Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Crafts Day on September 18, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

22 September 2008 · German Crafts Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Crafts Day on September 18, 2008, in Berlin, speaking on the state of the crafts sector amid global financial turmoil.
Main themes
German crafts sector, employment growth, economic restructuring and reform, international financial market transparency, social security systems, global financial crisis, energy prices and inflation, German industrial base, G8 financial regulation, pay-as-you-go pension systems
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,894
91st percentile
Sentences
252
93rd percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 48%47%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

252 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Mr. Kentzler,

Mr. Schleyer,

ladies and gentlemen,

thank you very much for the introductory remarks. As we often do, we also had a small meeting last week to discuss the current situation of German crafts. It has now truly become a good tradition for me to come here to you. I remember that one of my first appointments as Chancellor was the Handwerkstag in 2005 in Düsseldorf. Since then, we have maintained very close contact with each other.

I believe that since then, many things have changed for the nearly five million craftsmen and their employees in Germany. There are a number of developments that are quite positive. The nice thing, and I would like to say thank you for this, is that the depiction of the situation in the crafts is usually very realistic. The good is named – not everyone in the Republic does that anymore – and the bad is not ignored either. But in this balance, I believe it is often easier to get along with each other than if one only has frustrating negative messages. I think this also corresponds better to reality. It is also clear to you that economic success is not always equally pronounced in all trades; you just hinted at that. There are areas that are very much dependent on domestic conditions, and there are areas that also support the export sectors. Therefore, when we look to the future, we must of course try to take all areas into account to some extent.

Since 2005, we have created 1.3 million additional jobs. In 2007, we had more than 40 million employees for the first time. We have seen that to the extent that the number of employees subject to social security contributions increases, the situation of the social security systems also improves. When we took office as a government, for example, we did not know exactly how to manage the pension insurance properly. But simply through the improved employment situation, the possibilities to rebuild the fluctuation reserve have now increased. So everything is of course primarily related to the situation of the employees. And that will remain the case.

Therefore, our motto is indeed not just "restructuring" – we have made significant progress with the budget, but we have not yet reached our goal – but the motto is: continue to restructure, reform, and invest. This triad has proven to be effective, even last year. It should be continued in this legislative period and beyond with appropriate measures.

At the moment, we are working – you feel it, we feel it, and we read and hear it every day – in a more difficult economic environment. We can be very glad that Germany has a strong industrial and economic base, which of course also includes the crafts. The fact that we are not solely strong in the financial services sector makes us more robust, but of course does not make us independent of global economic developments.

Yesterday, I spoke in the general debate in the German Bundestag about how we will strongly push from the German side – I completely agree with the Finance Minister on this – for the international financial markets to become more transparent and for the risks to be better secured. I can only say – we sometimes speak differently in other situations – that it is also good in such a situation that our social security systems are largely funded on a pay-as-you-go basis, because pure capital coverage currently carries great risks.

But what I would like to emphasize even more, when you look at the United States of America, is that we have solidarity systems for the entire population and not purely company-based security systems. Domestic companies in the United States, for example in the automotive industry, have an incredibly strong structural disadvantage due to the aging workforce compared to new companies coming from other countries, which have predominantly young employees and therefore bear a much lower pension burden. So I believe we are on a very balanced and quite good path with the complementary capital security and the simultaneous solidarity pay-as-you-go system.

The difficulty with the current economic situation is that we, both from a European and a German perspective, cannot fully grasp the risks that are located in the American market. Therefore, we can only insist that such things do not happen again in the future. In my firm conviction, much of what we are experiencing now could have been prevented through more transparency and clearer criteria for the rating agencies. Unfortunately, I must say that we feel very confirmed in our G8 presidency that we insisted on exactly this, even though we were then rejected by the British and American sides. Today, we must jointly acknowledge that such regulations are necessary. In the meantime, there is also an increasing consensus on this in the United States and the United Kingdom.

At the same time, the rapid development in emerging markets has led to an increase in energy prices, which is of course also overall inflationary, reinforcing the feeling among people that they have no real income growth. Therefore, in the coming months, we must set the right course with prudence, reason, and a view to the future. That is why it is good and right that you also mention the measures that you consider necessary. I also want to tell you from my perspective where we stand and how we see things.

Interest payments on federal debt today account for 14 to 15 percent of the budget. They had a share of two percent about 40 years ago. It is absolutely certain that we cannot continue like this if we do not want to completely jeopardize the leeway of future generations.

In the coming decades, we will face a dramatic change in the age structure of society, especially in the area of employment. I was recently at BASF. There, Mr. Hambrecht vividly described it to me again. Today, 22 percent of employees at BASF are over 50 years old. By 2020, it will be more than 50 percent, namely 57 percent. This gives rise to a whole range of tasks.

Therefore, budget consolidation is not just some mathematical issue that one has now fallen in love with, but it is absolutely urgent. We are glad that we have made progress in reducing new debt. Of course, total debt is still continuing to rise. The budget that we will discuss in Parliament in the coming weeks is a budget that still has 2.5 billion euros in new debt. There will still be privatization revenues in the next three to four years. After that, the structural deficit of the budget must also be managed.

In order to bring all of this together, our most important benchmark must be to continue to ensure social security employment. We must not be satisfied with three million or 3.2 million unemployed; rather, we must primarily tackle the thick plank and bring the increasing number of unemployed back into employment. Otherwise, we will run into a gap between a shortage of skilled workers here and a high number of unemployed there, which we will then find difficult to manage.

We naturally want to utilize all leeway to create relief. We are of course not only looking at the groups you have in mind, but we must also ensure that consumers benefit. It is easily said: The federal government is collecting more taxes; something must happen to reduce the debt more quickly. I just want to remind you: There were collective agreements, for example in the civil service sector, which ultimately mean a strengthening of domestic demand when the money, if not saved, flows into consumption. One can say that entrepreneurs are being taxed too much, but if people do not have salary increases, then they cannot order anything from them or not more than before; that is quite simple.

The same applies – I will come back to health later – to doctors and nursing staff. The doctors have agreed to a collective agreement of 13 percent. They deserve it, and it should fundamentally contribute to strengthening domestic demand. But on the other hand, this naturally means that it cannot happen without affecting health insurance contributions, unless one were to close hospitals en masse, which would then also have difficult consequences. I always say jokingly: That is why the office of the Chancellor is so much fun. Because in the end, all ends meet with me. Therefore, I must solve the equation in such a way that the two sides of the coin – relief and budget consolidation – also fit together and do not drift too far apart.

There has been a pension increase. We have introduced parental allowance. We have introduced the tax deductibility of childcare and modernization measures in private households. Of course, we know that you wish for more, especially regarding the craftsman bonus. I will take this matter with me, but I cannot promise you that today; I must say that quite honestly. But the program has proven itself. We have generated a relief effect of 1.1 billion euros with it. It is important which measures you consider to be targeted, but I also cannot simply deviate from my budgetary framework.

We will continue to push for the reduction of the contribution in the unemployment insurance sector, which we have already nearly halved from 6.5 to 3.3 percent. I see further leeway. I also say that I know that there will be increases in the health sector – already due to collective agreements – and that we therefore also know our responsibility to do everything we can in unemployment insurance.

Mr. Kentzler, you asked earlier what the main school diploma has to do with the Federal Employment Agency. Questioning that is fundamentally correct. But if a child is declared unfit for training by everyone, what should be done then? Should one let it run free at the age when something should become of it and thus establish a career that does not lead to a qualified occupation – you would then later call for qualified applicants that you are missing – or should one perhaps try again to make something out of the school leaver so that you have another applicant? Of course, that is not the original task of the Federal Employment Agency. That is why there is also an education summit where we discuss with the states what can be done. There are now also very interesting cooperation programs. One can say that this may not be the ultimate wisdom. But compared to doing nothing, it is certainly cheaper and more intelligent for the Federal Employment Agency to pay attention in the last school years in the main schools and secondary schools to better align school diplomas with the requirements for vocational training, and that there are already BA offers in the form of internships or other things during school education to better prepare children for the professional path.

The willingness to do so has grown just as the willingness in the country has grown for a primary school teacher to enter a kindergarten and for a kindergarten teacher or educator to also go into a primary school. There have been and still are – due to one responsibility here and another responsibility there – so to speak, divided life stages of children that need to be overcome. The claim must be that every school leaver can obtain a diploma, and one that not only provides a school graduation but also offers a connection point for vocational training. I believe we are on a better path today.

So we want to lower the contributions. We have achieved quite a bit by reducing the unemployment insurance contribution from 6.5 to 3.3 percent. This means a relief of 25 billion euros per year for the contributors. This also benefits purchasing power. Of course, the corporate tax reform was also a relief for many.

We also need to implement the health reform. Here, we again find ourselves in a tension field. On the one hand, there are tariff increases for doctors. If you look at the situation of medical care in some of the new federal states, it is really concerning. In rural areas, it is very, very difficult today. Our doctors sometimes prefer to go to other European countries or they go to the Medical Service for better working conditions. The nursing staff also do not earn well. On the other hand, the state should not spend money, but it is still required to make attractive offers. If you look at the remuneration and payment of educators or teachers, from whom we really expect a lot, it is also not the case that the trees grow into the sky for them.

We will keep the parity wage supplementary costs below 40 percent. With the retirement age of 67, we have also taken a significant step to ensure the long-term viability of the pension insurance system. We have made further efforts regarding additional old-age security in the form of home equity pensions to strengthen the ability to live in one's own home in old age. This is also something that indirectly benefits you. Furthermore, this autumn we will receive a report on the minimum subsistence level, from which we can expect that those with children will receive a higher allowance for their child. There will also be a discussion about an increase in child benefits – in the order of about ten euros per child – which of course corresponds to your interest in increasing purchasing power. When we look at families, this is a very important point.

We also have a task ahead of us that intersects with what is important to you, namely the issue of tax relief. This task has been assigned to us by the Federal Constitutional Court. It has not yet received much attention, but it is extremely financially impactful. It concerns a ruling on the better deductibility of health insurance expenses. Essentially, this is another relief regarding when one must start paying taxes. You can almost see it as an increase in the tax allowance. The impact of this is extremely high. I do not want to elaborate further on this topic here, but I want to say: This is more than the relief brought about by the corporate tax reform. We must implement this by January 1, 2010, at the latest. If we do not implement it, the effect would be even greater – then one could deduct all health insurance expenses.

This is something that will provide significant relief for you in the craft sector and, of course, for the self-employed. We are currently working on how we can implement this, but this is an entirely unexpected additional task in our medium-term financial planning. Therefore, I am also a little cautious regarding further relief that I can promise, as this is a really big task. However, it is also a task whose solution directly benefits the contributors, that is, those who pay taxes.

We are also aware of the tasks we face regarding inheritance tax reform. There will be changes. You have mentioned two very important ones for you. This inheritance tax reform has a clear political goal, namely to facilitate business succession. We must adapt the reform – which makes the discussion difficult – to a ruling of the Federal Constitutional Court.

The Federal Constitutional Court has dealt with how real estate and capital assets should be valued for inheritance tax purposes. I believe it was clear to everyone that the Federal Constitutional Court would hardly say that these should be treated completely differently, which has been the reality in the Federal Republic of Germany for over 50 years. Politics has never decided on this. Then this question, like so many others, ended up at the Federal Constitutional Court, which then made a decision on it. The decision of the Federal Constitutional Court now changes the valuation of real estate. These new valuation standards will create incredible changes. We need to look very closely at this now.

This is combined with the statement of the Federal Constitutional Court or the statement of the Basic Law that relief in inheritance tax must be justified on a societal level. This has now led to questions regarding jobs, etc. We understand that in this 21st century, with massive economic shifts, it is nearly impossible to make statements about what a business in a specific industry will look like in 15 years. Therefore, the questions of holding periods and especially the "pro rata temporis" are key issues in this matter. I believe we have not only understood this but will also take it into account.

We have tried to address a point with the Debt Collection Security Act that often causes financial difficulties for small and medium-sized enterprises, namely when debtors do not pay on time. This law will be finalized in the Federal Council tomorrow. The legal framework against payment delays will be improved. However, I do not want to promise you that you will have no problems in this area anymore, as I am aware of the complexity of the matter. Nevertheless, we have made some progress here. My request to you is – and I believe you will do this – that there is good information about these new legal possibilities, as businesses need to be aware of them. I believe this could be an important step.

We have made progress in reducing bureaucracy costs. We have set ourselves the goal of reducing bureaucracy costs by 25 percent by the end of 2011, particularly regarding information and statistical obligations. We want to achieve half of this goal in this legislative period, that is, by next September. We have already been able to implement some simplifications that are very practical, such as the electronic tax declaration and the fully automated reporting and contribution process in social security. For example, businesses also benefit from not having to record driving times for smaller trucks like craft vehicles or sales vans. Just that alone brings some savings – sometimes they are small amounts, but for individuals, it is very important.

Therefore, I also thank the Central Association of German Crafts for the ongoing cooperation in this regard, such as in the development of the SME relief laws. The Federal Minister of Economics has now already initiated the third SME relief law, but it is laborious to continually find areas where SMEs can be relieved. For this, we also need practitioners who can tell us what is particularly burdensome for them. Not every one of your ideas – we know this – has been implemented one-to-one, but your suggestions and proposals have been important to us.

Mr. Kentzler spoke about energy and climate issues. In the coming weeks, until the end of the French presidency, we will face very difficult and essential negotiations for the German economy regarding the issue of certification in the period after 2013. This may not be directly significant for you, but indirectly it certainly is, as many of you depend more or less on energy-intensive industries.

We will enter the discussions with a very clear position and say: We stand by our climate protection commitments, but as an export-oriented nation, we cannot allow jobs in Germany to be destroyed, only to be created elsewhere in the world. This will be a very difficult negotiation because there are many European countries that do not have as broad an industrial base as we do, that do not have any chemical industry, aluminum industry, steel industry, or automotive industry at all. Since many decisions in the European Union today are made by majority, one always needs a group of countries with common interests.

In Germany, we have very ambitious climate goals – you know the climate package of the federal government. The share of combined heat and power generation will be doubled to 25 percent of electricity and heat supply, and the share of renewable energies will be increased to 30 percent in electricity generation and 14 percent in heat supply by 2020. This means there are significant shifts.

We have also discussed the building sector, which is of particular interest to you. Here, the potential for CO2 reduction is very large, as the building sector accounts for about 40 percent of total energy consumption. It is often referred to in the climate protection debate as the "sleeping giant," because we initially focused on very efficient industrial plants and are only now slowly moving into consumer areas. In this regard, the federal government's building renovation program is a proper program. We recently discussed that the program should be improved from your perspective, especially regarding the issue of single-family homes. Others, however, say we should prioritize large residential complexes. I will certainly take your suggestion into account in the discussions.

I believe we should also pay attention to the landlord-tenant relationship to ensure that it is worthwhile for landlords to invest in building renovations. We are looking at your proposals as well as those from the German construction industry. Currently, the utility bill in rent is essentially completely independent of the cold rent. But if I, as a landlord, can only pass my investments onto the cold rent and cannot benefit from a reduction in utility costs, then such investments do not pay off. Therefore, we are very open to improvement proposals in this regard. For this reason, the CO2 building renovation program will be increased again.

We do not believe that we should compensate for fluctuations in energy prices through short-term support measures, but rather that we should ensure long-term sustainable options to truly consume less energy. We will have a trend where energy prices will not fall anymore, but rather rise due to the limited supply. Therefore, we agree on this point as well.

We should also take the opportunity to make building renovations and the renovation of heating systems not too complicated and not impose too many additional conditions. This means we will continue to work on the programs and will fully incorporate your advice.

You spoke about education. This is a long-term issue. I would like to thank the ZDH, especially Mr. Schleyer, for both the commitment to dual vocational training in Brussels to make the entire system resilient to Europe, as well as for the provision of training places. In the training pact, the craft sector has always played a leading role. You are the backbone in this regard; that must be clearly stated.

This commitment will pay off in the coming years – that much can already be predicted today – as you will all still be looking for suitable applicants. You can already feel the interest in visiting schools and seeing where interested young people are. We all need to work together, above all, to maintain interest in technical professions. We also need to make educational pathways more permeable. We are currently discussing in the federal government about enabling masters to take up study programs. In this respect, we are already approaching what I call a "Republic of Education" in many areas and facets.

But we need to pick up the pace – that is also true. Therefore, we should continue on this path together. I was pleased that you are willing to demonstrate your examples again at our education summit. Because at this point, it will be decided whether Germany can really move forward and stay ahead or whether Germany will ultimately have to watch as a high proportion of non-trainable young people leads businesses to relocate to other countries because they cannot find the right workforce here.

Therefore, we will open the labor market on January 1, 2009, so that, for example, graduates in technical fields from other European countries can come to us. But anyone who believes that Germany is such an attractive country despite language barriers that the entire world will flock to us and that we can neglect our education here at home is mistaken. Moreover, we also have a human obligation, a societal obligation, to give everyone in this country a chance.

I already know that I am probably preaching to the wrong choir here, as you really do care about young people. But you also cannot make up for what has been neglected elsewhere. When a young person comes to you, they are already 16 years old or older. However, we now know that early childhood education in the first years of life is crucial. Therefore, we have said at the federal and state levels: We must work together to improve the care options for children under three years old.

I do not know whether you were all immediately enthusiastic about this program in your capacity as fathers or grandfathers, or whether you also asked yourselves: My goodness, can one not stay at home for the first three years? I can only tell you this: We have now discussed the education report for Germany in the federal government. In all the highly industrialized regions of Germany – the Rhine-Main area, Stuttgart, Munich, Nuremberg, Erlangen, Fürth, and so on – the proportion of under-25s with a migration background is between 40 and 50 percent. In Augsburg, today 50 percent of the children starting school come from families with a migration background. If we do not succeed in teaching these children language skills – unfortunately, there are also deficits here among children with a German-speaking background – then we will not be able to give these children any chance later on to enter technically demanding professions.

Educators tell us: A child can actually speak quite well after the first one and a half years of life. When children come to kindergarten at the age of three – we have largely ensured this possibility now – the children who can already speak German as a first language almost perfectly look at those who cannot express themselves yet or often do not master any language with relative calmness, and they avoid these children. Thus, the necessary integration is already lacking very early on. That is why the money invested in education is incredibly important, especially for those under three years old with a migration background, as it can prevent much longer and more expensive developmental processes later on.

Of course, these are things we also need to keep in mind: I cannot immediately allocate all the tax increases that I do not use for debt reduction to tax cuts or reductions in contributions. Rather, we must also invest in something from time to time. In building renovation and similar areas, incentives can be set for private investments, but in education, there must really be state investment, just as there must be investment in roads. I believe there is also support from the crafts sector that we have deliberately invested in research and that we want to make progress towards the goal of investing three percent of gross domestic product in research and development.

All of this, of course, are competing goals. From these goals, we want to implement what makes sense. That is why I also tell you: We are currently dealing extensively with this – the Federal Minister of Labor mentioned it again this morning in the budget debate – that the instruments of the Federal Employment Agency will be significantly streamlined. Olaf Scholz has said that an employee of the Federal Employment Agency must have the instruments in mind and should not have to consult a manual to know what types of funding instruments are available. This can also be made manageable. We will still do this in the coming weeks and months. By the way, we want to expand the Meister-BAföG and advancement scholarships – that is, especially the permeability that interests you.

If you open the newspaper at the moment, you might get the impression that we are now in an election campaign. We do have an election campaign in Bavaria, that is true. But afterwards, we have an incredible amount to do. I will only mention a few topics: inheritance tax, Federalism Commission II, debt brake – all long-term questions; budget discussions, further reduction of unemployment insurance contributions, health reform, child benefit, subsistence minimum, implementation of the Federal Constitutional Court ruling on the tax deductibility of health insurance contributions. So, it will not be boring in the coming weeks, and we will have to work very intensively.

In addition, all of this takes place in an economic environment in which we must do everything we can – this is the top priority – to create more jobs. More employment goes hand in hand with more growth. And growth is the basis for relief. In this context, I promise you that we will continue to be good partners, that we – because you are so important for employment in Germany – will of course take your wishes very seriously.

We hope that you will continue to engage in what you do for our society beyond business. German craftsmanship has its home in Germany. That should remain so. Therefore, even if we do not always have to agree, we want to continue to be partners on a common path. In this sense: Thank you very much. I wish us continued good contacts.