Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Tenants' Day on June 14, 2019, in Cologne:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 June 2019 · German Tenants' Day · Cologne, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed participants at the German Tenants' Day on June 14, 2019, in Cologne, outlining federal measures to tackle the affordable housing crisis.
Main themes
Affordable housing, social housing construction, housing benefits, federal and state cooperation, urban development funding, Bauhaus and urban planning history, Baukindergeld, housing summit, federalism reform, climate protection in housing, tenant concerns, quality of life
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,624
83rd percentile
Sentences
193
88th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 31%30%
  • Social 29%28%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

193 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Rips,

dear Minister Scharrenbach,

dear State Secretary Billen,

dear Mayor Reker,

dear colleagues from the Bundestag and the Landtag,

and especially you, the participants of the German Tenants' Day,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here, even though I knew that this would not be a day of complete harmony. This is about a central concern of people who want to live well in our country; and that is the issue of housing.

Regarding the question of the gender of a Federal Chancellor, I may say that – since I was just allowed to sign the book of the city of Cologne – at least once there was a mayor here who later became a male Federal Chancellor. That has happened before. What the future holds, we do not know. We will have to wait and see.

The issue of housing has occupied people, architects, and urban planners for many years. The large metropolitan areas in our country have emerged, partly due to industrialization. Quality housing has a long history. We think, especially in connection with the Bauhaus and the many garden cities, of a hundred years of wise and forward-looking urban planning. One aspect is the apartments where people live. The other is the living environment, the surroundings of a city. Many great things – from the prototype of the fitted kitchen to the design of gardens and the environment in the city – are legendary and belong to a good piece of German history. The issue of transport connections and many other aspects play a significant role in the quality of life in housing. But I want to start with the social issues that concern you and that also involve us in a permanent discussion, which does not always proceed harmoniously, but in which quite a bit has happened.

The current federal government, which you have just criticized, but for which I still want to speak a good word, has placed the issue of affordable housing at the top of the agenda. In September 2018, we held a joint housing summit. This took place in the spirit that we can only solve the housing problem in Germany if municipalities, states, and the federal government work together.

There is nothing good unless you do it – in the end, housing must be built on site. I was very impressed when Ms. Reker just told me that through a concentration on the task, it was possible, for example, in the city of Cologne, to complete over 80 percent more housing in 2018 than in 2017. That is a ray of hope. We must continue this work. At this point, we want to help and initiate our measures. I want to mention a few points. In this legislative period, we will make over 13 billion euros available for social housing construction, the Baukindergeld, housing benefits, and urban development funding.

Let me start with social housing construction. I listened very attentively when Ms. Scharrenbach said that they also want to open this up for modernization. I immediately asked whether that is legally feasible. If so, then that is very good, because social housing construction cannot simply be subjected to stagnation. We have significant climate protection challenges and much more. Therefore, social housing construction must also be able to keep pace.

The federal and state governments decided in 2006 in a joint action of the federalism reform that social housing construction would only be carried out by the states from that day on. There were so-called compensation funds for this, which will expire in 2019. Given the size of the task we see, and in light of developments – you have very well linked this in your application with the European developments of freedom of movement – we said: Although we had decided that federal support would expire in 2019, we will reopen the Basic Law and allow further compensation payments. Thus, we will make another five billion euros available for social housing construction in this legislative period. That is a correct step.

But we have very attentive budget politicians in the German Bundestag. They have looked at all the states to see whether the compensation funds that have been provided by the federal government for social housing construction in recent years have actually reached social housing construction. That was not the case in all instances. I do not want to single anyone out here. I just want to say: The social housing problem is so large that every euro dedicated to it must be spent in this area. I think we agree on that.

Then we have done something that also helps many people out of Hartz IV, namely out of the situation of having to apply for subsidies. We have increased housing benefits by 30 percent. I think that is a groundbreaking change and a really important step. I believe Mr. Rips cannot say that too positively. But I think 30 percent more is already good. This means that instead of 440,000 people, in the future, 660,000 will benefit from it. But the much more important adjustment is that we have linked this to the cost of living. This means that we will not have to ask every year, "Is it time for adjustment again?" or have long periods during which housing benefits do not develop in line with general costs, but we have now legally anchored the so-called indexing and thus created a bit more predictability in this area. I consider that to be very, very important.

We have introduced the Baukindergeld. I do not know how high that is in your course. But there are already 100,000 applications. The funds have already been largely exhausted.

We have initiated many measures that relate to the question: How can we build more apartments? You represent here – which is good and important; also in the spirit of partnership and the social market economy – the interests of tenants. We as the federal government must, of course, also ensure that enough housing is built. This cannot only happen through state funding, although we certainly need to do more than we have in the past. This also includes, for example, building housing for our employees in the federal sector. The states are also doing this to some extent.

We must also create an environment in which building is welcomed. However, it requires guidelines so that the wrong things are not built continuously, but that needs-based construction takes place. For this, we naturally need interested private investors who must also feel committed to the common good. Whether they have always done so is a matter of differing assessments. I am not pleased with every development either. But I believe it must continue to be interesting and attractive for a group of people who feel committed to this country to invest in housing. That is why we have initiated some measures that bring improvements and then lead to more apartments. Because the best answer to housing shortages is to create new housing. I am deeply convinced of that.

One initiative is to pass a special depreciation that – capped in price – brings a tax incentive for the creation of housing. This is currently in the Bundesrat and is unfortunately constantly – I must say – being mixed with regulatory measures by the Greens in the Bundesrat, so we are not making any progress at all. I would be very pleased if we could overcome this blockade in the Bundesrat. We have made various compromise offers. We want this not to become like the promotion of energy-efficient building renovation, about which I want to say again: I have never experienced a situation in my entire life where the trades, the German economy, and all environmental associations have urgently requested that the old building stock can be more easily renovated energetically to also do something for climate protection. It has never passed through the Bundesrat. We will now make a new attempt from the federal government and hope that we may still achieve a result regarding the promotion of energy-efficient building renovation. We must do something in the existing building stock because we really have great opportunities for more climate protection in this area, but also a significant backlog.

We have the land commission mentioned by Mr. Rips. I would say that the issue of land is indeed very pressing. Because let us be honest: In the large metropolitan areas, the joy of those who live in a not yet too densely populated district about new housing being built is often limited. This means that there must also be a public discussion led by the mayors about this – which is indeed being held – that creating new housing also involves finding sensible urban design so that people can feel comfortable. Not everyone has, as Ms. Reker just told me, the opportunity to build entirely new districts because the city boundaries are very limited. Therefore, we are thinking about how to find expansion opportunities for cities that have already grown to their limits. That is why we are considering what other possibilities exist. The results are to be published in the summer. I hope that some truly practical solutions will emerge.

We are, of course, faced with the question, which is also of great importance to you: How can we combat rent gouging? How can we tackle sometimes explosive rent increases? We introduced the rent brake. We reformed it right at the beginning of this legislative period. We now have an evaluation, an assessment of the results, and will consider what else can be done in light of this assessment. Your demands are more far-reaching than those I personally represent. But I believe we must work with such instruments of regulatory law, otherwise, we will find it very difficult to manage the situation.

This includes the obligation to provide information. This also includes the creation of rent indexes – and not just any rent indexes, but qualified rent indexes. Personally, I am not restrictive in this regard because I believe: Transparency must be tolerated. However, we must be careful not to become completely bureaucratic. I do not know whether a nationwide real estate register will help us. But having a qualified rent index on site, ensuring that rent increases are transparent, and having information obligations – I consider all of this to be reasonable and correct to ensure that things do not accelerate on their own. We are still in a very contentious discussion here. And if you have just given my coalition partner, the Social Democrats, a bit of a hard time, I must tell you: The Social Democrats are fighting for many of your concerns; I want to reiterate that for the sake of good order. Personally, I would not simply forgo this support if I were in your position.

Our topic is therefore: We want to achieve that we build 350,000 new apartments in Germany every year. This is also necessary, especially in the situation where we have a shortage of skilled workers. You rightly point out in your guiding application that any form of skilled worker immigration, whether within the framework of European freedom of movement or through a skilled worker immigration law, must also be reflected in urban development, in the question of having enough schools and housing. That simply belongs together.

One last word on the modernization levy: Here too, we have done something – of course not enough in the sense of Mr. Rips, but I still want to point it out. I consider it a good step that we have reduced the modernization levy from eleven to eight percent. Here again, there is a conflict that you also see; I know that: "What will still be modernized, what is attractive?" Is it still attractive at four percent, as you say? We have doubts about that. Therefore, we have taken the step to eight percent and will, of course, look at what effect this has.

Now to the property tax: We will, next week, I would say, very likely present a draft law that will also bring difficult parliamentary discussions, including in the Bundesrat. It is correct: The politicians have suspected that when the matter comes before the Constitutional Court, the Constitutional Court will probably not be completely satisfied with it. On the other hand, you also know that it is a very, very large wheel to change the property tax, which has grown historically and which, by the way, has been levied differently in the new federal states than in the old federal states.

We must see – and here the difficulty of a nationwide rental policy becomes apparent – that on the one hand we have highly valued urban areas and also other very highly rated residential neighborhoods, and on the other hand cities that have vacancies, where people who have invested just as much in their properties – I am thinking of single-family homes – today only receive a fraction, for example, as retirement security. This is a huge issue. For example, if one person built a house in Höxter and another built a house in Freiburg, if these houses were once, years ago, worth about the same, today the values are far apart. One can secure a good retirement through the sale, while the other has great difficulties just getting by. This means we also have the task, especially in densely populated regions like the Ruhr area, to achieve a good distribution through transport connections, through public transport, so that the interest in housing extends over larger areas.

This is something we have also considered and for which we have found an answer. Because we have not only reopened our Basic Law for social housing construction, but we have also opened it for the Municipal Transport Financing Act, because we need to do more on the federal level for public transport. Because we already suspected that the representatives of the states would soon come back and say that it is not enough, we specifically enshrined these matters in the Basic Law. The former Finance Minister, Mr. Schäuble, said: No one will touch the Basic Law quickly. But lo and behold, as soon as the funds seemed insufficient, it was said, "We will also participate in this financing," and the Basic Law was amended again. I believe that was ultimately the right thing to do.

The federal government faces the following task: On the one hand, we have the necessity to support municipalities and states. I have mentioned a variety of things where we are not only doing something in terms of regulatory law but also providing financial support. On the other hand, we also have growing international responsibilities – just look at today’s headlines regarding the international situation – concerning security, development aid, combating the causes of flight, and many other issues. Our tax revenue is always distributed equally – with a tendency to give more shares to the states and municipalities. We have newly created the federal-state financial equalization and done many other things.

However, we have a systemic problem – and I ask you to keep this in mind –: This is the problem that everything we newly regulate between the federal government and the states – except for housing costs – always goes according to the share of value-added tax. This simply means that those who are relatively well-off always receive more, while those who are relatively worse off tend to receive less. I can mention Gelsenkirchen and Düsseldorf, for example. This means that with every redistribution from the federal government to the states, the difference between financially stronger and financially weaker municipalities increases at the local level. We need to solve this problem – that is also why we established the "Commission for Equivalent Living Conditions." We have now almost exhausted our account for housing costs. We would then have to move to administrative management.

No problem, says Ms. Scharrenbach; she does not even have to negotiate directly with the municipalities about which apartments to rent out, since the federal government pays for everything anyway. But this is actually our only lever to really achieve an equalization of living conditions and financial strength. I believe we need to think about this again, especially since I must honestly say: As a federal politician – and I am a physicist and understand a bit about formulas, mathematics, and so on – understanding how the financial equalization takes place between the 16 federal states and the municipalities and districts is a science in itself, as we have completely different systems. It is almost impossible to find out exactly where a euro that we as the federal government have given for a good purpose has arrived at the municipality after we have distributed the value-added tax. This is a book with seven seals. But perhaps I will deal with this specifically when I am no longer in office, because I would really like to understand it.

We have a variety of options to build faster and also more environmentally friendly. We have the "Research Initiative Future Construction," which is also supported by the federal government. This year, I believe we are investing 790 million euros in urban development funding. The social city is more than the sum of all housing offers; much more is involved. I believe we also need to move towards more standardized construction, as we are not very quick in terms of planning law; Germany is known for that. Not everything takes as long as the construction of Berlin's airport, but many things are still progressing too slowly. Therefore, we also need to ensure planning acceleration. We may not need to approve every type of apartment separately, but can also benefit from the learning experiences of others in some areas.

In conclusion, I want to say that we have great challenges in two directions, for which urban development funding and various measures are important. The first major challenge is our demographic development. We need to adapt housing for the elderly – and I add: also for people with disabilities. Here we still have a huge task ahead of us.

Secondly, we will need a new form of mobility in the future – also as a response to the climate crisis. The nature of mobility will completely change in urban centers.

There is a federal-state working group that will present proposals for the reform of property and rental law. This also involves questions of accessibility, energy-efficient renovation, and the installation of charging stations for electric vehicles. This is also extremely difficult. If you have a property with 16 or 20 units, then the last one must also agree before the first can install a charging infrastructure. If we do not make faster progress here, we will not be able to address not only the expansion of the housing stock but also the necessary redesign of the infrastructure in the right time. And that would be very fatal.

Therefore, we must – and I am really committed to this – give cities and municipalities the opportunity to find solutions tailored to them for traffic management and thus for compliance with environmental standards – regarding nitrogen oxides, fine dust, and similar issues. This means that good municipal financial support is, of course, also in the interest of the federal government. But it is not the case that one solution solves all the problems of this country; rather, each municipality has its own special situation. I have dealt very intensively with various German municipalities in connection with exceeding limit values and can say that some are very innovative, while others are still lagging behind a bit. One must say: Such questions are essentially a matter for the leadership; the environmental officer cannot handle this alone. We have created a whole range of incentives for the renewal of public transport – for example, with buses or smaller vehicles that are electric, hydrogen, or gas-powered. But of course, everything must happen hand in hand in the entire transport sector locally.

So we are essentially in a phase where Germany needs to be fundamentally renewed once again. This includes more housing. In this respect, Gerhard Stoltenberg was not entirely correct when he said that Germany was built and nothing more needed to happen; some things are there, but not everything. I believe we can also make it clear in discussions with citizens that it can be enjoyable to renew Germany. However, this requires that we think of everyone; I agree with you on that. And tenants are an important group in this.

So let me say thank you. I have, of course, thought about whether I should come to you – of course, I have to consider whether I say yes or no. I was indeed pleased about the invitation, but I knew that I would also hear criticism. It is very important that we stay in conversation during these times, especially since many people hardly seek a conversation anymore. Everyone who is here is, so to speak, sent by others to participate in this German Tenants' Day. All of these are people who work in this area, who try to help others and represent their interests. I know that if one were to talk to each of you individually, everyone could tell a multitude of quite serious things that are not going as the fathers and mothers of the social market economy envisioned. Therefore, I explicitly say: We must stay in conversation; you must represent the interests of tenants; and we will have the issue of housing construction at the top of the agenda – and indeed housing construction that serves the common good.

Thank you very much.