Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "Global Sustainability" Symposium on October 9, 2007, in Potsdam:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 October 2007 · "Global Sustainability" Symposium · Potsdam, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Global Sustainability Symposium in Potsdam on October 9, 2007, speaking to Nobel laureates and experts about urgent climate action.
Main themes
Climate change, global sustainability, CO2 emissions reduction, economic cost of inaction, two-degree Celsius warming limit, IPCC scientific findings, industrialized country responsibility, climate adaptation, human-induced climate change, Stern Review on climate economics, international climate cooperation, security risks of climate change
Duration
~26 min
78th percentile
Words
3,171
78th percentile
Sentences
149
80th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 61%60%
  • Economic 19%19%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

149 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Frey,

dear Professor Schellnhuber,

dear Mr. Stern,

dear Ms. Wangari Maathai,

esteemed Nobel laureates,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here in Potsdam today for this symposium and would like to especially thank Professor Schellnhuber for taking this initiative, and also all of you, the Nobel laureates and experts, for being willing to engage with us on the central questions of the future – climate change is certainly one of the central questions of the future, if not the central question of humanity. I appreciate this, as you all have a lot to do. Time is one of the scarcest commodities in the world. With globalization, time is also being used more intensively. This means we are very grateful that your presence here makes it clear that this issue is just as important to you, the scientists, as it is to politics.

We have gained a climate advisor for our federal government in Professor Schellnhuber, who continually brings the topic of climate protection and the management of climate change into public consciousness with good, interesting, and also unprecedented initiatives. Just as you once initiated a declaration from the academies of sciences of the G8 countries, which has great significance, you, Professor Schellnhuber, have succeeded today, with the discussion of the Nobel laureates, in setting a milestone on the path to greater attention and awareness regarding climate change. The recognition of your good ideas is evident in the fact that you will receive the German Environmental Prize this year. – I do not want to congratulate you prematurely, but I do want to mention it here. – I believe this particularly acknowledges your achievements.

Where do we stand and what do we need to do in the coming days, weeks, and months? We know that climate change is a global challenge. We feel that it cannot be managed solely at the national level. However, we also know that the industrialized countries bear a great responsibility. We are in the fortunate position that, as part of the Rio process, we have succeeded in developing a specific convention for climate change with a scientific framework.

It is also a great honor that Mr. Pachauri, the chairman of the IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, is here today. This scientific body of the United Nations has managed in recent years to predict with ever-increasing precision the overwhelming likelihood that we are experiencing human-induced climate change.

In discussions, it must always be pointed out that there has always been climate change, but over very long periods during which far fewer people could adapt at a much lower technological level. However, the current situation is such that we will likely have nine billion people in the world by the middle of the century and that dramatic effects will occur in short timeframes – essentially within half a century. This acceleration of climate change must, in my view, be clearly attributed to human influences. We must recognize that it poses a threat to our security and our economic development and can, of course, lead to dramatic damage to our natural resources.

We will definitely feel the effects of climate change, but the IPCC states: adaptation to these effects can succeed if we prevent an increase of more than two degrees Celsius in average temperatures – and that is already a lot. Therefore, we must strive and act. This means nothing less than that we need to halve CO2 emissions by the middle of this century, based – in our view – on the year 1990.

Now we have a guest here today whom I would like to particularly and joyfully welcome: Nicholas Stern. He has done something that is also important: he has stated what will happen if we do not act. The climate discussion often leads to the question of what it will cost us if we act. However, this question is wrongly posed, as it suggests that if we do not act, nothing bad will happen. Mr. Stern has demonstrated that unchecked climate change will reduce our prosperity by at least five percent. It could even go so far as to have an impact of up to 20 percent.

In contrast, we can say: if we want to avert the worst consequences, we can already do so with the investment of one percent of our gross national product to keep the climate impacts such that there is no warming of more than two degrees Celsius. This means we do not have the choice of either taking one percent of our prosperity and suffering losses elsewhere or doing nothing and nothing happening. Rather, if we do nothing, we would face a dramatically higher loss of our prosperity. This would have completely incalculable consequences and would mean conflicts, security problems, and a danger to people.

This means that decision-makers in politics and business are now faced with a fairly clear data basis and must plan their actions on this basis. The good news is that there is still a time window available, so to speak, and that we still have a few years in which we can act sensibly and thus also follow the path of least cost.

Now we have negotiated a first agreement until 2012, the Kyoto Protocol. This agreement set quantitative reduction targets for developed countries for the first time. It also imposed a number of measures on developing countries. It is, of course, a major question of credibility whether this first step of the Kyoto Protocol will be adhered to, at least by those who have ratified it.

I must repeatedly point out at this point: the European Union also has much to do. Because in 2006, we achieved a reduction of CO2 emissions of about two percent. However, our target is seven percent. In the European division of responsibilities, Germany is to achieve about 75 percent of the reduction. Germany has already achieved the largest part of these reductions. Of course, many effects from German reunification are also involved. But the fact that we have already achieved 85 percent of our reduction commitments compared to 1990, while Europe has not reduced its emissions by seven percent as stated in the Kyoto Protocol, but only by two percent, shows that there are a number of European countries where CO2 emissions have dramatically increased. Therefore, Europe still has a huge task ahead.

For the time after 2012, we need a follow-up agreement. One of the successes of Heiligendamm was that the United States, Canada, and now also Australia and Japan have recognized – there have been ongoing discussions about this – that this should take place under the auspices of the United Nations and that we should complete the negotiations by the end of 2009 so that we can then prepare for the implementation of the post-Kyoto agreement. Therefore, at this year's next climate conference, which will take place in Bali, a roadmap – similar to a mandate – for the negotiations that must be completed by 2009 must be adopted.

I want to be very clear: for me, a post-Kyoto agreement only makes sense if there are clear reduction commitments regarding total emissions, but also clear responsibilities for individual reductions. Because I cannot imagine that it will work under the motto "We know what we need to achieve together, but we will all first make an effort and then see if we can achieve the overall goal."

We have a certain degree of flexibility regarding local or regional reduction commitments and in the choice of the instruments we want to use. Assuming we could agree on a global carbon trading system, we would certainly be able to meet a large reduction target relatively well. However, if no global instrument can be agreed upon, then we need regional reduction commitments. Both could be alternatives. But if a global carbon trading system is not agreed upon, then regional reduction commitments are necessary.

Now we still have a long way to go. There is agreement that a post-Kyoto agreement should be negotiated under the UN and by 2009. There may already be good steps towards an overall reduction target, but there are still no mechanisms and no regional allocation. This will be the work in the time until 2009, and it will still be hard work.

Now the question arises again and again: who can contribute what, who should take the lead, who should wait a bit longer?

I believe there are two things we should keep in mind.

The

first

is: what is our vision of justice in the world? How do we get all countries involved in taking responsibility? Because one thing is also clear: Europe currently accounts for 15 percent of global CO2 emissions, and this share will decrease. This means that even if Europe alone had no CO2 emissions, the climate problem would not be solved for the African continent, nor for Asia, nor for all of us. This means that sooner or later, we must bring everyone on board.

If we know this and also know that the right to development is, of course, particularly demanded by developing countries, then in my view, our long-term benchmark can only be that CO2 emissions per capita in the world must converge. This is a difficult task. Let us take a look at the world today: we have per capita emissions of four tons of CO2 per person. If we know that we need to halve this – now I am not starting from 1990, but from today – then this means: by 2050, two tons of CO2 per person. We in Europe produce an average of nine tons, in Germany eleven tons, Americans 20 tons, and China already 3.5 tons per person. This means that if we want to reach two tons per person, we must make a dramatic effort.

The

second

point is: the question of a long-term equal per capita output of CO2 emissions is interestingly linked to the inclusion of developing countries in that, as industrialized countries reduce quickly, the responsibility for developing countries also arises quickly. This means there is good reason for the most developed countries to rapidly deploy new technologies and new instruments to show that it is possible. Moreover, there is also a decoupling of economic growth, energy consumption, and CO2 emissions. The faster we implement this, the faster we will – this is my conviction – also bring developing countries on board.

You can see from this topic – which is why I find it so exciting as a politician – that you really have to act globally and that things are closely interconnected. Therefore, it is a topic from which all of humanity can learn how responsibility is shared in times of globalization.

Now, of course, with the implementation of new technologies – the European Union has made very clear decisions here – we also have a huge opportunity to help shape future export markets. This is, of course, also a reason for the economic attractiveness of implementing these new technologies. We have seen in the development of renewable energies, for example, that there are previously unimaginable technical possibilities.

I personally believe that we must always focus on energy saving. In Germany, for example, we have relied heavily on mechanisms that focus on industrial CO2 emissions. However, we know that 60 to 70 percent of emissions arise from private consumption. This means that through efficient heat generation, improved heating techniques, efficient cooling techniques – which are more important in other parts of the world – and improved transportation systems, you can also significantly reduce CO2 emissions.

We need to rethink things here. This will also have very interesting and yet unpredictable effects on agricultural products, as well as on the question of agricultural subsidies and land use, if we look at the entire market of bioenergies. We can already see this in some areas today, for example, when we look at corn prices in Mexico or grain prices here. Humanity must, of course, learn to deal with these new mechanisms. But all of this should not prevent us from engaging with the issue. To be honest, I am very optimistic about this. Because if we look at how we have learned to limit car emissions, keep our water clean, and recycle our waste, it has become clear that we have had incredible learning effects related to resource conservation over the last 20 years. We will also succeed in reducing CO2 emissions.

Therefore, we must take on our responsibilities to this extent. For this, we essentially need the entire chain from science to the implementation of new technologies to the conclusion of agreements in the respective regions. That is why we attach such great importance to the EU positions in this context, because we know: The European Union wants to be a pioneer here. We have offered to reduce our CO2 emissions by 20 percent by 2020 and, if other countries join in, even by up to 30 percent.

For Germany, this means that we must reduce our CO2 emissions by 40 percent by 2020, based on 1990 levels. This is, of course, a tremendous effort. Because until 2012, we can rely on the effects of German reunification for the first 20 percent reduction. Now, however, we must take another such step. For the first time in the history of the federal government's work, we have established a plan, a path that describes the individual steps we can take to achieve this. It is very interesting that the German economy has also looked at cost-benefit analyses. One does not have to agree with every detail, but for the first time, we are getting a sense that many of the measures we implement pay off very quickly. When looking at things over a longer period, it becomes clear that reductions of at least 30 or 35 percent are very achievable if they are implemented consistently.

In this respect, I believe that we need role models from the industrialized countries to encourage developing countries and emerging economies to follow our path and to avoid making many of the mistakes we made. It is already encouraging that, for example, in China, efficiency targets are being set for the first time. This means they know they have economic growth, but they are now also trying to take the step in China that we essentially took in the industrialized countries in the 1970s, namely to decouple economic growth from CO2 emissions. When the Chinese say they want to achieve a 20 percent improvement in energy efficiency by 2010, that is a very ambitious goal. When you travel to the individual regions, it is interesting to see that the governors are carefully considering how they want to approach this goal. This naturally leads to an interest in certain technologies, for example, in energy generation.

Sometimes we still focus too much on electricity generation rather than on energy generation. Electricity generation accounts for only about one-third of CO2 emissions and total energy consumption in Germany. This means we also need to look at – this will be one of the most interesting projects for developing countries – how we can create incentives and mechanisms through reasonable pricing systems in the heating sector, the entire heat market, and also in fuel consumption that contribute to ensuring that developing countries behave in a CO2-just manner.

The problem I repeatedly encounter – for example, on my trip to China and perhaps soon on my trip to India – is that where there is great poverty, the basic supply of electricity and heat is often heavily subsidized. This means it is very difficult to develop financial incentive mechanisms to save electricity and heat because pricing as a regulatory mechanism does not work as long as a large part of the population does not have the money to buy these goods at market prices.

We might need to rethink this point. In Germany, almost no new houses are being built compared to before, or only to a limited extent. In Europe, on this aging continent, the construction of houses with good insulation techniques is no longer a big deal. But in China and India, where prosperity is growing and where almost everything is being newly created, the situation is quite different. It pains me to think that we are not finding the right mechanisms to immediately set the standards – for example, for the insulation of houses – correctly.

One topic I would like to address at the end is the mechanism of adaptation. We in Germany do not need this as much yet. However, when you travel to Africa, you see that climate change is partly so palpable that these countries need to be enabled to have options for adapting to the changed situation until they reach their reduction targets. I would like to point out, for example, the expansion of deserts and the succession of floods and droughts. When we see how biodiversity is diminishing in South Africa – as impressively demonstrated by a project funded by Germany – which in turn has dramatic consequences for certain economic sectors, we must realize: Countries in Africa must be able to respond to this. Therefore, it is important to create adaptation funds within climate negotiations so that these countries are not set back while they must actually take on their own responsibilities. This is not seen in Europe, except in the Mediterranean region – in Portugal, Spain, and Greece, the effects are already visible. But the effects that are visible in Africa are already of the utmost importance for the African continent today. Given that one billion people live there, this is, of course, a huge challenge.

Overall, climate change is a topic where I am firmly convinced: Humanity can contain the problem of climate change to the extent that the consequential damages turn out to be manageable. But it can only do so if it acts together, if it approaches things with optimism, creativity, and initiative.

It is undisputed that industrialized countries have a significant responsibility – firstly, in accepting that a just world must grant every person the same right to CO2 emissions, and secondly, in setting an example by developing climate-friendly technologies. In the whole discussion, we must always remember: Inaction causes damages that cost us at least five times as much as what we have to spend if we take action. I would find it really exciting if we could see this as a global challenge and show under the UN umbrella: We can take on global responsibility together. If we do not do this, it will have implications for war and peace, for security, and for various conflicts. Therefore, every effort is worthwhile.

So once again, a heartfelt thank you to all those who are willing – even though they sometimes have completely different areas of expertise – to engage in this global human question, and who thereby contribute to encouraging others to get involved as well.