Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Global Solutions Summit on March 19, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

19 March 2019 · Global Solutions Summit · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Global Solutions Summit in Berlin on March 19, 2019, speaking on global governance, multilateralism, and sustainability challenges.
Main themes
Multilateralism, global responsibility, climate change and sustainability, democracy, international cooperation, compromise in diplomacy, G20 and global financial governance, systemic competition between national and multilateral approaches, shared community of responsibility, migration and conflict
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,195
78th percentile
Sentences
145
79th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.08
58th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 29%27%
  • Economic 22%21%
  • Institutional 19%17%
  • Environmental 14%13%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

145 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Professor Snower,

ladies and gentlemen,

thank you very much for the invitation. A lot has already happened here. I have looked at your program. You are working intensively, and you have probably discussed all the topics from various angles. But I am also very pleased to be here on the last day of this conference, because the questions you are addressing and dealing with are truly of extraordinary importance.

We are asking ourselves: What is the future of democracy, of multilateralism, and of the major challenges related to sustainability – foremost among them the issue of climate change, also considering the resulting consequences such as flight and civil wars, military or violent conflicts? The scope of the issues you are dealing with is global. In my firm opinion – which most of you share as well – they can only be solved if we do not see ourselves merely as a community of responsibility in national contexts, but if we also view our entire world as a community of responsibility.

Of course, this is easier said than done, as we often struggle to understand what shared responsibility means even in a national context. We in the Federal Republic of Germany have a federal system. Sometimes it is not so easy for the municipal level to understand itself as a community of responsibility in relation to the state level and the federal level, or vice versa. Projecting this onto the entire world is, of course, an incredible challenge for the individual. That is why the slogan "Think globally, act locally" might also be a good response, because not everyone can always grasp everything at the same moment.

But I believe it is undisputed: We need a shared responsibility for the world. We must ask ourselves how we can transform this responsibility into active engagement with energy. It is evident that if we understand ourselves as a community of responsibility in the world, we also need a multilateral approach. This means nothing other than that all actors are in conversation with each other in such a way that they want to find common solutions. This, in turn, means that I must make the effort not only to understand myself but also my partners. This requires the ability to look beyond one's own horizon, as we say in Germany. And it requires the ability to put myself in the other person's shoes, to understand their arguments, and to shape a compromise from my interests and the interests of others. That is why I will not tire of saying: Those who advocate for multilateralism must also be good at handling compromises, as one will never achieve a solution that is 100 percent one's own.

Of course, not every compromise is acceptable, but in a compromise – as I have always seen in my political work and continue to see – we must say that the benefits must outweigh the disadvantages. But there will never be total happiness for one party; rather, everyone will miss something. In the end, however, something will emerge for the whole that is more than the sum of individual interests. That is the added value of multilateralism.

Now, multilateralism is under pressure because, in recent years, a perspective has begun to take hold that says: This is all so laborious, it is so imperfect; and actually, as a national actor, I can achieve more for my interest group and come out better. We simply have to endure and engage in this systemic competition – which is a competition of two systems of thought. There are few compromises here. Either a nation sees only its own perspective, or it embarks on the path of finding common solutions with others and accepts that others also have interests.

It is regrettable that this development at the expense of multilateralism is occurring so quickly, as we have only just left the great international financial crisis behind us ten years ago. At that time, the G20 was established at the level of heads of state and government. Until then, it only existed at the level of finance ministers. I still remember very well how I spoke on the phone with George Bush, who was president at the time, and said – we agreed on this – that an international response to this international crisis was necessary. We then came together for the first time in the United States during the interim period between the presidencies of George Bush and, after the election, Barack Obama. At that time, everyone agreed to learn from the crisis, but also to combat the immediate consequences of this crisis with stimulus programs, general banking rules, and so on.

I will never forget that China played a very important role during this phase, particularly with large stimulus programs. We all implemented stimulus programs, but with 1.3 billion inhabitants, such programs are, of course, particularly effective. This helped ensure that the world economy did not slide further down but found a way to emerge from this crisis. We also found a multitude of banking regulations and – we all remember – said: Never again should a financial market actor or product be without regulation. We made some progress on these issues.

Now I come to what is called a backlash in English, to the question of whether we might not be better off alone, because the business of international order is, of course – there is no question about it – laborious. But I believe we must continue on the path of multilateralism and also of the G20 process. You, who are sitting here, have also made this your mission – with all the different interests, with all the different motivations for it.

That is why we are first advocating for a reform of international organizations, foremost the World Trade Organization. At the last G20 meeting in Argentina, we were able to agree with the United States that there should be a reform of the World Trade Organization (WTO). However, there is still no consensus on how it should look. Particularly urgent at the World Trade Organization is, of course, the issue of dispute resolution. Because if the relevant judges' positions are not filled again, then the entire mechanism – this is obvious – is not practicable.

We must say and also admit that the malaise, if I may say so, of the reform of international organizations did not begin with the current American administration. I remember well the presidency of Barack Obama, during which we repeatedly discussed WTO reforms and especially WTO agreements, until we decided to focus on bilateral trade agreements for a certain period. These bilateral trade agreements then sprang up like mushrooms. The European Union has also adopted a multitude of such bilateral trade agreements. They are good, but they are essentially only the second-best solution. The better solution is a comprehensive solution for the world. But for that, one must bring about a consensus among about 180 countries at the same time; and that proves to be extraordinarily difficult.

I am very pleased that the Japanese G20 presidency is now also expanding the issues to include the question of digitalization and the handling of data. Because we still have no international or multilateral regulations for that. Of course, one can do some things nationally and in Europe, but that is then not a truly comprehensive system. Therefore, the question of a global data regulatory framework, which is on the agenda at the G20 summit in Osaka, is, in my view, a very important building block of Japan's program, which we also need in order to be able to answer ethical questions of artificial intelligence, which will reach us sooner rather than later, on a global scale. That is why this is very important.

We have further questions. I mentioned the slowness of the reform of international organizations. I do not want to illustrate this with the example of the quota system at the IMF or the capital increase at the World Bank; that has also taken a long time. The truth behind it is that we are in a time when the balance of power in the world is shifting. These are shifts that can be compared to developments in geological history. Suddenly, a high mountain emerges where there used to be a depression. However, one can – or must – now decide whether to accept this high mountain or not. Thus, the balance of power is shifting between the United States and its economic power, which is very large, and, for example, China. This also applies in connection with other Asian states. With India, this will also happen one day.

How do we deal with this? Do we say: No, the landscape as we know it is ours; and we will not allow any changes to it, but work with everything we have against tectonic shifts? Or do we say: Okay, this is the result of efforts in other countries as well; we must deal with this new landscape, and we must do so fairly and honestly, of course reciprocally; we must accept it and not fight it as if we were in a battle.

Today, 30 years after the fall of the Iron Curtain, when we thought the systemic competition had been won in favor of democracies, we face a huge challenge because it turns out that we are in systemic competition with China. But the answer cannot be to simply fight those who are economically strong; rather, we must advocate for reciprocal, fair regulations and must not abandon the multilateral system. This is, in my view, the imperative of the hour.

Of course, we notice – this has been evident in Germany in the discussions about TTIP, the free trade agreement with the United States – that the complexity of systemic competition cannot simply be explained by saying: I will do the zero variant, the zero approach; I will reduce or eliminate tariffs. These are the tariff barriers to trade; there is much that can be done there. That is relatively straightforward; and one trusts those who deal with trade to be able to do that.

It becomes difficult whenever we move into the area of non-tariff barriers, when, for example, one creates a fantastic new technology for the control device at the airport for security checks and says: This is it; and only those who use this technology may fly with American or Chinese or German or any other airplanes – I do not want to exclude anyone. Suddenly, one has a trade barrier that has nothing to do with tariffs, but which leads to the situation that one can only sell one's own security devices at the airport. Those who buy others no longer have access for passengers.

This is happening in many places now, which is why people say: Well, if we think this through properly, we realize that we have non-tariff trade barriers, starting from social systems to environmental regulations. Everywhere there are regulations that can be exclusion criteria and that we cannot capture with tariffs, but which are now up for discussion. Of course, a societal discussion has arisen in which it has been said: Well, economists who are familiar with tariffs cannot simply start dealing with our environmental regulations or begin to, so to speak, bring chlorinated chicken to Europe. – What debates we have had!

This means that the big question of multilateralism will be how to deal with non-tariff trade barriers. That is why the spectrum of the G20 has expanded. That is why we are no longer only dealing with financial market regulation and tariffs, but also with climate protection, with environmental regulations, with the question of social minimum standards, with the value chain of textile products from Bangladesh to Germany, and with health issues, which of course also have a tremendous impact on the development opportunities of individual countries.

I think we can say that Germany, during its G20 presidency, did a lot to broaden the range of topics. We are pleased that Japan is now taking on some of these topics. The issue of global health continues to play a role. The role of women in societies continues to be important, which I consider very significant – both for the relatively highly developed industrial countries and in connection with the question of how Africa deals with its opportunities and how poorer Asian countries deal with their opportunities. The issue of climate protection, of course, also plays a role and is at the top of the agenda in Japan.

In the matter of climate protection – we see this particularly with the young people who are now taking to the streets worldwide – it becomes evident how we handle sustainability, how we think about the future. This means we not only have to address the question of whether we want to do something together – multilateralism – whether we want to go beyond the previous considerations regarding the reduction of tariff barriers and also take into account non-tariff issues, but we must also learn to think beyond the here and now and create regulations for the next year that will serve for the entire century. This is, of course, quite a complex task for a policy that has to face elections almost every day; every day in a different country. This means that these are indeed significant challenges.

But just as it is with the regulation of data handling, it is also the case with the question of how we can set the right signals regarding climate change. We actually need international solutions. One can try it with a stock market transaction tax or a financial transaction tax in Europe. We have done that now. A small stock market tax is coming out, so that there are as few market distortions as possible, because otherwise market participants from the area where regulation is taking place simply migrate to the area where there is no regulation.

We have a similar issue regarding incentives in the field of climate protection. Of course, theoretically, CO2 pricing is the best instrument. Fortunately, we are seeing an increase in CO2 emission systems from Latin America to individual states in the United States of America and up to China, alongside Europe. We also have a so-called EU Emissions Trading System (ETS). But it would make sense if we also had a global system for the non-ETS sector, for example, in the areas of transport, buildings, and agriculture. The big question is always: How large must the system be to still generate a reasonable effect? If the system is too small and only leads to displacement effects, then it is, of course, not sensible. This question will occupy us significantly in Europe with regard to the non-ETS sectors, where we need to achieve reduction targets.

I just want to say: We have the huge task in Germany of achieving the climate protection targets by 2030. We will have to establish this legally now. We will form a climate cabinet for this purpose. By the end of the year, we will pass a climate protection law or several laws. But we are facing enormous challenges, for example, in the area of transport. Germany is a transit country. Germany is credited with all emissions resulting from refueling in Germany. Regardless of whether someone comes from Poland, Belarus, Russia, or France: If they refuel in Germany, it leads to a German emission. This means we do not have precise control over how many emissions are generated in transport. Despite all reductions per vehicle in the years since 1990, we have not seen a reduction in transport emissions because these reductions have been offset by increased traffic. This means that if we need to save 42 percent of CO2 emissions in transport from today until 2030, that is an incredibly large qualitative change and can only be achieved through electric mobility or new drive technologies. It cannot be achieved with old drive technologies.

I could now talk about many things. But I just want to briefly mention – I always have a clock in front of me; that is also very healing –: It is particularly important to me that we promote the development of the African continent. In recent decades, we have essentially seen explosive development spurts in Asian countries, but we have not yet reached that point in Africa. I believe that the African Union has become much more self-confident, and we must stop looking at Africa in a paternalistic way. We must see Africa more as a partner in the true sense. This means we must also listen to the ideas there, demand "ownership," as one says today – the willingness to identify with certain goals and fight for them – and sometimes also keep our mouths shut. We often think we know better. We have gone through certain lines of development and then think: Well, it is quite natural that others listen to us and ask us: How was it, and how do you want to do it? That does not always work even with raising our own children; and one should certainly not try that with other countries.

However, we must also encourage African countries to develop trust in their civil society. Africa is such a young continent, as we here in aging Berlin or aging Germany cannot even imagine. We must develop the willingness to embrace the creativity of youth and also the characteristic of youth to think in much larger time frames and say: Yes, that can be an inspiration for us; that can also be a driving force for us. We do not yet have this willingness in Europe sufficiently.

In this respect, there is still much, much work to be done. I am happy to engage in further discussion on various points, but overall, I believe we must strengthen the voice of multilateralism in this broad approach, as I have just described, as much as possible. Politics alone will not be able to do that. It requires a strong civil society as well.

That is why I am so pleased that this conference has found great resonance this year, that there is intensive discussion here, and that everyone, when they return home, has many new contacts. Because then one can say: Let us, despite all the differences we have between non-governmental organizations from the environmental sector and other areas on the one hand and the politically active on the other, always keep a common approach in mind and say: Okay, from friction, from differences, creative impulses arise that we must embrace, that we must confront; but let us be a united front for a multilateral approach. Everything else, in my opinion, will not only fail but will unfortunately also lead to more violent conflicts and to more of what we have not had in Europe, apart from the Balkan wars, for 70 years, namely more military attempts at solutions. The European lesson from the last centuries is that we must avoid this at all costs and therefore should rather turn to the complicated question of multilateralism and fight for it.