Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on Federalism Reform before the German Bundestag on June 30, 2006, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

30 June 2006 · Session of the German Bundestag on federalism reform · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on June 30, 2006, urging passage of a landmark federalism reform to restructure constitutional responsibilities between federal and state levels.
Main themes
Federalism reform, constitutional revision, distribution of legislative competencies, federal-state relations, subsidiarity principle, municipal governance, university autonomy, civil service law, national stability pact, internal security coordination, political accountability, Sunday trading laws
Duration
~11 min
39th percentile
Words
1,336
39th percentile
Sentences
79
52nd percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 62%61%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Environmental 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

79 sentences in 20 paragraphs

Madam President!

Dear colleagues!

After years of intense discussion, the German Bundestag will today vote on the federalism reform. The federal government and the states have not taken this lightly in these discussions. Rarely has there been such a struggle among us. I find this more than understandable; after all, it is about a fundamental revision of our constitution. In my view, this is one of the most important reforms of our time.

I would like to say on behalf of the federal government that we are convinced that today we are setting the right course for our country. For this reason, this is a good day for Germany, and indeed for all levels: federal, state, and also the municipalities.

There is no doubt: Our federal system is good and has proven itself. People live in their states. However, in the 60 years since the founding of the Federal Republic of Germany – this has been unmistakable – an imbalance has arisen in this structure of federal order. In particular, complicated and lengthy decision-making processes have led to many uncertainties regarding political responsibilities. Federal legislation has tended to overshadow state legislation. For many citizens, it has become unclear who is responsible for what.

Therefore, this federalism reform offers the historic opportunity to reorganize the intertwined responsibilities, to enable freedom for responsible action, but also to create federal competencies where necessary in a changed world. This will make government action more transparent. For me, a very essential point is that the number of laws requiring consent will be reduced. This is a huge opportunity for the German Bundestag, because in my view, the non-requirement for consent and the elimination of the opaque mediation committee meetings will create a situation in which the debates in our house, in the German Bundestag, will become livelier and more intense, as every member knows: There is no second compromise line. I must stand by what I decide here. That is my responsibility.

The abolition of framework legislation is an unmistakable progress and means, especially with regard to universities, a strengthening of the autonomy of universities. We have returned some legislative competencies to the states. I believe it corresponds to the general understanding of the principle of subsidiarity to bring matters closer to the people: shop closing law, restaurant law, and assembly law.

The state parliaments will – this is true, but at least they are our colleagues in the parties who belong to these parliaments – receive new responsibilities in criminal enforcement and home law.

At this point, I would like to make a request. In the federalism commission, there has always been a discussion about how Sundays and public holidays can be particularly honored in shop closing laws. Therefore, it would be welcome if this were also expressed in state laws, for example, that there should not be the possibility of shop openings on more than four Sundays. That would correspond to our understanding. I would like to leave that with you.

There have been broad discussions in all factions, for example, also about the issues of career, salary, and pension law for state officials. Many in this house have found it difficult to relinquish a piece of competence here. Therefore, I would like to emphasize once again that it is very important for us that the so-called traditional principles of civil service, enshrined in the Basic Law, continue to apply. I believe that was also a very important step for us. The discussion about this was not easy.

In particular, municipalities will benefit from this federalism reform; because it is now enshrined that tasks may no longer be transferred to the municipal level by federal law. This means that this must happen through the states, which hopefully are committed to the principle of connectivity not only in principle but also in practice. This means that municipalities will be financially equipped as necessary.

One thing is very important for the federal side: the anchoring of the national stability pact in the Basic Law. It was almost a moment of glory, if I may say so. When we talk about federal-state financial relations, I wish for more such moments of glory. In the future, all public budgets will have an interest in avoiding violations of the European stability and growth pact, as the federal and state governments are jointly liable. This is an exceptionally good regulation.

It has been possible, and this is already a significant reason to support this reform, to create more clarity of responsibility in security policy. We have a completely changed situation regarding threats today. We have the traditional understanding that internal security is largely a matter for the states. It is important that it has been possible to anchor a coordination competence of the Federal Criminal Police Office for cross-state dangers, which enables us to provide people with a little more security and to do our utmost for them. This is, for me, a very essential point of the federalism reform.

I do not want to hide the problems. The hardest debates were held over education policy. As a federal politician, I say: It is important to me that there is a joint evaluation by the federal and state governments that can determine the performance of the education system in international comparison. Here, action must be taken together. I also say very clearly: I am pleased with the changes that have been achieved in the last discussions.

The question arose as to whether the overall structure of the comprehensive reform is being called into question. Many aspects had to be considered. We can succeed in advancing the modernization of our science system. Research and teaching form a unity. In the future, new cooperations will be possible if the states support them. Our system of science, research, and teaching will change. Therefore, it is good that there is a practical possibility – all states must agree, okay – that universities can cooperate with non-university institutions. This is a huge opportunity.

It would be surprising if there were not a multitude of discussions about the deviation rights. Nevertheless, I believe that particularly in the environmental sector, the federal level is among the winners of this federalism reform. The question of whether we need an environmental code must be answered clearly with yes.

Therefore, I consider it right that the Federal Environment Minister now has the opportunity to tackle such a project. This is, by the way, a very ambitious project. I advise against always assuming the worst regarding the deviation regulations and their use by the states, but rather to trust in the power of the factual. You will see: It will settle in reasonably. We have the chance to create environmental legislation in a coherent manner.

For all these reasons, I believe that we can, in good conscience, pass the first stage of the federalism reform today after these truly careful discussions.

Dear Mr. Westerwelle, I remember our conversation well. It was stated that immediately after the adoption of the first stage of the federalism reform, the second stage will be tackled. With particular involvement of our colleagues from the FDP, we have discussed with the prime ministers the question of the procedure and the tasks of such a second stage. We have again decided, especially with regard to the FDP, to involve the factions of the German Bundestag in these discussions from the very beginning. This was not only a fundamental consideration but also took into account that not all factions are in government. To now act as if the FDP had not been involved in the development of the first stage of the federalism reform, as agreed, before the second stage was tackled, I find a little concerning, to put it mildly.

In conclusion, I would like to thank everyone who has worked on the federalism reform, especially Edmund Stoiber and Franz Müntefering. With this project, we demonstrate courage for changes that will benefit the people in our country. Therefore, I appeal for your support.