Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Employers' Day on November 15, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 November 2016 · German Employers' Day · Berlin

Context
Merkel addressed German employers at the BDA Employers' Day in Berlin on November 15, 2016, marking 98 years of social partnership in Germany.
Main themes
Collective bargaining autonomy, social partnership, German economic prosperity, digitalization and labor market, employer-union relations, Stinnes-Legien Agreement, social market economy, investment policy, federal budget and fiscal policy, Equal Pay Act, infrastructure investment, European Union investment debate
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,109
87th percentile
Sentences
199
89th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
2.96
42nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 30%29%
  • Social 30%29%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

199 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President Kramer,

dear presidents of the business associations,

dear colleagues party chairpersons,

ladies and gentlemen,

good morning. I am pleased to be here with you today at the Employers' Day.

Mr. Kramer, you are hosting this Employers' Day on November 15. This is exactly the day, 98 years ago, on November 15, 1918, when the so-called Stinnes-Legien Agreement laid the first foundation for social partnership in Germany. The horrors of the First World War were still deeply ingrained in the people at that time. The post-war period was characterized by conflicting efforts from various political forces. In this turbulent phase of state self-discovery, entrepreneurs became aware of their special responsibility for social peace by accepting trade unions as collective bargaining partners.

The Stinnes-Legien Agreement is named after the chairman of the General German Trade Union Confederation, Carl Legien, and the industrialist Hugo Stinnes. The latter acknowledged the significance of the agreement with the following words: "The trade unions rightly say that what is now being imposed by a government [...], does not have the same significance as a free agreement between the trade unions and industry. The latter will remain, the former is something that can be revoked." History would prove Hugo Stinnes right, even though the agreement lasted only a few years. Because the idea of a collective bargaining partnership that regulates its concerns independently of politics ultimately prevailed. In 1949, collective bargaining autonomy was enshrined in our Basic Law. It has been a lived reality for decades.

This year's Employers' Day of the BDA demonstrates this once again, although I would like to say – we have often talked about this, Mr. Kramer – that we all must work together to keep collective bargaining autonomy strong, especially in light of the disruptive changes we are experiencing due to digitalization in the economy. In some areas, we have indeed succeeded in passing legal regulations that place companies that practice collective bargaining autonomy in a different position than those that do not, thereby placing more responsibility at the level of the collective bargaining partners. I personally believe this is right, as it can be done much more precisely and accurately tailored to a company and its specific concerns.

Collective bargaining partners naturally know their industries best. Therefore, we in politics are actually happy when they resolve the problems they have and need to solve themselves. I believe a large part of social peace in Germany is based on the fact that we have collective bargaining autonomy and both sides take responsibility. In many discussions with our European partners, we see how difficult it is to find openness from trade unions regarding the concerns of the economy when trade unions are not themselves involved in the responsibility for employment.

One example is the Equal Pay Act. It has been shown that your president – I must emphasize this – was able to shine in the discussion about it by demonstrating a good understanding of the Works Constitution Act, which, I must admit, was not entirely the case for the political representatives present at that moment. His knowledge then led to a truly amicable solution.

We are currently living in a phase of economic prosperity. I think that can be said for Germany. We have solid growth rates. In recent years, we have shown that the social market economy is adaptable. We have also increased our investment quota on the part of the state. It is above the European average. Our public budgets, especially the federal budget, are balanced. The labor market balance is impressive. This is, of course, also thanks to you. With over 43 million employed persons, unemployment is at its lowest level in a quarter of a century.

All of this is good news. I know that we must not rest on it. Therefore, we have also tried to bring predictability into the federal-state financial relations. We have completed the negotiations. This ensures security for the next decade. We are trying to strengthen investment capacity and accelerate investment activity with the establishment of an infrastructure company for transport. At the federal level, we have also taken responsibility to relieve municipalities to enable even financially weak municipalities to invest.

Consider, for example, the federal government's decision on tax loss offsetting. This has also improved the environment for private investments. In addition, tax cuts of more than six billion euros over the next two years will provide more room for private sector investments. When we talk about investments in the European Union, there is often the understanding that they must be state investments. I want to emphasize that the state's task also includes – and this is at least equally important – making private investments possible and not always relying solely on state funds – and sometimes even on borrowed money.

I recently discussed this with Mr. Weise: In the past five years, we have created 2.7 million additional jobs in Germany. Interestingly, these jobs are roughly divided into one-third due to a stronger labor participation of women and older individuals, as well as people from other countries in the European internal market who have found work in Germany. Nevertheless, we have the issue of skilled labor demand and skilled labor shortages. The figure of six million fewer working persons by 2030, which you, Mr. Kramer, mentioned again today, must prompt us to think early about how we can close this gap. It may very well be that in five or ten years, the question of tax relief will weigh less than the question of where to find skilled workers.

Therefore, I believe we need regulations that, on the one hand, improve the mobility of employees in Europe. Here, I see particularly the need for language education, and this applies to all professional groups. In European countries, one should at least be proficient in one foreign language.

We may also need immigration regulations in a more compact form than we currently have – although the OECD concedes that our regulations, while not well known abroad, are indeed relatively good – to better facilitate targeted immigration into jobs – I want to emphasize: into jobs. Because we must also see that the European posting laws and the social security regulations in Germany stipulate that for anyone who, for example, becomes unemployed after two or three years, the state is responsible – including all family members and children who may also not find work.

This means that we must proceed very carefully to avoid increasing our social burdens. You are also involved in this and say: Please, no total social contribution rates above 40 percent. This rule is important to you. I also consider it important. However, we still need to discuss the question: Parity or not parity? You add all social insurance contribution rates and say: Then we will soon exceed the 40 percent threshold. We take responsibility for this – I say this now as a representative of the CDU – that we have placed part of the health contributions solely on employees. This is then, when there are additional costs, still the most solidaristic form – of course one that can potentially be seen as a negotiation momentum regarding how these are divided between employers and employees. I can understand that. On the other hand: If we are to politically endure all of this through personal cost participation – without naming a percentage – thus without considering the social component, it will not be easier.

We all know: A modern health system in the 21st century is hardly manageable without any cost increases. There are savings potentials, but there are also significant dynamic elements due to an aging population that we cannot ignore. Social peace also includes reasonable health care that is accessible to every person in Germany. I believe you in the employers' sector know this just as well as we do in politics.

We have talked a lot about the future of the pension system. In this regard, it is very important, as far as the statutory pension insurance is concerned, to keep a double safety line in mind; that is, both the safety line of contributions and the safety line of the pension level, which is of course relevant for pension recipients. I believe we have set the framework correctly until 2030. We will also have to think about the time after 2030. A very good labor market situation, such as we currently have, can best mitigate the decline in the pension level. We already know today that the pension level in 2030 will not drop to 43 percent, but according to current calculations will remain at least at 44.3 percent. With a continued good development in the labor market, we can expect further changes to our previous forecasts.

Therefore, the key is, on the one hand, to respond to demographic change by gradually implementing the retirement age of 67 as we have agreed, and on the other hand, to do everything possible to maintain the economic situation so that people have employment. Nothing is more social than that social insurance contributions can be paid by as many employees as possible through socially insured employment.

I was very pleased, Mr. Kramer, in our conversation about the pensions of the future, to learn that the BDA also considers the issue of disability pensions particularly important. The majority of those affected by old-age poverty come from the group of people who become disabled relatively early. Therefore, after the first step to improve disability pensions that we have already taken in this legislative period, we will also discuss within the coalition whether we should take a second step. I believe this is the most efficient means to prevent old-age poverty.

After long discussions, we have achieved something that I also consider psychologically very, very important, namely the Flexi-Pension. It opens up new opportunities regarding whether one wants to reduce their work before reaching retirement age, and it improves the conditions for continuing to work after reaching the statutory retirement age. Thus, the employer contributions to unemployment insurance are initially waived for five years. This is also an incentive for companies to enable those who want to work longer to do so. Contributions will continue to be paid into the pension insurance. This means that the respective pension entitlement will also increase. This is also an incentive for longer working.

I consider this, so to speak, a harbinger of many regulations that we will need in the age of digitalization. We need to try things out. We may need to time-limit some of them. We must then evaluate them repeatedly because we do not yet know how they will work. But doing nothing because we do not know how something will work in the future would be the wrong answer to a time of great change. Therefore, I also consider this to be correct from a systemic approach. This can also advance us in the discussion about the White Paper of the Federal Minister of Labor.

The pension insurance is based on three pillars. I want to explicitly emphasize what Mr. Kramer said: All three pillars must retain their significance – the statutory pension insurance as well as private and occupational provision. After long consultations with the social partners, we have presented a draft for a so-called Occupational Pension Strengthening Act. There are still some questions to discuss; I have understood that. But if we could find a way for smaller companies to make greater use of occupational pensions, that would, in my view, be a good broadening of our foundations for the pension insurance of the future.

I would like to express my gratitude regarding what we particularly discussed last year at this employer day, namely the large number of refugees arriving in our country – to you, the BDA, and the members who have engaged in an incredible way; both in terms of the so-called rational consideration of the situation and in terms of taking action. I would also like to thank you for the discussions we had repeatedly last year. We have managed to organize and control the processes much better. Since Mr. Weise is present here and is responsible not only for the Federal Employment Agency but also for the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees, I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to him. If new challenges, which we will continue to experience in our country, are tackled by everyone with exactly this verve and solutions are provided, then we need not worry about our country.

With regard to digitalization and the necessary embedding in the public sector, I currently always state that refugees in Germany are actually privileged because we have a core data system that creates connections from a federal authority to the local immigration office in the municipality, which we do not yet have for citizens of the Federal Republic of Germany in the form of a citizen portal. In this respect, this is an incentive, regardless of the federal level – whether it concerns the municipal, state, or federal level – to ensure that citizens can present their concerns and are then automatically directed to the right place. This is something that must be prioritized in the coming years. However, we must not do this at the pace at which we are trying to introduce the health card; that has already taken a long time. I also do not know if employers have always been on the right side in this regard, as transparency in the health system does not seem to be as well-loved everywhere as I would imagine.

I wanted to thank, not to scold, and therefore I say: Let us now continue to tackle the major topic of integration in general as well as integration into the labor market together. We know that successful integration requires time and patience. We know that it requires a multitude of additional efforts. We have tried to respond politically in the right way and to create certain securities. We have ensured more legal certainty during training and employment for two years after successful training. We have launched a program to create job opportunities for asylum seekers so that they can gain insights into professional life even during ongoing asylum procedures. We have also waived the priority check in most employment agency districts in Germany.

I have the impression that, when all of this was not yet the case, many had already made the first attempts to integrate refugees into their companies but failed and thus threw in the towel. You can certainly try again. Because the conditions have really changed. Temporary work for refugees is also possible. Therefore, give people another chance.

We live, as one says today, in a time of disruptive changes. Therefore, the topic of education is of central importance. Mr. Kramer, it was evident how passionately you are attached to the "Chancen-Euro." I think that is a great initiative that complements much of what we are doing.

You have relatively clearly advocated for lifting the cooperation ban. I want to say: We already have an exception to the cooperation ban in Article 91c of the Basic Law when it comes to questions of cooperation in the digital sector. This may open up opportunities for us as a federal government to become more involved in investments in vocational schools. But we must insist on one thing: We as a federal government must also have competencies if we are to provide funding. Usually, the cooperation ban is essentially about financial flows for which there are no substantive responsibilities on the part of the states; and that, in my firm opinion, is not acceptable.

At this year's IT Summit, the topic of education will be the central theme. The IT Summit will take place the day after tomorrow in Saarbrücken. I would like to encourage you to do two things relatively soon.

First, it is about adapting existing occupational profiles to the requirements of Industry 4.0. I mention, for example, even though I am not a subject expert, the adaptation of mechatronics training, which must occur continuously and also proactively.

Second, it is about developing interesting occupational profiles in the IT sector that do not rely on a university degree. These occupational profiles are, in my view, still not well enough known. The trend towards further academicization is actually progressing very strongly, especially in the digital sector. However, to strengthen our pillar of vocational training, we need new efforts here as well. We will also discuss this intensively with the economy the day after tomorrow in Saarbrücken.

The keyword digitalization brings me to the fact that we are currently in a situation where both within the European Union and our country as well as worldwide, the question is being debated: How do we want to shape globalization? Globalization is taking place; and we can shape it by strengthening multilateral instruments. I believe we have succeeded to some extent with financial market regulations; that must be further developed, but much has happened in recent years. The alternative is that we become protectionist, isolate ourselves, and everyone tries to keep as much of their own national interests as possible. I am glad that you, just like me, believe: We must shape globalization multilaterally. Despite all wars, despite all conflicts, it is indeed the case that poverty and hunger have decreased in recent years and not increased; and this is happening against a backdrop of high global population growth, which will also continue.

This debate about openness or isolation will occupy us significantly in the coming years. It will be the subject of political discussions – we see this, for example, in connection with free trade agreements – and it will also be the subject of discussions between business associations and employees as well as in civil societies overall. Next year, we will be the host country for the G20 summit. I would like to carefully place these questions on the agenda. This includes the topic of fair supply chains for products manufactured in various countries, as well as the question of multilateral agreements, for example, in the area of trade.

We are currently experiencing a kind of paradox: We have spent years dealing with the conclusion of trade agreements that were essentially aimed at reducing tariffs. There has also been a long-standing, actually decades-long discussion – when I was still Minister for the Environment, I also participated in it – that tariff reductions do not enable fair trade in the world. That is also completely clear. Those who produce at the expense of the environment and without adhering to social minimum standards have better competitive chances than those who comply with social and ecological standards. This criticism has been increasingly taken up. It has been considered to a much greater extent in agreements like CETA or in the ongoing negotiations on TTIP than before. And just at the moment when this happened, those who feel responsible for social and environmental standards said: It cannot be true that now the traders are dealing with something we understand more about. This then turned into a greater rejection of CETA and TTIP than of agreements we have concluded with Singapore and South Korea, or hopefully will conclude with Japan or Australia someday. This rejection, in my view, is the reversal of what we need to shape globalization.

Now, one can discuss in detail whether we need other negotiators or whether we need to broaden the negotiating basis. We can also discuss whether we need more transparency, although it is quite atypical that negotiations are particularly successful when everything is laid on the table at all times. The bargaining partners – the trade unions, for example – would scold us if we said: Please inform us daily and publicly about the status of your collective bargaining negotiations at IG Metall or IG BCE; then we will publicly comment on what we think about it, and then you can continue negotiating tomorrow. This way, negotiations would probably never come to an end.

If we want to safeguard our interests – our European interests – in negotiations on trade agreements, it means: If not everything is known at all times, then it is a backroom deal; and we cannot accept that. However, from my perspective – I am preaching a bit in the wrong church here – we cannot proceed socially in this way. Therefore, I seriously consider whether we as Europeans – looking at the North American market, at Canada and the United States of America – do not have a fundamental interest in setting the standards for the future shaping of globalization with the North American continent – that is, in my firm conviction, our opportunity – and not leave it to China and other Asian countries when they conclude their free trade agreements.

Of course, when it comes to shaping globalization, it is first about our self-understanding in the European Union. There, we must say, the vote of the British for leaving the European Union represents a deep cut; there is no question about that. We are now faced with the question: What are the 27 doing to regain trust in the European Union and also to maintain good relations with Great Britain in the future? Because the German economy is very much dependent on the British economy; and vice versa. But can we compromise at any cost?

I want to point out again – and I am also grateful that the BDA sees it the same way –: The European Union only unfolds its advantages on the basis of certain principles; and these principles include the four fundamental freedoms, namely the freedom of movement of persons, services, goods, and financial market products. Suppose we make an exception for Great Britain regarding the free movement of persons; then this would mean that we would endanger the principles of the entire internal market of the European Union because all others would then also want exceptions.

Therefore, I personally believe: We will have to prepare for a discussion with the Commission about free movement. Because if, for example, someone comes from an Eastern European country to Germany under the free movement, is only temporarily employed, but thereby acquires a lifelong entitlement to permanent social benefits here, then I see that as a question we need to discuss again. Because free movement, for me, means that the worker can earn the money he needs for himself and the support of his family in another member state. In this respect, we certainly need to talk about the question of when lifelong securities according to the social standards of the host country apply.

However, we must not shake the fundamental question of free movement, in my firm belief. But it is again a paradox that the British have scolded us for years for taking transitional periods with regard to Poland and other Eastern European countries, and today they are the ones complaining that they did not take these transitional periods and want to restrict free movement throughout Europe. That is not acceptable. However, before we can conduct fair negotiations, Great Britain must first clarify how it wishes to exit, which, according to statements from the British Prime Minister, is to occur by March next year.

The good situation today says nothing about our situation in five or ten years. Digitalization represents such a profound change in the way of production, social cohesion, information, and communication that we do not yet fully grasp the implications. We do not want to reverse technical developments in any way; there is no reason for that. However, we must develop rules for them and introduce them in such a way that they can unfold for the benefit of people.

This means, however, that we in Germany – this is now more of a speech for the BDI, Mr. Grillo – need to achieve a change in attitude towards the issue of data. Data minimization, as the Constitutional Court has imposed on us in certain rulings, is not the motto of the hour. Rather, data diversity presents itself as a value creation opportunity for the future. It will be extremely necessary to continue to grapple, argue, discuss, and ultimately find solutions together on this issue, so that we will still have a strong share of industrial value creation in our gross domestic product and continue to have so many jobs in ten years. There are still many paths to be taken for this.

In this sense: To good cooperation, dear Mr. Kramer, dear Steffen Kampeter, and dear representatives and allies of the BDA.