Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the eleventh German World Bank Forum on June 20, 2013, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

20 June 2013 · Eleventh German World Bank Forum · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the eleventh German World Bank Forum in Berlin on June 20, 2013, outlining Germany's development cooperation priorities and post-2015 goals.
Main themes
Development cooperation, Millennium Development Goals, poverty eradication, global coordination, international standards, human dignity, effectiveness of aid, sustainable economic growth, World Bank partnership, German development policy, post-2015 agenda
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,109
77th percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Environmental 20%20%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 14%14%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

166 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Dear President Kim,

dear Ms. Mohn,

esteemed ministers,

I would especially like to welcome my cabinet colleague Dirk Niebel, ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here with you and would like to extend a warm welcome on behalf of the Federal Government.

Our Basic Law begins with the sentence: "The dignity of man is inviolable." This short yet clear sentence defines the foundation of our lives and the mandate for political action. I often say: This sentence from our Basic Law is not only meant for Germans or Europeans, but it is to be understood globally. With every person who is hungry, with every child who cannot go to school, with every family that must flee their homeland due to violence or war, we become aware of what our tasks and our mandate are – particularly in development cooperation.

We know that global challenges cannot be mastered by nation-states alone. They require global action. The actors are international organizations as well as states and private entities. We feel, for example, when following budget discussions or other debates in the German Bundestag, that it is not so easy for a nation and national decision-makers to transfer responsibility to an international level. We are experiencing this process. We are going through it because we want to shape globalization. This also requires trust among the actors.

If development cooperation is to be successful under these conditions, then I believe that above all two things are necessary: the development of common standards and objectives as well as an incredibly high level of coordination. I am very grateful that the German World Bank Forum is addressing these issues. Therefore, I would also like to sincerely thank the organizers: the Bertelsmann Foundation, the Berlin office of the World Bank, and the Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development. I am very pleased to have accepted the invitation to present some fundamental aspects of German development cooperation from my perspective – not because the minister could not do it as well, but because I want to show through my presence that development cooperation is a cross-cutting task, that there is indeed a ministry for it, but that it is also a special responsibility for the entire Federal Government.

We have repeatedly tried – and this is quite natural – to draw conclusions from both successes and mistakes of the past and to critically examine our projects and approaches in development cooperation. At the center of development policy is not only the sum of the available money; I do not want to downplay that, but we must – and this is quite obvious – also ask about the effectiveness of the resources used. This question is gaining importance. And that is a good thing. Behind it lies a constant learning process. This learning process has been particularly fostered by the fact that the international community has agreed on Millennium Goals. This has made it clear what our tasks are and what we want to achieve. This certainly meant a change in thinking for some actors in development cooperation. Because when the international community has set such goals, then those are the priorities that one must orient oneself towards.

We all know: The path to freeing people from poverty and misery is rocky. But we can at least say: We have made progress in development cooperation. Since 1990, nearly a billion people have been freed from the shackles of absolute poverty. The proportion of people without access to clean drinking water has been halved. We are also seeing significant progress in primary education and in the fight against AIDS, malaria, and other diseases. But we also know: We will not fully achieve the Millennium Goals by 2015. Therefore, we must continue to work.

I thank the World Bank for being an important source of impetus. At your spring meeting, you set ambitious goals for the eradication of absolute poverty by 2030. I believe President Kim is also a man of action and practical experience. It is all the better that you are now at the head of an international organization because you know what you are talking about and how difficult the necessary coordination is, and because you have a lot of understanding for the actors.

On the path to achieving the goals, we can only make progress if we have an approach that places the participation of all segments of the population at its center. Commanding development from above or simply expecting it cannot work. There must be an activation. Truly sustainable economic growth is only conceivable if it benefits everyone and not just a few.

I am pleased that this thought is also reflected in the report of the high-level expert group on the further development of the Millennium Development Goals. It is indeed the case – you in this circle know this – that on the one hand we have these goals. We will not achieve them in all facets. We must continue to work on that. But on the other hand, we must also develop new goals for the time after 2015. An expert group has been set up for this purpose. Former Federal President Horst Köhler has been part of this expert group for Germany. I recently had an extensive conversation with him. I believe that this expert group has found a very good and interesting approach.

The central element of the recommendations of this expert group is the linking of development goals with the idea of sustainability. This is very important because we have repeatedly experienced in international conferences – whether at climate conferences or biodiversity conferences; in all the discussions and negotiations that can be traced back to the sustainability agenda from Rio – that developing countries, but also emerging countries, have told us: You constantly impose regulations on us regarding how sustainably we should manage natural resources; but in reality, you do not want our development. Therefore, I believe that the connection of the ecological, economic, and social dimensions, which encompasses the principle of sustainability, with a clear commitment to the development of the less developed regions is the key to being successful.

The tasks in the individual regions are of course completely different. What they all have in common, however, is that economic performance, environmental and resource protection, and social responsibility are interdependent; and that also across national borders.

Let us take climate change as an example. It knows no national borders. Droughts and floods as consequences have significant economic repercussions. I mean, we are seeing dramatic developments in Africa as a result of climate change. We cannot assign everything one-to-one. But even in Germany, it is concerning that we have had two so-called century floods within a decade. That does not allow us to sleep peacefully. We now see what damages can occur and that we must not only react to them. This means that prevention must be a completely natural thought.

Economic weakness and social distress increase the temptation to pursue quantitative growth at any cost, even without regard for climate protection. This means that the danger is great of getting caught in a spiral. We know – despite all the climatic impacts we have to endure – that it is primarily the poorer countries that are affected. We see dramatic developments especially when famines break out in areas and people are forced to leave their homes. Therefore, we must make progress in climate protection.

I often like to quote the Stern Review in connection with climate change, which tells us what happens and what costs arise if we do nothing for climate protection. It is often said what costs are incurred if we do something for climate protection. But we must also be aware of what happens if we do nothing.

I very much welcome that World Bank President Kim strongly supports an integrated approach. He has made sustainable growth, climate, and environmental protection a priority concern. It is also good – we just talked about it when entering – that President Barack Obama mentioned this point yesterday and named it as an important concern of the United States of America. This priority concern should also be more strongly considered in World Bank projects in the future; and that is good. Because in the long run, economic development is not conceivable that is based on the plundering of nature.

Today, just over 7.1 billion people live in the world. By 2050, there will likely be over nine billion. Each of them has a right to food, water, energy, and resources. Therefore, we need a change in awareness. Because if we consume more than we produce, if we consume more than can be renewed, then we are consuming the future at the expense of subsequent generations.

The term sustainability was coined in Germany 300 years ago – at a time when mining was being conducted in Germany. Suddenly, it was realized that there was not enough wood available for smelting the ore. Then it was recognized: You can only smelt as much ore as you have wood that can regrow. This is how the idea of sustainability was born. It still fits very well into our present time. Although it is so simple, people have still not learned to adhere to it. The temptation is also great to move forward as quickly as possible.

Therefore, we must continually convince and say: It is possible – we have experienced this in Germany – to decouple growth from resource consumption and pollutant emissions. However, I also say: We, the industrialized countries, have already caused a lot of damage in this regard. Therefore, we as industrialized and highly developed countries are also obliged to promote the technological development that can decouple growth from pollutant emissions. It is about technologies for energy savings and renewable energies. These are future markets and also mean new jobs. However, we still have a lot to do with some other issues. In Germany, we have not yet decoupled the two factors of economic growth and land consumption as well as we should have.

We are experiencing in Germany that the expansion of renewable energies is fundamentally correct but also requires an integrated approach. We currently have an incentive system for the expansion of renewable energies in Germany that works so well that we are facing problems with the large expansion success. This means we must also be as quick in expanding the networks. We need to develop storage technologies. We must have permanently baseload-capable power plants available when there are not enough renewable energies available and the storage capacities are still insufficient.

This means we have to invest a lot in the restructuring of our energy supply. But this also brings us future market opportunities. To some extent, there are now costs associated with the fact that we first have to learn how to deal with such a paradigm shift in energy transition, with a change in energy supply to renewable energies. Others do not have to replicate all of this but can certainly benefit from what we have learned.

Bilateral cooperation will increasingly be complemented by multilateral efforts in our globalized world. Therefore, the joint trip of President Kim and UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to the Great Lakes region in Africa was certainly a good and important signal. The willingness of the United Nations to advance something together in the field of development could not have been better documented than through such a joint trip. I also very much welcome that you are coordinating with the IMF, with Christine Lagarde, to deploy the World Bank and the IMF in a coherent manner. In the past, there often seemed to be an antagonism: one was the good guy and the other was the bad guy. I do not want to judge how that was divided. In any case, I find a better coordination very commendable.

We have also succeeded – I have advocated strongly for this – that all relevant international organizations are involved in the G20 framework: from the OECD to the World Bank, the IMF, and the WTO, the World Trade Organization, to the ILO, the International Labour Organization. I do not need to emphasize that I would prefer if we also had an organization within the UN that would symbolize environmental protection and sustainability more strongly than before.

Since the German G8 presidency in 2007, I have invited the heads of international organizations to my Chancellery once a year. At first, they all looked at me and probably wondered: What is the purpose of us all coming here? However, this has also created an atmosphere of togetherness; and in the G20, it is now evident that there is a shared sense of responsibility and that it is good that we incorporate the needs and expectations of international organizations into our national policies.

Development cooperation alone with state and public institutions will not be enough – it is no coincidence that we are here at the Bertelsmann Foundation. Rather, we also need the expertise and economic experience of the private sector. If countries want to be capable of action themselves – that is certainly the experience of the Federal Republic of Germany – then this will only be possible in partnership in the long run. We call this Social Market Economy – a partnership between the public sector, private economy, and representatives of workers. For years, there has been complaints – I do not want to exclude that I was once among those who complained – that things in Germany move too slowly, that some things are cumbersome. But we have also seen how important it was, especially for overcoming the consequences of the international financial and economic crisis, to involve workers and the economy. The German trade unions and international trade unions are now making many efforts to ensure that the culture of dialogue and the shared responsibility for development cooperation are truly lived. Therefore, alongside the G20 meetings, there are now not only economic meetings but also meetings of international trade unions. I find that extremely important.

Companies are the ones that invest. This makes it clear that states cannot dictate everything. It is very important that development cooperation – Kofi Annan always said this repeatedly – is also connected with the establishment of companies, with taking responsibility for other people. The state will never have as many financial resources that could guarantee the prosperity of entire countries. This is only possible with a thriving private sector. Broadly distributed economic activities are also a means against corruption. Things become more transparent when people can ask questions and get involved.

Of course, we need the right framework conditions for this. We have seen from the tragic events in Bangladesh that it is unacceptable when there are dramatically poor standards for working conditions and pay. It is an advantage of the new media that such things no longer remain unknown but are questioned. This also leads to self-commitments, to more awareness of responsibility in the economy, and sometimes it creates a sense of guilt in industrialized countries when we wear materials that were produced under conditions that are completely unacceptable.

We need a lot of broad support from all parts of society to meet all development goals. Europe is currently in a rather difficult situation – you know that. We are, of course, faced with the question: Do we first take care of ourselves, do we take care of our European neighbors; and what will happen to development cooperation, what will happen to our commitment to others? We experience this discussion every year during the budget consultations; Germany is probably not the only country in this regard. The development minister has always come out of the budget discussions reasonably well, but of course, it is also noticeable that we now have a lot of engagement in our European neighboring countries.

Personally, I wish for two things in conclusion.

The first is that we do not lose sight of the Millennium Development Goals, which we will not all achieve by 2015, but that we continue to work towards achieving them. When I look at African and some Asian countries, I can see that we are making very good progress in some areas. However, it makes no sense to exceed all Millennium Development Goals for ten countries in Africa and to be satisfied with the remaining 40 countries and say: We did not meet them there, but on average, it is okay. I believe that the Millennium Development Goals will only find acceptance in the individual countries if they also apply to each individual country. If I were to say, "Look, the goals apply on average to Africa, which is why we do not have to achieve them in country x" – I would rather not name a country, lest I mention a good one as an example – "because we already have outstanding results in five other countries," then the population of the respective country would not be able to accept that. This means that we must work towards ensuring that, in the end, the goals are achieved in each of the countries.

I almost feel a bit sorry for African countries when I think about how many donors they have and who all rushes to them. Therefore, it is good that there are organizations like UNDP that sometimes take over coordination for the countries. And it is also good that there is the World Bank, which can also develop larger projects. – I see our head of GIZ. I have to be careful whether it is called GEZ or GIZ; but I have learned. – Our GIZ also bundles many things, including private activities, in development cooperation. I believe that coordinating forces are in high demand.

That is also my second wish: that we learn not to overwhelm countries whose governance capacities are already difficult with many good suggestions, but rather to give them the chance to truly implement everything. In this context, we will certainly have to continue to engage in friendly and partnership-based discussions about good governance.

Recently, we addressed the Sahel region again at the G8 summit. We have seen what has happened in Mali. We are strengthening the armed forces there. We need sustainable – truly sustainable – governance structures in all countries of the region so that what we set as good goals is not put into question with every change of government. There will still be a lot to do.

With that, I want to conclude and thank you all for your commitment – and of course also for inviting me. Thank you very much.