Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "European Patent Forum" of the European Patent Office on April 18, 2007, in Munich:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

18 April 2007 · European Patent Forum (30th anniversary of the European Patent Office) · Munich, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the European Patent Forum in Munich on April 18, 2007, celebrating the 30th anniversary of the European Patent Office.
Main themes
European Patent Office anniversary, intellectual property protection, innovation and research, knowledge society, European competitiveness, patent quality and examination, software and new technology patenting, European integration, global competition, know-how protection
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,020
86th percentile
Sentences
226
91st percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 43%42%
  • Institutional 33%32%
  • Geopolitical 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

226 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Professor Pompidou,

dear Ms. Brimelow,

dear employees of the European Patent Office,

esteemed guests,

You are all celebrating together at this event today and tomorrow 30 years of the European Patent Office as a remarkable success story. Therefore, the Federal Government would like to convey its heartfelt birthday wishes. I do this as Federal Chancellor and also on behalf of the Federal Minister of Justice, whose State Secretary is here today. I do this as President of the European Council in a special way also on behalf of the other Member States of the European Union.

The success story is already evident in the numbers you can look at. Patent applications have grown from 10,000 in the inaugural year of 1977 to around 200,000 in 2006. There were newspaper articles today about the combined power of patent professionals, which pointed out once again that the workload has become so high that a proper examination has not become any easier. We must, of course, also reflect on this.

From seven founding members of the European Patent Organization, there are now 32. From 100 employees of the European Patent Office, there are now almost 6,500 from nearly 30 different nations. As the German Federal Chancellor, I am of course very pleased to have come to Munich, as the European Patent Office is the largest European authority that we host in Germany. Of course, it is far removed from Brussels, Strasbourg, and other important places. However, we are proud to have the European Patent Office here in Germany. We did not choose the least hospitable city in Germany as its seat, although I could not even say which is the least hospitable city in Germany, as they are all beautiful. Munich is certainly particularly beautiful.

Of course, the presence of the European Patent Office in four countries is an example of the success of European unification. However, what is particularly impressive is not only the quantity but also the quality of the work of the European Patent Office. The examination procedures are among the most efficient in the world. The examiners are excellently trained. The European Patent Office follows the conviction that only those patents contribute to technological progress that are granted for truly original inventions. This, of course, requires examination. A clear indication of the consistently high quality of the patents granted is the relatively low number of legal disputes that arise following patent grants. I therefore welcome the approach of the European Patent Office to maintain the high quality of its examinations, searches, and patent grants despite the increasing number of applications I have already mentioned.

I am deeply convinced that we need a strong European Patent Office, as Europe, in particular, is highly dependent on a functioning system for the protection of intellectual property as an exporter of high-quality technological goods, because creativity and inventiveness are the fundamental prerequisites for prosperity and employment. For this, we not only need the capabilities, but we must also design the mechanisms that serve to secure and protect these capabilities within a reasonable legal framework. We all know that Europe is not particularly rich in natural resources. Therefore, it is all the more important for us to optimally utilize the resources of the knowledge society. What made Europe strong in the 20th century, namely the development of the industrial society, must make Europe even stronger in the 21st century.

We know that the transition from an industrial to a knowledge society also presents completely new challenges for patenting. When we think only of the software issue, when we think of completely new technologies, we know that this is a huge challenge. On the other hand, we also know that we have significant problems if we cannot protect our intellectual property. Therefore, to optimally utilize the resources of the knowledge society, we need two things

:

We need

first

further incentives – also beyond the patent system – for research and innovation.

Second

, we must prevent know-how from flowing out uncontrollably and being misused.

Both aspects of what I have mentioned are of utmost importance.

Innovations must be continually reworked. Competition has significantly intensified for Europeans. Other countries will not ease their efforts in the future; rather, they will become even more competent competitors for us. It is no longer the case that emerging countries only copy – that is also a huge problem – but they are building their own innovative industries. And we are increasingly confronted with this. Patent applications from these countries – as you who deal with this at the European Patent Office know best – are increasing rapidly. We must not sit idly by. On the occasion of the celebrations for the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome, I said: The world does not wait for Europe; rather, we must take on the challenges. As the largest economy in Europe, Germany naturally has great significance in this context. This is something that is repeatedly pointed out to me by other Member States.

We want to set a good example. We have already taken some steps in this direction. We want to further improve the economic framework conditions for inventors and entrepreneurs. I believe we can show some progress in this regard. As of January 1 of next year, the corporate tax reform will come into effect, which will strengthen Germany as an investment location with a tax burden of under 30 percent and position it well internationally. This corporate tax reform will relieve partnerships, which have their own legal form in Germany, similarly to how it applies to corporations. This will also provide an excellent foundation for small and medium-sized enterprises and family businesses.

While I am on the topic of small and medium-sized enterprises, I want to remind you that the innovative strength of Europe significantly depends on these businesses being able to participate in global developments in accordance with their shares. They have a large share and form a solid foundation of the European economic and social model. It would not be possible to implement what we associate with property in Europe, namely the social obligation of property, solely with large "global players." Therefore, small and medium-sized enterprises need good opportunities, especially in identifying market niches, responding flexibly, and developing innovative, yet untested products.

For small and medium-sized enterprises – as we know from the discussion about the Lisbon Strategy in the European Union – the questions regarding bureaucratic effort are much more relevant than for large companies. Therefore, it was very important that we decided in the Council in March to reduce the costs of bureaucracy due to statistical and reporting obligations at both the European and national levels by 25 percent by 2012. The Federal Republic of Germany has also committed to this.

As part of the Lisbon Strategy, we have also set ourselves the goal of increasing research and innovation expenditures per Member State to three percent of GDP. Germany has developed a high-tech strategy for this purpose, under which we will provide 15 million euros for cutting-edge technologies by 2009, that is, by the end of the legislative period. What is new about this – and this must also become European thinking – is that we are looking across departments at where our opportunities in the global market lie, where we stand, where we need to catch up, where we are leading, and what we can do for ideas that are often patented here but sometimes have a long way to go before market launch and utilization as a product. We know that in Germany – but this also applies to other European countries – we have many ideas, but we have not turned many ideas into the products that ultimately enable prosperity for our own population.

When we think that the first computer was built by Konrad Zuse in Germany, and when we see where today the great value creation is generated through hardware and software facilities, Europe has many reasons to consider whether we need to make special efforts in areas related to digitalization. There are a multitude of European projects. I will only mention the keyword "Galileo." However, you all know from your experiences that there are many difficulties in cooperation in Europe. Time is also a very important factor here, as others are not sleeping either.

We therefore need a climate in which ideas can ignite, in which they are secured, and in which they can be turned into products. In Germany, we have just introduced a new instrument for small and medium-sized enterprises as part of our high-tech strategy, the so-called research premium, through which smaller and medium-sized enterprises can receive a grant of 25 percent when they commission research projects at universities, technical colleges, or universities of applied sciences. This allows us to particularly promote innovations in these businesses. The legal design of cooperation between science and industry is a very important area in this regard. Legal coordination needs often leads to high administrative and financial costs for smaller companies.

Under my leadership, the Federal Government has established the "Council for Innovation and Growth," in which experts from business, science, and politics advise on how we can accelerate, improve, and secure the path from idea to product. Therefore, we have also tasked an expert group within this Innovation Council to develop building blocks for the design of contractual relationships between universities and industry. We want to minimize the effort involved in contract design and thus simplify the transfer of intellectual capital into marketable inventions.

Secondly, the Innovation Council is addressing the question of how patents can be better utilized. This involves new approaches and instruments. On the one hand, it is about intensifying patent trading. On the other hand, the public should be made more aware of using patents more in credit relationships. Small and medium-sized enterprises might receive better conditions for loans if they have patents available. However, this again requires a new way of thinking in assessing the potential value of such patents. The prerequisite for this, of course, is your qualified work. If those who are to assess the effectiveness of such patents cannot rely on the quality-oriented granting of the patent, it would be a very poor start. Ultimately, what I just mentioned in the Innovation Council also concerns whether and how intangible assets can be accounted for. This is a very important point in order to properly assess future successes through an improved evaluation of the capital base at the beginning of a company.

We know that we must look beyond the borders of individual countries and further strengthen international cooperation. It is clear that research and development play a key role here. Research and development are indeed the driving forces behind our economic dynamism. This is also reflected in the award of the "European Inventor of the Year," which will be presented this evening and which shows how much importance you attach to this field. I believe you do this not only out of self-interest, because if no one invents anything, you could patent nothing and everyone would be unemployed. I think you also do this out of a European mindset, because our continent should be involved in shaping a modern and humane world.

The importance of research and development – I have just mentioned the German component – is, of course, also reflected in the Seventh EU Framework Programme for Research. This research framework programme sets new standards. With a budget of 54 billion euros for the period of the financial outlook, it is the largest research funding programme in the world. With a significant share of the funds, we have established a European Research Council. We celebrated its founding a few weeks ago in Berlin. This European Research Council is based on the criteria used by the German Research Foundation. It will allocate research funds purely based on academic qualification. You know that the European research programmes were partly selected based on regional criteria. That was also good to bring Europeans closer together. However, they have not always adhered to all standards of scientific excellence, but have also served to bring member states closer to research programmes. The part managed by the European Research Council, however, is to be allocated and managed strictly according to excellence criteria. This is intended to contribute to ensuring that basic research can truly be oriented towards new and future-proof directions.

An important factor in this area is also the promotion of young talent. Europe does not have too many researchers and engineers. If we really want to achieve a research share of three percent – about one third from the state and two thirds from the economy – we must address a shortage of engineers and scientists not only in Germany but throughout Europe. On the one hand, this problem can be solved by attracting the best minds from around the world. However, we must also strive to ensure that the best come to us. The competition is fierce. Many Chinese are more likely to return to China from America than to come to Europe. But we must also provide our own young people with excellent prospects in our European member states; otherwise, they will also go to other parts of the world. Europe is a continent that is overall facing demographic change. Therefore, it is very important to provide good research framework conditions to anyone who can contribute to our prosperity.

Of course, the protection of innovation also plays a very significant role. The protection of innovation will also determine whether there is a willingness to invest in research and development. This is even more true in a globalized world, as some often have only a slight time advantage. Therefore, a functioning patent system is of great importance. Over time, some protection options may become unnecessary.

The research effort must, of course, also be profitable. Only those who have some security that they can re-utilize their investment as a product and that their innovation will not be stolen will invest in research and innovation. Therefore, the protection of intellectual property is not only a topic we discuss in the European context, but also a topic that Germany has placed on the agenda of the G8 summit in June in Heiligendamm as part of its G8 presidency.

Furthermore, we will launch an EU initiative for a charter on the handling of intellectual property at public research institutions and universities. With this, we want to at least demand a voluntary code of conduct that can create more security for researchers. Such a charter would be a very good way to demand protection for European companies from cooperators in developing countries where we have not yet reached binding global framework regulations. We could then say that we want to enable you to participate in innovative processes, we want you to produce new products, but you must adhere to certain rules.

We also want to strengthen the transatlantic partnership. To this end, a meeting between the United States and the European Union will take place in Washington on April 30. We also want to pursue a number of improvements in patent protection. I believe that in the area of the transatlantic partnership, beyond tariffs, which we are negotiating multilaterally in the Doha Round, there are a multitude of different standards, approval procedures, and testing trials in non-tariff areas – ranging from accounting to the approval of medicines, cars, and many other things – for which we waste billions and billions, even though the fundamental approaches of these approval procedures are very similar. You know the differences between European patent law and American patent law. These two laws are developing, if I follow it correctly, not together, but very differently. For Europe and the United States, which together account for 60 percent of the world’s gross social product and conduct 40 percent of world trade with each other, it is certainly important to remain closely connected here. We will adopt a framework paper at the EU/US summit at the end of this month.

We know that a functioning patent system can significantly promote innovation. Therefore, we must present technical inventions openly worldwide to encourage others to further innovations. On the other hand, the exclusivity right provides an incentive to invest in research and development at all. After 30 years of your activity, we must also address the state of Europe. I have said we have a Seventh Framework Programme for Research. We now have a European Research Council. We are in the process of establishing a European Institute of Technology. This is intended to develop reasonable top products in applied research together with the economy. We have a number of large European projects. I mentioned "Galileo." However, to be able to speak of a closed innovation strategy, the European patent system must also be improved. The framework for a European patent reform is actually clearly defined. There were more than 2,500 statements from companies and associations regarding the hearing in the European Commission last year. So there has been no lack of interest.

With an overwhelming majority, we voted for a new attempt at the Community patent. However, a Community patent only has value if it truly meets certain requirements. I will mention the keywords that are important to me in this context. – I have also discussed this with the Federal Minister of Justice because the topic of the Community patent has already occupied the European Council in Lahti. – The keywords we must demand here are "uniform," "legally secure," and "affordable." The whole thing must also be achievable with a reasonable effort. Achieving all of this does not seem so easy. We are always so proud of our diversity in Europe. However, with the Community patent, we must also reduce diversity to some extent. Therefore, we either need the Community patent very quickly or at least a further development of the systems we already have today. Therefore, I join all demands that state: It cannot remain as it is; it must move forward.

One issue here is also translations and the costs of translations. Today, up to 40 percent of the total costs of a patent are incurred for translations. This is, of course, a significant cost burden. In every state where the patent is to be valid, the patent holder must submit a translation in the respective national language. Therefore, it is necessary to implement the "London Protocol" quickly. Anyone who has dealt with this in more detail knows that it is not entirely simple. The "London Protocol" provides for only the patent claim to be translated into the official language of the respective state of validity. The translation of the extensive explanations and descriptions could be waived. The application and granting procedures would remain unchanged.

I assure you that I, at my level, just like the Federal Minister of Justice, will fight with great enthusiasm for us to continue working in this direction. However, we will not enter into a half-hearted compromise. If development is once on the wrong path, it will not be easy to change it again quickly. Therefore, I ask for your support at this point. We know the needs of internationally operating companies. Therefore, we must act here. With all the joy and pride in our respective languages – I believe we have 23 recognized languages in 27 member states – it is necessary to think overall about Europe. Therefore, the "London Protocol" is already an important step in the right direction.

As a second point, we need a reform of patent jurisdiction. We need a unified European patent justice system. It is of no use if I only have procedures for the approval of patents but no system for the resolution of disputes. All parties must be able to rely on the fact that such disputes can be resolved in a common European court system. There is a largely formulated paper, the draft of a European dispute resolution procedure – "EPLA." It has been on the table for a long time. This draft includes patents granted by the European Patent Office. However, the court system provided for in the draft could also include disputes over the future Community patent. We could resolve that relatively quickly. Where there is a will, there is a way. We must act according to this motto. We will also keep a close eye on ensuring that no small hooks and eyes are laid out through the back door, but that we get on the right path.

After last year's successes were not so overwhelming, the European Commission has presented a new communication on patent strategy. The good thing is that the results of the patent hearing are somewhat accurately reflected. – I do not know who from the Commission is here today. It will surely be reported on shortly. – However, we are not yet really pleased about it. We must continue to work together. The German presidency will immediately pass this work on to the Portuguese presidency.

I will mention the keywords once again: simpler, more affordable, and legally secure. That must be our goal. Many have also advocated this at the summit in Lahti. For the perfection of a truly coherent research and innovation strategy of the European Union, the elements I just mentioned are indispensable.

We see that promoting innovation and patent protection are two central challenges when we talk about the future of our continent. I am convinced that we can master them if we know where we want to go and if we continually reflect on the secret of success of European integration. That has always been the spirit of togetherness and the spirit of cooperation. After centuries of wars, we have learned – and this is the real success story of the European Union – that it is always better, in the medium and long term, to reach a compromise with the neighbor for one’s own interest than to achieve a short-term success but have conflicts in the long run. This spirit must also enter the area that concerns you.

Jean Monnet once said with regard to European unification – I quote: "Nothing is possible without people, nothing lasts without institutions." Both belong together. Today we are in an institution that has proven itself. Such an institution is the European Patent Office. It drives the unification process forward. That it succeeds – I return to Jean Monnet – has to do with the people who work as employees in this European Patent Office. It has to do with those who bear responsibility here.

Therefore, let me conclude, esteemed Professor Pompidou, by expressing my heartfelt thanks for your work at the European Patent Office, which will continue a little longer and which you will then hand over to Ms. Brimelow, who will continue your work as president. Mr. Pompidou, you have made a significant contribution to making the European Patent Office one of the most efficient patent authorities in the world. I would also like to thank your wife, as it is often not easy to deliver the performance required at leading positions without the support of spouses.

I wish you, Ms. Brimelow, much success in leading the European Patent Office. I believe that you will continue the work with just as much passion and joy. I have already seen in the few minutes of my presence that the onboarding and handover process is in good hands.

The motto of our German Presidency of the Council in the first half of 2007 is: "Europe succeeds together." You are an example that this is true, that it is right, and that this motto must be brought to life every day. If Europe is to remain a continent of ideas and innovation, you will play a significant role in that. This is the foundation for all of us to live together in peace, prosperity, and security for the next 50 years. I thank you for your commitment, wish you interesting contributions to the conference, and much enjoyment in your work at the European Patent Office.