Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Crafts Day on September 13, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 September 2012 · German Crafts Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed craftsmen and tradespeople at the German Crafts Day on September 13, 2012, in Berlin, linking skilled trades to the Euro crisis and European values.
Main themes
German craftsmanship and skilled trades, trust in the Euro and European monetary union, European sovereign debt crisis, competitiveness and economic sustainability, European integration and shared values, democracy and rule of law, social expenditure vs. economic output, solidarity and fiscal responsibility, innovation and global economic standing
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,216
92nd percentile
Sentences
264
94th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%51%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Environmental 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

264 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Kentzler,

dear craftsmen and craftswomen,

ladies and gentlemen,

the second day of craftsmanship, which takes place the day after tomorrow, is themed "We are craftsmen. We can do this." You just emphasized that, Mr. Kentzler. And that is indeed correct. Everyday life is unimaginable without the products and services of craftsmanship. Precisely because of this everyday presence, craftsmanship in Germany is met with a great deal of trust. Customers and consumers trust that bakers and butchers exercise hygienic care, that electrical cables are properly installed, that cars run reliably after repairs, and much, much more. This basic trust is there; and it is also thanks to craftsmanship itself. You can do this. And you even do what you can. For that, a heartfelt thank you.

As craftsmen, you know how much depends on the trust placed in you and your performance. This brings us to a topic that concerns you just as much as it does me; and that is the Euro. A piece of trust has been lost in the markets. Trust can be quickly lost. You may also know from your own experience: rebuilding it is a very complicated and sometimes lengthy process. And that is why the European sovereign debt crisis, which is fundamentally very much about a crisis of trust, cannot be resolved with a bang, but we will need many steps to restore what the markets initially offered the Euro at the beginning of its introduction – as could be seen in the almost uniform interest rates – and what has been significantly lost due to the shocks of the international financial crisis.

There is distrust in the financial markets regarding whether some Euro countries can service their debts in the long term. This is closely related to the question: Is competitiveness sufficient – given the existing debt burden and the current regulatory framework – to bear these debts? We in the European Union as a whole, but especially in the Euro group, are asking ourselves: How can we regain trust?

I am very grateful to the German craftsmanship for laying out in six fundamental theses on the future of the European monetary union how you see things. The fact that these positions reflect strong support for the European project is not something that can be taken for granted in these times, but is all the more important. Therefore, I would like to quote from a passage of your position paper: “(...) the historically unique and foundational basis of the values, legal, peace, and freedom community shared by all member states and their citizens.”

I believe we must not forget that we are indeed not just a group of countries that have a common currency and a single market, but that the member states of the European Union in general and the Euro countries in particular have united to prevent war from arising again, to live together in peace – with the awareness that shared values unite us.

Within Europe, most parts are accustomed to democracy prevailing, to being able to express one’s opinion, to practicing one’s religion, and to enjoying press freedom. All of this seems self-evident to us. But anyone who goes beyond the borders of this Europe realizes that this is not yet self-evident for many of the seven billion people living in the world. This means that if we want to make an impact with our 500 million Europeans, if we want to advocate for freedom of expression, for democracy, for the rule of law – you as entrepreneurs also know how important the rule of law and reliable legal systems are – then we do well to present ourselves together and assert ourselves in a world where there are many other ideas.

But we must also see that we can only survive in this world if we are truly competitive, if we can sell our products. And we must keep in mind: We are 500 million, which means we account for just over seven percent of the world’s population. This over seven percent of the world’s population still produces almost a quarter, that is, 25 percent of the world’s gross domestic product. But we also have about 50 percent of the world’s social expenditures. When you compare this, you see where the problem lies. If we want to maintain this, we must be very innovative, very creative, and always have the latest products. Otherwise, we will not be able to afford our prosperity in the long run.

Therefore, it is of no use to talk about where we can be solidary in Europe. Of course, we must be solidary, but if we want to live in prosperity tomorrow, if we want someone to still listen to us in the world tomorrow, then we must be competitive, we must also learn to live off what we earn and not spend more each year. The current problems have arisen because we have not managed to do this to a sufficient extent. They have developed over years in many countries, and they are not new to us in Germany either. We too must continually ensure that we find markets for our products in the world and can sell them.

The problems can essentially only be solved in the countries themselves. And that is why it is so essential to approach this by saying: Yes, we belong together, we have many advantages with our common currency, we want this common Europe. Therefore, we are of course solidary, but support only comes if the corresponding efforts to overcome the problems are made.

That is why yesterday was an important day when the Federal Constitutional Court accepted the legislation – on the one hand, the solidarity mechanism, the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), and on the other hand, the Fiscal Pact, which ensures that the Stability and Growth Pact, as it was already adopted at the introduction of the Euro, must be adhered to more bindingly in the future and that not every country can do whatever it wants.

This dual approach will accompany us in the near future. Of course, this is also associated with some painful cuts. Of course, it is difficult when around 50 percent of people under 25 in Spain are unemployed. Of course, it is extremely difficult what we are demanding from the Greek citizens. But if we want things to improve, we must not send the wrong signals and pretend that progress can be permanent and sustainable without reforms.

Because this is a laborious process, and because there are of course political resistances against it, the doubts of investors about whether this Eurozone will hold together in the long run have unfortunately grown. We must now do everything to dispel these doubts. I always say: You underestimate our political will to really achieve this. Politics works a bit differently than the discreet group of investors from your industry knows. But we also know that with the high national debt we have, and with the high national debt in Europe as a whole, we also need non-European investors whom we must convince again that their money is well invested in the Eurozone.

Now, each institution in Europe has its own task. The European Central Bank has the task of ensuring monetary stability. At the moment, we already have some problems within the Eurozone. We have low interest rates. This is good for the federal budget. When you have to finance your debts through new bonds, low interest rates are welcome. – When I look at Mr. Schulte, I am not so sure that low interest rates please him as much as they do the federal government. – This means we need to get back to normal waters in Europe.

And it is true: Germany has, for example, paid about three percent for ten-year government bonds for many years. We are currently paying 1.5 or 1.6 percent. Interest rates are significantly higher in other countries. We must accept interest rate differences – that is why I am also against a mutualization of debts, to be clear; craftsmanship and I, as well as the entire federal government, are completely in agreement on this – but it is also important that the systemic questions – does the Eurozone hold together or not? – are answered again by saying: Yes, it holds together.

In this context, the measures decided by the ECB are also to be understood. But – and I absolutely support Mario Draghi on this – the countries must do their homework themselves. The ECB cannot replace political action. Therefore, we will have to carry out both structural reforms and at the same time ensure that we address the mistakes or shortcomings that were made in the creation of the Economic and Monetary Union – for example, the lack of enforcement rights. If countries permanently violate the agreements on closer economic coordination, we must intensify our efforts again, because you cannot simply have a common currency and each country does whatever it wants in its financial and economic policy.

This raises a multitude of questions – also questions that you often hint at when it comes to vocational education systems and similar matters. So, how far do we want to harmonize such things? How far do we want to allow differences, also as an advantage for competitiveness? I believe we must primarily focus on the question: What is best practice? It is, of course, in a certain way almost a bit schizophrenic, I must say, when on the one hand, at the moment in every European country, people say to us: How great is your vocational training system; we want that too. – We also help with that; and I also thank craftsmanship for its helpful contribution. – On the other hand, it is always pretended that only university education is something that can be measured, and that vocational training and dual education are lagging behind. If we want to remain a continent with industrial production and craftsmanship, vocational training must also be an equally important pillar alongside university education. That is completely clear.

I recently made this clear again – even if this is not the central topic for craftsmanship – using the example of elderly care. If it is demanded that one must have a high school diploma, that is, have gone to school for at least twelve years, then that corresponds to the tradition in some countries. But for us, it is also good if one has completed ten years of school and then three years of vocational training for a full-fledged profession. From my perspective, that is often the better way. And this applies to many skilled trades as well.

Of course, the question arises – and we can discuss this as well –: How do I define the boundaries? Where does a certain professional order become a barrier to not allowing others? We have already talked a lot about this, but the answer cannot be that without any qualifications, all skills are demanded. We do not have that in the academic field either. There must also be comparability of vocational qualifications if one wants to perform certain activities. In this respect, I will advocate clearly for this, and the federal government will also do so, and we are indeed in good dialogue.

When we talk about this in Europe – consolidation, often also called austerity, or growth – then I mean: This alternative does not exist. Long-term, sustainable growth will only occur on the basis of solid finances. These alone are not enough, but they are a necessary condition for long-term growth. By the way, growth is one of those things that we cannot simply write into a law and then implement.

Instead, growth is a delicate plant that must be nurtured and cared for, and therefore we must ensure that there are people who are eager to undertake something from which growth can arise. That is why it is so important that we have growth-promoting conditions in Europe. This naturally includes less bureaucracy. This includes as efficient regulations as possible. This includes as uniform approval procedures as possible, so that people who want to engage in various European countries do not always have to study completely new textbooks everywhere. This also includes, of course, providing relief to the citizens of Europe wherever possible or setting incentives.

With that, I come to topics that you, Mr. Kentzler, have also mentioned – for example, the topic of building renovation. We have been talking about a possible tax incentive for a long time. I want to say it again, because you are also speaking with your political leaders on site: We had very intensive mediation committee negotiations. The head of the Chancellery, Roland Pofalla, has taken up the topic.

We have addressed all the conditions of the countries regarding flexibility. It is therefore not true that we said "eat or die," but we have indeed taken the suggestions of the countries into account. However, we always come to the following point; and I ask for your understanding: It cannot be that everyone has more value-added tax revenues afterwards, but only the federal government bears the losses in income tax. It has been intensively and very convincingly demonstrated – also by the crafts – that the expected additional tax revenues more than compensate for the losses. Therefore, I also ask you once again to put pressure on this issue.

We are now entering a period of weaker growth again. We want to achieve the energy transition. We must use energy efficiently. And it is simply unacceptable that we are not making progress in this area. Therefore, once again my request: Stay on it, do not give up. Some boards are a bit thicker than one thought at the beginning. But drilling boards somehow belongs to your trade.

A second point is that we are negotiating with the countries about the question: What happens when incomes rise – thank God there is a favorable wage development – and cold progression eats up a large part of the additional wages? It would be a good rule to increase the basic tax allowance – there will soon be another report on securing existence – and then not to take everything away from people by having a steeper tax increase curve, but to offset this cold progression.

I believe that in the current phase, where growth is significantly shaped by domestic demand, it would be more right than wrong to say that we are really fighting cold progression. The federal government has said: We will take on everything that we have in terms of a legal shift of the tax curve, so what does not necessarily have to be done by the countries, but we do expect that the countries also take on a share of the tax losses, as they are also receiving more tax revenues from income increases. Here, too, we are in what I consider to be a truly absurd dispute. Perhaps we can also work together to ensure that reason prevails here.

And the third point is – again in the interest of domestic demand –: We can – and this happens almost automatically according to the legal situation – lower the pension contribution rate by about 0.6 percent; the exact number has not yet been determined. We know that in the long term we will, of course, also have rising pension contributions again. But we have already lowered the health insurance contribution rate by 0.6 percent during a stimulus program, if you remember, and raised it again when we came back into an upswing. That did not bring joy, but the temporary reduction helped us in a difficult time.

Now we have the opportunity for around 5.4 billion euros in relief in pension insurance – equally shared between businesses and employees. Why should we not take advantage of this opportunity in the current phase? Therefore, we as the federal government will try to achieve this contribution reduction. But there is also resistance building up. In this regard, I would like to draw your attention to this point, as the relief would also be a reflection of our very good employment situation, to which the crafts have also contributed.

We have the major issue of securing skilled workers. It is very important that we maintain our dual education system. By the way, a final look back at Europe: I believe that after we have created a fairly uniform internal market, we must also gradually create a mobile labor market in Europe. In this regard, we have a significant disadvantage compared to a large economic area like that of the United States of America. There are no language barriers and no national borders. We have complete freedom of movement, the right of establishment, and an internal market. However, the mobility of workers is still low. This will not be overcome in two, five, or ten years, but that must be our goal.

This is related to the fact that we say: Young skilled workers must learn a foreign language. It must become completely normal that not only students move back and forth in Europe. In the past, craftsmen went on a journey; that was somehow more normal than it is today. If we simply reconnect to the tradition and all sing together "Wandering is the Miller's Joy," then we have already achieved something again. Therefore, we are also working on a close coordination in the EU Professional Qualifications Directive to advance these matters sensibly.

Now I would like to talk about the energy transition. I will look into the issue of energy consulting again. We need to see why craft businesses are not involved in all publicly funded consulting programs. Otherwise, the energy transition is, of course, a major topic that has occupied us for years. Mr. Kentzler, you said it: It will not be available at zero cost. However, in the long run – especially if we strengthen energy efficiency – it can provide us with a) an export hit and b) also less energy consumption. This means we will also have a return here.

But at the moment, you have the problem that you are also concerned with the question "How high are our energy costs?" I believe it is undisputed that we say: The companies that are strongly in export competition must be exempted from certain levies. Now we have somewhat expanded this; and I must note: Through the slight expansion, the problem has actually become larger and not smaller, because, of course, some desires have been awakened, as someone just said, because many do not benefit from it. We were quite proud to have broadened the exemption from levies, but the number of people who then realized that they were not included despite the expansion has increased. I cannot make you a promise off the cuff here. We certainly need to talk about it again.

We now have the following tasks to solve in Germany: On the one hand, we need to advance the expansion of power lines. There are a number of energy line projects. These are specified in the so-called EnLAG, the Energy Line Expansion Act. They can only be implemented by the states. The federal government is not shirking from this; rather, the states have full planning authority over these routes. If we do not get these routes, we will not be able to direct renewable energy to the places where we will need it one day. In addition, there is the federal task of planning the large transmission lines from north to south, which will then be operated with direct current. The planning for this is currently taking place. The relevant law will be implemented by the end of the year. And then we will talk to the states about how we organize the approval procedures. We have agreed that the spatial planning procedures, especially those crossing state borders, will be conducted by the federal government. We are still in discussions with the states about whether we will also conduct the planning approval procedures at the federal level or return them to the states.

The question of whether we are making sufficient progress with the expansion of power lines – this concerns not only the expansion of the large lines but also that of the distribution networks – is significantly related to whether we can also feed in all the renewable energy. You have all followed how the law on renewable energy had to be revised due to the dramatic expansion of solar energy. There are indeed craft businesses that benefit from the installation of solar panels. But we now have the following situation: As soon as you have a funding stock – the EEG funding is indeed an interesting investment model that offers many people advantages – it becomes increasingly difficult in a democracy to change such a nice law again with democratic majorities. This has led to us taking relatively long to revise the EEG. This has resulted in the funding still being such that it caused an incredible increase in solar energy.

The good thing about the law that has now been passed is that it has a cap up to which funding occurs and then no longer; that is 52 gigawatts. However: Germany needs an available capacity of around 65 gigawatts on a normal day. We will be able to provide 52 gigawatts with solar energy relatively soon – at least on sunny days at noon. We are also experiencing a fairly rapid expansion of wind energy. If I add up the plans of all federal states for the expansion of wind energy for the coming years, it shows that we have about 60 percent too much planned wind energy. The EEG states that this must then also be fully compensated; regardless of whether the electricity is taken or not.

This means we also need a revision here; you have already demanded that. But this is a legislative revision for which we need majorities. And to find these, we need a lot of reason. People must somewhat step back from their own involvement. We want to continue to promote renewable energies, but we need to find a way – and we are also having constructive discussions with the states about this – that we do not jeopardize supply security by overloading the networks.

Price relevance also plays a role here. It is about not overstraining affordability while simultaneously guaranteeing environmental friendliness. There is often the question: Yes, what were you thinking? I have had the best forecast reports on my desk, according to which even in the most optimistic scenario, the expansion of solar energy would fall far short of the target set for 2018, which we will now have already achieved by the end of 2012. Some renewal rates in the area of renewable energies, some degressions cannot be predicted. You know that too.

Innovation means innovation because there has not been anything like it before. But when you are moving in such a field, you must also be able to act at any time to counteract exaggerations. We need to work on that now. Not everyone should think only of themselves – I mean the politically responsible ones as well – but we must find reasonable solutions together. We will remain in conversation about how we handle the exemption from levies and non-exemption.

I cannot give you a blank check here today. You know, Mr. Kentzler, I only commit to what I can also deliver. And if I do not do it as I probably should now with solar energy, whose expansion has progressed much faster than any report predicted, then that must also be named. But all the more I must be careful when it comes to making further commitments.

The entire question of secured financing, including credit financing, is, of course, an existential question. It is true that we rightly said as a lesson from the financial crisis: We need stricter regulations. After the financial crisis, we said: Every product, every financial center, and every financial market actor must be subject to regulation. And that remains our goal. We also said: Banks – now international shadow banks are also being reviewed; this is perhaps at least as important as bank regulation – must be made more resilient to shocks. And that means, according to the Basel III rules, more equity, which of course brings a number of measures that also lead to difficulties in granting loans.

Basel II was already a step that had significant consequences for many, including smaller companies. We have had to establish: The United States of America, for example, has not implemented Basel II to this day – we have done so with much love. Yes, I dealt very intensively with what had to be provided from your side, what forecasts had to be made.

And I mean: Of course, there must be standards for lending. But I believe that the relationship of a bank, a cooperative bank, a savings bank, or another bank to its customers must also allow for a degree of human judgment. If I only regulate everything with a measuring tape, my risk will not necessarily be lower than if I have known a customer for 20 years and can assess their performance.

So, if there is no room left for discretion, and instead the application of all indicators always leads to huge calculations, for which you also have to pay for advice, then that is unrealistic.

Basel III is fundamentally correct. However, Basel III will only have its fair effect if it is also applied across the Atlantic and in other parts of the world. If we in Europe were the only ones applying it, that would be bad. Therefore, we need to examine what is necessary for medium-sized enterprise loans now. What you say about the trilogue is somewhat hopeful. If the trilogue result is indeed as it is – I have not checked that since yesterday – then it will also be adopted. Trilogue results are relatively watertight; that is at least my experience. But we will continue to ensure that the craft sector also receives what is necessary, and that there are no overestimations and exaggerations of risks that could lead to difficulties.

We are in Germany at a stage where we have somewhat more quickly reached what I had wished for, namely the level of economic performance from before the crisis. I had said back then that this would be possible by the end of this legislative period, that is, by the end of 2013. But now it is already 2012, and we have reached that point. However, we notice that after the very vigorous recovery process, a certain uncertainty has now set in. The economic forecasts for the next one or two years are no longer so optimistic. All the more important it is that we strengthen our domestic demand, that we increase our flexibility in the labor market rather than decrease it, and that we maintain it in any case, and that we address and solve our problems in the proven social partnership that is lived out in the craft sector.

We have a good economic development. We have reached the level of 2007 or 2008 again. However, we must also see that we now develop the Euro question as gently as possible and, above all, decisively continue the structural reforms. And we must also ensure that we sustainably secure our skilled workforce in Germany – lest in the end companies migrate because there are no suitable people to be found here to work in the companies.

In this situation, it is now very important that we focus on the essentials. We must say that it is of course also important to consolidate our finances step by step. We are currently being criticized a lot – we have good tax revenues; we should save more. Yes, but we also see that we have a responsibility for Europe and must ensure that we do not fall into a recessionary trend. This means we invest in research, we invest in development, we lower contributions and do many other things because we believe that this is important.

Nevertheless, you can gauge what has actually happened when one now, towards the end of the year 2012, says: We are roughly back at the economic strength we had before the crisis. Normally, one would say: One must at least have a growth of 1 to 1.5 percent. This means that this crisis has cost us a lot, even though we have come through the labor market so well. You can see this in the increase in the total debt of the Federal Republic of Germany.

We have had struggling state banks, we have had HRE. We have had to spend taxpayer money to rescue banks. And we have implemented stimulus programs like all other European countries – I believe, wise stimulus programs. But these have also cost us money. I would like to remind you, for example, of the scrapping premium. This was well received and did not cause the distortions that were claimed – what has not been said about it. And that is why I say: We have not done all this badly, but this crisis has indeed cost us a lot of strength.

Now it is about us collectively further developing all of this, especially since our demographic changes in Germany are very strong – part of the very good labor market situation is of course also based on this. You can feel the demographic change when you look at the number of school graduates, as more people are leaving the workforce than are entering it after school.

All the more important – my last request to you – is that we must create better integration for migrants. Among children under five years old – I have already made this clear today in another context – every third child has a migration background. If we do not succeed in bringing the educational achievements of these children up to the level of those of German descent, then we will have a huge problem in the medium term. And that is why I am also pleased that, for example, the football clubs of the Bundesliga will be playing in jerseys with the inscription "Go your way" next Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, thus addressing the issue of migration and saying: Everyone should go their own way here.

Wherever you can, support integration. I know that you in the German craft sector do this in many, many places, because we must give these people a chance as well if they are willing to learn. They must be able to sufficiently master our language and be able to make themselves understood. That is clear.

Overall, I would like to thank you for a very good cooperation. I have the impression that we will also remain in good contact in the coming months. Working with Mr. Kentzler and his team is enjoyable, and it is enjoyable with all of you. Thank you for what you do for our country. You can do this – and you can be proud of that. All the best.