Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day on November 12, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 November 2019 · German Employers' Day · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Employers' Day in Berlin on November 12, 2019, marking the 30th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall and discussing economic and geopolitical challenges.
Main themes
German reunification anniversary, social market economy, competitiveness and economic performance, digitalization, climate change, geopolitical competition and multipolar world order, China's rise, social cohesion, skilled worker shortage, CO2 emissions and climate policy, fall of the Berlin Wall, East German economic development
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,688
90th percentile
Sentences
249
93rd percentile
Readability
56
80th percentile
Grade
9.8
19th percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
5th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%35%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Not in focus 4%

249 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Kramer,

esteemed presidents of the business associations,

Mr. Hoffmann,

Mr. Hundt,

esteemed guests and members of the BDA,

good morning first of all and thank you very much for the invitation. I am the first in a long line of political representatives today and would like to first congratulate Mr. Kramer on his re-election. Congratulations. I look forward to working together because you truly embody what is also written on the wall here: "Building bridges." For that, a heartfelt thank you, because I can imagine: Even for you, so to speak, the pressure – in light of the increasingly escalating language – to hit hard is not insignificant; rather, you are sometimes told: Now really go for it. That you still approach matters in the required factual manner – and we still listen – Mr. Kramer, is your strength and distinguishes you.

When we are here on Sonnenallee, in this not only cozy but obviously very practical building, dear Steffen Kampeter, it reminds us that three days ago we celebrated the 30th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. Personally, I spent my research life as a physicist not far from here, in Adlershof, and I used to travel from Friedrichstraße – so to speak, always along the Wall – to Adlershof. That we are today a reunified country is a great fortune. And that the Social Market Economy has contributed to the fact that German unity has largely succeeded shows what a great brand it is. I would like to express my heartfelt thanks to all who contributed to this.

The economic performance of the new federal states has more than doubled between 1991 and 2018. Unemployment today is only one-third of the value from 2005. In Thuringia, Saxony, and Brandenburg, we have lower unemployment rates than in North Rhine-Westphalia. We have a major issue – even in my constituency in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern – the shortage of skilled workers, but not so much the issue of unemployment anymore. We had times when we were used to over 20 percent. Today, it is already significantly better. Thuringia has the highest industrial density with companies of twenty or more employees. So much has been created. But we all know: There is still much to be done, because shedding a dictatorship and embarking on freedom is something that also disrupts biographies. Therefore, we must continue to engage in conversation with each other in the East and West. And to all who do that, a heartfelt thank you.

During the time when German unity was achieved and European unification progressed, many other things happened in the world as well. The year 1989 not only changed the world for us in Europe. In 1989, China's gross domestic product was 8.8 percent of that of the United States; today it is 66 percent. So you can see how the balance of power in the world has changed and that we have also entered into a competition of systems. We thought in 1989 that this was the final triumph of freedom, which would simply continue to develop. But to be honest, one realizes today that very different political systems, such as the Chinese, the American, and the European, are in competition with each other. And that, of course, means that we are also challenged. This challenge is directed at Germany; it is directed at all of Europe.

You have just pointed out – and I liked that very much – these changes, the multipolar order, and the fact that there are no legal claims to prosperity. This is, by the way, also a lesson from German unity. We, who lived in the former GDR, experienced this firsthand, because it was not the evil Treuhandanstalt, but the economic bankruptcy, which had already been noted by Mr. Schürer from the Politburo, that brought us into these difficult initial phases.

You have pointed out that even in these times of a multipolar order, a new struggle and competition of systems, social cohesion is the prerequisite for solving fundamental questions. Essentially, the entire political debate is driven by the requirements of competitiveness and social cohesion; and also by two major challenges: on the one hand, digitalization, which is completely changing the way we work – you know this from your practice – and on the other hand, the great challenge of climate change for humanity.

Let me take this opportunity, because this is not normally the core competence of the Federal Association of German Employers' Associations (BDA), to say just one word: You say that climate protection measures should not be rushed. That is certainly correct. But on the other hand, hundreds, if not thousands, of scientists tell us: You have only a certain budget of CO2 emissions that you can emit; otherwise, you will have global warming that is significantly above two degrees Celsius. What that will mean in terms of damage and impacts for our economic model is difficult to predict. In any case, we are likely heading into a future where we cannot say: Oh yes, we didn't want to rush it; and it should take a little longer. And that is our problem at this point.

Therefore, the phase-out of coal is the right decision. I would also like to thank you for your calming involvement in this matter – I also extend my thanks to Mr. Hoffmann from the German Trade Union Confederation – as it was not a simple undertaking. But the fact is: We are one percent of the world's population, yet we produce two percent of CO2 emissions. We need to reduce that. And the question arises: How quickly must a highly developed country like Germany actually set an example? I support Ursula von der Leyen when she says: The European continent should be the first to become climate-neutral and to lead the way technologically and innovatively in how to achieve the future way of doing business. And that drives us a bit with regard to the timeline. You must also see that.

We live in a multipolar world. And in this world, it seems to me – I want to say this quite openly – that we are increasingly entering into protectionist tensions instead of cooperating. When we had the great financial and economic crisis of 2008/2009, the G20 emerged at the level of heads of state and government as a forum to say: We must work together as major industrial countries; then we can overcome this crisis. However, this lesson was not sustainable, and at the moment we are actually retreating.

The question is: How do we engage against this? Because we are directly affected. We are experiencing a phase of economic weakness. This may be related to cycles, it may also be related to the challenges we face in Germany – I will come to that – but it is also related to the fact that there are great uncertainties in the world. This concerns the trade relationship between the United States of America and China and also the exit of Great Britain from the European Union, whereby I share your opinion that we have not yet legally structured the agreement on both sides. But I give this agreement a very good chance that it will also find approval on the British side. That would be good for all of us. Why has this now succeeded with Great Britain? It has succeeded because it became clearer what Great Britain wants. On the one hand, this is a painful message: no customs union, a life as a third country, essentially as a competitor on our doorstep. We must also be aware of that; it will put us under pressure again. But on the other hand, there are legally binding transitional provisions and the negotiation of a free trade agreement. That is the task we face. So we must remain strong now.

We have a long phase of growth behind us. The risk of poverty has decreased, primarily because the number of workers has increased. I also want to make it very clear, because there is always the impression that despite the high employment rate, the risk of poverty is as great as it was before: that is not the case. But now it is important to maintain this high level of employment.

Therefore, it is also right that we, as you said, not only achieve the black zero, meaning we manage without new debts, but also overall meet the Maastricht criteria again. This is good news for the future in light of our demographic development. And yes, the zero interest rate policy has also helped us; that must be said. But I think monetary policy will not be infinitely stretchable in its possibilities. The new president of the European Central Bank will soon tell us something about that. However, this puts pressure on the political sphere to also do something again for competitiveness and investments.

The federal government wants to stick to solid budgetary policy. And I think the current phase of the economy speaks more in favor of strengthening growth forces than taking hasty measures now. This is also an agreement between the two of us.

We must continue to nurture the "Made in Germany" brand. Of course, digitalization also comes into play here. I want to say just one thing about this – because this is more of a topic for the Federation of German Industries – we all have to work hard on digital transformation and grapple with it. The federal government is doing a lot here, even if from your perspective it is sometimes too slow. But companies are also challenged. My concern is that the many years of well-filled order books may have obscured the view that a huge technological change is underway, and this shortcoming will become visible when the economy slows down.

Therefore, I ask for support when, for example, the Minister of Economics proposes the establishment of a European data management platform, because we need to maintain a certain sovereignty in Europe. Today, so many companies have simply outsourced their data somewhere – to American corporations. I do not want to categorically view that as bad. I just want to say: The value-added products that are created with the help of artificial intelligence will put us in dependencies, and I am not sure if that is good. Therefore, we must be clear: What strategic capabilities do we want to retain? So when the Minister of Economics comes today, do not tell him that it will all be expensive anyway. It will be expensive, which one realizes when reading that 50 billion dollars are invested in a few corporations in America in one year just to better structure the taxonomy of data and to better develop AI algorithms. One naturally wonders: Where is this investment power supposed to come from to keep up? It certainly cannot come solely from the state. But I believe we still have a chance in Europe if we collaborate with France and others in this regard.

Now, however, back to your bread-and-butter business: We want and will keep social contributions below 40 percent. In connection with the basic pension, which I will address shortly, we have agreed to reduce the unemployment insurance contribution rate by 0.1 percentage points to then 2.4 percent by 2022. This gives us a little more safety margin. It is, of course, clear that demographic change puts social security systems under pressure. Therefore, a high number of employees is existentially important for us. According to current forecasts, for example, we will not exceed the pension insurance contribution rate of 20 percent by the year 2025. That is five years longer than previous forecasts indicated.

Now to the topic of basic pension, because the discussion has somewhat gotten out of hand. But the politics themselves are also to blame for that. The CDU, under the former Minister of Labor Ursula von der Leyen, was the first to advocate for the introduction of a life performance pension, a kind of basic pension. Not everyone in the party was in favor of this, but it was included in our government program. The first legislative period passed. We then took up the topic again under a different name in the second legislative period, that is, in the Grand Coalition from 2013 to 2017. And now we are in the third legislative period; and one cannot really say – even from the CDU's side – that we did not want a basic pension. We have always called it "pension" and at the same time pretended that we could add it to the basic security, which entails a comprehensive means test. When we then considered the entire construct, it became clear: This would mean that if we did it with a means test and, for example, a ten percent surcharge, as stated in the coalition agreement, someone who has collected the same pension entitlements as someone in, for example, Uckermark or in my constituency in Vorpommern would have about 200 to 300 or even 400 euros less in basic pension than someone in Munich, because the latter receives hundreds of euros more due to the different housing benefits. This has proven neither practical nor particularly just in argumentation. I have a constituency where the basic pension would be very low. And in the understanding of the people, it would not even be considered a pension if one had to go to the basic security office and undergo a comprehensive means test there.

Then there was the proposal from Hubertus Heil: We will no longer conduct any tests. That, of course, is completely out of the question; everyone has now realized that. We have a second type of needs assessment in social law. This is applied in widow's pensions or survivor benefits and, for example, in BAföG. Only the incomes are checked in this case. And that is exactly what we will do. This allows for an automatic comparison between the tax office and the pension insurance, so that people are not subjected to a comprehensive examination. But even filling out 16 pages for survivor benefits is an accepted model. We want to do it better, make it less bureaucratic, but it is essentially the same mechanism that we are applying now.

Now I want to say something to you regarding the cohesion of society when it comes to how we treat people who have worked for 35 years. The fact that we have so many workers and such a high employment rate today is also related to the fact that we had a low-wage sector for years. It is also related to the fact that economic growth after 2009 was much higher for years than wage increases. And all of this has, of course, flowed into the pension biographies. There was also a low-wage sector before that; I stand by that. But if the result is that people who have worked for 35 years are in the same position as someone who has not worked a single hour, then you have a justice problem; and we need to provide an answer to that. We have now tried to provide that answer; and it is an important matter for cohesion. So much for that; no one has blackmailed anyone here. This has become a very important issue in the coalition; yes, that is correct. For me, it has also become a question of credibility, as I will not be able to provide an answer to it in a fourth legislative period because I will not run again. But if we were to go before the people in a fourth legislative period and say, "Look, but next time the basic pension will definitely come," we would eventually make ourselves ridiculous.

Now to the small group of things we have done well. This includes that we routinely compensate for cold progression. When we were not doing that, people talked about it. Now no one talks about it anymore. That is also the essence of politics: that we should leave as little as possible for discussion.

Furthermore, we are reducing the solidarity surcharge. You know that I have a bit of a guilty conscience about that; I would have preferred a tax allowance rather than a tax threshold. That is a coalition compromise. We have now slightly expanded the transition zone, so that 96.5 percent of taxpayers are relieved in some way. But many of you sitting here will belong to the 3.5 percent who are not relieved; yes, unfortunately, that is the case. That pains me in a way, which is why I would have preferred the tax allowance. But that is a compromise; and I stand by it as a good Chancellor.

I am pleased about Peter Altmaier, who has proposed a corporate tax reform. Perhaps you could discuss that again today with the Finance Minister. Maybe we could at least consider some elements again, because I do believe that the competitive conditions have changed due to what has happened in America with a corporate tax reform, as well as what has been done in France. This means we definitely have a need for action here. It does not help you if you know that I wish for that as well. It is as Helmut Kohl always said: What matters is what comes out at the end. And in that respect, we have to deliver.

Regarding the reduction of bureaucracy, we have now initiated a third Bureaucracy Relief Act. This will, among other things, enable electronic sick leave certificates. The electronic archiving of tax data will also be facilitated. And we continue to adhere to the "One in, one out" principle, which we have actually exceeded. So if a bureaucratic measure is introduced, bureaucratic effort of the same extent must be eliminated elsewhere. We have exceeded that. However, European regulations are not taken into account. Therefore, it is good news – and we will also work with the Commission President during our Council presidency – that Ursula von der Leyen has announced in her program to apply the same method – "one in, one out" – in the European Union. This will improve our legislation.

In addition, we have amended the Posted Workers Directive. I understand that you are very upset about the bureaucratic effort. We are working on all channels; Hubertus Heil as well. I recently spoke with the French President, for example, about the A1 certificate, which is really anachronistic if one wants to talk about a functioning internal market. We are working on this issue; and I hope to be able to report a success to you in the foreseeable future. It is just that this is always linked to so many side conditions. The construct itself has already been recognized as inappropriate, but they are still trying to regulate a few other things. Regarding the accounting of "Who is responsible for unemployment insurance and social security contributions overall?" one must be careful about how this works between the different member states. And that is why we have not yet reached a point.

The case law of the European Court of Justice, which is leading us back towards time clocks, is also dramatic. Therefore, we will look at what leeway we have – which is not much – or what may need to be changed. And when I look at Mr. Hoffmann, I say: If we ever had the opportunity to implement the European Working Time Directive 1:1, that would be a lucky day for me. But we might first try with these experimental spaces that we have planned, which are very important.

We have introduced tax incentives for research; something that has always been desired. You know, it was always said: It should become a small and medium-sized enterprise instrument. That is why we capped it at a certain level; and now it has become a small and medium-sized enterprise instrument. There is also no double funding. If there is funding from the ministry, there is only the tax incentive for research. But regardless, we wanted to have it. Now I read an article today: Yes, but it is still not clear whether it really affects the medium-sized companies or just the very small ones; and the very small ones do not have a research department and cannot apply for the funding; and then this does not work and that does not work. To that, I simply say: Dear people, we are cautious, but sometimes you are too. I mean, we have to try it now. Then we will look after three or four years at how it works, whether all the bad things that are now feared occur. Then we will revise it if necessary. We must get used to not believing that laws are always made for eternity, but especially in times of such great transformations like these, just looking after three or four years: Does it prove itself, does it not? And then we may do it anew if necessary. I believe that is the best approach.

We have a surge in investments. By the way, in connection with the climate protection package that we have passed, we will also receive significantly more investments for the coming years. But you are absolutely right: The bureaucracy and planning procedures are hindering us. We have already initiated three planning acceleration laws at the federal level, two of which were only passed last week in the cabinet. We proceed as follows: For large projects, we develop an individual law for each of them – for example, we want to expand shipping on the Weser – and with this individual law, we try to define the measures in such a way that it leads to an acceleration of the processes. That is one point. Another point is: The planning of transport projects, for example, is carried out in the states. This means we need more best-practice comparisons between the federal states. We know, for example, that the approval for the construction of a wind power plant takes twice as long in some federal states as in others. The states should look at each other to see where their state planning laws differ and which work better and which worse.

Regarding the complex of court proceedings, one could – we can do this at the federal level – remove one level, so that everything goes directly to the Federal Administrative Court. The Federal Administrative Court says, of course: If we then have as many proceedings as the lower administrative courts, then the waiting times will be correspondingly longer. So we must limit this to important projects. But we still have leeway – and we are now working on that – to make court proceedings faster. For example, we have concluded the "Pact for the Rule of Law" to support the digitization of the courts, so that some things can go faster.

This brings me to the point: How much of the transformation of a society – digitization, climate protection, completely new mobility concepts, digitization of schools – is actually a federal task and how much of it is the responsibility of the states and municipalities? It is often said in public discussion: Well, this does not work and that does not work; that is somehow a federal task. However, our Basic Law is structured quite differently. The federal government is actually only responsible for things that are enumerated in the Basic Law. For all other matters, the states and municipalities are responsible. That is the federal order. We are constantly changing the Basic Law because we are taking on new responsibilities: for social housing, for equipping schools with computers, for the municipal transport financing law, and so on – because it is always said: the federal government must do something when the world changes. However, the federal government cannot do everything, especially since our VAT revenues will, for the first time – I do not know if it is now or in two years – be lower than those of the states and municipalities. Therefore, we have other structural problems – which also have to do with pension burdens and many other things – that will occupy us in the coming years.

I do not want to shirk responsibility; I just want to say: There must also be joint projects. That is why we have, for example, entered into a strategic auto dialogue with the states. But that the federal government should per se build every charging station in Germany and that neither the economy – which I believe used to somehow cover the gas stations – nor the municipalities and states should have anything to do with it, that cannot be the case. I must say this here, to defend myself.

I believe you are somewhat satisfied with the Qualification Opportunities Act, which offers new possibilities for further education. And we also need to talk about how we deal with areas affected by structural change. We recently discussed this in the strategic auto dialogue and asked ourselves: What short-time work options do we still have? We need to talk about that. I have the impression that some sectors are already very affected by structural change and weak economic conditions.

We agree that the Skilled Immigration Act is a good thing. But it has to work now, of course. That is why we are holding a Skilled Immigration Summit in December, involving employers, trade unions, and various ministries. The message is: We will have good cooperation between the Chambers of Commerce abroad and the Federal Foreign Office regarding visa issuance. The Federal Foreign Office will establish a subordinate agency, which is a complete innovation for the Federal Foreign Office – there has never been a subordinate agency within the Federal Foreign Office before – that will deal with visa procedures. The professional qualifications must be determined by the Chambers of Industry and Commerce or the German Chambers of Commerce Abroad, while the visa issuances will come from us. And then I believe we can come together relatively quickly if we also select some focus countries for a few key professions.

My last point, which concerns us all, is the question: How can employer associations work well with trade unions and how can collective bargaining coverage be maintained? I mean, the trend is not looking good; we must see that: In the East, collective bargaining coverage is clearly below 50 percent, in the West it is just above 50 percent, but constantly declining. And one must naturally ask: How will such a country cope in ten years, when there will be many more start-ups and digital companies as part of a major digital transformation, which do not even think about a works council at their founding? Where do we want to go? I can only encourage you: Have the discussion with each other, because otherwise we will eventually find ourselves back in a situation like that before the introduction of the minimum wage, where state interventionist measures, as you would call them, or necessary actions by the state for social cohesion, as Mr. Hoffmann would call it, come into play. In any case – round and round – it remains a law.

And I believe: the great stability of the Federal Republic of Germany, which I joined as an active member 30 years ago, is based on the fact that politics does not determine everything. It has its tasks to fulfill. We take criticism in politics seriously. But this stability arises from the fact that there are also people outside of politics who take on responsibility.

We have seen in the great Euro crisis how different the understanding of trade unions is in Europe and how different the understanding of businesses is among entrepreneurs. Where trade unions and companies seek solutions together – as hard as it may be – cohesion is inherently better regulated. Therefore, I wish you success in your discussions, because where you come to us with a joint proposal, the law can be quickly drafted in the Grand Coalition.

Thank you very much.