Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Digitising Europe Summit 2019 on February 19, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

26 February 2019 · Digitising Europe Summit 2019 · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Digitising Europe Summit 2019 in Berlin on February 19, 2019, speaking on Europe's digital future and competitiveness.
Main themes
Digitalization in Europe, European digital sovereignty, Social Market Economy, data security and data sovereignty, competition law reform, European single market, global data governance, GDPR, telecommunications investment, China and US data models, European values and human dignity, level playing field
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,556
69th percentile
Sentences
139
78th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Technological 21%19%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

139 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Read,

Mr. Ametsreiter,

Mr. Reiter,

ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to thank you for the invitation to this Digitising Europe Summit! I am very pleased to accept this invitation for the second time because I believe that a truly important discussion is taking place here. You are discussing what the trademark "Made in Europe" will mean in the future. How attractive will Europe remain in the digital age?

Mr. Read has just reminded us, despite all the optimism, that we need to be faster and more resolute. Nevertheless, I want to start with the European theme alongside the technical questions. In a few months, a new European Parliament will be elected. We should not forget, in everything we discuss, that the European Union is a guarantor of peace, freedom, and prosperity for us. It should remain so. The single market is undoubtedly the foundation for economic success and for European integration. But I can only agree with Jacques Delors, the former Commission President, who said: "No one falls in love with a single market." That is true. Therefore, it must be clear in all technical developments and discussions about digitalization that it is always about people, their dignity, their freedom, and their security. That must be at the center.

This is also what characterizes the European social model, which we describe in Germany with the term Social Market Economy. This social model has proven itself reasonably well over the last seven decades. But we also know that not everyone in the world shares these values and this way of living, doing business, and working that we have in Europe. Therefore, we Europeans must keep our competitors in mind and confidently pursue our own path. That is what it is about.

Europe must provide its own answers to data-driven business models. But when I say "own," I must also emphasize "provide answers." It cannot be the case that we only describe the uniqueness of our path while the answers lag behind the times. This means that our own solutions must be solutions to the problems that need to be solved in the world. That is the great challenge we face.

We want to work with partners, including from all over the world. Of course, in my understanding, it would be best if we had reliable global framework conditions – also to avoid distortions of competition. You mentioned, Mr. Read, that we need a "level playing field." In fact, it would be the task of the G20, for example, to work out certain regulations. But we are far from that because we have very, very different attitudes towards the use of data and the framework conditions we find for it.

In fact, there are two poles in the world. One is, so to speak, the United States of America, where many data are in private hands and the regulatory questions regarding data handling are far less clarified and regulated than they are with us. On the other side is the pole of China, where state access to data is something very self-evident, as we experience, for example, with "social scoring" or "social crediting."

We now need to look: What is our understanding in this area? What does our own path mean? How can we establish or maintain value chains in Europe and thus also ensure prosperity for tomorrow? Therefore, we must, so to speak, wisely define what we have always done in the Social Market Economy – that is, on the one hand, to define the framework within which our developments take place through politics, but on the other hand, also to leave enough room for companies to develop.

I just told Mr. Read that I, together with his predecessor, attended many, many meetings with the European Round Table and discussed with the European Commission and the respective French President whether we in Europe are actually ready to allow companies that can play a global role, or whether our competition law is not actually sufficiently prepared for the global situation. We have not had much success with this perspective so far. In Europe, when thinking about the profitability of telecommunications companies, there is a strong focus on the customer. That is nice. But one must always ask: Are the investment opportunities sufficient? Are the possibilities to accumulate capital to invest enough to keep up with those who are leading in this area? Unfortunately, we have now also seen from another example that the perspective on competition leaves me with doubts about whether we can really reach global players in this way. But for that, we must also find a European willingness to change competition law.

Questions of data security, data sovereignty, and ethical issues must therefore be clarified alongside questions of economic freedom. That is why there have been dramatic struggles in recent days, I would say, after we established the General Data Protection Regulation, for which we receive more praise outside of Europe than within Europe. But I believe that, in principle, it is the right approach. What we often lack, however, is that when we have made a regulation and we sit back for the next decade and say, "Now we have done it," while we actually need to become a faster learning system in the digital world – we must learn from the weaknesses of such regulations, which are naturally present, and say: we need to improve. This is an important point that Europe must learn better.

Now we have a discussion about copyright and related rights. The State Minister from the Chancellery is here; we represent somewhat different positions. I have said that we must finally find a solution in Europe. When 28 countries are striving for such a solution, it very much depends on Germany and France. A serious controversy has erupted regarding how we deal with start-ups. The upload filters are already being called the Merkel filters. I have endured many shitstorms, millions of complaints – not millions of legal complaints, but so to speak, mental complaints. But I believe that the question of the extent to which rules from the real world must also apply in the digital world will continue to concern us. I, for one, believe that the internet cannot be a space where intellectual property is no longer protected at all. We must continue to fight this battle.

Interestingly, these political struggles are no longer taking place between the parties, but between the respective groups: those who tend to have the rules of the traditional world in mind and those who feel more at home on the internet and believe that different rules need to be applied there. We simply need to continue this discussion.

Security and trust in the security of data is essential, also for the acceptance of new business models. You have also pointed out acceptance issues – whether it is about Industry 4.0, autonomous driving, or telemedicine. This means that balancing freedom and security is a very outstanding issue for Europe.

This also applies to Artificial Intelligence. We, as the federal government, have developed a strategy for this. Because I believe that we need to be faster in Germany. In implementing this strategy, we will primarily need to pay attention to one thing – as you mentioned – namely that we have a reasonable skilled workforce. The skills are not sufficiently available. The specialists are also not sufficiently available. We have a multitude of efforts – from Girls' Day to promoting STEM subjects in schools – but we have not yet been sufficiently successful in making it clear to people: If you have digital skills and pursue corresponding professions, you have endless opportunities – use them! There is still a reluctance here and an excessive concentration on traditionally known professions.

That is also my request to all those sitting here in the hall who know how the world will develop. It is not a question of whether there will be fewer jobs, but of whether we have the right education for future jobs. This question is on the table. Since we have a demographic problem in Germany anyway – we will have about six million fewer people of working age by 2030 than in 2015/2016 – it is of course crucial that we have a sufficiently high number of trained individuals in new technologies.

We, as the federal government, will spend an additional three billion euros on Artificial Intelligence in the coming years of this legislative period. That may sound like a small amount, but in Germany, it is always composed in such a way that one part is at the federal level and the other at the state level. There are federal states where a lot of effort is being invested in the development of Artificial Intelligence.

I believe that we have all the possibilities in research. But we have a difficulty in transferring research results into industrial and other applications. We need to focus on that. We cannot do this alone as Germany. That is why we have agreed in the Aachen Treaty, the new Franco-German treaty, that we want to jointly develop the entire network of Artificial Intelligence with France. I think this must then also be extended to Europe.

As a state, we also have a task to make digitalization tangible. Unfortunately, we are not at the forefront in European terms in this regard. But we are determined to digitalize all interactions of citizens with their state by the end of this legislative period, perhaps by early 2022, thus creating a citizen portal through which all over 500 functions can be accessed digitally. You cannot imagine how difficult this is in a federal system. It was first necessary to carry out a constitutional amendment to give the federal government any competence in this matter. We were only able to carry out this constitutional amendment at a very favorable moment in the last legislative period, namely when the states were discussing the federal-state financial negotiations with us. In their full concentration on the money that comes to each, they said: Well, okay, if you really need a constitutional amendment for that, then you can have it. So we had the constitutional amendment. Then we created the corresponding law, the Online Access Act.

Now we are trying to incentivize the various federal states to engage in a small competition regarding which functions each state wants to digitalize first. The crucial question is, of course – and we are still debating this with the Federal Office for Information Security, as you can imagine – how the citizen's access to this account actually takes place. It must be such that I do not have to carry one device on the left and another device on the right in my pocket, but that it works simply. And we are looking at others around the world to see how to do this sensibly.

This is a huge task, but I believe it is an absolutely necessary task to show people what digitalization can mean in terms of simplification. And that, of course, also has a certain learning effect for the acceptance of digitalization overall.

In conclusion, I want to address the question that you – and when I say "you," I mean Vodafone and many others – are currently concerned about: the question of digital infrastructure. We need better infrastructure. While I am not always convinced that everything elsewhere is as brilliant as it is presented to me – but regardless, it is currently not sufficient here. We are indeed facing a completely new task. We must no longer create something that we classify as public service, such as electrical lines and water and sewage lines, through the state; rather, we want it to arise through private investments. We must set the appropriate state incentives so that, in the end, it truly becomes a public service for every household.

You have your investment interests; that is clear. That is why we have no problem with broadband connections between, I would say, Cologne and Düsseldorf. But where my constituency is located, it looks a bit gloomier. The people expect us to have a connection for every household. And while we are still talking about these households, people say: Yes, but a household is of course not enough; I also need a connection when I have my picnic on the meadow. Or the Minister of Agriculture would say: The farmer also needs it in his agricultural machine.

This means we need comprehensive coverage with internet access. At the moment, there is quite a bit of confusion in the discussion. I would say: Anyone who drives through the Brandenburg forests more often would already be pleased about 2G availability on the country roads. The standard must be 4G today. We will reach 99 percent of households – so I don’t say anything wrong: What did you promise? 2021 or even 2020, I believe – reach. Then the one percent of households comes to us and asks: What about us?

So we now need to find reasonable ways to connect private investment power with state funding. Because it is currently about the auction of 5G frequencies and everyone says, "This is a very favorable moment to address everything where we are still deficient," we are currently in a very difficult discussion. Because at the moment, the frequencies to be auctioned are not even about achieving comprehensive 5G coverage. It is, so to speak, also about achieving as comprehensive 4G coverage as possible. In our discussions, it is, on the one hand, about the question, "How many conditions do we impose on you for the auction?" and on the other hand, about the question, "How much freedom do you still have to make the investments that you believe need to be made?"

So this is a tough battle, which I believe does not require further detailing for an opening speech; you will discuss this further elsewhere today. You should just know: I am aware of this battle; and it is currently being fought not only by the federal government but also very strongly in the parliamentary arena. Since we have fallen short of expectations in some areas – something that concerns the connection with 50 megabits per second – a certain impatience is palpable. And from this impatience arise political demands, where we really have to be careful that they do not become an overdetermined equation, as I would say as a former physicist.

In this sense, there is much to be done. We know that our prosperity for tomorrow is at stake. For the next European Council in March, I have requested that we have a discussion among the heads of state and government about the industrial location of Europe once again, because I have the impression that in the sum of rules we create – in the environmental area and in other areas – a regulatory framework could emerge in which a free development cannot thrive sufficiently. I absolutely agree with you, Mr. Read: This is not a question of decades, but this question is now on the agenda. We cannot simply move on when we see that the large companies are all outside of Europe.

Therefore, thank you for what you are doing – critical discussions with you included! And thank you for inviting me!