test, and it will first be examined how many reporting obligations, how many control obligations, how many statistical obligations there are. Such things are extremely labor-intensive, especially for small businesses, because they cannot afford entire departments to deal with such matters. In Holland and in Great Britain, they then said: With the regulatory jungle that exists, we want to cut, throw away, and redo 25 percent. That is exactly what we want to do in Germany as well, and – our EU Council presidency will contribute to this – we want to gradually introduce this in Europe as well. The European Commission is ready to put all its directives to the test and to ask: What regulations are actually in place, where do they come from, and what should we perhaps eliminate? I believe this is also an important signal for Europe. For 50 years, only directives have been added. If one falls away now, nothing happens; on the contrary, it may even be good.

We have – I do not want to beat around the bush – had a long discussion about the implementation of the so-called Anti-Discrimination Directive. In the end, we managed to come relatively close to a one-to-one implementation. Even if Hans-Gert Pöttering also comes from the beautiful city of Osnabrück or at least its surroundings, I must say: Even in Europe, one must consider whether certain directives are even necessary. We are a country that has developed an extraordinarily large number of its own laws against the discrimination of people with disabilities and older people. I do not know whether it is, so to speak, essential for the functionality of the European Union to have regulations in this area that often do not fit into our legal system and that are then very difficult to implement.

We have already discussed one point a lot, and we will have to continue discussing it. That is the question: How does the merging of unemployment assistance and social assistance work? This merging is fundamentally correct. The CDU has demanded it for many years, always under the premise: If a person becomes unemployed at a certain age – let’s say between 35 and 55 – then there is, as it has been so far, no permanent connection to previous employment through unemployment assistance. We live in a world where many things are changing. We only wanted one transfer payment, and this means: Promote and demand. It must also be demanded. It must be demanded that the person who receives a job offer accepts this job offer and cannot evade it by saying: I live off transfer payments.

The law had been in effect for about a year when the new federal government took office. Now we have already made two significant changes. And I believe these are not the last. Suddenly, there was a tendency for many who had children to remove these children from their own household. They formed a new need community. In my home, in my constituency, the municipal housing companies were pleased. They had had over-occupancy or under-occupancy. Now they have full occupancy again because children have moved out and established their own households. But when the situation arises that 24-year-olds receive much more than if they worked all day as a cook or in another profession on the island of Rügen or elsewhere, then distortions arise that have nothing to do with promoting and demanding.

Therefore, we have made a change and said: Especially for those under 25, the barriers will be raised, and the payments will be lower. And we have stipulated in the Hartz IV Development Act: Anyone who refuses a job offer three times will receive not a single euro more in transfer payments, but only in-kind benefits. It must be achieved that work is accepted. We will have to deal with the question again in the fall: Should we provide for a combined wage, set up the low-wage sector so that more incentives to work arise? But we must examine all of this very carefully.

I spoke of 40 billion euros. Here we really must get to the point where people do not have the impression that one can live quite well on the transfer payment Hartz IV, but that every single person – I am not talking about those who have no chance of finding a job – feels the strong call of society: Wherever you can get a job, you have a societal obligation to accept it because you ultimately live off the transfer payments from taxpayers who go to work every morning and exert a lot of effort. Here, a collective societal responsibility must be felt and contributed by everyone.

In the Grand Coalition, we have...

Two

Core areas of key points discussed.

The

first

is health reform. I would like to say: It is not pleasant news for me either that we have to expect health insurance contributions to rise by about 0.5 percent at the turn of the year. – This is not decided by the government, but each health insurance fund must decide for itself. – This is related to various measures, it is also related to rising costs due to medical and technological progress. And it has something to do with the structural measures that we are now agreeing on for the next few years, which cannot take full effect until January 1, 2007.

On July 1, we enacted a new pharmaceutical law. I do not know if some of you have already noticed that as a result, drug prices have already fallen significantly, in some cases by up to 40 percent. This will bring us significant savings. But we have much more to do in the healthcare sector, of course.

In the Grand Coalition, we have agreed on essential points regarding health reform, which we still need to implement into law. There will be significantly more competition. I personally am convinced – we have now also set the course for this – that we can only initiate this competition if the insured person is enabled to assess whether their fund is performing well or poorly, whether it is better than another fund, and if the insured person has the opportunity to choose "their" fund with the corresponding conditions.

The fund that is much discussed in public, which I do not want to bore you with, is essentially the prerequisite for us to achieve transparency and for individuals to know at the beginning of the year: My fund needs more or less money to fulfill the services of the statutory health catalog than another, with my fund I get something extra, my fund offers me certain options. This way, the insured person gradually becomes an informed insured person who can form a judgment.

In order for them to do that, they must also know what costs they incur. This means we first need to develop a fee schedule for doctors. This will take two years. – Today, doctors receive points and later they get the message about what the point is worth, but no one has an overview of the exact costs. – A similar process is now being implemented in hospitals. Then, for the first time, we will have the opportunity to determine what a hospital stay, what a specific operation in the hospital sector, and what it costs in the outpatient sector with a specialist. This is almost impossible to compare today.

We will – I am now looking at the Minister-President – also need more transparency in the hospital sector. Some municipalities still help hospitals a bit, while others have privatized their hospitals. You can hardly compare the work of a specialist with the work of a hospital when the specialist, as a freelancer, has to manage everything themselves, while the hospital may still receive support from its home city.

This means we must embark on a process where everyone must also say to some extent: Yes, we must also look at what the costs are. You do this in your businesses, and it must also be the case in healthcare. Otherwise, we will not make any progress.

Recently, it has often been pointed out: When the fund comes, the funds will have to lay off people. Because today, 30 to 40 percent of fund employees are only busy collecting contributions. I say: That is bitter. But that cannot be our top priority. We are obligated to the money of the insured. This also concerns the additional wage costs of the crafts. Therefore, we must do everything we can to ensure that people receive good healthcare, but we do not have to do everything to keep the structures as they are. These structures must change everywhere in Germany.

Furthermore, we will enable things that are not possible today, so that funds do not have to negotiate with all doctors in a city, but can decide with which doctors, with which groups of doctors they want to negotiate. It will happen that pharmacies and funds can negotiate with pharmaceutical manufacturers. We will set a maximum price for a drug, and if someone wants to offer below that, they can do so. This will also be related to the quantities. Then it will suddenly be found that the medication costs different amounts for a specific fund patient, regardless of whether they are with one fund or another. Then the insured will think again about why it is different for one and the other. All these things we will set in motion. They are the core of the health reform that we are now implementing.

Now we come to the exciting point you mentioned. It is true: We have a deficit at the beginning of the year, but we are addressing it step by step. You say it is not happening quickly enough, but when I look at you, you would not advise me to raise taxes; you were already hesitant about the value-added tax. – So we are doing it step by step. We say: The financing of children's health is not only a task for health insurers, but it is a task for the general public. Child benefits are paid by taxpayers, parental benefits will in the future be paid by taxpayers, and children's health should also be paid by taxpayers in the future.

We will do this in several steps. This will lead to either a reduction in additional wage costs or, in connection with medical and technological progress, no longer an increase. As of January 1, 2008, we will for the first time legally establish the employee and employer contributions. And we can assure you that then the health insurance contributions will not rise for many years – we cannot all think beyond 20 years, but in a period that I set until 2012 or 2013 – that is, employee and employer contributions will remain constant. We all do not yet know how the structural reforms will impact, but this will be legally established for the first time. And through the gradual financing of children's contributions, we can absorb the costs. I think this is a very reliable message for you, which you also need regarding the development of additional wage costs.

Mr. President, another point you mentioned is, of course, the corporate tax reform. We probably agree that we must manage to tax partnerships and corporations in a form-neutral manner, as it is so nicely called, that is, uniformly. We have – as you all know – very different conditions in partnerships. 70 to 80 percent already pay less than 30 percent in taxes today, and a certain share, which is of great importance, pays significantly more than 30 percent. Therefore, we must ensure that the burden for all does not exceed 30 percent. That is certainly our declared goal. And we must, I think, ensure that partnerships, whether through an investment reserve or through retention, that is, through better treatment of the assets remaining in the business, experience significant relief.

Tomorrow, we will adopt key points in the cabinet. We will then still have to discuss how we can further develop the trade tax without municipalities having to fear being worse off. At the same time, we must ensure that we do not have substantial taxation on a large scale, as that would also lead us in the wrong direction. I also tell you: Article 115 of the Basic Law, which concerns the budget, must be taken into account. This means: We will not be able to afford relief beyond five billion euros in the medium term over the next few years. This must now be brought into balance, and we will continue to seek dialogue with you.

But I believe we are making significant progress – also in Europe – towards a competitive tax law, where it no longer needs to be said that one must go elsewhere to run a business properly. I believe we are also doing an important service to the crafts when we say: Partnerships and corporations must be able to compete fairly in a form-neutral manner.

When we look at all this, the question remains: What do we invest in the future? The federal government essentially has two focus areas.

The

first

is the question: Where will the jobs of the future be created, what must we do for that? In this respect, education is a very essential point. We have just reminded each other that perhaps some could still offer an apprenticeship if the readiness of young people coming from school were better. That is a problem. Therefore, what the Minister-President said is so important. The school education, the school qualifications must be such that they fit the requirements for vocational training, to the demands of a modern profession.

In this respect, both sides probably need to move. It is actually incomprehensible that children in Germany go to school for ten years, but after graduation cannot do what is needed to enter a reasonable professional life. That must not be the case. Perhaps sometimes too much is learned and too little is practiced in fundamental skills. One does not necessarily have to know a multitude of facts. What is more important is the approach, the ability to think in contexts.

Secondly

, one must consider whether the job profiles are not, to put it somewhat loosely, a bit over the top, whether they demand what absolutely needs to be demanded. I know that the modern technical world places entirely different demands on today's job profiles than it did in the past. Whoever is assigned to a state-of-the-art machine must already be able to program a bit and be familiar with CAD/CAM. That is beyond question. But we must ensure that we offer training modules that young people can also manage and with which we can also create opportunities for simple tasks.

Education is the core area. Regarding apprenticeship places, I want to point out once again that in three, four, or five years, we will have entirely different discussions in Germany. Then we will no longer ask what we will do with the many school leavers, but we will ask where we will get young people from. Therefore, I ask those who have the financial means to do so to use them and give young people a chance. I will, even if I am booed at the DGB Congress for it, not tire of saying: The IG BCE did the right thing and said: We will not raise the training allowances in the collective bargaining negotiations of the coming years. I am not talking about cuts, but about not raising them, as that would not be responsible. It is worth much more today in magnitude if a young person receives vocational training than if their apprentice salary increases by two percent. I am deeply convinced of that.

When we talk about training, we naturally also have higher education and science in mind. When one looks at China, when one looks at the United States of America, it becomes clear that in order to keep up with other countries, we must invest three percent of our gross domestic product in research and development. Therefore, it is also important, when one considers the non-state sector, that capital formation takes place in businesses so that money can flow into these areas at all. Whoever always lives from hand to mouth cannot innovate and cannot achieve new research results.

But the federal government is providing six billion euros more in this legislative period to contribute to the state's share of these three percent of gross domestic product for research and development expenditures. We will also organize this in a high-tech strategy so that it does not become "scattered," and we will focus on what is truly future-oriented, with which we can intensify our strengths, with which we can then truly become world-class.

Our prosperity depends to a significant extent on whether we, as the Federal Republic of Germany, can continue to perform as we have for many years, namely that we are clearly better and faster than others. The Federal President has said it completely correctly: We must be so much better as we are more expensive. If we want to maintain our social systems, if we want to provide assistance for the disabled, as I saw today in the special education facilities, then we must not only be able to do what everyone else in the world can do, but we must have the unyielding drive to be better and to develop new products. For this reason, investment in science and research is of fundamental importance.

For many years, there has not been enough intensive discussion in this country about technology, technologies, engineering sciences, and much more. I consider it a disgrace that we have 10,000 too few engineers each year. This is not a good trademark for Germany, a country that has been known for its inventors, tinkerers, and engineers. This must change again.

One more general remark. We live in a complicated world. When I sometimes talk to people about health reform, they say: Spare us all the details, we actually don’t want to hear that, it’s all so complicated. Then I always say: The statement "the electricity comes from the socket and I don’t need to worry about anything else" has not advanced Germany. Everyone knows quite well today at the OBI hardware store. Then one can also understand how the German healthcare system works and also decide there for what is particularly cost-effective. I am firmly convinced that we can only get a grip on our problems if we apply the educational standards we have in everyday life, and indeed in all areas. This is a very essential prerequisite for us to also demonstrate a conscious way of thinking again.

Therefore, I believe we are on the right track. But in eight months, the results may not yet have shown themselves. By the way: Without a Grand Coalition, the federalism reform that we have now decided upon would not have come about at all. It is a huge undertaking with many complications and also many compromises that everyone had to make, but something that will advance our community because we are finally returning to the state we were in when the Basic Law was enacted: That not 60 or 70 percent of the laws require approval and that no compromises are made in the mediation committee where it is no longer clear who is responsible for what, but that there are now clear responsibilities again.

I was told today that the welfare associations are not satisfied with the federalism reform because, for example, the home regulations, the home law fall under state jurisdiction. I replied: Why do you assume from the outset that the states will do it worse? The states are closer to the people. Decisions must return to the people. That is the task in this republic. What is decided at the federal level must be something that cannot be better decided at the state level. It is not about hoarding competencies, but about having clear responsibilities that people can see through and where they can also say: You, member of the Bundestag, or you, member of the state parliament, decided that; please stand up for it. Store closing times, restaurant opening hours, and much more can be decided in the states. I am quite sure of that. Therefore, it is right that we now give that back there.

Mr. Mayor, we have also established in the federalism reform that the federal government may no longer simply transfer tasks to the municipalities. This is also an important point. The states are already friendly towards the municipalities. So nothing can happen to them anymore. It is very important that we do not deprive local politics of its creative power. I said that today in the town hall. I consider that to be a very essential point.

I believe that we are on a path where certainly some still wish for more, but where it is also important to place the triad "Renovate, Reform, Invest" in an overall context. I recently said: It is perhaps a bit like starting to build a house. You cannot yet see how cozy the living room will be. We are indeed in a very strong working atmosphere, but the perspective must be clear: We want growth and we want jobs. With 4.5 million unemployed, jobs are the be-all and end-all. None of us can be satisfied with what exists. Therefore, I believe that the steps we are taking are going in the right direction. We need more of that. We, as the federal government, are determined – also in conversation with you – to do what is necessary for Germany.

In this respect, I am happy to refer to what was said here today. The Football World Cup has actually shown how eagerly people want to be proud of their country, how happy they are when people from abroad come to our country. The heads of state and government told me again at the final what is thought about Germany during those days: That we can be cheerful for more than an hour, that we are proud of our country, that we want to take action. We should preserve this spirit. And we in the federal government want to contribute to that.