Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers e.V. (BDZV) on September 22, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

22 September 2008 · Newspaper Congress of the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers e.V. (BDZV) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers Congress in Berlin on September 22, 2008, discussing media policy and industry challenges.
Main themes
Newspaper industry challenges, digitalization and online competition, media diversity, antitrust law reform, inheritance tax for medium-sized businesses, advertising revenue decline, financial market turbulence, freedom of the press, media policy, German print media landscape
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,482
81st percentile
Sentences
186
87th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%40%
  • Economic 27%27%
  • Social 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

186 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President Heinen,

dear Presidents – I am not exactly sure if the President of the World Association has already arrived; but the European President, Mr. Lehari, is present –, esteemed colleagues from the parliaments – I would like to specifically mention you, dear Mr. Westerwelle –, ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here today for the opening of this year's Newspaper Publishers Congress to once again highlight current issues and to account for the position of the federal government.

I believe that this summit of the newspaper industry has long established itself as an important forum for experts and practitioners. Here, you analyze trends, discuss current media policy issues and challenges, of which there are indeed quite a number, and you seek – this is the essence of your association – constructive solutions. In this regard, politics wants to be at least a sympathetic partner. For we are deeply convinced that not only does your association have a right to exist, but above all, your products have more than just a right to exist.

Even in times of increasing digitalization, newspapers are indispensable in the media landscape – I say this explicitly. They are as essential for millions of German citizens as daily bread. I believe this is indeed due to the fact that we have a remarkable range of high-quality newspapers in Germany. This meets the various informational needs. You can assume that politics is an interested partner; a partner that not only believes that this is good for the citizens, but also knows that the diversity of information is the foundation for our work to be disseminated in a factual manner – which can be critical, informative, or also supportive.

At the outset, I want to say that we are very aware of the medium-sized structure of this industry and will take its concerns into account in the discussion about the future inheritance tax. To put it bluntly: The draft law, as it currently stands, must undergo significant changes to ensure that this medium-sized structure is preserved.

I do not want to present lengthy discussions about the problems we face in implementation. One point is the question of relieving the medium-sized businesses, especially during the transition from one generation to another. The other point is the significant task posed to us by the Federal Constitutional Court regarding the valuation of real estate and capital assets. For decades, it has been a truism that the ruling had to come as it did. But politics has always known how difficult it would be to implement it. That is why the decision was also left to the Federal Constitutional Court. Now it is about minimizing the distortions in the valuation standards so that dramatic consequences do not arise for the German medium-sized businesses.

I also want to say something about the antitrust framework, which ensures diversity. I believe that changes are necessary here. Bringing about these changes is extraordinarily difficult with the coalition partner. But I must be honest: It is not entirely easy with you either. Because when a solution has been found for two-thirds of the stakeholders, there is always one-third that has objections for certain regional or other, for example, historical reasons. Antitrust law is ultimately also always market law. But I can only say: In the interest of truly future-proof German industries, we need changes. Therefore, I will continue to advocate that we try to bring the various interests together.

The diversity of offerings in newspapers is by no means a given today – especially in light of massive online offerings and strong international competition. From this perspective, it becomes clear how eminently important the antitrust question is. We must primarily see that the European antitrust framework is different from the German one and that significant distortions can arise from this. Therefore, there is a need for action here.

We can say that printed products, such as printed books, have been able to hold their ground very well despite electronic competition. But we must also face the fact that newspapers and magazines have had to endure significant declines in circulation and losses in advertising revenues. It is to be expected that competitive pressure from electronic, especially online-based media offerings will continue to increase. We must do everything we can to ensure that the tense economic situation, now also exacerbated by the turbulence in the international financial markets, does not further impact this. This is not entirely within our national control. You know that. But at least we must try to shape the economic conditions in a comprehensive framework so that we can advance our economic development in Germany, at least somewhat decoupled from or not too closely linked to negative developments in other regions of the world.

You are therefore – I am aware of this – facing significant challenges. The question of how to address the structural change in the media world is being approached very courageously by you. I want to say that explicitly. We naturally wish that this takes place at a qualitatively high level. That you need the appropriate framework conditions for this goes without saying.

I am firmly convinced that newspapers will continue to be an integral part of the media offering in the future. With their reports, comments, and features, they convey reliable knowledge – comprehensive, differentiated, and fact-oriented. In doing so, they provide readers with orientation in complex issues. This is precisely something that online offerings cannot easily achieve. Therefore, I am convinced that newspapers will continue to be political leading media that enliven public discussion and also constitute the vitality of a democracy. This means we need print media, especially for the political culture in our country. It is about readers taking the diverse offerings seriously and embracing them. Therefore, we in politics are also very much looking forward to your exhibition in the parliamentary area. We thank you for the fact that such an exhibition will take place in the Paul-Löbe-Haus.

The interrelationships between politics and media are such that we can say: On the one hand, democracies are unthinkable without a free and truth-bound media landscape; on the other hand, media can only thrive and unfold in enlightened societies and functioning free democratic orders. Therefore, I would like to refer once again to the judgment of Albert Camus, who wonderfully said: "A free press can be good or bad, but a press without freedom can only be bad."

You can be assured that I will continue to advocate for press freedom – both abroad and at home. You have expressed slight criticism of the hearing procedures in the Interior Committee between the lines, if I understood correctly. We can gladly go into detail again to achieve improvements in the procedure or, if necessary, also in substance. I have no interest in sweeping such questions under the rug. Press freedom should be and must be. We can only advocate for it elsewhere if we live it at home in an appropriate manner.

Media policy has, for these reasons, the task of securing the fundamental right to press and freedom of expression as a cornerstone of our democracy. We also need it to further develop democratic orders elsewhere in the world and to make them an essential part of society there.

In times of globalization, we repeatedly encounter the fact that fair competition between countries is only possible if there is also a certain minimal structure of a shared understanding of values. To put it bluntly: Those who enable child labor, who allow environmental ruin, who do not respect patents and intellectual property cannot engage in fair competition. To advocate for our economic order, we need communication and thus also press freedom.

All of you gathered here in this hall are aware of your outstanding social responsibility. Therefore, I would like to express my heartfelt thanks for the fact that you are not only guided by professionalism and economic efficiency, but that an inherent professional ethos is also part of your work, that you feel committed to values, that you live the hallmark of press diversity and quality journalism in our country. This is by no means a given in light of many economic challenges. Therefore, I would like to take this opportunity to sincerely thank you for that.

Strategies to connect traditional and new media offerings in the journalistic and economic sphere are new business models that you are opening up to. Some of you have been practicing this for years and, by the way, with a lot of success. This includes the connection of print offerings and internet-based service offerings that you, Mr. Heinen, mentioned. The interplay can only work if network operators with their own information offerings do not push traditional providers to the margins. Here we find ourselves again in a situation where you must position yourselves among the various providers. Of course, this is where the task of media policy comes into play, ensuring that publishers are not discriminated against and that content-rich and demanding products can also find a secure place within new structures.

Now we quickly come to the topic of free newspapers. I think there is a certain need for discussion among you on this. Regarding the postal service, I believe we all agree. However, this problem is not completely resolved. But you can discuss that later when I am gone. Regarding the postal service and free newspapers, I have a very clear stance: I believe that this is not the task of the postal service. I also believe that it would not be right to find a publisher who then finds a large distributor. You can also do something with the component 1:99. The federal government will make its position very clear on this. But you must also always keep a sharp eye on your various providers.

I do not want to go into the minimum wage for postal services again, but I just want to say: Thank you for stating that we are now taking a step in the right direction regarding the abolition of the VAT exemption. I just want to say that it was certainly always the better way to put the postal service on the path to privatization. If you recall the hour of decisive discussions in the Bundesrat in the early 1990s, you will see that agreements were made regarding the wage structure that are also reflected in the law, which at least restrict the scope for maneuver. That was the condition of the SPD majority in the Bundesrat at that time. I recommend reading that again.

Now we need functioning distribution structures. Therefore, I would like to advocate once again for the Grosso system, which, with a market share of over 50 percent, is the most significant distribution network and is considered the most efficient distribution system within the European Union. I believe this model is also the practical side of the constitutionally guaranteed press freedom. Because this freedom would be in vain if publishing products could not be purchased everywhere at affordable prices. Therefore, I believe that the press Grosso has proven itself as a guarantor of press diversity. It should also remain an important instrument for safeguarding information and freedom of expression.

Those who want diversity in the markets must ensure functioning and fair competition. Therefore, from the perspective of the federal government, the media must assert themselves in a free economic and journalistic competition. The reduced VAT rate of seven percent on press products does not stand in the way of this. On the contrary: We show that this is part of the basic needs and must remain affordable for citizens in the future.

We cannot get by in this entire area without state regulation – despite all free competition. Even Ludwig Erhard had to confront the Federal Association of German Industry when he introduced antitrust law. Medium-sized structures can only exist permanently under certain competitive conditions. Therefore, it is important that we take a look at advertising – Mr. Heinen, you have said a lot about this. I do not want to say that every advertisement is important, but I believe it carries weight when the Chancellor says: I am still against advertising bans. Unfortunately, this does include certain exceptions.

I still believe that Ms. Bätzing supports the fundamental line of the federal government. This line is also in a certain continuity – I would like to remind you of the tobacco advertising ban. I can assure you: We are against advertising bans and also see the efforts being made on your side. We are even more against – how should I put it, to remain polite – such excesses as those in the area of automobile advertising. What is currently circulating in Brussels is, in my view, unacceptable.

However, I also say – now the European association president comes into play: Our German position is honorable, but it must also be capable of gaining a majority. Since many decisions in Brussels are now made by majority rather than unanimously, it is important to gain supporters for such a position within the European Union. When I look at how competencies of the European Union are almost deceitfully acquired – from food labeling to advertising issues – which are actually not really present, I can only urge the European associations to be extraordinarily vigilant and to really do everything to convince other member states and other media providers of our line, because otherwise we have a rather difficult position.

When we talk about your existence and fair competition, we cannot overlook public broadcasting. The controversial discussions surrounding the twelfth amendment to the broadcasting treaty have shown how strongly German media policy is now integrated into the European framework. I believe that the aid compromise found with the EU Commission regarding the fee financing of public broadcasting was a success. The Commission has suspended the aid procedure against Germany based on this compromise. Important prerequisites have been created for the Commission to accept the implementation of the compromise in the twelfth amendment to the broadcasting treaty.

Now we come to the central point, which is of utmost importance to you, namely the functional mandate of public broadcasting. It must be clearly defined what public broadcasting is allowed to do in order to fulfill its basic supply mandate and where its limits lie.

We agree – this was clearly expressed by Mr. Heinen – that there should be public institutions, that they are indispensable when it comes to the dissemination of information and cultural offerings. But there are a multitude of areas and program elements that can be just as well covered by private providers. This applies to entertainment offerings, such as games, online dating services, or non-broadcast-related chat rooms. Therefore, it was also important from our perspective – we have had numerous discussions about this; I personally have as well – to agree on a negative list that excludes such offerings for public institutions from the outset.

We know, of course, that print media must refinance free online offerings through advertising and announcements. They do not have the option of collecting fees, while these offerings from public institutions can remain ad-free thanks to fee financing. We must ensure that there is no situation of competitive distortion that unfairly disadvantages private providers. In this respect, a clear separation of internet offerings is necessary. Accordingly, public institutions are limited to broadcast-related online offerings and non-broadcast-related digital offerings that have been tested for their societal benefit and their impact on the media market in a three-tiered test.

I know that the devil will certainly be in the details. There is no question about that. Therefore, I believe that there will continue to be a certain skepticism about how the boundaries will be drawn. We must remain in conversation about this. But I hope that we have come closer to a viable compromise. I also believe that the discussion has not always been conducted solely for the benefit of public institutions.

However, there are also a number of cooperation projects that are highly commendable: ZDF and "Zeit," WAZ Group and WDR. All great. But my request to you is also that, despite all economic pressures, you face the challenges of the times and do not, so to speak, fall back on certain aspects of public institutions, which could create the impression that you cannot offer a diverse, high-quality offering on your own. I hope you can sense what I am talking about. I could also put it differently: The need in detail must not ultimately provide justification for the other side. – You could hardly live without it. That is the relationship between cooperation and separation. – Then we will continue to support you vigorously, without neglecting the necessity of public broadcasting.

Both parties I am currently speaking about are likely represented here in the room. Our common concern should be that the EU Commission does not continue to narrow the scope of media policy diversity. I believe that some things can be better regulated in the nation-states because there are historically grown structures. This applies to both the newspaper landscape and public broadcasting. Therefore, we need certain leeway.

The protection of intellectual property is an extremely important area. We want to find effective ways to combat digital piracy. We also need international cooperation agreements between providers, rights holders, and consumers to reconcile copyright protection and data protection.

The protection of intellectual property is a crucial point for ensuring press freedom. I believe that we have taken an important step with the "Law to Improve the Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights." However, comprehensive protection of intellectual property can only be achieved together with our European partners. Therefore, I believe that voluntary cooperation between service providers and rights holders should always be considered. Everything that is agreed upon voluntarily does not require as much legal regulation. This has a lot of positive aspects.

In this context, I would also like to commend the self-regulation of the media in the area of youth protection and many other areas. Here, too, we cannot do much legally, which you are certainly addressing within the framework of your self-regulation. You have clearly demonstrated, using the example of alcohol consumption, the variety in which you fulfill this responsibility.

We know that in order to maintain the newspaper landscape, we naturally need a certain level of education among the population. The "National Initiative for Print Media," which Culture State Minister Bernd Neumann launched in the spring, has already been praised by him in this context. Projects like "Newspaper in the Classroom" and "Magazines in Schools" by the Presse-Grosso Foundation and the Reading Foundation are very, very important projects. I can only urge you all to continue in this direction. We must strengthen the ability to read as a central contribution to our education policy.

At this point, I want to quote Professor Noelle-Neumann: "Only a society that reads is a society that thinks." I believe that can still be said today, despite the presence of the internet and online offerings. Therefore, the ability to access all information on the internet immediately should be added to the ability to read, which found its dissemination with Gutenberg's printing press. But it should not replace it. We must learn a cultural ability, but not unlearn another for it.

Since I believe that education is the key to the prosperity of our society, it is an essential political interest – whether at the federal or state level – that the ability to understand complex relationships through reading is maintained and strengthened. However, there are significant deficits here. I do not want to hide that. I believe that the ability to understand completely new issues solely through reading has not increased in our society – I say this very cautiously. For example, I sometimes have the impression in my correspondence with my party that the ability to grasp a completely new political issue solely through reading is not infinitely developed. Since we are a people's party, I suspect that this is also the case in other areas. Mr. Westerwelle can say later whether this is also true for the FDP. It may be even better there.

I assure you that we will certainly have many more topics of discussion next year. But I can also assure you that we cannot overestimate the importance of your industry, if I may say so. You represent an industry in structural change. In such times of structural change, it is important that politics does not set overly regulatory frameworks in which the industry has a future. In this sense, we want to continue to engage constructively with you about the future of your sector. It is not only enjoyable to read newspapers, but it is also enjoyable to speak in front of newspaper publishers. Best wishes to your association.