Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "Falling Walls" conference of the Einstein Foundation Berlin on November 9, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

9 November 2009 · Falling Walls conference of the Einstein Foundation Berlin · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 'Falling Walls' conference in Berlin on November 9, 2009, the 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall.
Main themes
Fall of the Berlin Wall, freedom and courage, German reunification, science and innovation in political change, knowledge society, Eastern Bloc collapse, democracy and market principles, personal experience of 1989, Central and Eastern European revolutions, surveillance and dissent
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,190
78th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
51
64th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
3.08
57th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 39%37%
  • Social 21%20%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Economic 8%7%
  • Technological 6%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 4%3%
  • Not in focus 5%

148 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to reassure you that I will also be meeting with my colleagues, heads of state and government, today. The love for this event is not so pronounced that I would forgo that. But I am very glad to be here because this event and the auditorium, of course, have something to do with the change in my life that occurred shortly after November 9.

When I followed the fall of the Berlin Wall on the evening of November 9 in East Berlin at the Bornholmer Straße and immediately seized the new opportunity to simply cross the border, I was still a natural scientist – a physicist at the Academy of Sciences, at the Central Institute for Physical Chemistry, as it was beautifully called. That night, I did not go to Ku’damm, but rather went to work in Adlershof the next morning. I did not want to collapse onto my desk right away, so I postponed my first longer stay in West Berlin to Friday evening.

The fall of the Wall thus decisively changed my life, but it did not tarnish my love for science. I do not understand as much of it now; the more emotions I can invest in it. In this respect, science and education still hold a very high place in my political work.

It is exciting and interesting that the longing for freedom, as well as the courage to fight for freedom, has repeatedly enabled great changes. Thus, November 9 is a symbolically significant day, especially in German history. It is a dream and a trauma in many respects. But it is also, and precisely, the fulfillment of a dream. Many contributed to this fulfillment. But it would not have been possible without the courage of the people in the former GDR. Whether they decided to make their discontent with this system clear through their emigration or whether they believed that the system needed to be changed from within – both forms of disobedience were important in bringing down the Wall.

This was, of course, coupled with the courage that we had already seen some time earlier in Poland during the free elections in June 1989, with the courage that broke its way from 1968 to the "Velvet Revolution" in Czechoslovakia, with the courage in many other Central and Eastern European countries, and finally also in Romania, where the dictatorship had a particularly sharp manifestation.

When the heads of government from almost all member states of the European Union are with us this evening, it shows that what we experienced on November 9 at Bornholmer Straße and then at more and more border crossings – the Brandenburg Gate was only opened in December – was a European event, that it was the collapse of a part of a bipolar world order, and that democracy, freedom, and also market principles triumphed over unfreedom and planned economy.

In this regard, science may have had a greater share than is sometimes said today. Of course, the fall of the Wall ultimately also happened because people were courageous. But they were also courageous in the 1950s and 1960s. And time and again, these uprisings were suppressed. But what happened in the mid and late 1980s? Essentially, the harbingers of what we now call the knowledge society were also visible. The prosperity of a country was enabled much more through scientific and technological innovations than in the period after the Second World War and in the early years of the Federal Republic.

The ability to process data, the international networking, the possibility of exchanging information in ways that could not easily be spied upon certainly played an important role. Every letter could be opened and read. Surveillance became significantly more difficult when information was passed on via computers. But above all, the high technological capability that the West had developed meant that even in the Eastern Bloc, people were needed who could think and who created new knowledge and innovations from connecting thoughts. In this process, the system hit a limit. Because you cannot tell people: Please think from 7:30 AM to 5:30 PM, but when you leave your workplace, please immediately stop thinking about society, because then the dictatorship of the working class applies; and under this, there is nothing but obedience. – That did not fit together.

Therefore, there were two possibilities. Those who thought well and who also thought well in science were often on the best path to becoming dissidents. Some of them also left the republic. Or those who could actually think well were held back, so that they said: If I am not allowed to think all day, then I will not think fully during the eight working hours either. It has been shown that tank and machine production, steel forging, and all these things still went reasonably well, but at the moment when progress and prosperity were essentially created through the linking of new thoughts, it became more difficult for the Eastern Bloc system to maintain its competitiveness.

Innovations were thus a significant contribution to the fact that freedom could break through. I am not saying that everything is economized. But I do say that the economic superiority of the West, which also had its roots in the possibilities of freer thinking, made a significant contribution to the fact that comprehensive thinking could not be restricted in the East.

It is good news that all systems and social constructs that are to be successful cannot be created without freedom. Politicians must also come to terms with this. This complicates political life. But it is also a much greater joy when the whole society thinks along, when there is criticism and permeability of information. We do not only want this for ourselves, but we also want to create it where, fundamentally, walls still prevent the possibility of the world living together peacefully.

We have achieved this in Central and Eastern Europe. Today, as I said on the 50th anniversary of the signing of the Treaty of Rome, we are "united for our happiness." We have even managed to ratify a new treaty basis with 27 member states. Democracy, as we have all experienced by now, also requires a high degree of patience. Everyone is equally important, which is why everyone must be convinced. This can be experienced in many examples in the European Union. But if we want to spread our way of life here in Germany because we find this way fascinating for other parts of the world, then we Germans, with 80 million inhabitants, can no longer achieve much on our own.

The world has over 6.5 billion inhabitants. The number will rise. While at the beginning of the 20th century, about one in four people in the world lived in Europe, by the end of our century, only about one in 13 people will be a European. I do not even want to talk about Germans in this context. This means that if we Europeans want to assert ourselves, if we want to bring interesting ideas, we do well to cooperate and thus at least represent our ideas with 500 million people. This applies, by the way, to larger scientific efforts just as much as to political projects. Much cannot be achieved alone anymore.

But we also have the obligation, due to the fortunate experiences at the end of the 1980s and the beginning of the 1990s, to contribute to solving the problems of this world better. We have experienced the impossible as possible. This gives me, at least, the strength to say: Let us also try this in other places in the world, for example in the Middle East peace process or in the fight against terrorism, the great challenge of our time. We must approach this completely anew. During the Cold War, there was a clear order. The world was divided into two parts. Both parts of this world had the goal of surviving themselves. Everyone wanted to win the conflict, but neither side wanted to destroy itself in the process. With the so-called asymmetric threats, we are now facing a different challenge because many are putting their own lives at stake to help what they perceive as a good cause succeed. This means that the simple principle of deterrence, as in the Cold War, does not work. Therefore, we must find completely new ways. We are feeling our way forward on these paths.

How will we deal with the different ideas of those who embody the asymmetric threats, who say yes to terrorism, with the means of democracy? This battle has not yet been won. But one cannot evade it, because we are dealing with a worldview in which the individual does not count and which aims to destroy democracies or shake them to their core, as we experienced on September 11, 2001. Therefore, one cannot duck away from these threats, but must collectively try to find other ways to overcome them than those we know from the Cold War.

We know from painful European history that the ability to tolerate is one of the prerequisites for living together in friendship. Tolerance is not arbitrariness. Tolerance does not question certain fundamental values. But living tolerance is often difficult nonetheless. Tolerance requires one to empathize with the thoughts of the other, to engage with their history and feelings, with what they have experienced in their lives, and to try to understand them from this perspective in order to find a common path into the future with the other.

Europe lacked this ability for many decades, if not centuries, when it only thought in self-interests and later in national state structures. Even today, it is often interesting and exciting to see how laborious discussions within the European Union can be and, above all, how much knowledge of our history and culture of other countries is required.

It is still quite understandable when Czech President Klaus demands an amendment to the Lisbon Treaty analogous to what Poland and Great Britain received. But when we then talk about property issues and suddenly the Cypriot President says he has something to note regarding the Turkish part of Cyprus, others immediately notice that one is not quite as well educated and factually secure regarding the property issues between one part and the other part of Cyprus and how to assess the Turkish interventions.

This means that if you want to solve problems today and tear down walls, you must automatically engage intensively with other parts of the world. I believe it is still one of the great walls we have to overcome in a globalized world that we often already have difficulties asking the right questions. And this ability to ask questions and obtain information, for example, to know the African continent and the Asian continent as well as one’s own European homeland, is fundamentally the prerequisite for being truly tolerant without giving up one’s own values.

I believe our generation – I will take mine; many here are younger – is not particularly well prepared for this because our thinking is still very much shaped by bipolarity. I still remember that in the former GDR, one simplified African geography. Every second African state was more or less under the influence of the Americans and every other second state under the influence of the Russians. I know a lot about those under the influence of the Soviet Union; the others did not appear in our geography or any other classes.

It is no longer that simple today because these countries, of course, are going their own ways as a result of the collapse of the Cold War, because we need to know something about every country, because suddenly old conflicts have much more significance again, such as tribal conflicts and the consequences of colonial conflicts. This means we must delve deep into our history to be able to contribute to peace processes, for example in Africa. It is not so easy to say what tolerance means in individual cases when things heat up between Eritrea and Somalia. But we need to know more about the world. The internet helps us with this. But it does not solve the task. Therefore, I am sometimes almost a little envious of the younger people who grow up in these times and, I believe, also gain a better fundamental feeling for our world in which we must resolve conflicts.

We must, of course, also tear down the walls between our expectations of life and what we intend to leave for future generations. This brings many tasks in economic and financial policy as well as in environmental policy to our attention. It will be the case that peaceful coexistence is only possible with a global order in many respects.

This brings us to a new point: Is it enough for governments to cooperate, as is the case now during the international financial and economic crisis? – In European terms, one would say "intergovernmental"; that means each government speaks for its country and then they make joint agreements. – Or do we need, due to the respective self-interests of nation-states, the ability to cede a piece of our competence to multilateral organizations?

The Europeans are relatively accustomed to this. We do not love everything that is said in Brussels. But at least we have voluntarily ceded many competencies to Brussels, the European Union. There is no purely national German agricultural policy anymore. The original form of the European Union is, so to speak, the coal and agricultural sector. There is a unified European environmental policy in many areas. And we are increasingly forming policy areas as so-called communitized areas.

Our American partners find it much more difficult to cede a few competencies to the IMF or to any other international organization. One is a member of the UN, but has a veto right. Submitting to majority decisions of an international nature is, at least in the United States of America, not yet practiced. In the European Union, this is also not the case in foreign policy and tax policy. But in many other policy areas, Germany has to live with being outvoted and then other decisions being made.

This means that one of the most exciting questions in overcoming walls will be: Are nation-states willing and able to cede competencies to multilateral organizations, no matter the cost; even if it means a condemnation? We have such examples. The establishment of the World Trade Organization is one such example, where there are arbitration procedures that decide on trade issues without any member state's veto right, and if necessary, impose penalties. But we have too few such examples.

Therefore, the current struggle for a new climate agreement after Kyoto is a very specific struggle regarding the question: Are we able to do something together against climate change? But it also stands pars pro toto for the willingness to commit globally and act together in areas that can only be solved globally. Therefore, the conference in Copenhagen in a few weeks will be of great importance. But one does not need to be a prophet to say: This process will not be over; it will continue. But I say: This world will not be a peaceful and good world if we do not find more global order and more multilateral cooperation.

This is, of course, also connected to the new experience that Europe and America, even when they agree, will not be able to solve such global issues alone. The end of the Cold War could largely be determined between the Soviet Union, America, and Europe. The question of whether we can master climate change cannot be solved without America and Europe. But if no one else joins in – we will also get Russia on board; that is not in question – then the temperature worldwide will still rise by more than two degrees. This means we need China, we need India, we need the emerging countries.

It is also a result – actually a beautiful result – of the fall of the wall, the end of the Cold War, that in the last twenty years economic upturn and development in the emerging countries have been possible. But this also requires a much more multipolar way of thinking than we have been used to until now. This is the task that you or many of you will have to deal with.

How do we deal with countries and regions that come from very different traditions, that have completely different political systems, with which we still want and need to cooperate to solve global problems? And how do we manage to set an impulse on one side from our wonderful experience that walls can be torn down, while on the other side not appearing as the teachers of the world, because others have completely different ideas about solutions? This will occupy us in the coming years.

This means that the end of the Cold War, the fall of the wall in Berlin, the unification of Europe, also the much better coexistence with Russia and the end of the bipolarity of the world have opened a curtain behind which there is not a well-ordered world that we can now look at like a beautiful land, but completely new conflicts have emerged.

What remains from my perspective – this is the encouraging experience of November 9, 1989 – is our firm confidence that the individual person who fights for freedom – for a freedom in responsibility and not for a freedom that robs others of their breath – can achieve an incredible amount. Equipped with this experience, we should understand globalization as an opportunity and courageously tackle the multitude of conflicts we face today. This requires always new forms of thinking. Therefore, one should not get stuck in old structures; these exist not only in politics, but sometimes also in science.

It is quite astonishing: In the past, I always thought from my small GDR perspective that everything in free science was completely transparent and so to speak objective. In the meantime, we also hear from professors who first have to send entire student bodies to other continents to undermine other theories from the ground up. So, it cannot be claimed that paradigm shifts always find their way along the easiest path, even in science. Therefore, I can only say to those who deal with science: Be a role model for us politicians. Because we need a vibrant society that continually inspires us to tackle even seemingly unattainable and unachievable things.

I find it wonderful that you have gathered here today to use November 9 to discuss the walls of our time and to consider: How can we get out of this? We need this kind of thinking. Therefore, I wish you much success in this and, of course, the ability to also take a little joy in what we were able to experience on November 9, 1989. I do so, despite all the unresolved problems in the world, not only today but time and again in my political life.